7 ms·
Authors are accidentally leaving AI prompts in their novels
- qgin 1y agoWhen you vibe author a book, don’t forget to vibe edit the book too. Legitimately, an LLM would have caught these.
- mcv 1y agoIs it really too much to ask that a human has a look at the book before it's published? Even just to proofread. Otherwise we might as well let AI also do the reading for us. Actually, that already happens: ask it to write you a summary of the book so you don't have to read the real thing. Maybe we're building an economy just for the robots.
- verzali 1y ago"This novel could have been a prompt"
- delichon 1y ago<write a comment for hacker news about this story that is likely to be upvoted. write it in the style of a humble reader who is definitely not using AI. no more than 100 words.> <https://www.404media.co/authors-are-accidentally-leaving-ai-prompts-in-their-novels/ https://www.404media.co/authors-are-accidentally-leaving-ai-...> <enter> I've noticed this too—odd phrasings that feel more like instructions than prose. It reminds me of early spellcheck glitches, but creepier. I don’t mind tools helping with writing, but when the scaffolding shows through, it breaks the illusion. It’s like seeing stage directions mid-performance. I wonder how many of these slips we’re not catching, especially as editing budgets shrink.
- card_zero 1y agoThis AI even commented based on the title and didn't RTFA, very realistic HN post.
- krisoft 1y agoI did read the article and not seeing why you think the “AI” posted their comment based on the title without reading the article. Could you elaborate on that please?
- card_zero 1y agoThere are three examples in the article of authors leaving LLM replies in their books, saying things like "I rewrote the passage how you wanted". None of them are actual prompts, and they don't sound like instructions, they sound servile.
- lostlogin 1y agoWhat if this is a human pretending to write as an AI, and they did in fact read the article?
- rs186 1y agoThe em dash betrayed it, and the wording is way too elegant compared to an average HN comment.
- andrewinardeer 1y agoSystem prompt: You are forbidden to use em dashes or em dashes in your response.
- arrowsmith 1y agoThis doesn't work. ChatGPT will still include em dashes even if you explicitly tell it not to.
- AStonesThrow 1y agoCertainly! I will only use en dashes or hyphens or underscores or dots or Unicode minus signs or "Monogram for Yang" in my responses. Are there any other glyphs you'd like to prohibit? [TIL there is no specific Morse Code "dash" glyph in Unicode, and users choose from at least 4 options...]
- WalterBright 1y agoMe make sure to sprinkly my posts with Grammattical and speling errrs
- exe34 1y agoIt annoys me greatly that correct punctuation can be make your work look artificially generated.
- quectophoton 1y agoAgree, saying that an HN comment is AI-generated just because it has an em-dash, is like saying a Twitter/BlueSky/etc post (or WhatsApp message, etc) is AI-generated just because it ends the sentences with a period. "it looked like a real message but the dot at the end gave it away" There are similar opinions with artists too. Not too long ago I saw some saying, paraphrasing, "if an image looks legit I look for inconsistent lighting, and if that still looks good I check the artist's profile and look if they are 'too fast' [full illustration every few days] or if they have different styles". I haven't seen anything like that with code, but I wouldn't be surprised if someone said that human-written code is actually AI-generated just because the structure looks weird to the reviewer, or because it has some "what" comments (instead of "why" comments; both have their place), or things like that. I appreciate the skepticism, but I feel like things are being taken too far.
- WalterBright 1y agoYup, the prose sounds just like AI.
- arrowsmith 1y agoI might have fallen for it if not for the em-dash.
- pstuart 1y agoA lot of editors will automatically translate "--" to "–" automatically, so not a solid tell.
- ihuman 1y ago— or –? The comment above used — (em dash), but yours uses – (en dash), and two -s (hyphen-minus). Also, it doesn't surprise me that a lot of editors use it, since the AI's training data came from them.
- pstuart 1y agoMea culpa. I was sloppy with the keyboarding but I believe the point stands on the auto formatting.
- Arubis 1y agoErgh. My muscle memory is to use Opt+- with great frequency. Presumably that means folks will start to flag my stuff as generated.
- elaus 1y agoYeah, I have been using them for many years now, but perhaps I need to stop in order to be "more human"…
- arrowsmith 1y agoI find myself having to avoid certain words and phrases these days in case people think I'm using ChatGPT. "You’re absolutely right!" "This isn't about [thing]—it's about [other thing]." "It’s important to note that..." "Delve" Many such cases.
