8 ms·
See how a dollar would have grown over the past 94 years [pdf]
- tiahura 1y agoThe small cap edge is surprising.
- default-kramer 1y agoAnd it's not obvious thanks to the logarithmic scale... There must have been a better way to present this information.
- ArtTimeInvestor 1y agoLooks like that was a one-time event in the 70s. The rest of the time, the small stocks line goes roughly parallel to the large stocks line.
- rokobobo 1y agoRight--in log scale, the gap has stayed roughly the same until around 1980.
- BlandDuck 1y agoIn finance there is an ongoing discussion of whether the small-cap premium still exists. For technical discussions, look for the terms "SMB size factor".
- _vaporwave_ 1y agoI thought the same initially but this may just be a case of recency bias. Small caps have underperformed large cap stocks for the last ~12 years but these things tend to go in cycles: https://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2025/04/24/small-caps-vs-large-caps-the-cycle-thats-about-to-turn/ https://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2025/04/24/small-cap.... It will be interesting to see how the next cycle plays out with the recent concentration of returns in large cap tech stocks (Magnificent 7).
- ty6853 1y agoIf we're allowed to cherry pick years, now do gold https://sprott.com/media/3783/fig1-jh-gold-perf.png https://sprott.com/media/3783/fig1-jh-gold-perf.png
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoThe cool thing about about something with a consistently high return and a long-horizon (going back 100 years) - you're still getting a high return. It's about ~6% CAGR vs ~8% if you picked the absolute best vs absolute worst time around the Great Depression. If you include re-investing dividends, it's about ~8% vs ~10%. You're not getting anywhere near that with gold over any sufficiently long non-cherry picked time horizon. The even better thing about the S&P is it has relatively low volatility. You're really unlikely to put all your eggs in the S&P at the absolute worst timing. Sure, it's possible. Not likely.
- throw0101c 1y agoHeres a site with a slider where you can pick arbitrary start and end times: * https://www.macrotrends.net/2608/gold-price-vs-stock-market-100-year-chart https://www.macrotrends.net/2608/gold-price-vs-stock-market-...
- whalesalad 1y agoThe Y axis scaling is so misleading.
- sokoloff 1y agoIn what way? A semi-log presentation is perfectly suited for this type of data. (To be frank, I would find any other presentation to be misleading.)
- yesfitz 1y agoIt's logarithmic scaling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logarithmic_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logarithmic_scale It's helpful when dealing with investments because it shows percentage change more clearly than absolute: https://www.leekranefuss.com/2019/04/why-you-should-use-logarithmic-scales-to-make-investment-decisions/ https://www.leekranefuss.com/2019/04/why-you-should-use-loga...
- andrewmcwatters 1y agoNo one spends percentages. You spend dollars. Differences in annual compounding are tremendous. I would even argue logarithmic scales on charts are rarely useful. They’re inappropriately used in financial charts all the time.
- floundy 1y agoThis comment is a microcosm of how HN is essentially indistinguishable from Reddit nowadays in the quality of discussion.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- fasthands9 1y agoWhen I was born in 1990 my grandparents spent like 5k on government bonds that my dad didn't tell me about until I was 30. It was a very nice treat, but when I did the math to see how much more it would have been if just invested in the market I gasped.
- ryandrake 1y agoNot comparing apples to apples, though. Those government bonds were, by any reasonable measurement, risk free (EDIT: as another commenter noted, not exactly, we could call them "minimal risk"), while "the market" is not. Looking back in hindsight is always risk-free, though, which can lead to faulty conclusions.
- jameslk 1y agoOn the timescale of 30 years for gov bonds vs diversified US stocks, this is almost meaningless statement. The longer a risky asset is held, the less chance of loss you’ll have. Short-horizon returns are extremely volatile, but that volatility "mean-reverts" over time. This is especially true for stocks vs bonds. Because the cash flows of bonds are fixed, prolonged inflation or rate spikes can deliver a loss that stays a loss, making long-term "safety" in bonds partly an illusion. http://www.efficientfrontier.com/t4poi/Ch1.htm http://www.efficientfrontier.com/t4poi/Ch1.htm
- ryandrake 1y ago> On the timescale of 30 years for gov bonds vs diversified US stocks, this is almost meaningless statement. The longer a risky asset is held, the less chance of loss you’ll have. Short-horizon returns are extremely volatile, but that volatility "mean-reverts" over time. This is only true if you look back 30 years. What will happen in the next 30 years? Do you know for sure?
