7 ms·
Prohibition and ice cream in the US Navy
- potato3732842 1y agoAmericans replaced alcohol with sweets, generally. There's a reason a huge fraction of the modern candies and confections either got their start or took on their modern forms during this era. Prohibition is probably single handedly responsible for more of the "processed sweet junk" in the American diet than any other singular policy. It really is the gift that keeps on giving. That said, ice cream is aa highly underrated dessert and I have a hard time thinking of a better item to have available on un-air conditioned ships in a tropical environment, absolutely on par with a cold beer.
- cco 1y agoI refer to this as "hedonic exchange", the idea that there is a base rate of hedonic drive that animals tend to satisfy and that this drive is mostly fungible. You see this in the data for smoking as well, as smoking decreases, you tend to see caloric intake and obesity rise at the population level.
- nemomarx 1y agosome of that could be nicotine appetite suppression, right?
- Reasoning 1y ago> You see this in the data for smoking as well, as smoking decreases, you tend to see caloric intake and obesity rise at the population level. Nicotine is an appetite suppressor so that relationship is probably pretty direct.
- kayodelycaon 1y agoNicotine reduces appetite.
- Spooky23 1y agoIt’s also something to do.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- timewizard 1y ago> that there is a base rate of hedonic drive I think there's an individual rate. I highly doubt there is a "base rate" for groups overall. I also think environmental factors play a huge part in prevalence.
- losteric 1y agoPerhaps we’re trading different stress/anxiety coping mechanisms?
- keybored 1y agoThat looks like a technical term but (only) you specifically use it?
- asdff 1y agoI see this readily with my cats too. Give them a treat, they gobble it down instantly then look up at you and yell for another one. Next day and they are sitting by the cabinet they saw you put the bag in and yelling for more treats. The most shrill and pitiful yells too. There is zero self control because out in the wild, self control means you don't survive. You eat all the calories that show up in front of you. You can't afford to be choosy. The idea of abundance comes at direct odds with how we are wired in survival settings, and it's no surprise we struggle with obesity as a result. Selection has not factored in the availability of a gas station on every corner full of dopamine hits for a few dollars.
- senkora 1y agoYou might like the book "The Age of Addiction, How Bad Habits Became Big Business" by David T. Courtwright. It talks about substitutability of pleasures, among other things. The most interesting idea that I took from it was the idea of "blending" and "intensifying" of pleasures over time. For example, with alcohol. Initially humans had fermented fruits, then beer and wine, then distilled alcohol. The pleasurable substance was refined over time and the pleasure was intensified. In parallel, humans blended together multiple pleasures at once, for example combining alcohol with milkshakes or making sugary cocktails. The book makes a strong case that this process of refining, intensifying, trading, and blending pleasures has been a constant force throughout civilization, and it applies the same argument to the internet and social media.
- Spooky23 1y agoI’m curious as to the impact of weed. I live in a college town — the bars are empty. Everyone is home sparking up.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- steviedotboston 1y agoI quit drinking a couple years ago and my ice cream consumption went way up.
- nimbius 1y agothis is definitely not a tradition still practiced. if you want ice cream youd better hope its being served at the chow line (it absolutely isnt, unless youre on a submarine) or youre going to the Nexcom ship store to pick up a knock-off magnum bar in exchange for quite a lot of your real money.
- yamazakiwi 1y agoMy Ship Store only had Yoohoo's, Monster's, and Uniform Items.
- badc0ffee 1y agoI'm wondering who's out there underrating ice cream.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Avshalom 1y agoIce cream is, culturally, a things kids eat because they like sugar, not a thing adults savor because it's fucking sublime.
- dylan604 1y agothose are broken adults.
- quesera 1y agoI have never seen an adult disdain ice cream. We just eat the better stuff.
- THroaway225 1y agoactually ice cream sandwiches are known as a "dad thing"
- dylan604 1y agothe lactose intolerant. people with teeth that ache with cold. people concerned about sugar/fat intake. i can think of a lot of people that underrate ice cream. it doesn't make them sane though.
- bluGill 1y agoThere is lactose or sugar free ice cream if you need them
- themadturk 1y agoAs a type-2 diabetic, I pretty much avoid ice cream. Now and then my wife insists on a stop at Dairy Queen, so I do indulge in an ice cream cone the, and she will often give me a spoonful of ice cream at home (Tillamook Oregon Strawberry...yum). Sugar-free ice creams seem to have largely disappeared in the Pacific Northwest. Dreyers or Haagen-Daaz (don't remember which) used to have one or two varieties regularly, but not anymore. Most others are in expensive pint sizes (Ben & Jerry's sized, but even more expensive).
