5 ms·
OpenAI is retaining all ChatGPT logs "indefinitely." Here's who's affected
- gnabgib 1y agoRelated: OpenAI slams court order to save all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats (1101 points, 2 days ago, 906 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44185913 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44185913
- pxc 1y ago> Magistrate Judge Ona Wang granted the order within one day of the NYT's request. She agreed with news plaintiffs that it seemed likely that ChatGPT users may be spooked by the lawsuit and possibly set their chats to delete when using the chatbot to skirt NYT paywalls. Are users who deliberately skirt paywalls ever shy about it? Since when?
- paulddraper 1y agoSince lawsuits I guess.
- pxc 1y agoAre they going after individual readers like those old RIAA and MPAA campaigns? Or does this just refer to the lawsuit been these two companies?
- triceratops 1y agoIt would be a bit much if this linked to an NYT article.
- creaturemachine 1y agoWith the requisite paywall-bypass link as the first comment.
- jonplackett 1y agoIf removing paywalls works then why do they need everyone’s chats to prove it? Just set up your own account, bypass a paywall, save that chat log. This seems completely unnecessary.
- stuffoverflow 1y agoThis whole case is even more stupid when you take in to account how NYT's paywall is implemented. Anyone can bypass it just by refreshing the page and stopping it immediately after contents become visible. I don't know what ChatGPT uses to browse web but it wouldn't surprise me if it repeated stuff from those paid articles because it uses wget or something similar that doesn't support js and therefore the paywalls weren't effective.
- wvenable 1y agoThe paywall news sites want to have their cake and eat it to -- they want web crawlers, like Google, to read the full contents of the article but hide it from site visitors. If they simply put all their content behind a paywall entirely and effectively then this would be a non-issue. If ChatGPT is getting this content it's literally because they allow it.
- gruez 1y ago>The paywall news sites want to have their cake and eat it to -- they want web crawlers, like Google, to read the full contents of the article but hide it from site visitors. There's nothing contradictory about this? Plenty of companies give free access to journalist/reviewers/influencers, with the hope that they'd draw in paying customers. Wanting to only give free access to certain people isn't "want to have their cake and eat it to". It's standard business practice and well within the rights of publishers/rights holders to do.
- wvenable 1y agoYes there is. They don't want ChatGPT to have access but they don't prevent access by ChatGPT. Technically they're actually giving everyone free access. By actually legitimately preventing access they would completely mitigate this problem.
- longnguyen 1y agoShameless plug: I build Chat Vault to help you import all chat data from ChatGPT, Claude, Grok and Le Chat (Mistral) to a native mac app. You can search, browse and continue your chats 100% offline. It’s free while in beta https://testflight.apple.com/join/RJx6sP6t https://testflight.apple.com/join/RJx6sP6t
- nopelynopington 1y agoNice
- subarctic 1y agoIs this something I could do with openwebui?
- accrual 1y agoOpen WebUI does support import/export from a JSON file, but may need a translation for ChatGPT data.
- puppycodes 1y agoI'd be very suprised if they weren't already doing this, the major change however might be attribution to those queries? If you think this is scary you should see what google has been doing for a decade.
- Trasmatta 1y agoI seriously doubt they were already doing this. What would the benefit have been? The vast majority of users will never delete their chats, so it's not like they lose a ton of data by hard deleting conversations.
- puppycodes 1y agoThe benefit is you train models on all the data you receive and also you want some audit trail of how that data got there. This is just a hunch though!
- Trasmatta 1y agoWhat I mean is that the vast majority of conversations never get deleted by users anyway. So why risk breaking privacy laws (and their own privacy policy) for the percentage that do?
- inquirerGeneral 1y ago[dead]
- ViktorRay 1y agoHere is the direct link to OpenAi's official response: https://openai.com/index/response-to-nyt-data-demands/ https://openai.com/index/response-to-nyt-data-demands/ That official response was discussed on this website yesterday. Here is a link to the discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44196850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44196850
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago“This does not impact ChatGPT Enterprise or ChatGPT Edu customers. This does not impact API customers who are using Zero Data Retention endpoints under our ZDR amendment.” The court order seems reasonable. OpenAI must retain everything is can, and has not promised not to, retain.
- throwaway314155 1y agoFrom bio: > Trade private equity > The court order seems reasonable. Checks out.
