13 ms·
The first comment on that article caught my attention: > I am a grad student in the philosophy department at SFSU and teach critical thinking. This semester I
by simonw 1y ago
The first comment on that article caught my attention:
> I am a grad student in the philosophy department at SFSU and teach critical thinking. This semester I pivoted my entire class toward a course design that feels more like running an obstacle course with AI than engaging with Plato. And my students are into it.
It would be interesting to take a class of students and set them an assignment to come up with assignments for their fellow students that could not be completed using ChatGPT.
About ten years ago I went to a BarCamp conference where one of the events was a team quiz where the questions were designed to be difficult to solve using Google - questions like "What island is this?" where all you got was the outline of the island. It was really fun. Designing "ChatGPT-proof assignments" feels to me like a similar level of intellectual challenge.
- aprilthird2021 1y agoYeah, that does sound like a good idea and a good way to prove one has learned the ideas presented in the course and the relationship between them well
- coldcache 1y agoI find it difficult to think of examples that aren't just based on niche information (what did we talk about on this day? what analogy does the teacher make repeatedly?). Maybe multimodal stuff?
- pixl97 1y agoEven multimodal stuff is something is advancing pretty quickly. And with the more widespread incorporation of things like this, the information will be fed back into AI systems as training data making finding new things more difficult.
- lynx97 1y ago> where all you got was the outline of the island As a blind person I can't help but notice that this "innovative" question design is inherently inaccessible to people like me. Yes, I know I'm not the norm. However, I can't help but notice that this avoidance of text based assignments is making accessible teaching even more impossible. Say welcome to a new generation of Digital Divide.
- mantas 1y agoIt’d be bad if there was no alternative. But different people can get different assignments and that’s ok. Complaining about this is like me complaining about people drinking milk since I’m lactose intolerant.
- mootothemax 1y ago> It’d be bad if there was no alternative. But different people can get different assignments and that’s ok. While there are possibly noble goals behind your suggestion, in practise this puts anyone outside the mainstream in the category of “other,” people to be managed separately. I’ll leave to your imagination how much work is often put into supporting these “other” assignments and how up-to-date they’re kept va the mainstream. > Complaining about this is like me complaining about people drinking milk since I’m lactose intolerant. If this is genuinely your approach, you are being part of the problem; if taking a step back to reassess feels like too much work, I’d encourage you to explore why it feels that way, what emotions is this bringing up internally?
- imawakegnxoxo 1y agoI think "everyone gets the exact same test" is a whole level of hell worse than "everyone gets a test that makes sense for their abilities and goals" Are you just concerned about the administration side of things? I think the GP here has a pretty reasonable outlook here "Some people can't do some things the same way as others and that's ok, people are different" Is the vibe I got from that post
- fallingknife 1y agoEither the test must be the same for everybody or it is not a meaningful signal.
- mantas 1y agoYes. But there will always be an obscure case you can’t cover. Let’s say a test is written. Someone can’t write, but can dictate answers. Is it still the same test or not? On the other hand, how far can society tip-tap around such alternative takes? Could he go study in a field where hand writing is expected and society would still be forced to adapt?
- UncleMeat 1y ago> Designing "ChatGPT-proof assignments" feels to me like a similar level of intellectual challenge. This is indeed true. But a challenge is that few professors are being given the time and training to help do this. When you are on a 4/4 and just keeping your head above water you don't tend to have enough time to adopt experimental pedagogies and completely replan your courses. And professors are largely being tasked with doing this independently rather than having universities offer training or support with adjusting methods to be more AI resistant. And unfortunately the fast speed of development of these tools is making good ideas obsolete quickly. I know some people who switch to having students make podcasts rather than writing papers as a final assignment and then we started seeing "create your own podcast" tools appear and made it roughly as easy to cheat on this assignment as a traditional paper.
- simonw 1y agoMy suggestion here isn't to have the professors do this: it's for the professors to challenge their students to do this.
- UncleMeat 1y agoI am friends with an unusually large number of professors, many of which are at very top institutions. The "make your own pedagogy" approach for students leaves huge portions of the classroom doing zero work whatsoever.
- simonw 1y agoThats useful, thanks. Sounds like this approach won't help most students.
- fallingknife 1y agoWhat was the point of having those students in the classroom in the first place?
- tehjoker 1y ago
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- Zorass 1y ago[dead]
- ivape 1y ago“Cannot be done with chat gpt” Is a military base the only place “no devices” can be enforced or something? How deep is this addiction? I’m scared to ask what the academic version of fizz-buzz would be at the end of a 4 year degree, “hey write one paragraph describing a simple paradox, an example of irony, or an example of a metaphor”.
- pixl97 1y ago>Is a military base the only place “no devices” can be enforced or something? I mean with the force of law, yea. Businesses get away with a little bit more in places because they pay you to show up. But if you think anyone is going to university/college to have all their devices taken away all the time and pay for the privilege then you might be confused.
- cvwright 1y agoNo but people do pay universities for (among other things) a meaningful credential that testifies to their knowledge and abilities. If taking away phones is what’s required to make that credential meaningful again, then the universities must do it. I think of it like a personal trainer. Do you pay them to make you sweaty and sore? Not really, but sweat and soreness are consequences of doing what it takes to build muscle/endurance/etc.
