7 ms·
Online sports betting: As you do well, they cut you off
- arrosenberg 1y agoIf a casino or sportsbook allow unlimited losers, they shouldn’t be able to cut off winners. Conversely, if they cut off winners, they should be required to reimburse loses above a statutory limit. In a healthy economy “Tails I win, heads you lose” businesses should not be allowed to succeed.
- rightbyte 1y agoYe well there is room for improvements. I have done sports betting like three times, when I realized the odds were bonkers, and retrieving the money after winning was an extreme hazzle that took weeks with photocopies of passports and gas bills and what not. Paying the bets took a minute. I mean, online betting is a shady business. Physical casinos at least have some sort of brick wall to bang your head against.
- dist-epoch 1y ago> retrieving the money after winning was an extreme hazzle that took weeks that has nothing to do with sports betting. it's the same with trading stocks/forex/..., it's KYC/AML
- paxys 1y agoYup I have used these apps, and it takes 10 seconds to deposit and withdraw money. They have every incentive to make it as seamless as possible, otherwise they aren't going to get repeat customers.
- PaulHoule 1y agoWas watching the Kentucky Derby at a party, thought it might be a hoot to bet the favorite to show [1] on my phone but I didn’t quite do it. I would have won but it could have been a hassle to get paid. [1] A heuristic to minimize your losses, because favorites are underbet, if you have minimal information
- gruez 1y ago>and retrieving the money after winning was an extreme hazzle that took weeks with photocopies of passports and gas bills and what not. Paying the bets took a minute. Blame the AML/KYC/income tax regulatory regime. Placing a bet doesn't require KYC any more than spending $10k at a club doesn't require KYC. However once the casino needs to disburse money Uncle Sam suddenly wants his cut and to make sure it doesn't go to Bad People.
- rightbyte 1y agoIt is not really KYC though since we didn't meet or even talk or chat?
- gruez 1y agoKYC means collecting documents/ID on your customers, not going on a date to "know" them.
- const_cast 1y agoRight, but elephant in the room: gambling is shady and addictive business. If we let gambling go on under the table, it will probably become worse, not better. Ideally we probably should have higher barriers to gambling on both sides, kind of like we do cigarettes.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- david422 1y agoI don't disagree - but also realize that the other option is not to play.
- mlinhares 1y agoThat doesn't work for vices in general, there has to be an externally imposed limit.
- gaze 1y agoThis is such an old moral argument. Do you think society should protect people from the nearly unlimited downside inherent to having bugs in human behavior exploited or do you think that doing this is wrong and that it's in fact immoral to stop people from being punished by their own bad decisions, because that's what they deserve.
- personjerry 1y agoTo play devil's advocate, why do you get to decide what's a "bug in human behavior"? If they're happy about it... ?
- aquariusDue 1y agoIs water addicting? /s We can endlessly debate morality, ethics and all that regarding lots of things, but in my humble opinion gambling could be reduced to: "Would people still engage in those games of chance if there was no monetary aspect to it?" And then how many of those people who would still engage with them are "notorious" gamblers on whom those games had a clear negative impact (in most people's eyes).
- Kinrany 1y agoThis is easy to legislate at least: casinos must use play money that no one is allowed to exchange back for real money.
- Teever 1y ago
- 1970-01-01 1y agoWe're just doing it wrong with all-cash betting. We need to change the game to include goods. Don't like your shirt? Go bet it at the casino. If you lose, the casino takes it and goes to sell it at auction. If you win, you get some cash to go buy and own a new shirt.
- parpfish 1y agoIf you bet your shirt, you should only be allowed to win other shirts. Or maybe a matching pair of pants.
- SketchySeaBeast 1y agoI feel like you've just invented extremely unwieldy chips.
- Kinrany 1y agoThat's not a problem, we'll just replace shirts with special wooden tokens of the same color
- jplrssn 1y agoInsurance companies are supposed to operate in this way, but some are happy to take your money as long as they believe they can profit and only start enforcing policy violations etc once you've become a net liability.