- thegrim33 1y agoCould also just look at their submission history; all they do is post political content every single day of their life. Such a person is not going to have overly impartial/intelligent takes on issues. I wish there was a plugin that could do sentiment analysis and auto-filter out such users from submissions/comments shown to me. Or just a button I could manually click to never see a person's posts again.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoFair enough, I’m by default deferential to our courts. In this case, however, there is a simple solution if OpenAI doesn’t want to save data: don’t retain it in the first place. If OpenAI committed to privacy as a value, their protests would have merit. But in this case it sounds like they want the ability to retain the data as well as delete it despite being in the midst of litigation. That’s simply not a privilege anyone is afforded by the courts. (We’re also talking about the Times versus a $100+ bn tech giant whose CEO has direct lines to heads of state. There is no David to default sympathy to.)
- mjburgess 1y agoIn the air, at the moment, seems to be a counter-revolutionary sentiment against the managerial class, the administrative state, and institutions of mass monitoring and the like. There have been several events (, forces, ) intruding themselves into the lives the masses: covid, ai, adtech -- which are making-visible the "exorbitant privilege" of being a rent seeker on top of people's mass communication. Impositions like this, of course, put the rent-seeking in people's faces -- but privilege always remains, pending a court order or an executive demand. It feels that there's mass loss of patience with this, a kind of "lay anarchism" that is presently across the popular internet. Many are exhausted at the power which accrues to AI companies from the non-consensual theft of the online social commons. Others, at political censorship. Others, at the secruity state. And so on. But it's all directed towards the same privilege made possible by internet centralisation. Who will channel this politically, where it will go -- of course -- isn't clear at the moment. The anger at this seems febrile, and its more than some fussy libertarians. The economic conditions of egregious rent-seeking and the political conditions of mass control are visible to the people. It all seems a little mid-19th C.
- crmd 1y agoI personally agree fully with your sentiment, but I don’t see any place in today’s American polity where this spark could catch fire, because there’s no donor class that would ultimately benefit. It would have to be like the French Revolution.
- mjburgess 1y agoWell each of these institutions are targeting people in power, it may only be a matter of "one more wrong move" and there's a critical mass of the political elite willing to tear it down. I think DOGE was never actually a cost saving exercise, that was just a disguise for an attempt to destroy the counter-political power of the administrative state -- it isnt so hard to imagine a political party trying again, this time, competently. And so on with each of these instituions. There's quite a lot of bipartisan support now for breaking up monopolies, dramatic restricts on the power of executive police forces, and the like. For different reasons, either side, but the targets are the same.
- kleiba 1y ago> Late Thursday, OpenAI confronted user panic over a sweeping court order requiring widespread chat log retention—including users' deleted chats—after moving to appeal the order that allegedly impacts the privacy of hundreds of millions of ChatGPT users globally. When "delete" actually means "hide from my view", you can only hope that you live in a country with strong privacy and data protection laws.
- sixothree 1y agoEven when companies are honest about how "delete" works, they will use weasel language such as "delete from history" or "delete from inbox" instead of actually doing the thing the user intends.
- xeromal 1y agoThis half the time due to people wanting to recover their accidental mistakes from deleting stuff. IMO hard deleting things is generally a bad practice until the user wants to delete their entire account or some other very explicit action is executed.
- josefritzishere 1y agoIt is still the process at most large firms to delete data after certain intervals of time. the failure to have and follow a data deletion policy is a huge legal risk... even if that interval is 10 years. Forever is the one definitively wrong answer.
- xeromal 1y agoThat's what I meant by very explicit action.
- bombcar 1y agoPart of that is the company doesn't even know what they do internally - sometimes it purges instantly, other times it gets marked deleted in a database table that never gets purged until the fifteen billion row table takes down the service.
- gmuslera 1y agoNot only the users of ChatGPT are affected, also the users of other hosted LLMs, most of which can get the same kind of orders from the jurisdictions they belong to.
- pier25 1y ago> The order impacts users of ChatGPT Free, Plus, and Pro, as well as users of OpenAI’s application programming interface (API) So how does this work with services using the API like Copilot or Cursor? Is OpenAI now storing all the code sent to the API?
- ChrisArchitect 1y ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44196850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44196850
- Dachande663 1y agoQuestion for the crowd: if using the OpenAI service in Azure, is that included in the retention? OpenAI say API access but don’t specify if that’s just their endpoints or anyone running their models.
- filmgirlcw 1y agoYou’d have to check with Microsoft. OpenAI says that this doesn’t apply to customers with a Zero Data Retention endpoint policy, but my recollection is that Azure OpenAI doesn’t fall into that category unless it’s something that is explicitly paid for. That said, OpenAI also says that ChatGPT Enterprise customers aren’t impacted (aside from their standard policies around how long it takes to delete data, which they say is within 30 days), but only Microsoft would know if their API usage counts as “enterprise” or not.
- Beijinger 1y agoDon't ask: How do I murder my wife and get away with it?