5 ms·
If I could choose to have children again, I wouldn't. Not because of them; because of me, and the world. But they are here, so the only path is forward. Geopoli
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
If I could choose to have children again, I wouldn't. Not because of them; because of me, and the world. But they are here, so the only path is forward. Geopolitical turmoil, climate change, the future is high volatility imho. Growth and the "good times" are over because of demographics and populism, balkanization is highly probable.
We have living arrangements both in the US and Western Europe. I hope to be able to get my kids EU citizenship eventually with various visas and residency. If the US improves, they can come back. If it doesn't, they can remain in Europe as they approach adulthood. Nationalism is silly, you'll get dragged by the median electorate. We/they are not Americans, or Europeans; we are just humans looking for community with other good humans with some sense of community and collectivism.
After failing hard earlier in life, I became risk adverse, but also have had some success. I hope to have enough investments by the time I stop working that my kids can survive without working if needed. I also hope I have provided them enough resources and life skills to live a good life after I'm gone until they're gone. This is my apology to them for their existence in this macro, I hope they accept it, and failing that, at least understand it.
You can't change the winds, you can only adjust your sails. Optimize for optionality. Better to have a plan you don't need than to need a plan you don't have. No one is coming to save us.
> So, if you can put your hatred aside for a few minutes. What are your ideas on what the US, Europe and Latin America can do to survive what's in the horizon?
Build for capability and security, not profit. Build so you can build when you need to build, build and protect the machine that builds the machines. Not hopeful, but that is the advice. Everything else is people, politics, policy, and capital to make that happen. "A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they will never sit in."
- unsupp0rted 1y ago> If I could choose to have children again, I wouldn't. A lot of people aren't willing to admit this publicly, or even privately to themselves.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoMy ego is dead, I am emotionally healthy and actualized, and in a few decades we'll all be gone and none of this will have mattered. I cannot speak for others, but I will speak the truth for me. If a compliment, thank you. I hope it encourages others to be more honest with themselves.
- perrygeo 1y agoGrowth and the good times are over because the resources that provided that growth are dwindling. Peak oil is almost certainly behind us and everyone knows it, shifting their foreign policy accordingly. Recent events have laid bare that there's no facade of "manifest destiny" or ideology behind it... it's just naked aggression, scrambling for a bigger slice of the shrinking pie. If it were just a shrinking energy/resource base, we could muddle through and build a better political system. Same with climate change. And biodiversity loss. And chemical pollution. And global nuclear warfare. And the decay of social morality. All of these things are solvable in themselves, but in aggregate I think we're running into harsh economic realities that we might not be able to solve all of it at the same time.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoNot to go to far off topic, but from an energy perspective, I'm not worried. We're about to hit 1TW/year in global solar deployment, batteries are following fast behind that. My concern is what happens when stakeholders deeply entrenched in the petro economy start to fail (Russia, Middle East, etc), as well as the lagging impact of climate change; we're on escape trajectory with regards to clean energy and electrification, but climate change mitigation will still cost trillions, and the resulting climate changes will be felt by those existing over at least the next century (assuming humans discover an efficient, inexpensive greenhouse gas sequestration mechanism and a reversal can be engineered). Energy abundance is coming, but the transition and disruption will be messy. https://rmi.org/insight/x-change-the-race-to-the-top/ https://rmi.org/insight/x-change-the-race-to-the-top/ Demographics dynamics is where the pain will come from. https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/dependency-and-depopulation-confronting-the-consequences-of-a-new-demographic-reality https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/dependency-and-dep... https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-42657-6 https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-42657-6 https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/spring/summer-2018/demographics-their-implications-economy-policy https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/spring/summer-2018/demogra...
- perrygeo 1y agoThose machines don't provide energy, they simply capture it. We get our energy from solar radiation, either directly or stored in underground carbon bonds. We burned through our oil reserves, which represent the solar energy of millions of years of photosynthetic capacity, in a few centuries. And demand keeps growing. How do you intend to maintain and continue growing the energy supply without access to fossil fuels? Reverting to an annual energy budget determined by the sun is a fundamentally different game to having millions of years of energy at our match tip. It's the difference between living on a fixed income vs drawing down a savings account. And as we draw down our savings account (burn oil) to invest in our fixed income future (solar) we should not fool ourselves into thinking this means an infinite savings account. Whether we draw our savings to zero or plan wisely for fixed-income, either way we are looking at decreased energy availability, aka degrowth.
- chistev 1y ago> After failing hard earlier in life, I became risk adverse, but also have had some success. I hope to have enough investments by the time I stop working that my kids can survive without working if needed. I also hope I have provided them enough resources and life skills to live a good life after I'm good until they're gone. This is my apology to them for their existence in this macro, I hope they accept it, and failing that, at least understand it. I like this.
- JohnFen 1y ago> If I could choose to have children again, I wouldn't. I agree. I feel that I've done my children a disservice by bringing them into the world as it is. I just didn't know this is how things would go.
- dardeaup 1y agoWhen would have been a good time to bring children into the world? There has never been a perfect time and there never will be. Billy Joel's 1989 song 'We didn't start the fire' addresses the idea that the past wasn't always better than the present.
- JohnFen 1y agoOf course there's never been a perfect time. Every time has its problems. But the ones we're facing now are greater than at any time in my life, and we're not only failing to address them, we seem to be intent on making them worse. The world my children are inheriting is a substantially worse one that the world I inherited.
- Whoppertime 1y agoI would have been more worried if I lived through 1939-1945, or the Cuban Missile Crisis. Kids going duck and cover under their desk. Nuclear exchange seemed inevitable. And yet the cold war never went hot. The experts of the 1960s didn't see the Soviet Unions collapse in the 1990s coming. We may find the inevitability of climate apocalypse as inevitable as nuclear apocalypse with the Soviet Union turned out to be
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- burnt-resistor 1y agoLife involves some measure of suffering, but also an opportunity for existence, love, and joy. Denying that completely is absurd and an incel attitude. I saw the handwriting on the wall 30 years ago, but couldn't say what form it would take. I knew that prices of things would go up, wages and employment would decline, and misery would increase over time. I think there may be some very large scale (conventional, hopefully) wars and billions of people migrating as climate refugees within the next 5-25 years. Imagine Gaza but it's entirely possible Putin will not be stopped and the MAGA movement leaders will emulate Bibi and Putin in terms of war-making. It's also probable that even more brutal, repressive, and self-destructive future leaders in the spirit of Nero and Caligula will emerge. None of this is set in stone. Fate doesn't exist. Nothing bad has to happen. We can choose to reorganize and change attitudes if we are willing to be steadfast with solidarity.
- jonasft 1y agoIronically, this kind of mindset just makes the demographic freight train of population collapse even worse. The best thing you can do for society rn is to keep making babies, so that the population doesn’t collapse faster than we can handle