- senkora 1y agoProhibition also had the effect of largely killing off the small breweries started by various immigrant groups in the United States. When it ended, the industry rapidly consolidated around the large-scale industrial breweries which have dominated the market ever since. This is a big reason why the beer industry in America is weird. You have large mass-market brewers on the hand one, and small craft brewers making more creative beers on the other hand, but you don't have many medium-sized brewers making high-quality traditional beers. It's pretty hard to compete with Europe in that segment.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Prohibition also had the effect of largely killing off the small breweries started by various immigrant groups in the United States Same for wine production. Beringer, Mondavi...these were families who secured sacramental wine contracts from the Church.
- dfxm12 1y agoBooze is regulated unevenly from state to state, which is a weird aspect in America that could make it hard to grow depending on where you are in the country. Outside of that though, I don't think prohibition has too much of the blame as consolidation is the natural conclusion under capitalism. Breweries that get to a certain level get bought out by multinational corporations. I was in Asheville, NC a few years ago. It was kinda funny to me that one mark of fancy restaurants was to boast about their pre-ABInBev Wicked Weed bottle lists (I'm more a fan of Burial Beer either way).
- Spooky23 1y agoIt’s a different time scale. The microbreweries of the 90s were an upstart. In the 70s and early 80s, you probably had a half dozen SKUs account for 90% of volume. My grandfather ran a busy bar in Brooklyn and had like 4 beers on tap. The other thing was post prohibition ABC laws usually gave distributors a lot of power. They had exclusivity agreements and would stuff the channel or segment the market as they saw fit. Grandpa’s bar was Reingold and Schaeffer. Microbrews went crazy in the 90s, and the big brewers bought and created brands to regain share. Then cheap capital led to M&A by bigger fish.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- keybored 1y agoHigh fructose corn syrup and subsidies? Hm maybe not.
- AStonesThrow 1y agoAs children, we loved to partake of Grandma’s supply of Sen-Sen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sen-Sen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sen-Sen It was much later that I learned that it was one of the powerful breath mints which people often used to cover-up after drinking booze. [Grandma didn't drink! I don't think that Grandpa did, either. Their house never had alcoholic drinks or anything else related.]
- selimthegrim 1y agoThis puts the police chief in the Hardy Boys in a whole new light.
- euroderf 1y agoOK, that explains Sen-Sen. They didn't really seem to be an actual candy.
- abeppu 1y agoConcurrent with the WWII ice cream barges, the Navy _did_ actually have a lot of alcohol but really didn't want anyone to drink it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torpedo_juice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torpedo_juice
- sidewndr46 1y agoAt least one Soviet aircraft doubled as a flying bar https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5xygj1MOIdo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5xygj1MOIdo
- SoftTalker 1y agoDidn't they also have an exception for "medicinal" use? I wonder how often the pharmacist's mate was called upon for a prescription?
- EA-3167 1y agoLovely little article, a good story and some interesting history. My grandfather fought in WWII in the Pacific, in the Navy, and he was the only guy on board who couldn't stand the ice cream. Turns out he was a skinny kid and his grandmother made him drink milkshakes to fatten him up, even when he REALLY didn't want to touch them; so a lifelong aversion to ice cream was born. Oh, and Max Miller of 'Tasting History' fame has a very entertaining video on this very topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qiyo8D0nH70 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qiyo8D0nH70
- ceejayoz 1y agoThere's a possibly apocryphal story about a Japanese higher-up who realized the war was lost when the ice cream barges showed up, because the Allies had that much spare resources for a treat while the Japanese troops were starving in the jungles.
- wagwang 1y agothats what happens when you have 1 support unit per in field troop instead of 36.
- teachrdan 1y agoI've heard the same said about German POWs in WWII. Towards the end of the war, when they were served tea and biscuits while their comrades in the field starved, they knew the British (and Allies more generally) were going to win.
- carabiner 1y agoThere's also the version with the NY cheesecake.
- idontwantthis 1y agoI heard of a Boston Apple Pie.
- ashoeafoot 1y agoThe absence of horses
- rasz 1y agorussians are running donkeys nowadays in Ukraine, doesnt seem to break their morale at all
- _carbyau_ 1y agoAt it's heart a battle is a logistic operation to make an impact. A battle rifle fired bullet is a delivery; working back from that bullet as to how it got fired reveals a "tyranny of the rocket equation" kind of logistics. If your opposition has something as basic as food while you don't. Well, logistics is broken == "ability to make an impact" is broken
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- yamazakiwi 1y agoI was on an Australian Navy ship in 2008 and they could still have beer then. They were also paid different by job which I found interesting. I remember hearing a lot of stories about "the good old days" when people would drink and smoke weed or opium on ships. When I was in, alcohol and drugs had been replaced by Monster energy drinks. I don't remember getting ice cream while deployed.
