7 ms·
BYD Beats Tesla in Europe for First Time with 169% Sales Surge
- moogly 2y ago"There's no exceptions."[1] [1]: https://fortune.com/2025/05/21/elon-musk-fears-tesla-demand-problem-denies-declining-sales/ https://fortune.com/2025/05/21/elon-musk-fears-tesla-demand-...
- piva00 2y agoHe is such a slimy bullshitter: > The Tesla CEO asserts he’s seeing a major rebound in customer interest for his EVs despite persistent evidence to the contrary. “The stock wouldn’t be trading near all-time highs if things weren’t in good shape,” he said. > Tesla’s return to the elite club of trillion-dollar market cap stocks is all the evidence Elon Musk needs to convince him the worst of the blowback over his political activism is over. Like a conman losing its grips on the victims' confidence, he entered the phase of "do not believe your eyes and ears" phase of the swindle. Last earnings showed a steep decline in sales, just around my house in Sweden I've seen 3 neighbours with a new BYD the past 3 months, the one right across my house used to have a Model 3 which I haven't seen in a while. I can only definitely call him a liar on the next earnings report so there's some 2 months before we can see actual figures and not just his words...
- philipallstar 2y agoFor all its marvels, Tesla giving away so many of its discoveries, combined with a deeply Tesla-unfriendly local environment and a China willing to plough a huge amount of money into crushing a genuine manufacturing rival, it doesn't look too good. I hope they get back on top, though. I just don't see how.
- s_dev 2y agoThe boycott of Tesla isn't related to the quality of the cars but the political overtures of the CEO.
- owebmaster 2y agoThe customers noticing the quality been not great is just consequence
- moogly 2y agoA little bit of column A and B and C. Quality is fine (except their rust protection, last I checked), but not making a new mass market car in 5 years, and just 2 lackluster refreshes to pretty milquetoast cars, and no technical updates is a bit baffling with tens of billions of cash in the books (hopefully non-cooked). Their 1.5 models on offer feel quite dated, even with the refresh. Makes you wonder if, perhaps, doing small incremental updates and spending time on fart apps and light shows is perhaps less successful in the long run than doing bigger updates every 3-5 years. The rest is a bunch of broken promises.
- AlecSchueler 2y ago> A little bit of column A and B and C. You think sales would be declining anywhere near as rapidly if it weren't for the nazi salutes, DOGE, and white genocide stuff etc.? Talking about comparatively small strategy errors in a company that was such a big force in the market seems like painting over the elephant in the room when the CEO is going off the rails and talking about exporting his personal brand of neo-facism via threats to "Make Europe Great Again," openly funding far right groups who are later declared illegal extremists etc. There's bad business and there's BAD business.
- moogly 2y agoJust disagreeing that the sales performance is _solely_ about that. Tesla yearly sales stopped growing in 2024. Also declining in China, where they don't care about what Musk is doing. Musk is still well-liked there, in fact. Competition is heating up and Tesla have been focusing on stock pumping stratagems instead of their core product line, and continuing to dig their own grave, but Musk's megalomania surely has accelerated that a ton.
- 2y ago
- JKCalhoun 2y agoMaybe Tesla can do something about their "deeply Tesla-unfriendly local environment"?
- moogly 2y agoThat is interesting rhetoric. All external factors except the "giving away" thing, which is also strange. Are you thinking of the poisoned patents?
- dagw 2y agoI just don't see how. Simple. Musk steps away and the company issues a full statement distancing themselves from Musk and his politics. Tesla negotiates an end to its fights with the unions in Europe. Stop focusing on the Cybertruck and start making an updated Model 3 and a lower priced Model 2. Maybe push out a new Model S to take on the high end market while you're at it. Perhaps do some sort of marketing campaign to highlight that they're now just a cool car company again. People in Europe still like Tesla the car, and would happily start driving them again given some incentives.
- jeffhuys 2y ago> Musk steps away and the company issues a full statement distancing themselves from Musk and his politics. I'll tell you right now: the stock will plummet. That's my prediction.
- AlecSchueler 2y agoBut sales would go up. What a mixed up muddled up world we live in, eh?
- jeffhuys 1y agoI actually doubt that. Also.. I want to know: people say that Tesla owners should sell their card if they don’t want them keyed. Who should they sell them to?