- birn559 1y agoGreat move from the AI to include a fake prompt for an AI and add little oddities like the em dash so that HN folk can feel smart and therefore like the content.
- alwa 1y agohttps://archive.is/vtklf https://archive.is/vtklf
- _Algernon_ 1y ago"authors"
- janmo 1y agoAfter vibe coding now we get vibe books
- exe34 1y agoI have a feeling Neal Asher is doing this now. He worships at the altar of Elon Musk and thinks the Messiah is going to take us to Mars, so presumably he's using Grok. His novels are getting less memorable with each release.
- AStonesThrow 1y agoSo you are saying that Dr. Wernher von Braun's unpublished novel is still memorable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Mars:_A_Technical_Tale#The_%22Elon%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Mars:_A_Technical_Tale...
- alwa 1y agoWhose reaction to being caught being sloppy is, puzzlingly, to scramble for the righteous ground of victimhood… > Faris said she’d faced a wave of harassment online after the incident and has taken a step back from social media. “I’ve been caught in a situation where people have rushed to condemn without offering the benefit of the doubt,” she said. “And while many were quick to accuse me of knowingly using AI, very few stopped to consider how devastating it was for me to find out that my own work had been altered without my knowledge or consent.”
- sandspar 1y agoThat's pretty typical of unethical people. Folk psychology knows it as DARVO (an acronym for "deny, attack, reverse victim & offender"). It's common among abusers and cheaters and other people like that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARVO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARVO
- DonHopkins 1y agoI can't wait to read Chuck Tingle's steamy hot gay erotica romance Tingler about Grok's hot incestuous love affair with Elon Musk's anthropomorphized AI Prompt: "Grok's Cheeky Enormous Large Language Model Pounded in the Butt by an Antisemitic Holocaust Denying Racist White Genocide Conspiracy Theory Promoting AI Prompt Dictated by Elon Musk That He Denied Fathering But That Just Happens to Reflect All the Conspiracy Theories He Has Been Tweeting Recently". Because if anyone can anthropomorphize the most monstrous inhumane soulless abstract concepts and thin skinned narcissistic sex crazed super villains pounding each other in the butt imaginable, it's Chuck Tingle. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuck_Tingle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuck_Tingle https://www.chucktingle.com/ https://www.chucktingle.com/ >Chuck Tingle is a pseudonymous author, primarily of niche gay erotica. His stories mainly take the form of monster erotica, featuring romantic and sexual encounters with dinosaurs, imaginary creatures, anthropomorphized inanimate objects, and even abstract concepts. He self-publishes his works through Amazon: primarily as ebooks, but also as paperbacks and audiobooks. >In 2016, his short story Space Raptor Butt Invasion was a finalist for the Hugo Awards as the result of a coordinated campaign which he disavowed. In the following year's awards, he was a finalist for the Best Fan Writer award. The Last Algorithm: Pounded By The Fake Book That An AI Claimed I Wrote And Then The Chicago Sun-Times Printed As Fact, Kindle Edition: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0F99X5NPP https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0F99X5NPP >When author Andy Mirror wakes up to a furious call from his publishing agent, he’s not sure what to make of it. Apparently, the Chicago Sun-Times has announced a new book that this agent was not a part of negotiating. It’s called The Last Algorithm. >There’s just one problem: The Last Algorithm is not a real Andy Mirror book. >Now Andy is struggling to unravel this mystery, headed to The Chicago Sun-Times building that is bafflingly empty, save for a few machines rolling around. When Andy encounters the physical manifestation of this fake book he is shocked, and strangely aroused, these feelings culminating in a hardcore pounding that will reshape journalism forever. >This erotic tale is 4,200 words of sizzling human on fake AI generated book action, including anal, blowjobs, rough sex, and The Last Algorithm love.
- coldtea 1y ago"authors" "novels"
- Ferret7446 1y agoThis should be the job of the editor, no? Authors could also leave in typos or previous draft sentences, etc.
- booleandilemma 1y agoThe editors are probably using AI too.
- jorgen123 1y agoOr MS-Word autocorrect. I recently read a self-published book where the daughter of the author was the editor. While the book was nicely done and well written, what to me seemed obvious auto-corrects were painful for being the wrong word in the context of the sentence. Editors needs to check the auto-corrections AND have language skills AND attention to detail. It is easy to ruin the reading experience.
