7 ms·
We are no longer a serious country
- draw_down 1y ago[dead]
- nabla9 1y agoBond markets are more important than stock markets, so it's understandable to be worried.
- jmclnx 1y agoWait until Trump gets rid of Powell and others and replace them with his lapdogs. That could happen next year. Why Wall Street is not going after Trump and his cronies is beyond me. If Trump takes over the Fed, that will make the 1930s look like fun times.
- digianarchist 1y agoTrump has already yielded to the bond market twice in the last few months - is there really a reason for Wall Street to be worried?
- ffsm8 1y agoYou are taking a very different fact from these circumstances then I would. If he Trump tried once and was forced to backpedal, I'd say you're probably spot on. But considering he tried again quickly after shows, that he ain't gonna take a no. He's just gonna keep trying. At that point: yeah, I'd be worried. But I'm not American, so I didn't particularly mind
- jaredklewis 1y agoThis phenomenon has given rise to the hilariously named "Taco Trade" (https://www.ft.com/content/4d136adf-7e45-4ac8-937c-5151e3833e83 https://www.ft.com/content/4d136adf-7e45-4ac8-937c-5151e3833...)
- 6510 1y agoI type that in google then youtube autoplay immediately started a video about it. The future is here where the machine knows what you want before you... want it. Or without you wanting it? No one can tell anymore. Trust the process!
- vessenes 1y agoAgreed that policy changes whipsaw markets and that causes disinterest in the dollar, and agreed that could be real bad (TM) for America. The rest of this essay just reads like griping and cherry picking though. Complaining about the name of the bill "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" is just dumb. Senators and Reps name bills all sorts of funny things aiming to be catchy or what have you, it's part of our process. And, it seems much more likely that whipsawing serves the purpose of someone than that people in the whitehouse are "unserious". I'd rather see Mr. Krugman's estimable mind devoted to figuring out who is benefiting, how long they will benefit, and what that will do to others than to read him complaining about the name of a bill.
- therobot24 1y agoI think you're focusing too much on the analogies he used instead of the thesis -- everything is aligning to a leader who isn't respected outside of the USA, much like kim jong un. That if saber rattling is the future of the US, then divestment will only increase and won't easily return. And further, the benefactors of this transformation is whoever doesn't have to adhere to our saber rattling which will be as many other countries as possible.
- vessenes 1y agoNo; he's failed to engage in the pathos part of convincing -- he's whistle calling to his liberal readership base by implying the administration is dumb -- he's not seriously engaged with where the country is at, at least in this short essay lite. I agree with you that saber rattling is a major change in foreign policy for the US. There aren't a lot of stops between "reserve currency" and "former reserve currency". That said, there also aren't a lot of options globally. I think the benefactors of the saber rattling might be a little closer to Pennsylvania avenue than you suggest, though.
- aredox 1y ago>implying the administration is dumb Sorry, but that administration is dumb, period. Stop being politically correct.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- selivanovp 1y agoYes, USA is not. But not because of just Trump. The process started a while ago, when USA elites decided that they’re “exceptional”, and started to promote so called “rules based order”, with the only rule that reads like “USA may do whatever they want to do, and you have to obey our orders, or you’ll be punished”. Diplomacy is dead in USA. These days nobody sane in the world believes anything coming out of White House, not even a paper, and Trump is just a current facade for the same elites that nobody trusts.
- jimbob45 1y agoUSA may do whatever they want to do, and you have to obey our orders, or you’ll be punished It's our fault for being the only ones to take defense spending seriously? We just reopened the shipping lanes clogged by the Houthis, which literally the entire world profited from. That could have been done by anyone else but wasn't, because they happily benefit from US interventionism but then pretend to hate it too. You can't have it both ways.
- sixothree 1y agoFairly clear we wouldn't have allowed anyone else to do that.
- achandlerwhite 1y agoThe US maintaining order (and providing foreign aid) is a form of soft power which this administration doesn't seem to value (or maybe even understand). It also benefits US corporations and their interests' abroad.
- BuckRogers 1y agoTariffs grant an extremely significant diplomatic lever for both affairs and world peace.
- Animats 1y agoThe "rules based order" period worked a lot better than the period that included WWI and WWII.