- jameslk 1y agoThe same type of argument can be made about bonds and even cash. And if a diversified portfolio of US stocks all suddenly go bankrupt, that probably means the US is toast and therefore bonds are screwed too. Outside of catastrophic black swan events, like I said, stocks generally mean revert if you have a long enough time horizon to allow it
- lootsauce 1y agonow do purchasing power of the dollar https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SA0R https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SA0R
- ty6853 1y agoIt was relatively stable if you could go back to the century before that graph starts, when there was no federal reserve.
- p_j_w 1y agoNow do frequency of recessions, depressions, and panics.
- ty6853 1y agoYou mean like the great depression which happened not long after formation, which some prominent economists have argued was exacerbated by the fed? Things did stabilize quite a bit after we bombed the rest of the industrial world into oblivion, though, creating a period of prosperity roughly equal in expansion to the period from the end of the civil war to before the creation of the fed.
- 9rx 1y agoTo be fair, while what you say is no doubt true, the Federal Reserve didn't gain the tools that it would now use correct for that until the mid-1930s and in some ways not until the 1950s — when the Great Depression was already well on its way to being over/was ancient history. It was something quite different leading up to/during the beginnings of the Great Depression.
- throw0101c 1y ago> You mean like the great depression which happened not long after formation, which some prominent economists have argued was exacerbated by the fed? The tight monetary policy of the Fed (dictated by the rules of then-orthodox gold standard) made the Great Depression worse: * https://www.nber.org/books-and-chapters/financial-markets-and-financial-crises/gold-standard-deflation-and-financial-crisis-great-depression-international-comparison https://www.nber.org/books-and-chapters/financial-markets-an... And it was only after leaving the gold standard that countries started to recover: > In the end, recovery from the Great Depression does not begin until countries give up on the combination of the Bagehot Rule and of commitment to sound gold-standard finance. Those countries that have central banks willing to print up enough money so that people are willing to spend it--it is when you adopt such policies that your economy begins to recover. If you don’t, you become France, which sticks to the gold standard all the way up to 1937, and never gets a recovery. When World War II begins, Nazi Germany’s production--equal to France's in 1933--had doubled between 1933 and 1939. French production had fallen by 15%. * https://delong.typepad.com/delong_long_form/2013/10/the-great-depression-from-the-perspective-of-today-and-today-from-the-perspective-of-the-great-depression.html https://delong.typepad.com/delong_long_form/2013/10/the-grea... It was the 'sound money' orthodoxy that everyone adhered to that made things bad, and not the Fed specifically. It's not like things were any more stable pre-Fed: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1873 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1873 * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1893 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1893 * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1896 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1896 * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1907 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1907 And the "Great Depression" used to refer to something else pre-1930s: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression It should also be noted that how the Fed (or any central bank) was run one hundred years ago, and how it/they are run now, are two different things. We've learned a lot (sometimes through painful experience(s)) about how to run economy(s).
- jihadjihad 1y agoRule of 72: time for an investment to double is roughly 72 / the interest rate [0]. Annual return on small-cap stocks: ~12% Time to double: 72/12 ~= 6 years Number of doubling periods: 99/6 ~= 16 Final investment value: ~2**16 ~= $65k ~= $64,417 Math checks out. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_72 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_72
- marsten 1y agoI've always found it amusing that mathematically it should be the rule of 70, but it's commonly rounded to 72 because the latter has more convenient divisors. 70 is divisible by 1, 2, 5, 7, 10, 14, 35, 70 72 is divisible by 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 12, 18, 24, 36, 72
- MarkusQ 1y agoIt's also because in the interest rate range we're normally dealing with (5%-10% APR) the approximation of 1+x/100 as 1.01^x in the derivation of the rule is off a bit, and something like 1.0097^x works somewhat better. ln(2)/ln(1.0097) is about 71.8, thus the use of 72 and it's convenient divisors.
- trod1234 1y agoInteresting, thanks for sharing this.