- gruez 1y ago>and only start enforcing policy violations etc once you've become a net liability. No, they'll just hike premiums or refuse to insure you.
- const_cast 1y agoYes, but at least we know this is bad and set things up like the affordable care act to try to get rid of this behavior.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoThat isn't what is happening. Earlier this year, sportsbooks lost a lot due to punter-friendly outcomes (a series of favourites winning), and they didn't cut people off. Doing this is extremely bad for business because: people won't come back, and you aren't giving customers the opportunity to lose that money back to you. So what you are seeing when people are limited is not this but arbing line moves between bookmakers, people bearding for someone else, etc. One of the articles mentions stuff relating to player behaviour - for example, if you bet on Australian Rules Football, you bet every game for multiple weeks then it doesn't matter if you win or lose, there is going to be a limit - there is a grey area, but the majority of people being limited don't fall into this category. They are just people doing stupid stuff (I have done this, I used to arb line moves 20 years ago in the UK, I have been banned everywhere, it is stupid and I should have been banned).
- nly 1y agoYeah, I got gubbed everywhere in the UK as well. When Betfair first came on to the scenes the traditional online (and offline) bookmakers were like fish in a barrel for arb bets. I still remember when the first major bookmaker (pretty sure it was BetVictor) started tracking Betfair markets automatically. Now they all do it.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoBookies in the UK never set prices, apart from parlays (which are admittedly a growing part of the market). Even in the early 2000s, it was Asian books that set lines and tech just made it easier for them to access. Margins have gone from 20% to 2% (or lower) because bookies can confidently set lines a few days before the event. Also, their tech even today is still dogshit. It looks like they are tracking Betfair prices but most bookies use third parties for pricing, OpenBet for example, and so it is usually the third party tracking. There is still inherent latency so the main tool has been delays and limiting certain customers. This is why ppl who say they should just take any bet are idiots, it isn't a stock exchange (and most of these third parties also have massive latency in their stack too, naming no names...the stuff I have heard about how they run things is incredible).
- scoofy 1y agoGambling should not be trivially easy to participate in. That's the real problem. If we're pretending it's entertainment, then it shouldn't matter that winners get shut down... because it's just supposed to be fun. If we're not pretending it's entertainment, then we need to deal with the fact that it's a huge negative payoff vice we shouldn't be allowing to happen easily (make it legal and rare). The idea that we're trying to create "fairness" in a business that basically wouldn't exist if the operators don't have a guarantee of success is ridiculous. We can either require sports betting agencies to have betting lines that require their bets be balanced or we can basically ban them from becoming a large industry.
- kelnos 1y agoI personally think of gambling as entertainment, but that's a luxury of mine, as I don't have a gambling problem. On the (infrequent) occasions I gamble, I pre-set a limit and never spend/lose more than that. If it's gone, I'm done. Every now and then I lose that money so quickly that it's not fun, but that happens so rarely that I generally feel like I've enjoyed myself and have paid an appropriate amount for that enjoyment. Paying for entertainment is a normal activity. People do it every day. But gambling feels different: you can pay a nearly unlimited amount for it. There are usually limits in other forms of entertainment. I can only see so many movies in a theater in a day. I can only go to so many concerts. The number of board games I can buy is limited by the storage space in my house. I'm sure there are exceptions in some types of entertainment I haven't thought of, though.
- incangold 1y agoAnother example of “entertainment” with scope for unconstrained spending: digital goods in the less scrupulous kinds of video games
- danillonunes 1y agoWhich coincidentally often contains gambling mechanics such as loot boxes.
- thrance 1y ago> In a healthy economy “Tails I win, heads you lose” businesses should not be allowed to succeed. That's every gambling place/app, should they all be made illegal? Not that I'm disagreeing...