- pfortuny 1y agoWell, the change of sign in the correlation looks to have happened in a very narrow time window, so… sour grapes from Krugman?
- Herring 1y agoVote for republicans => get red state policies. Trump won the popular vote. America is trying very hard to become one big red state. Red states have had the worst outcomes for generations but they keep going back to republicans. The reasons escape me. The Civil War was basically southerners strongly preferring to use slaves instead of modernizing. Lots of them died for this. Make it make sense. This dysfunction goes a lot deeper than any one administration. Maybe the rise of China will motivate them to get their act together.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 1y agoNot sure what Trump does could be called red state policies. There are elements of them, but it's mostly an endless chaos machine and he tries to personally profit or enjoy himself with it. But mostly profit.
- Herring 1y agoThe overlap is extensive. Abortion, immigration, racism/DEI/trans, tax cuts, deregulation, judicial appointments, fossil fuel production, skepticism towards green energy and climate change, prioritizing conservative Christian religious preferences, restructuring/downsizing the Federal Government etc etc. Most of what he does is currently and historically very popular in red states, with predictable outcomes. Corruption is non-partisan, but they definitely turn a blind eye to it.
- jmclnx 1y ago[flagged]
- sleepybrett 1y agoI mean sure there is an element of both racism, both because kamala harris is non-white but also immigration fear mongering, and sexism... but also as someone who voted for her, Kamala Harris fucking sucks. Just a terrible candidate, perhaps only rivaled by Joe 'wheel me out to the community room so I can play some bigno' Biden.
- 1y ago
- BuckRogers 1y agoPaul Krugman is more political operative than economist at this point. I would be more interested in lower profile economists.
- regularjack 1y agoWhat different does it make, what matters is what the text says.
- BuckRogers 1y agoBecause if your primary function is being a political operative, your credibility has been compromised when you address subjects that you tie to politics. Which he clearly does within the article that you say is the only thing that matters. I would agree. But I think you’re missing my point.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- w10-1 1y agoThe divergence between interest rates and the dollar is historic and bodes ill for investors and company builders who historically have been able to rely on the relative stability of the US. As a reminder, the Mary Meeker slides on AI reported that the US share of top companies in the public equity market went from ~50% in 1995 to ~85% recently. Still, the signal from US debt might reflect only changes in a few dominant players (and we famously have adversaries investing in US debt -- Middle East, China, Russia). Also the big beautiful bill shows even Republicans want to spend now and pay later, so this might be unwinding the false expectation of austerity during the Republican trifecta. Both are transitory and neither really goes to seriousness. The real question is whether we've lost seriousness by continuously moving upstream, into financial and information services and technologies. Our willingness to sell IP/infrastructure now rather than protect and control (milk) it over time reflects a generational lack of diligence. (Sorry - not trying to diminish exit strategies for interim investment tiers.)
- mwenge 1y agoBut this isn't 'buy now, pay later'. This is a tax giveaway to the rich, enabled by future borrowing and savage cuts to public services.
- geoka9 1y ago... and common tax in the form of tariffs.
- tiahura 1y agoThe US economy can do just fine with the 10Y at 5%. And, at today’s level of 4.359, it is lower than when Trump took office in January.
- therobot24 1y agorepublicans wanna spend the way 'they want to' and cut every way the democrats want to spend, and just the opposite is true too (austerity only really matters when it's the other party with the control of the budget) pair this with each district, state, and constitute company/nonprofit/whatever looking for a piece of the pie creates an utter mess of non-stop spending
- wodenokoto 1y agoI think krugman is right that most capital still believes that things aren’t as bad as they sound and underneath all the noise surrounding the White House is a rational government. But I also think there is a lot of money to be made playing Trumps game. If i as an investor just jumps on when he says jump and jumps off before the last fool, there is money to be made. At least that’s my explanation as to why sudden declines in tariffs (or even just breaks) causes investor confidence to return.
- tiahura 1y agoMost capital believes the us economy is better than the alternatives.
- robocat 1y agoYet European share prices have rallied: clearly some capital disagrees with your sentence. Disclosure: this foreign capitalist has caused a 5 figure blip by selling all US shares (the move aligned with my other personal goals).
