4 ms·
Yes, but the bar for skepticism is higher than that, because LLMs also compile code and catch errors, and generate and run tests; compile errors and assertion f
by tptacek 1y ago
Yes, but the bar for skepticism is higher than that, because LLMs also compile code and catch errors, and generate and run tests; compile errors and assertion failures are just more prompts to an LLM agent.
- what 1y agoCitation needed. Here is copilot “fixing” a failing test: https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/commit/fe173fc8f44dbd0a9ed909383f0dc17bc9a36d35 https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/commit/fe173fc8f44dbd0a9ed... It rewrote some comments, changed the test name and added extra assertions to the test. Baby sitting something like that seems like an absolute waste of time.
- BeetleB 1y agoYou want a citation for things so many people are doing daily with LLMs? Just because they can't fix most failures doesn't mean they can't fix many.
- what 1y agoIt’s a failure that it created and when told to fix it did this. It’s beyond bad.
- BeetleB 1y ago> It's a failure that it created and when told to fix it did this. It’s beyond bad. No one's disputing this was bad. People are merely claiming it can also be good. I've dealt with plenty of humans this bad - it's not an argument that humans can't program.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- callc 1y agoIt seems like the underlying issue is trust.competent programmer - even a junior - and trust them to finish the task correctly. It might take multiple tries, and they may ask for clarification, but since they’re human, we trust they are intelligent. There are some people who fall into the bucket that we can’t trust them to finish the task correctly, or within a time frame or level of effort on our part to make the task offloading exercise have a positive benefit. If we view LLMs in the same light, IMO currently they fall into “not trust” category to really give they a task and trust them to finish it correctly, with us being confident we don’t really need to understand their implementation. If one day LLMs or some other solution reaches that point, then it definitely won’t look like a bubble, but a real revolution.
- BeetleB 1y agoVery well put. The trick is to do either of the following: 1. Find simpler tasks for which the trust in LLMs is high. 2. Give tasks to the LLMs that have a very low cost to verify (even when the task is not simple) - particularly one off scripts. I once had a colleague who was in the "not trust" bucket for the work we were doing. So we found something he was good at that was a pain for me to do, and re-assigned him to do those things and take that burden off of us. In the last few months I've had the LLM solve (simple) problems via code that had been in my head for years. At any point I could have done them, but they were a chore. If the LLM failed for one of these tasks - it's not a big deal - not much time was lost. But they tend to succeed fairly often, because they are simple tasks. I almost never let the LLM write production code, because of the extra burden that you and others allude to. But I do let it write code I rely on in my personal life, because frankly I tend to write pretty poor code for my personal use - I can't justify the time it would take to write things well - life is too busy. I welcome the code quality I get from Sonnet or Gemini 2.5 Pro. That's my point in this thread. Writing code is a pretty diverse discipline, and many are dismissing it simply because it doesn't do one particular use case (high quality production code) well. I didn't take LLM coding seriously until I found well respected, well known SW engineers speak positively about them. Then I tried it and ... oh wow. People dismissing them is dismissing not only a lot of average developers' reality, but also a lot of experts' daily reality. Just look at the other submission: https://sean.heelan.io/2025/05/22/how-i-used-o3-to-find-cve-2025-37899-a-remote-zeroday-vulnerability-in-the-linux-kernels-smb-implementation/ https://sean.heelan.io/2025/05/22/how-i-used-o3-to-find-cve-... He used an LLM to find a security vulnerability in the kernel. To quote him: > Before I get into the technical details, the main takeaway from this post is this: with o3 LLMs have made a leap forward in their ability to reason about code, and if you work in vulnerability research you should start paying close attention. If you’re an expert-level vulnerability researcher or exploit developer the machines aren’t about to replace you. In fact, it is quite the opposite: they are now at a stage where they can make you significantly more efficient and effective. If you have a problem that can be represented in fewer than 10k lines of code there is a reasonable chance o3 can either solve it, or help you solve it.
- motorest 1y ago> It rewrote some comments, changed the test name and added extra assertions to the test. Baby sitting something like that seems like an absolute waste of time. I've worked with real flesh and blood developers who did the exactly same thing. At least with LLMs we don't have to jump into a 1h long call to discuss the changes.
- lolinder 1y agoWhen used that way they also regularly get into loops where they lose track of what they were supposed to do. The last time I set Cursor on something without watching it very very closely it spun for a while fixing tests and when it finally stopped and I looked what it had done it had coded special cases in to pass the specific failing tests in a way that didn't generalize at all to the actual problem. Another recent time I had to pull the plug on it installing a bunch of brand new dependencies that it decided would somehow fix the failing tests. It had some kind of complete rewrite planned. Claude Code is even worse when it gets into this mode because it'll do something totally absurd like that and then at the end you have to `git reset` and you're also on the hook for the $5 of tokens that it managed to spend in 5 minutes. I still find them useful, but it takes a lot of practice to figure out when they'll be useful and when they'll be a total waste of time.
- tptacek 1y agoIt happens to me every once in awhile, but I'm not sure why I would care. I usually set it off on some question and go tab away to something else while it flails. When I come back, I have a better-than-average shot at a workable solution, which is a science fiction result. When I first began programming as a teenager, one of the mental hurdles I had to get over was asking the computer to "too much"; like, I would feel bad writing a nested loop --- that can't possibly be the right answer! What a chore for the computer! It didn't take me too long to figure out that was the whole point of computers. To me, it's the same thing with LLMs spinning on something. Who gives a shit? It's not me wasting that time.
- kasey_junk 1y agoI’m now at the point where I tell it to do something _and then drive to Wisconsin_ giving feedback at the Marz cheese castle and continuing my trip.
- tptacek 1y agoI feel like you might know where I'm coming from being confused at people's reaction to this stuff. This is science fiction. I think it's just not sinking in with people. If I could bet on this, I would bet everything I could on "skill with LLMs" being the high order bit of being an effective software developer 5 years from now.