- armchairhacker 1y agoPolymarket seems OK (or at least unethical for a different reason): the prize pool is entirely from the gamblers’ money, and evenly distributed to the winners. I don’t think Polymarket does this, but I also think it would be OK if the casino takes a cut of the prize pool, as long as it ensures that winners never receive less than they bet. For example, the casino may receive $losers/n (they pick n, $losers = total bets of losers), and winners receive $bet($losers(n - 1)/n + $winners)/$winners, $winners = total bets of winners, $bet = their bet). Then it’s “tails = I win you lose, heads = we both win someone else loses, except nobody wins if everyone gets heads but that’s extremely unlikely (especially with more than 2 options)”.
- uxp100 1y agoThat’s not really casinos in the same way as apps. Casinos find the other side of the bet for you and take a cut. They make money in transaction costs. They profit either way, but don’t cut you off for winning (at the sportsbook, other games may be different). Apps sometimes are taking the other side of the bet themselves, and thus will cut you off for winning.
- thrance 1y agoYes, however casinos don't need to expell winners*, as the games are already rigged in the house's favor. Slot machines are set to give back 80% of the money invested, the dealer has a small advantage in black jack, etc. * If you start applying the martingale to roulette, you will quickly be pointed to the exit.
- saghm 1y ago> the dealer has a small advantage in black jack Yeah, but if you try to "count cards" (i.e. actually utilize probability to play effectively) they'll throw you out. The parent comment is right that this is basically how all gambling against a business works. I'd totally be in favor of them all being illegal, but I also doubt that it would be feasible due to most people not sharing this view; it would probably go down about as well as prohibition (which ironically is also something I'm one of the few who would be relatively unaffected by given that I don't drink).
- blinded 1y agoHard agree. Would never work for a gambling or gambling adjacent company.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- parpfish 1y agoToo many people are willing to do sketchy stuff if you can frame it as solving fun math/ML problems, and I have to admit that a sports gambling company would have a lot of fun data to play with. But too often the ability to turn everything into a math problem lets you easily abstract away the reality of what you’re doing
- jeffbee 1y agoBut would you invest in one? The VC firm for which this orange site is the public mouthpiece has backed lots of them.
- blinded 1y agoNope. Not directly.
- sharkweek 1y agoIt has taken over the lexicon of most major sports to the point I can barely stand watching most of them now… NFL broadcasts lean so heavily into betting odds, parlays, prop bets, everything… it’s so obnoxious hearing about X player hitting the over, only to go to a commercial offering some free money if you place a certain sized bet. I really hope (but am not holding my breath given how much money is involved at this point) they ban sports betting advertising in the future.
- gffrd 1y agoI’ll go further: I hope they ban sports betting altogether. It was a mistake, and we should accept that.
- lenerdenator 1y agoYou can't ever truly ban it; there's always a guy who's willing to operate a racket. The question is, can you reduce the harms? We went wayyyyy too permissive with sports betting by allowing it online. It should be something that you can do at a casino, but on your phone, at home, alone? That's just begging for serious harm to the addicted.
- triceratops 1y agoThey were talking about banning gambling advertisements, not gambling itself. Banning gambling is a terrible idea.
- const_cast 1y agoBanning online gambling is a great idea and we should do that. There's far too little barriers so addiction gets created way too easily. And then it's too difficult to avoid, because smartphones are like arms at this point.
- gffrd 1y agowhy is it a terrible idea?
- bartread 1y agoI would guess this is not true for betting exchanges where backers and layers are directly connected to eachother and the exchange takes a small cut of every transaction regardless of which side wins or loses. I wouldn’t have thought it would matter to them if you were a consistent winner because your repeat business helps to provide liquidity to the exchange.
- dist-epoch 1y agoThis might come as a surprise to you, but the more volume you trade, the higher commission you pay (in percentage terms) on sports betting exchanges. BetFair calls it the Expert Fee :)) If you make more than $100k profit, you pay 40% extra Expert Tax on it :) https://support.betfair.com/app/answers/detail/expert-fee-faqs https://support.betfair.com/app/answers/detail/expert-fee-fa...
- tough 1y agolol how is that legal
- genewitch 1y ago25% of their 40% take goes to lawmakers?