- Macha 1y ago> Two of Trump’s cabinet members were able to beard him in the Oval Office while Peter Navarro, responsible for the original tariffs Is this some meaning of beard I am so far unfamiliar with? The only meaning that jumps to mind is the facial hair, and when I looked up in the dictionary I was reminded me of the LGBT meaning, but neither of them fit here.
- r2_pilot 1y agoI believe the expression is "beard the lion in his den".
- ed 1y agoThanks! I’m a native speaker (US) and was unfamiliar with this idiom. Cambridge dictionary does list this definition of beard: > to face, meet, or deal with an unpleasant or frightening person in a brave or determined way
- readthenotes1 1y agoIt's a little old fashioned. Many sayings have a naval origin, a bunch of others have a biblical origin. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Samuel%2017%3A35&version=NKJV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Samuel%2017...
- wagwang 1y agoA giant share of America does not care. They don't care if spy drops 40% or if bonds default. They aren't bought into the system at all.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoTrue. But a lot of rich people have to be, "Bad form, old boy. Can you let the tariff thing drop already? Why, I just lost several T this month alone."
- tunesmith 1y agoReading this, I'm struck with a familiar feeling. I wonder if other dem-leaning readers can identify. I remember the old joke about how economists have successfully predicted five of the last three recessions. Now it's more intense and political. I feel like there's so much doomsaying amongst those who aren't wired to support Trump. Like they/we are successfully predicting 57 of the last 14 emergencies. Here, Krugman points out some real financial data that might be concerning, but then also devotes equal time to the freaking name of the bill, which, come on. Completely irrelevant to understanding what is really going on. And, I know that that is part of the point/strategy, that some of this branding is trolling to distract people. But where is the actual sober analysis that is better able to tell the difference between the 14 emergencies that are real and the 43 that aren't? That's the familiar feeling; just the sense that I don't really know what is going on, and there are fewer and fewer resources that allow me to make sense of it.
- jack_h 1y agoPeople complaining about the name baffle me; the name of the bill is irrelevant, only the legal effect matters. I’ve been doing a lot of independent research myself since finding useful, non-partisan sources is a huge issue anymore. I’ve found LLMs to be very useful in helping[1] me navigate these areas so I can learn enough to make my own determinations. For what it’s worth my opinion is that this country is in a very bad position that could very well lead to massive world wide economic problems in the future. When and how that manifests is impossible to say; there are a lot of possibilities but I’m expecting the next decade will show us the path we’re on and what that looks like. The tariffs are having an effect (which is to be expected) but it didn’t start there nor does it end there. I think one of the biggest problems we face as a nation is that the citizens do not understand what’s going on and end up parroting what someone else said without really understanding it, usually filling in the gaps of their knowledge from their own world view rather than reality. I don’t mean this as a denigration as most people have families and jobs and do not have enough time to know enough to have well-informed opinions about everything, myself included. However, it is leading to absurdities like screeds about the name of the bill. [1] I don’t trust the LLM of course. I’m not asking it if X is happening or if Y is a problem. More of a way to guide me to finding good primary resources.
- Animats 1y agoIt's possible for a rich country to fail. - How Venezuela went from the richest country in South America to a disaster area.[1] - Decline of Argentina.[2] - Decline of Portugal.[3] Portugal used to be a world power. Yes, Portugal. - Decline of Roman Empire.[4] This is a real worry. The US is on that path. [1] https://www.history.com/articles/venezuela-chavez-maduro-crisis https://www.history.com/articles/venezuela-chavez-maduro-cri... [2] https://worldhistoryjournal.com/2025/04/02/history-argentina-crisis-complete-guide/ https://worldhistoryjournal.com/2025/04/02/history-argentina... [3] https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/cross-gold-brazilian-treasure-and-decline-portugal https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/cross-gold-brazilian-treasure... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_the_Western_Roman_Empire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_the_Western_Roman_Empi...
- ValveFan6969 1y agoAny second now...
- burnt-resistor 1y agoSecular cycles theory. The key is identifying that nothing is written in stone and leadership can reboot the cycle back to stability through sensible and appropriate major reforms, shortcutting without the chaotic, uncreative destruction or arbitrary accelerationist fantasies.