- bryanlarsen 2y ago> I just don't see how. Split the hype part of the company from the profitable but dull part. Robots + FSD + Elon Musk -> hype part. Merge with xAI for full effect. Cars + Utility Storage + new dull CEO -> profitable dull part.
- rsynnott 2y ago> I hope they get back on top, though. ... I mean, why?
- philipallstar 1y agoBecause they lead the world in electric innovation, and while Chinese copycats now exist, it's much, much easier to copy than to innovate.
- AlecSchueler 2y ago> I hope they get back on top, though Why? As someone terrified by recent political developments it's unfathomable to me that anyone could have any well wishes for them as long as Mr Musk profits from their success.
- mrguyorama 2y ago>Tesla giving away so many of its discoveries, What "Discoveries"? >Tesla-unfriendly local environment It is Musk who is unfriendly to Europe.
- zarzavat 2y agoMusk's Nazi salute is going to go down in history as one of the stupidest things a businessman has ever done. There's still plenty of people in Europe with a personal connection to WW2, family members who died fighting or died in the camps or bombings. There are relatives I never met because of the Nazis. It's unthinkable for me to give any sum of money to - let alone purchase a car from - a company associated with neo-Nazism. I couldn't care less about DOGE or anything Musk is doing with US domestic politics, it's really just that salute that would prevent me from buying a Tesla.
- fsloth 2y agoTotally agreed. And do note this is an opinion coming from EU. We really, really, really don’t understand _anyhting_ about US internal politics and most people here in EU countries who _think_ they do really don’t. And vice versa - europolitics are mostly non-sequitur in US context. It seems inconceivable to some in US how some ”tropes” are not just ”harmless larping” but actually in a specific environments deeply insulting gestures. I do realize the deep wounds nazism caused are plusibly hard to understand if one is not european. But that does not really excuse someone who clearly signals he strives to be a thoughtleader. In general it’s Pauling and Vitamin-C again. You are great at something and thus presume those intrinsic strengths serve equally well in some other context. Human failures aside, hurtfull things are hurtfull and they cannot be reasoned away. Forgiven - sure, in right circumstances. Forgotten as well.
- pestaa 2y agoNot sure why this is downvoted. Even if you dispute if that have gesture was a Nazi salute, or think that people shouldn't consider the behavior of a CEO when making a purchase, this is the reality.
- infecto 2y agoMy thinking as well. Regardless of intent, trolling or otherwise, the fact that he did that is a huge miss and the most irrational behavior, not something you want in a leader.
- 2y ago
- Spivak 2y agoIt's really a shame you literally can't buy a BYD car in the US because they're great vehicles. They're "boring" electric cars— not trying to redefine the driving experience, not trying to be luxury cars. Just your Honda Civic Toyota Corolla of EV. They've got a smooth ride, pretty nice faux leather trim, and a decent stereo.
- paxys 2y agoThat's selling them way short. Yes there are plenty of cheap/economy cars in the lineup but higher end BYD models are significantly more luxurious than anything Tesla can put out.
- osigurdson 2y agoIt does seem that for the average person, an EV is only going to be an "add-on". You still need a gas car for any kind of road trip so the EV should just be a little, low cost, grocery getter. Maybe once we start seeing 1000+ km ranges that will change. The rate of improvement in terms of range has been glacial however so that might be a long way off.
- StopDisinfo910 2y agoModern EV ranges are in the ballpark of 350km which charging time under one hour. That's more than enough for most nowadays especially in Europe where long trips are not the norm and well past grocery getter. You can cross most European countries with one stop.
- osigurdson 2y agoSo all EVs on a 400km+ trip will be at the charging station 1/4 of the time. I don't think that works at scale. Charging stations would be like event parking at a Taylor Swift concert. Gas cars are still objectively better which is sad and unexpected. I never would have predicted this insanely low rate of improvement 10 years ago. In terms of trucks / tow vehicles, it is even further off. The Cybertruck laughably has 250km of tow range. Disconnecting every 2 hours to charge for an hour is absurd. Until we see a step change in battery technology, EVs are grocery getters in my books. So, might as well double down and make them super cheap with 100km range.
- coreyh14444 2y agoCan confirm anecdotally, I am seeing way more Chinese made cars on the streets of Copenhagen. Just this morning I did a literal head-turn to check out an XPeng sedan I hadn't seen before. One of my partners drives a Chinese SUV and gotta say the massaging seats were pretty sweet. me: American, used to own a Tesla Model S.