- tough 1y agooh, I see, incentives alignment eh
- bartread 1y agoAh, yes, now that's interesting. In the UK you do not pay tax on winnings from gambling so, assuming the government gets a cut, this might be in lieu of tax that they would otherwise not accrue from the professional/expert gambler due to their winnings not being taxable. And modern KYC checks mean, I'd imagine, you can't simply subvert this by running multiple accounts or by periodically shutting down your accounts and setting up new ones.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jaoane 1y agoI remember seeing here posted years ago an article written by someone who worked at a casino as a croupier or something similar, talking about how you will lose your money there no matter what... Anybody knows what I'm talking about? I tried looking for it and I came back empty-handed.
- elpocko 1y agoIsn't this common knowledge? The statistical odds are always in favor of the casino, otherwise there would be no casinos. You can only win short-term, if you're lucky; long-term, the bank always wins.
- hshdhdhj4444 1y agoIn a physical betting space, usually located in casinos, I can also get free drinks. There’s also other stuff to do and it requires actual physical effort to be there and bet all the time. Online sports betting is a mug’s game. I made a few hundred dollars and have quit for a couple of years now once I learnt that they can kick you out for doing too well.
- parpfish 1y agoI can see some benefits to in-person sports betting. Putting money on a game you don’t care about can make it exciting. Getting a bunch of people watching a game together with money on it is a way to drum up a crowd of enthusiastic temporary fans for any game, which might lead to a fun high energy atmosphere. The problem is that the crowd will likely have divided rooting interests and things could get… confrontational
- chasing 1y agoI mean, no shit? Casinos aren't in it for fair play and sportsmanship.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pastor_williams 1y agoAnother good article about sports betting: "The Online Sports Gambling Experiment Has Failed" https://thezvi.substack.com/p/the-online-sports-gambling-experiment https://thezvi.substack.com/p/the-online-sports-gambling-exp...
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoSome related discussions here: The Online Sports Gambling Experiment Has Failed https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42110194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42110194 Legalizing Sports Gambling Was a Mistake https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659458 Should Sports Betting Be Banned? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41665630 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41665630
- dismalaf 1y agoThis is why I never gambled against the house... If you play poker against other players, the house will never cut you off (they take their rake and are happy). And as long as you give some action and are social, the whales keep playing you too (they're rich enough).
- Apreche 1y ago~~online sports~~ betting is for losers
- paxys 1y agoOver the last few years watching sports (in the USA at least) has been unbearable. Every other ad is for gambling apps. Broadcasters show live betting odds on TV alongside the game. Announcers and analysts are constantly talking about their favorite parlays. All athletes have endorsement deals with bookmakers and encourage young fans to participate. Sports leagues themselves have close partnerships with the largest gambling companies. And who ensures everything is happening above board and there is no fixing? Don't worry, self regulation works.
- zem 1y agothe fact that having your game constantly interrupted by ads didn't in and of itself make watching sports unbearable just shows how bad the downward pressure on what is considered acceptable is. gambling ads will probably become the new normal in a couple of years.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoThere was match fixing in the US before legalization. In fact, the US is one of the only places where you have had major sports events being fixed due to gambling, despite gambling being legal in many other places. One of the greatest incentives to stop match fixing comes from having regulated operators who will report unusual betting behaviour. For example, the massive problems with match-fixing in low-ranked tennis has been tackled by bookmakers. There is an issue with advertising but that is unrelated to the match-fixing one. The latter is one of the absolute oldest lobbying lines the Republicans used when they were getting all their money from Adelson (it was accompanied with some mad intellectual gymnastics about how sports betting at casinos was also magically unaffected by this, same with underage gambling).
- MrMember 1y agoI'm in favor of legal sports betting but there needs to a serious crackdown on advertising during events and league partnerships. The UFC has an official sportsbook partner. In the UK a book sponsors the second tier of soccer. It's out of control.
- anthomtb 1y agoIn the pre-online sports betting days, was there a legal way to bet on a game besides going to a casino and visiting the sports book? I remember newspapers publishing odds but still have no idea how people made wagers (other than physically visiting a casino).