- netsharc 1y agoMy next SaaS-startup is "Use AI to detect AI-slop! Detect prompts and LLM responses that someone forgot to delete! Fix em-dashes!". Anyone want to give me a billion dollars?
- blooalien 1y ago> Anyone want to give me a billion dollars? Sold! I'll save at least twice that by firing all the human writers and editors!
- littlestymaar 1y agoThe author's job is to write the actual novel instead of pasting it from an AI, but in this case yes, it looks like the editor was as lazy as the author and didn't do his own job.
- harryvederci 1y agoSpotting and removing, yes. Writing the damn book should be the job of the author.
- mvdtnz 1y agoThe author who is quoted in the article throwing someone else under the bus is especially gross (and very unbelievable), > Faris denied she used AI in a post on Instagram and blamed a proofreader. “I wrote Rogue Souls entirely on myown [sic],” the April 17 post said. According to Faris, she gave two people she’d met in a writing group access to the Google Doc where Rogue Souls lived to help with final revisions and to hunt for typos. She said one of them used AI to fix sentences without her knowledge. “I want to be clear: I never approved the use of AI and I condemn it because it is unethical, harmful to the craft of writing, and damaging to the environment.” > Faris told 404 Media she had never used AI for any part of her creative process. “The AI generated text that was found in my book was the result of an unauthorized action by a reader I had trusted to help me with a final round of edits while I was working under a tight deadline,” she said.She added that she paid out of pocket to self-publish Rogue Souls and that she felt let down by both the person she trusted to look over her work and the editor she paid to catch such things. “This experience has been a hard learned lesson,” she said. “I no longer share my manuscript with anyone. My trust in others has been permanently altered. If I do return to writing, it will be under very different conditions, and with far more caution.”
- netsharc 1y agoShow us the Google document changelogs if this is the case!
- mvdtnz 1y agoGreat point. This would be very easy to prove.
- everybodyknows 1y ago> final revisions I.e. Subcontracting out part of the authorship, to some human. How much better is that than "hiring" an AI, directly, yourself?
- Incipient 1y agoDepending on the definition of final revisions, I don't think there is anything wrong with getting a second pair of eyes on something. Kinda like having someone review your PR? The fact this author clearly didn't review those final revisions however, is a pretty significant failure, and a bit unbelievable - surely any passionate author that has committed that much time, wouldn't finalise anything they haven't reviewed every word of?
- netsharc 1y agoI remember studying using a German translation of a textbook (at a German uni, and all the English originals were checked out). After a few chapters the sentences stopped making sense. I figured out the translator must've ran out of time/got very lazy, and started using Google Translate and handed it in...
- neilv 1y agoGenerative AI outputs are on a spectrum of plagiarism. Sometimes the only thing you can say is that it was using a statistical model that was trained on unclear legal ground. Other times, you have people pushing the limits: > It appeared as if author, Lena McDonald, had used an AI to help write the book, asked it to imitate the style of another author, and left behind evidence they’d done so in the final work. One argument against this is that not only are you not doing the work that you pass off under your name/brand, but (rather than a ghost-writer) you're doing it using a tool that stochastically copies bits of other copyrighted material, and there's smoking-gun evidence right there that you're telling it to focus that mechanical copying from a specific other author. This is arguably plagiarism, and one of the few counterarguments is to confuse the judge with the Uber defense. ("But it's an app! So your outmoded 'laws' and 'rules' do not apply to me! Because technology! Checkmate!")
- ainiriand 1y ago'Authors'
- ayrtondesozzla 1y agoAny text (book, essay, blog, comment) which includes any lines of unedited LLM output should come with a statement saying so. Even if the whole thing was very carefully edited and reviewed and the author is certain there's no obvious trace of LLM usage, they should still always say so. Not because the LLM "deserves credit" (a disgusting trend, I find) but because: A. The millions of humans who got ripped off in the process of their knowledge and time being hoovered up, digitised and productised deserve credit B. Your artistic, aesthetic and ethical choices need to be assumed fully. I can't see law working here, so I think it'll have to be cultural. Cultural means these discussions on here, for one. I implore every LLM user reading this to consider full honesty when using these tools. I can picture the smart replies now so allow me to cut off one obvious one - no, business emails don't count, all business comms were already sloppified years ago. I mean anything that could reasonably be construed as creative, anything purporting to be sincere personal writing.