- derbOac 1y agoSomething about titles (and tone?) like this bother me — absolutist in time as well as in geography. It's maybe a subtlety that doesn't matter but I see it a lot lately and it's part of a pattern that I see as lazy and obscuring underlying issues. Things are bad right now, but making stereotyped statements like this, as if the entire country just flipped a permanent switch after Trump was elected and it will be like this forever doesn't do anyone any favors. It doesn't explain what's happening, what happened before Trump was elected, what happened after Trump was elected, it doesn't point to any solutions — it just sweeps all of these issues under the rug and implicitly or explicitly attributes things to some sudden catastrophic change in Americans, like an asteroid the size of North America just collectively hit everyone on the head on Jan 20th. Absolutist statements have always been around — there's plenty of examples during the pandemic, the online tech boom of the 90s and 2000s, and so forth — and it seems to be happening again. But this time to me it seems irresponsible not just for being so extreme, but also because it shirks away from any attempt to solve any problems. I don't expect Krugman to solve problems all the time — he's allowed to despair — but I at least expect him to have some courage and proactivity in his overall stance toward the situation.
- Imustaskforhelp 1y agoTo be honest,from what I've heard, trump has been saying all these things before elections and america voted it. From an outsider (non American),I am not sure.. but I have been looking more into american scandals due to trump and due to Michael Moore documentary. And I have come to only one conclusion, I feel like you guys aren't picking the people who are better for the job but rather whose worse. The shift is so real. And I don't trust democrats too much either. But they are better than republicans at the moment. If you guys are even in the position that you can literally get a guy elected as president that can effectively erode trust on america as a whole,you need to rethink elections. How can I trust america if there is even a 1% chance of such happening again (more than 1% for sure) Trust shouldn't be played with. It's a hard thing to get The only guy I have genuine trust is Bernie sanders. But he's too old but that to me feels like the only hope in America. I truly like how Bernie sanders is kind of like the north pole in my short understanding of american politics and has always been saying the things that I personally resonate with too. I kind of wish,I had a Bernie sanders in my own country tbh. The guys a true gem.
- sharpshadow 1y agoThis raises the question if one should blame Trump or the previous administrations politics which created Trump.
- regularjack 1y agoNo, it really doesn't.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- happytoexplain 1y agoOnly in the sense that you could blame anybody in part for anything if you travel through enough indirection. E.g. if I call you cunt for no reason because I'm drunk, and you say I should be more polite and maybe you sound a little annoying when you say it, and in response I stab you, you could say that you're partially at fault for what happened.
- HocusLocus 1y agoSeeing Krugman call out Trump specifically while starting the graph half way through the Biden Administration... gave me sort of a Climate Change vibe. Sure they are in 'lockstep' as presented recently, but is this a new normal or outlier? What is he 'hiding' to imply these are lockstep values? I chose a start date half way through the last Obama Administration (2014) and scaled to 100 relative to values on that date. I didn't match Krugman's relative scales but plotted it again ( https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1JqXv https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1JqXv ) ... you can see the trends in the graph across two Trump presidencies a bit of Obama and all of Biden and it paints a different overall picture. A lot of wild variance is hidden.
- benmmurphy 1y agoDid Krugman post the FT graph verbatim or did he post a different graph? He mentions in the article that the FT graph looked cherry picked. > Actually, the chart was a bit too neat: When I set out to reproduce it, I found that the FT chose a time period during which the relationship looked especially clear.
- aredox 1y ago>gave me sort of a Climate Change vibe. You mean the thing that was right from the beginning, that is happening right now and that is even worse than the forecast?
- Izkata 1y agoYou should go back and read the climate change commentary from the 90s, which had costal cities already underwater due to melting polar ice caps. It's nowhere near as bad as most people were told it would be.
- aredox 1y agoWhen was that ever the scientific consensus? I was there in the 90s, thank you, I am old enough for that. The real affirmation is that "Coastal cities underwater" is a "risk" for roughly a dozen of them by "the end of this century". You are strawmaning it.
- smitty1e 1y agoI'm not sure how to balance Dr. Krugman with the empirical evidence: "US Army Hits Annual Recruitment Goals 4 Months Early" => https://link.theepochtimes.com/mkt_app/us/us-army-hits-annual-recruitment-goals-4-months-early-5867281 https://link.theepochtimes.com/mkt_app/us/us-army-hits-annua...