- paxys 1y agoYup those odds were for entertainment purposes only wink wink
- pjc50 1y agoUK used to do this via bookmakers, who ran either high street shops or at the race being bet on. Football betting had "the pools", betting by post across a number of fixtures. Most famous was run by a retailer. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Littlewoods https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Littlewoods See also https://www.onlinebetting.org.uk/betting-guides/football/history-of-betting-on-football.html https://www.onlinebetting.org.uk/betting-guides/football/his...
- lenerdenator 1y agoThere's basically no redeeming value to online gambling. When gambling was legalized in my area in 1990s it brought at least some working-class jobs and tax dollars. Now, those tax dollars were funded by people with an addiction, but they at least went somewhere local. And you can still go gambling occasionally and get a good meal and some drinks and maybe see a show. Worst comes to worst, at least in my state, you can sign an affidavit banning yourself from the casino floor. Online gambling is just a Skinner box designed to take money out of severely addicted people's pockets. That's it. You can speed run racking up losses because the games are shorter and can be done faster. The sites operate out of jurisdictions that have loose regulations on the games. For all you know they could be making it not only unlikely, but impossible, to win. Watch a few YouTube docs on a streamer named BossManJack if you want to see just how consuming it can get.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoThere is redeeming value: it is fun and harmless for most of the population. The same people that I have seen rage against other people gambling will also argue in favour of legalising drugs which are more addictive and can cause psychosis. In addition, making it illegal does not stop actual addicts gambling. You can go offshore and get completely unregulated services, that comply with no regulators on harm prevention. The US was the largest sports betting market in the world when it was illegal in every state bar Nevada. Also, online providers maintain lists of self-excluded people with state regulators (to be clear, the state holds the list, people put themselves on the list and are banned everywhere). Casinos are significantly less regulated in this area because, due to the nature of the product, is not possible to put in limitations to the product (for example, reality checks, loss limits, giving you access to data on your usage). All regulated sites have third-party verification of their games by specialist testers and state regulators. Every change to every line of code that touches a regulated service is reported. It is not possible for operators to lose at casino games because of the scale, and you think they are willing to destroy it all to get your $10 faster? The issue with online gambling is: some people cannot resist telling what other people (usually people poorer than them) what to do, and some people have not thought the alternatives through.
- paulbjensen 1y agoI recently read about a story in my local newspaper (Colchester UK) about someone who stole £13,000 from his girlfriend's phone via her banking app so that he could fund his gambling addiction. He was found guilty of theft and sent to prison. I wonder if there is any merit in building an app that helps gambling addicts by letting them play the same games that they would play on their phones, with a few caveats: 1 - It's all virtual money, just like a demo account on a stock trading service where you can test it out without real money being involved. You don't use real money, and the app is free to download and play. The goal isn't to make money from the app, it's to help treat gambling addiction. 2 - Where the games would tempt you to place another bet and say "better luck next time?" or "so close" and tempt the player to make another bet, this game would do something different: - When a player loses on their go, it would say "if you'd staked real money, that would have cost you £2 etc". - It would also remind you of the total balance, and say "if you'd played for real, then you would be down £200 tonight, but because you played this game instead, you've saved yourself £200." - When a player wins on their go, it would say "congratulations on winning, that was your first win in the previous 6 go's". The idea is to change the cognitive behaviour of the player so that a) they get to play a game that they enjoy playing and find addictive to play, but crucially b) they don't lose any money, and because they are shown the reality of what gambling is like from an accounting perspective, their cognitive association with gambling is changed. It's better to play a fun game for free then to play a game that drains you of all your money. How is that idea. Good, bad?
- pjc50 1y agoSuch things exist, but for the gambler the crucial thing is the possibility of winning real money. Also apps that don't make money don't pay for advertising themselves. (Compare vs gatcha, which doesn't allow you to cash out. Predictably there's also gatcha simulators if you just want to roll for things meaninglessly)
- PaulHoule 1y ago… when I got a real smartphone I wanted to try Fate/Grand Order because I was a fan of the fanart but when I saw the summon screen it used the same visual language as slot machines and I lost interest.