- stackskipton 1y ago>I was also surprised to learn that they were paid differently by job. US does this in roundabout way. Medical officers have various Special Pay along with Flight Pay, Flight Deck pay and so forth. Not to mention various bonuses for various ratings that have come and gone. It makes sense from manning standpoint since certain ratings will have siren call of civilian jobs compared to others. (ITS, CTN vs YN, RS)
- yamazakiwi 1y ago>US does this in roundabout way. Medical officers have various Special Pay along with Flight Pay, Flight Deck pay and so forth. Everyone gets various special pay depending on their command and those don't compare to the Australians varying pay largely by role. >It makes sense from manning standpoint since certain ratings will have siren call of civilian jobs compared to others. (ITS, CTN vs YN, RS) I'm not sure what you mean by this. If you are deployed on a ship then everyone has "siren calls". All 4 of those rates earn the same money and get additional pay for command based increases unrelated to their rate specifically.
- stackskipton 1y ago>Everyone gets various special pay depending on their command and those don't compare to the Australians varying pay largely by role. What special pay? Sea Pay or Hazardous Duty pay? That's obviously location based incentives and not rating based compared to Flight Duty pay, though that's consider "Hazard Pay" >I'm not sure what you mean by this. If you are deployed on a ship then everyone has "siren calls". All 4 of those rates earn the same money and get additional pay for command based increases unrelated to their rate specifically. Siren call of much higher job prospects with a ton more money for ITS/CTN compared to YN or RS.
- psunavy03 1y agoTwo beers per head are still authorized after 45 days underway when there's no port call scheduled in the next two weeks. But they still make a bureaucratic circus out of it to avoid hoarding and trading. They crack the beers before they give them to you so you can't stash them.
- cabinguy 1y agoI had that happen once in my three years in the fleet and they didn’t open them for us (long time ago). We did have kegs & BBQ on the pier in GITMO once, too (“pigs on the pier”). I was in when they were just starting a/the tobacco ban on the ship. You could smoke them, but you couldn’t buy them . It created an excellent black market opportunity for entrepreneurs onboard. Last fun fact - my ship was catered by Krispy Kreme donuts every morning when we were in port - long, long before they were a nationwide brand.
- hatsunearu 1y agois it 2 beers per day?
- yamazakiwi 1y agoOnce, per deployment that meets that requirement
- adriand 1y agoOf all the reasons I would not enlist in the military, this one never occurred to me, but it is now probably in my top five.
- IncreasePosts 1y agoHow far we've regressed. 400 years ago you would get a gallon of beer per day if you were a sailor.
- 1y ago
- arbuge 1y ago> Ice cream was important for morale. In 1942, the U.S.S. Lexington was slowly sinking from a Japanese torpedo attack, before the crew abandoned ship, they broke into the freezer and ate all the ice cream. Survivors describe scooping ice cream into their helmets and licking them clean before lowering themselves into the Pacific. TIL...
- defen 1y agoCompare to the wreck of the HMS Wager in 1741, where some of the crew broke into the spirit room, got drunk, and drowned when the ship went down.
- EvanAnderson 1y agoFor anybody not familiar with the HMS Wager and the subsequent story the Damn Interesting podcast did a nice episode about it: https://www.damninteresting.com/dead-reckoning/ https://www.damninteresting.com/dead-reckoning/
- asdff 1y agoI'm reminded of that scene in The Master where Joaquin Phoenix gets his hooch directly from the torpedos on his ship.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- zabzonk 1y agoIt's gone from the Royal Navy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rum_ration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rum_ration along (one perhaps hopes) with "sodomy and the lash".
- rjsw 1y agoThere is still beer on Royal Navy ships.
- forgotusername6 1y agoThree cans a day
- dmurray 1y agoActually, one of those things was brought back in in 2000.
- tetris11 1y agoConversely, Chris Spargot did a great video about government-run pubs during WW2 in Britain, where the government offered good wages to workers who would help make shells, and then recruited all the local barkeepers under a decent steady wage to stop the workers from bribing the barman to give them more alcohol. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pyijHCkW3xc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pyijHCkW3xc
- jdross 1y agoTrue story: My great uncle was a secretary to General MacArthur during world world 2, and one of his jobs was to source and procure ice cream to the front for the general and the troops.