- Balgair 1y agoOh gosh, 72 is way more anti-prime, I've always just used the rule of 70 in my head though. if I have a calculator handy, I'll use [(69.3/rate) + 0.3] as that's really close to the actual numbers for rates under about 10 or so. I'm curious as to what other methods people use. Honestly, I should probably just memorize the 12 or so numbers. For those interested, here's a mnemonic that I cooked up quick with chatGPT: 70 bears ate 35 lions who ate 23 tigers who ate 18 wolves who ate 14 dogs who ate 12 cats who quickly ate 10, 9, 8, 7 mice who ate 6.6 grasshoppers who ate 6.1 barleycorns Look, I know this is not the best, but hey, it's Friday. Please help me out and make up a better one. 70, 35, 23, 18, 14, 12, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6.6, 6.1
- moralestapia 1y agoClassic meme. I wish I had invested $1,000 back in 1926 but I was busy in a non-material state in the hyper-realm.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- dedicate 1y agoThis isn't a chart of returns; it's a chart of who had nerves of absolute steel. Be honest, who here has actually lived through a major dip and not been tempted to smash that "sell" button?
- rufus_foreman 1y agoI don't get tempted to smash the sell button during major dips, I get tempted to smash the buy button. The only time I smashed the sell button was during the stock market bubble in 1999. I wanted to buy during this year's dip but I took a look at my asset allocation and I was still way overweight in US stocks compared to my target so I couldn't justify it. Hopefully people freak out even more next time. Stock market crashes are my happy place.
- trod1234 1y agoI think the same could be said of anyone who has successfully traded regularly over several years. To do that kind of business you have to have mastered yourself or set up systems where the emotional rollercoaster ride doesn't change your choices. > I wanted to buy during this year's dip... The Stock market hasn't had a real crash in quite a long time as evidenced by a number of things including the PE values and stock buybacks, lack of general price discoverability towards chaotic whipsaws and the indexes topping all time highs. People are going to lose the shirts off their backs when it does come, and it will come suddenly without warning. Best to keep that in mind when greed might try to lead you astray. Greed is both a friend and a trader's worst enemy. Printing money enrolls participants in boom bust cycles. We've had a boom for the last 10+ years nearly straight. The stock market is way overdue for a crash. Its an avalanche prone area with a massive snowpack built up. There's always some chaotic trigger that gets everything moving again.
- marklubi 1y ago> I don't get tempted to smash the sell button during major dips, I get tempted to smash the buy button. Same. Not quite dollar-cost averaging, but when I'm confident in the long term outlook of a company, if they dip, I like to buy more. Just before the COVID lockdowns, I sold everything and went to cash for a month or so. Bought back all my previous positions right about the bottom of the dip. Massive gains on that one... hard to time things that well all the time though. Edit: One additional thing is that you can't be emotionally invested in the investments. That's just a recipe for poorly thought out choices, and ultimately a disaster
- maltyr 1y agoPerfect time to revisit the Futurama episode where Fry realizes he's rich. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6JwkaLt9pf8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6JwkaLt9pf8
- fuzzythinker 1y agoI don't watch Futurama, so I may be wrong in how the story goes. But I think he thought that he's rich but inflation shouldn't be much lower than interest (irl, it's actually way higher), so the 4 billion is likely worth 4 bucks or at most 4 hundred.
- recursivecaveat 1y agoIt seems like the episode treats him as legitimately rich, but you're right: assuming targeted 2% inflation, it's like $10. That's being pretty generous too, 1000 years is a long time to go without some kind of societal shakeup event where people stop honoring 800 year old numbers on a screen as legitimately valuable. It's not like there is any entity today who would feel obligated to give you $4 billion dollars for your 11th century banknote.
- actinium226 1y agoAstute observers will note that the $1 in stocks gets margin called shortly after the initial investment in the late 20's and so in a sense the return over 100 years is 0.
- ashdksnndck 1y agoThe title doesn’t mention owning stock on margin.
- mjburgess 1y agoBut nor does it include owning stocks in companies that go out of business, or indeed, nations.
- ashdksnndck 1y agoI think that’s generally included when you compute total return of an index. For example, Enron should be part of the drop shown in 2001.