- bdangubic 1y agothey cut me off I sign up my Pops, they cut him off I sign up my wife, they cut her off I sign up my Sis… by the time I out of family members I’m sipping Piña Coladas in the Carribean :)
- devonsolomon 1y agoI had deep-access to this industry in a past career - the way online sportbooks talk about their customers in private is all you need to know to know that this isn’t business, it’s predation.
- Akasazh 1y agoCare to share stories?
- 1024core 1y agoOne spring I wanted to checkout the parks near Vegas: Valley of Fire, Hoover Dam, etc. But I stayed in Vegas because the cheapest hotels were there. Every evening, after a day of hiking, I would walk into a casino, sit down at the gambling machine, insert a $20 bill, and hit "drink service". A few minutes later a free beer emerged, and I promptly hit "cash out", collected my $20 and walked away (after a stop at the free popcorn machine too). I think I may have come away with more than 80% of their clientele.
- codr7 1y agoAfter just having tech lead a team for a month at one of the bigger providers of online casinos and sports betting; because I simply couldn't find anything else at that point in time and I had already struggled for quite some time without an income; I can only agree with most in this thread. I wouldn't mind if we made the whole thing illegal, it's like a giant leech on society. And I've never before in my career come across a company so stacked with narcissist assholes on the management side. https://github.com/codr7/yolo https://github.com/codr7/yolo
- chistev 1y agoIs it possible to be a profitable bettor long term? By long term I mean thousands of bets? For example, guy like Picks office on Twitter is profitable, but I don't know if that's a large enough sample size.
- kelnos 1y agoI would expect so. Some types of sports betting, like parlays, are mostly (entirely?) games of chance, so you avoid those. But the published odds of a team winning a match are subject to the research done and models made by the person setting the odds. If you have a better model, or somehow have access to better information, you could certainly end up with a profit in the long term.
- Rastonbury 1y agoThere was some academic work that says if you and the bookie have similarly accurate models with random noise, the bettor will come out ahead because the bookie has to make the market and accept all bets, whilst the bettor can chose when to play and only bets when they believe they have an advantage.
- mrandish 1y agoThis has always been true of physical casinos as well. If you win over time, you'll be 'uninvited' - as demonstrated by how quickly casinos will ban anyone they think is card counting in blackjack (which isn't illegal or against to rules). I guess I'm surprised anyone is surprised that casinos do this and always have. There has never been anything "fair" about a casino's relationship with players. Your only role in the relationship is to, on average over the long run, lose money. Their role is to take your money. A "sharp" player is anyone who consistently plays in a way that, on average over the long run, makes money, breaks even or minimizes your losses below the expected rate of return in the casino's financial model. Any player who is not a sharp, is a 'valued customer' (aka 'playing like a consistently predictable loser'). Casinos have always been adept at spotting any players who behave in ways more like a sharp than a valued customer.
- foogazi 1y agoShould be restricted to accredited bettors Either complete a probation period to show proficiency or demonstrate sufficient net worth
- Zaylan 1y ago[dead]
- curtisblaine 1y agoIf winning bettors with working models sre getting cut off, they should sell predictions to "losers". Even give them out for free. If sports books are not playing fair, just ruin their businesses.
- Balgair 1y agoPrediction: By 2035, a common interview question for hedge-funds and FANGs will be: "Can you make unlimited bets on fanduel and draftkings?" Goofus: Yes, I bet on them all the time. Why do you ask? Gallant: I don't really bet, actually. Haven't even downloaded the apps. Galaxy: Fanduel has me limited to 25 cent bets. Hardrock at 2 dollar bets. And draftkings kicked me off entirely. I'm waiting for a good opportunity for betmgm until I open an account there. Further, people will pay to be 'mules' for professional gamblers so that those gamblers will wreck the reputation of those people at the large gambling apps, making it seem like the 'mule' is actually a 'sharpe'.
- RandyGoldy 1y ago[dead]
- OlvaJownday 1y ago[dead]