- create-username 1y agoIt’s always a good moment to remember that it must still be proven that ice creams are not good for your health. The nutritionists who have tried to prove that evident theory have all admitted that the health benefits of the ice cream are akin to those of the yogurt. Edit: even though, I’m avoiding emulsifiers like e-471, e-472 and so on. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35562705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35562705
- nartho 1y agoI believe that excess sugar would be the issue, Yogurt contains no sugar
- create-username 1y agoYes. Maybe eaten sugar is less harmful than drinking it. That’s what the latest evidence suggests
- nartho 1y agoIn the case of ice cream, do you really eat it or drink it though ?
- themadturk 1y agoDepends on the yogurt. Many commercial yogurts in the US have added sugar.
- GJim 1y agoSomehow, Americans adding sugar to yogurt doesn't surprise me.
- n2d4 1y ago> The nutritionists who have tried to prove that evident theory have all admitted that the health benefits of the ice cream are akin to those of the yogurt. That doesn't sound like they "admitted" to anything. It can at the same time have the health benefits of yogurt, and be bad for you. In the particular case of ice cream, what makes you think it's healthy despite the high calorie and sugar content? All I could find was a study from 2018 [0], which specifically investigated diabetes 2 patients (who are very conscious about their sugar intake) and didn't control for the rest of their diet. Any claim that the amounts of sugar in ice cream are net beneficial for you will need extraordinary amounts of evidence. [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2023/05/ice-cream-bad-for-you-health-study/673487/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2023/05/ice-cre...
- former_navy_843 1y agoOfficially, the Navy switched from alcohol to ice cream. Unofficially, when I served in the US Navy in the 2000s I was surrounded by the most extreme levels of alcohol consumption I'd ever seen, by far. In the US Navy today, on any ship you will find people who get blackout drunk several nights per week every week. Junior and senior. The Chief of the Boat on my submarine regularly showed up to work drunk, haven driven himself to work. The Topside Watch reported him multiple times and it was always swept under the rug. We had nuclear reactor operators who snuck bottles of liquor onto the ship to drink while at sea. It was standard practice for Chiefs to take their divisions to bars and pay for their drinks all night so they could be drunk and immobile under Chief's supervision instead of drunk and mobile out in public. Our head Engineering Officer made a joke one day how it wasn't a problem that one of the reactor operators was drunk because "this is nothing new, we always start the reactor up drunk during WestPac". Extreme alcoholism is still rampant in the US Navy, and that includes among the people who operate the nuclear power plants and the people who guard the nuclear weapons. But yes, they also have ice cream now.
- codyb 1y agoJust wrapped up reading "The British are Coming" by Rick Atkinson (great book!) about the start of the American Revolution and half the letters from the generals were in request for or talked of shipments of rum and mead and wine. Many captured soldiers were just the ones too drunk to flee when they needed to. It was a brutal endeavor. They did not have ice cream.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- yamazakiwi 1y agoWhile everything you said does happen, it is not everyone, nor is it every command. In my 4 years we never had a single sailor show up to work drunk at my command, even once. They would be reprimanded. They might showup hungover sure, but not drunk. I did hear stories from other ships about a few high ranking officers showing up to base drunk but those were isolated incidents. I never talked to anyone who had ever snuck alcohol on the ship and I was cool with everyone. I was on a destroyer so maybe on a larger ship this is easier to get away with. I myself had my Liberty removed for 6 months because some kid who was not invited to our party stole 2 bottles of alcohol from us and got blackout. We found him in the beach bathroom passed out on the ground and had to physically carry him for a 45 minute walk back to base. He was in the hospital for 3 days. We lost our privilege to leave the ship for 6 months. Let's be honest. Being in the Navy is terrible, alcohol is the way the culture copes with how terrible it is. You experience so much bullshit that the only thing that keeps you going is the idea that one day you'll get back to land and be able to get wasted. The problem is you can't drink or celebrate at sea so people go overboard once they get back on land. Yeah people get too drunk and drink too much, but so do college kids, which are the same age as many of these sailors.
- HacklesRaised 1y agoRum, sodomy and the lash, there's no other way. Yarrrggghh!!
- lupusreal 1y agoThe USS Olympia had refrigeration and ice cream before alcohol was banned, so I'm not sure I totally buy the supposed relationship between the two.
- devrandoom 1y agoSailors in WWII drank the fuel for the torpedos, which happened to be clean ethanol. https://www.adn.com/alaska-life/2024/12/15/torpedo-juice-the-legendary-illegal-world-war-ii-liquor-drunk-in-alaska-and-across-the-world/ https://www.adn.com/alaska-life/2024/12/15/torpedo-juice-the...