5 ms·
YouTube Is Swallowing TV Whole, and It's Coming for the Sitcom
- batch12 1y agohttps://archive.is/JpPIu https://archive.is/JpPIu
- drumhead 1y agoIt quite the Darwinian experiment isnt it. Thousands of new videos every day, some get popular, get copied and a new trend emerges. Before you know it millions are watching and it didnt even cost that much to do. Legacy TV companies must be so envious.
- matthewdgreen 1y agoAnd yet almost none of it has made it to legacy TV. I think Mr. Beast had some reality show on Amazon for a bit? You'd think legacy TV folks would be thrilled to grab up all this great cheap content and throw it on their platforms, but I see very little of it.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> You'd think legacy TV folks would be thrilled to grab up all this great cheap content and throw it on their platforms This reduces them to YouTube wrappers. A risky strategic position with advertisers, viewers and investors.
- matthewdgreen 1y agoBut YouTube doesn’t own the content, they’re just a platform. I’m surprised I don’t see all these famous influencers showing up in mass-broadcast culture, having their faces plastered on billboards, etc. the way traditional celebrities are.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> YouTube doesn’t own the content, they’re just a platform They own the distribution. That's arguably a more-powerful position than owning a small piece of IP.
- matthewdgreen 1y agoMy point is that the IP is also valuable. So why aren't the owners of the IP taking that IP and leveraging it into valuable properties on other media? I can only think of a tiny number of examples where this happened. This wouldn't even require them to give up their YouTube streaming business, because it's not like YouTube is forcing creators to sign exclusive streaming deals (are they?)
- elif 1y agoMr beast "had some reality show on Amazon" he released a season of a reality show which broke many world records and got renewed with a larger budget for two more seasons. But the path was paved way before last year. Think of how many podcasts started as one person on YouTube and became major multiplatform productions with dozens of creatives. If "reality" isn't your thing plenty of narrative fiction has been picked up by Netflix and HBO, Cobra Kai probably the most recognizable but also maybe you've seen broad city or workaholics. In journalism we've seen Channel 5 get at least one HBO deal, etc But I think you'll find that the majority of these creators are making enough revenue on YouTube that these deals are more an optional way to grow their audience than "the next step"
- eptcyka 1y agoWho would want to be featured on legacy television these days?
- spacedcowboy 1y agoNot for me it’s not. YouTube is useful for things like “how to build a giant 3D printer” or “compare this CNC machine with that one”. It’s ok for a general place to link a video to (though I generally just put them on my own server”. It absolutely sucks at entertainment. And the reason it sucks so badly at entertainment is just greed - I tried the free trial of YouTube Premium this last month, because the one thing I loathe about YouTube over everything else is the number of adverts, and ‘premium’ promises an ad-free experience. But no, this sucks too, it just sucks slightly less. You still get loads of ads in ‘premium’ except they’re called ‘sponsored content’. That’s just sophistry and frankly makes me dislike the platform even more. I hate being lied to as well as forced to watch ads (sometimes the whole thing, sometimes there’s a ‘skip’ button after 30 secs or so.) I can put up with this shit when it’s some instructional video, when I can mentally ignore whatever crap someone is trying to sell me for 30 secs or so. I cannot and will not put up with it when I want to be entertained. Ads ruin the entire entertainment experience. If traditional TV is having its lunch eaten by YouTube, then I guess I start watching less TV, or subscribe to Apple TV+ / movie-streaming services (without ads). There’s a lot to do in this life, TV is not a requirement…
- perching_aix 1y agoThe sponsored content thing is not really a YouTube problem, unless you're of the opinion they should offer circumvention for it and/or ban it altogether. It's on the individual creator. You can install Sponsorblock to get rid of them (in the browser). Works like a charm, is reliable, YT isn't interested in fighting it, trivial to set up.
- j1elo 1y agoThe way I see it, it's 100% crystal clear that YouTube should be asking creators to register the timestamp ranges of their sponsored blocks when uploading a new video, in order to make their Premium subscribers to automatically skip them, as part of the premium they are paying.