- pixl97 1y ago>meaningful credential that testifies to their knowledge and abilities. No they don't, or at least a significant percentage of them don't. They pay the university because it is a paywall between them and even getting an interview in the first place.
- aydyn 1y agoBut that isnt a good long term strategy. If degrees hold no real signal, employers are going to start noticing and the value of a degree decreases. So its in universities best interest to actually test for competence. ... In theory.
- dleeftink 1y agoAmong others, Howard Rheingold has been active in this space. For those interested, check out the Peeragogy Handbook and the post that sparked the idea[0]. > The more I give my teacher-power to students and encourage them to take more responsibility for their own learning, the more they show me how to redesign my ways of teaching [0]: https://clalliance.org/blog/toward-peeragogy/ https://clalliance.org/blog/toward-peeragogy/
- dirkc 1y agoIt's fun to see how old that article is and that the ideas still apply! Power dynamics are not considered enough when people talk about education. My believe is that the more you balance the power dynamic, the more learning is prioritized over education.
- dleeftink 1y agoFor an even earlier account, see the learning networks described by Illich (1971) in the Deschooling Society [0]. [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deschooling_Society https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deschooling_Society
- homarp 1y agohttps://bsky.app/profile/hrheingold.bsky.social/post/3lprsquw6nc2f https://bsky.app/profile/hrheingold.bsky.social/post/3lprsqu... points to a compiled syllabus and links to recordings of lectures and video chats in a free pdf, about an "intro to cooperation studies": https://rheingold.com/texts/IntroToCooperationStudies.pdf https://rheingold.com/texts/IntroToCooperationStudies.pdf
- sampl3username 1y agoI am a zoomer. Is it really that hard for everyone to NOT use AI? Using AI very clearly atrophies your cognitive skills.
- sdenton4 1y agoI'm a millennial who has watched the complete failure of my generation to realize the promise of those Obama 'Hope' posters. "Everyone don't do X" runs into problems when there are clear incentives to do X. Like, say, grades which eventually will be used to determine who gets to graduate, who gets into which schools, who ultimately gets easier access to higher paying jobs. And simple convenience is an incentive in itself - if doing X saves time, it will be the default. This same dynamic is why we still have a climate crisis, even though everyone has known about the problem for thirty years. "Everyone just do Y" is what we call a collective action problem. When there are clear incentives to defect, it is also a free rider problem.
- exe34 1y agoReminds me of https://xkcd.com/810/ https://xkcd.com/810/
- yupitsme123 1y agoIf a teacher knows the topic that they're teaching, then a 30 second talk with a student is enough to determine if the student actually knows anything. Maybe "assignments" aren't the best method of building and verifying knowledge.
- lapcat 1y agoThat comment struck me as odd if only because Plato is not commonly part of the standard critical thinking curriculum. Introduction to philosophy or history of philosophy yes, but critical thinking no. This is not to say that Plato didn't think critically. Of course he did, as do all (or most) philosophers. I'm just talking about university courses and textbooks.
- aleph_minus_one 1y ago> Designing "ChatGPT-proof assignments" feels to me like a similar level of intellectual challenge. Designing a "mostly ChatGPT-proof class" is in my opinion actually rather simple: just be inspired by the German university system: Each week you have to complete exercise sheets which are often hard. But being capable of solving a certain quota of the exercises is just the beginning: this only qualifies you for being allowed to take the actual (oral or written) exam. In this sense (as many professors will tell you), the basically sole purpose of the quota for solving (often hard) exercise sheets is actually preventing students from the "self-inflicted harm" of doing an exam that they are not yet prepared for. And yes: while it is forbidden to "cheat" (e.g. ChatGPT) on your exercise sheets, this policy is typically not strongly enforced (you will nearly always just get a unequivocal, strongly worded oral reprimand by the tutor). Instead, if you did this, you will for sure not be prepared for the upcoming exam, and flunk it (and most students are very aware of this). Oh yeah, I didn't mention yet that if you flunked the same exam typically 3 times (depending on the university), you have "finally failed" (endgültig nicht bestanden), and are not allowed anymore to study the same degree course at every German university.
- oceanplexian 1y ago> I didn't mention yet that if you flunked the same exam typically 3 times (depending on the university), you have "finally failed" (endgültig nicht bestanden), and are not allowed anymore to study the same degree course at every German university. When Europeans wonder why they are falling behind the United States both economically and technologically (Especially in the AI race), here's a perfect example of why. A culture that turns you into a some kind of a permanent failure because you failed to check a box some arbitrary number of times isn't one that produces innovation.
- tstenner 1y agoOf course, the next European neighbor country where you can continue your studies (even taking most of your credits with you) is often only a few hundred kilometres away.
- 1y ago
- ModernMech 1y agoAs a professor of Computer Science, I'm about ready to allow my students to use AI -- if you can't beat 'em, join 'em. But they're not going to like it, because what I'm going to do is significantly raise the bar. For the last several years I've been allowing students (college sophomores) to do take home exams where they essentially have to build a networked system in C++. I tell them not to use AI but I have to assume they are. Even still, the solutions are not all that great, despite unlimited time and resources, they still submit work that falls into a roughly B average. Which, if they didn't have AI, maybe that would be a C average, so perhaps the standards just need to go up. Still, it's not like they're all getting 100%. AI is still really only as good as the person driving it, and it still, despite all the hype, hallucinates like crazy, such that if they don't pay close attention and constantly course correct, they can't expect the project to actually work.