3 ms·
Do Patients Without a Terminal Illness Have the Right to Die? Rights are not applicable here. How exactly would you stop them from self termination?
by Bender 1y ago
Do Patients Without a Terminal Illness Have the Right to Die?
Rights are not applicable here. How exactly would you stop them from self termination?
- jaoane 1y agoIt means whether we have to pay for their self termination.
- brokensegue 1y agonot really. it's whether it's legal for doctors to do it.
- Bender 1y agoAh well in that case I am indifferent. There are many painless low cost or free methods that I will not mention here. I hope those that are suffering know people that know what I know and do not get suckered into paying for some service. Medical businesses are not required. Either way a doctor would violate their oath by performing this whether it is legal or not.
- dns_snek 1y ago> Either way a doctor would violate their oath by performing this whether it is legal or not. Are you referring to "do no harm"? According to my own moral compass helping someone end their life with dignity is not doing harm, quite the opposite. You could even argue that leaving them suffering when you have the means, knowledge, and consent to help them is doing harm.
- add-sub-mul-div 1y agoIt's no more your business than what roads "you" pay for with your tax dollars, you may never use those roads but you are not the protagonist of reality.
- tanseydavid 1y agoPaying attention to (and caring about) the philosophical, moral and economic implications of our legal system does not require elevating oneself to the level "protagonist of reality." I don't know if I would even call that hyperbole.
- kbelder 1y ago>It's no more your business than what roads "you" pay for with your tax dollars Wow. It's your duty to just accelerate into abuse and corruption.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- echoangle 1y agoYou can put them in a closed facility and minimize their exposure to stuff they can harm themselves with (ropes, cables, strong fabrics, drugs). It’s not like this is unheard of.
- Bender 1y agoReagan closed most asylums in the US. While your statement is technically true how does that ease their suffering and not make it even worse?
- echoangle 1y agoI wasn’t talking about the US. And I also didn’t say that this is a good thing, I support a right to suicide. I was just saying that this is absolutely a right that the state can theoretically prevent with at least some success.
- tanseydavid 1y agoI think this is an issue where formalities and details really matter quite a lot. Of course, it is not possible to absolutely prevent anyone from self-terminating if they are sufficiently motivated but "self-termination" tends to have legal/criminal aspects attached to it. Thought experiment: if it is decided that a person without a Terminal Illness indeed has a right to die "would this or would this not completely negate something like an involuntary 5150 hold based on possible self-harm?" The more I think about it, the more this seems not just possible, but likely. I can only speak for myself but this seems like an unintended consequence.
- Bender 1y agoI think this is an easy thought experiment. If a person is considered a danger to others and not just themselves then involuntary hold is warranted given that the alternative often ends in termination by cop to protect the public. If they are only a danger to themselves then there would no longer be a need for involuntary hold if the only danger is truly just to themselves and in reality it isn't really even a danger given they consented to it whereas harm to the public can not be consented to. This is one of the rare cases where it is really their body, their choice.
- NoahZuniga 1y agoYou can't stop someone from stealing something. But it does make sense to say that people don't have the right to steal stuff. So the concept of rights clearly does still apply. Also, the concept of a right is very related to law. If you have the right to die, than it can't be criminal for someone to help you die.
- Bender 1y agoIf you steal the court can put you in jail or fine you. If you self terminate what would the court punish you with? I am assuming the person has already liquidated their assets and given it to whomever they choose. I do not believe the law has any bearing as it has no control. I believe the most they could do is yell at the moon.
- jmye 1y agoThe issue GP raised is the criminalization of “helpers” - e.g. a doctor administering lethal drugs. Certainly a law against suicide is irrelevant to someone who successfully uses a shotgun, alone in a field.