- temporallobe 1y agoI’m a YouTube premium subscriber. It is absolutely a YouTube problem because content creators are blatantly bypassing the entire “ad-free” experience with impunity. And nobody can convince me with any clever wordsmithing that “sponsored content” is not an advertisement. It would be the same as saying those happy-ending massage parlors are not prostitution or that OF is not porn. And by the way, YouTube’s own TOS and other related literature make no distinction between these two types of ads; in fact the language is pretty broad because it says “ad-free experience” and makes no distinction between non-skippable ads and so-called sponsored content. Content creators reap the benefits by essentially double-dipping while YouTube looks the other way, because, I would assume, it has no legal or financial impact on them. I put up with some of it because I really enjoy certain channels, but in other cases I have simply unsubscribed and have stopped engaging. I have nothing against ads or making money in principle, but I detest being deceived and gaslighted, especially when I am paying for something.
- mjburgess 1y agoThere's a plausible argument that advertisement killed "mainstream media" as a mass media. It survived only while there were no other options, giving the illusion of genuine mass appeal. The reality is it was an entirely fake constructed world designed by advertisers, and to some lesser degree, the political class: governments in the TV age pressed hard to ensure the public never got what it wanted (consider, eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-Code_Hollywood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-Code_Hollywood). It seems we are roughly in a place where power has equilibrated between creators giving the people what they want: advertisers have no choice but to go to mass media platforms, because one's under their control are dead. And "free speech" is increasingly been given an ahistorical radically liberal interpretation. Thus we can have multi-hour podcasts with politicians asked real questions on the audiences mind; we can have companies held to account for the real quality of their products; films, games, and other media can be reviewed by people who share the tastes of their audiences -- rather than have their tastes "made" by the nominated ad-friendly elite. The whole traditional media ecosystem, of course, is in a full-blown panic about this -- and continues to blame the new media and their audiences (their customers, whom they long forgot existed as anything other than domesticated animals that will turn up to the only game in town). It's hard to tell how many involved realise they are purely a construct of an advertised-determined, government-sanctioned world -- a world that almost no one ever actually lived in. My great concern with the "YT is being TV" direction is that this history repeats. Just as facebook (etc.) centralised and ad-santisied the "local, independent" internet -- so will, YT/spotify/etc. just return the mass media back into advertiser hands. Many will say: this has already happened, etc. But I think: not quite. I think at the moment it feels like a balance. One hopes the internet stays free enough, in protocol, that if advertisers (and governments) try again to dominate and control the mass media, there are ready-made alternatives to spring up.
- diggan 1y agoToday I was gonna watch a ~14 minute video on YouTube while having a quick lunch. After the 1:30 mark, YouTube showed me a five second ad. Fair enough. After 4 minutes, it served me a 30 seconds ad, bit less fun, but fine, YouTube gotta get theirs also. After 6 minutes they showed me a 1 minute ad, and now I started getting frustrated. At the 7 minute mark they tried to show me another 1 minute ad, but at that point I just shut off the TV as it's just too frustrating when they're trying to shove in as much ad-time as there is real-content-time. One of the initial reasons YouTube was better than TV was because it lacked so much ads everywhere. Same for the streaming services. They're quite literally shooting themselves in the foot with adding so much ads... Now my fingers are itching to build a tiny little service for myself, where I can have a bunch of YouTube channels in a .txt file, and have yt-dlp iterate over them once a day and add automatically to Jellyfin, or something similar, almost solely out of spite. Realistically, I'll probably just avoid YouTube on the TV for a week, until I forget how painful that experience is.
- adingus 1y agoIt's rich for a TV exec to call YouTube 'slop'. Compared to traditional TV, where 1/3rd or more of your time is spent watching ads for prescription drugs or fake silver coins, the YouTubers I watch put much more thought and artistic energy into what they produce than the laugh track trash on TV.
- throwaway290 1y agoYou skipped the part about how much of your time is spent watching ads on Youtube? If zero and you've got UBO on then you are stealing revenue from your favourite YouTubers who put so much thought and artistic energy into what they produce
- 9x39 1y agoIt’s zero but we paid for YT Premium which splits revenue with creators.
- tialaramex 1y agoYoutube Premium actually pays the Youtubers similar or possibly slightly better than running Youtube advertising and I don't watch ads to fund that, I pay them money. I guess you could argue that the stuff where Hank Green is telling me to consider buying a crash course coin is advertising? But by the same token arguably watching Carl Sagan play Blue Prince is advertising how great Carl is? Where are we drawing the line here?