- throw0101c 1y ago> But nor does it include owning stocks in companies that go out of business, or indeed, nations. Which is why you invest in the entire market, internationally diversified. There are now funds (mutual/ETF) that allow you to do this with a single purchase: * https://www.finiki.org/wiki/Asset_allocation_ETF https://www.finiki.org/wiki/Asset_allocation_ETF
- floundy 1y agoIncorrect, the DJIA lost around 90% of its index value in the Great Depression, so the theoretical portfolio in this exercise would have declined to around 10 cents, but holding an asset at a negative return does not result in a margin call if one is not trading with leverage. In practice, it would have been a toss-up between individuals' outcomes because index funds as we are familiar with them today did not exist at the time. The DJIA was a price index but there was no way to invest in the DJIA basket as there is today, so brokers picked stocks on behalf of investors. So it's certain that some investors' portfolios did decline to zero during this time due to bankruptcies of all the companies they happened to be holding.
- ortusdux 1y agoReminds me of the iPod color I bought in 2004, that, had I bought stock instead, would be worth ~$225k.
- scotty79 1y agoYou could have still sell it used and buy Bitcoin in 2010 and earn even more. But who knew.
- dachris 1y agoIt's a nice graph, I think the most well known one is in "Stocks for the long run" [0] I'm more concerned how it will grow over the next n (lets say 50) years. Somehow, it doesn't really fit into my head that there will be another 7 doublings of money invested stock market over the coming 50 years (as others have commented, 10% annually is doubling every 7 years). Reality is complex of course, there's inflation, there's taxes, dividends don't grow the stock market cap. Still, I would assume less growth due to several factors. The last few decades have seen several tailwinds that can't repeat in the same way: - falling corporate tax rates globally [1] - falling interest rates [2] (since 1980, until 2020) - rising P/E ratios (partly in response to falling interest rates) [3] - demographic expansion [4] - improvements in diversification (index funds, theoretically you need a lower risk premium than when investing in individual stocks) And I'm not sure that headwinds coming from environmental degradation of many types are already priced in. I still think that stocks will do better than bonds (there's a risk premium [5], those are real assets, there's innovation and growth), just be cautious about assuming that the future will mirror the past. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stocks_for_the_Long_Run https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stocks_for_the_Long_Run [1] https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/global/corporate-tax-rates-by-country-2024/ https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/global/corporate-tax-rate... [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DGS10 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DGS10 (choose max in the time scale) [3] https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population [5] https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/ https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/ ERP currently at about 4.4%
- nly 1y agoSo many people's future retirement prosperity is now so tied to the performance of stocks that we better hope it continues.
- grobbyy 1y agoIt's also worth noting that's US stocks. The story in Europe or Argentina would be completely different, and there was no way to figure that out in 1920.
- jonplackett 1y agoThis should be ‘see how the value of a dollar has decreased over 94 years’ Thanks inflation
- d_burfoot 1y agoNote that the government has huge incentives to downplay the inflation rate. Over the time period of the graph, the price of gold went up by about 100x; I would consider that a more accurate estimate of inflation than the 18x number implied by the chart. Due to the way exponentials work, you can hide a lot of inflation over 100 years by claiming the annual rate is just half a percent lower than it really is.
- Lerc 1y agoIt would be worth seeing the price of a loaf of bread, a dozen eggs, and a bottle of milk. While not capturing the complexities of modern technology, they are available across the entire period and probably have a closer relationship to people's lives than the price of gold.
- lesuorac 1y agoGold is up ~40% over the past year. Are you really going to claim inflation is up 40% over that time period? I think Gold is too susceptible to price fluctuations from speculators and that you should use Copper or something that people don't hoard to re-sell.
- verteu 1y agoFor reference, CAGR from 1926 to today: Milk: 2.5% (*low-quality data) CPI: 2.9% Copper: 3.4% Gold: 5.2%
- baron816 1y agoStatistics like CPI really aren’t meant to be used to track inflation over many decades. It’s really only meaningful over a handful of years, and only when we’re talking about the economy as a whole (not to use it to say any individual or group is better or worse off). A dollar today can buy many things it could not buy 100 years ago. The price of gold is a completely useless measure of inflation. Governments have a long history of manipulating its price as a policy goal. Even today, governments buy and hold large quantities of gold.
- throw0101c 1y ago
- Kon-Peki 1y agoHere is essentially the same chart but with 10x more information. Unlike the original chart, it also shows stock returns without dividend reinvestment. And that isn’t pretty :) https://www.crsp.org/wp-content/uploads/CRSP_Investments_Illustrated_Big_Picture_2025.pdf https://www.crsp.org/wp-content/uploads/CRSP_Investments_Ill...