- throwaway290 1y agoNo I wouldn't argue that, it's fair. Promotions or product placement and that stuff are everywhere and no place is special in that. But I bet the guy I replied to doesn't actually pay for premium. Most people who say "TV sucks because ads and YT is great because no ads and creators braining" mean that they can block ads on YT and those brainy creators can deliver stuff to them for free, so it's totally better than TV yeah. like it's "better" if you can steal stuff than if you have to pay for it)
- jmclnx 1y agoI noticed more ads on YouTube recently, a small say 10 minute clip could have a 3 minute add at the start and in the middle. Plus I think the young likes the small clip type content than traditional entertainment. Just look at ticktoc (I never use it) how it is dragging all the young people to their content. I an curious about seeing an age breakdown, but that is hard to get.
- mathgeek 1y ago> I an curious about seeing an age breakdown, but that is hard to get. Not difficult as all, as there are plenty of studies and research in the area. Quick google gets a bunch of results, and of course you can ask Perplexity or any LLM that has research capability.
- otherayden 1y agohttps://unbloq.us/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-05-28/youtube-creators-compete-with-hollywood-studio-sitcoms https://unbloq.us/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/20... I made this auto-redirect tool that automatically redirects you to a site's archive link :)
- GeekyBear 1y agoAs someone who used to enjoy the History Channel before it went downhill, that sort of more educational content is on YouTube now, but not on cable.
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoAnd you can find videos that fit exactly your audience type, your conspiracy belief, and your specific alt-history fetish. I find a lot of nonsense alt-history entertainment, but much less unbiased, un-audience captured actual history. And those that are unbiased quickly get attacked, pushing them to some opposite extreme than their attacked, attracting an audience drawn to that pushback and boom, another audience captured creator.
- GeekyBear 1y agoGive Fall of Civilizations a try. It is original content and well done. https://www.youtube.com/@FallofCivilizations https://www.youtube.com/@FallofCivilizations
- darknavi 1y agoShout out to high quality, more independent "TV" media like Dropout (ex College Humor). https://www.dropout.tv https://www.dropout.tv
- qoez 1y agoIs it actually funny though?
- null_deref 1y agoIf you like improvisation, some shows there are pretty good in that aspect
- tecleandor 1y agoAnd I have to say that I don't like the 'improv' stuff just in general, but this people is REALLY good.
- tecleandor 1y agoI've been been having a lot of fun with their Game Changer series and some chapters of Very Important People and Smartypants. Of course, it has to be your thing (and not all their productions are "my thing"), but I find it well produced and handled with certain love for the product and people working there.
- mathgeek 1y agoThankfully Comcast’s minor holding in Dropout hasn’t resulted in anything too terrible thus far.
- perching_aix 1y ago> PewDiePie (...) was later accused of inspiring White nationalist shooting rampages. What a bizarre and vile characterization. You know it damn well that's bollocks. Cracking some edgy jokes doesn't mean you're suddenly responsible for some insane asshole shouting you out before committing genocide. Absurd. Never ceases to disgust me when media reports on the story like this.
- jccalhoun 1y agoI teach at a community college and unless it is sports, most people, especially (but not limited to) young people, don't watch much tv or movies at all. I try to give examples from current tv shows and rarely have any of the students seen them.
- jajko 1y agoWho watches stuff like Wednesday or even a better example, Stranger things? These are not series my parents would (want to) watch. These are primarily aimed at teens/tweens IMHO. The list of such shows is very long, pulling them out randomly since I just saw trailers for next seasons. Maybe your students are somehow outliers?
- smoovb 1y agoAds are now my pet peeve. I will not tolerate them. Let me pay for content I want.
- nickthegreek 1y agoyou can pay youtube to remove their ads.
- lif 1y agoAm curious about what true competition Youtube has. (And if the answer is "essentially none", then when is Youtube going to be broken up?)
- varsketiz 1y agoNetflix, TikTok
- chloe000 1y ago[dead]
- cadamsdotcom 1y agoRecently sold my TV after not switching it on for 5-6 months. There’s lots to do outdoors. You can spend your TV subscription money on equipment for whatever hobby you enjoy. Plus, it’s (currently) hard for commercial interests to enshittify the patches of the world we’ve demarcated as public spaces.