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago> I am seeing way more Chinese made cars on the streets of Copenhagen Also, a lot of European car brands' EV models are also rebadged Chinese models or the brand is Chinese owned. MG, Volvo, Dacia Spring
- close04 2y agoDacia Spring is fully a Renault model (Kwid/City K-ZE) based on a Renault-Nissan platform (the CMF-A) and just manufactured in China. MG, Volvo/Polestar/Lynk & Co, or Lotus are brands owned by Chinese automotive groups SAIC and Geely.
- seydor 2y agothe speed with which china is making crucial things affordable (photovoltaics, EVs) makes you think about the utility of the patent system ...
- jcfrei 2y agohttps://archive.ph/NkYpk https://archive.ph/NkYpk
- arresin 2y agoIt’s probably a pricing thing. I can imagine BYD is aggressively pricing now in Europe and Europeans in general have less disposable income.
- dagw 2y agoIt’s probably a pricing thing. It really isn't or at least not just price. BYD, at least in Sweden, are not cheap cars in an absolute sense. Many car brands have cars that are cheaper than the cheapest car BYD sells in Sweden. MG, Peugeot, Citroen and others all have smaller and cheaper EVs if what you mainly care about is price. BYDs focus is much more on value for money at the mid level.
- AlecSchueler 2y ago> It really isn't Right? Surprised to see speculation about something easily disprovable on this forum.
- rsynnott 2y agoNah; BYD are subject to tariffs, and they haven't brought their lowest-end stuff to Europe. They're not particularly cheap, and don't as far as I know compete on at all in the sub-30k space. This is really a story of (a) BYD rising from a low base and (b) Tesla plummeting; the biggest manufacturer at the moment isn't either of them (it's VW AG).
- bryanlarsen 2y agoBYD just announced the "Dolphin Surf" with a 20k introductory price for Europe.
- rsynnott 2y agoUh, huh, they've actually launched it vs just talking vaguely about it now, apparently, yeah. Yeah, okay, that'll be a big shakeup.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- StopDisinfo910 2y agoUnsurprising. Tesla were always a weird fit for the European markets. They are too big and especially too wide. The finish is haphazard. At their price point, which is high for all the segments they compete in, they don't really compare favorably to European brands. They used to be able to compete on battery performance and drive trains but that's hardly the case anymore. It was always pretty clear that Tesla is entirely driven from the USA and has no idea of how and what to sell to European in a way not too dissimilar to other American car makers which could never really succeed in Europe either. Meanwhile, BYD is genuinely competitive in Europe. Their cars are well positioned in the middle of every segments they are in. They would actually be on the more accessible side without tariffs. Their design is nothing to talk about but they blend well with other cars. Their size is great. They do ok confort-wise, nothing extraordinary but not too shabby either. Basically, they are ok cars at an ok price, something which can't be said of Tesla.
- beAbU 2y agoTesla is mad popular in Ireland. They are everywhere. In my town alone there are two Model 3 taxis, out of a total of about 10 taxis locally.
- rsynnott 2y agoMight be just sampling error? (10 taxis isn't a lot of taxis). Most electric taxis I see in Dublin are VW id3/4. (Though Toyotas seem to be on the rise now that Toyota has grudgingly released an EV; taxi drivers have always loved Toyota.) EDIT: Yeah. So far this year, the id.4 is number 18 overall, Kia EV3 is 26th, Tesla Model 3 is 27th, Tesla Y is 86th. So Telsa's... not quite irrelevant, EV-wise, but kinda getting there (note that Hyundai, Kia, VW, BYD etc all have a bunch of models vs Tesla's two models, and Tesla's still trailing). https://stats.beepbeep.ie https://stats.beepbeep.ie
- AlecSchueler 2y agoSmall towns are more likely to give sampling errors, would suggest looking at national or even county level statistics to confirm your feeling.
- jqpabc123 2y agoNone of it matters to Tesla stock --- investors have moved on from the dream of owning the worldwide auto market to owning the worldwide robo taxi market and personal robots --- which are still just dreams with no better (if not less) chance of success than the one they just abandoned. Apparently, the goal is to keep the dreams alive without ever actually fulfilling any of them.
- spwa4 2y agoSo, fresh from angering virtually every government in the world, Musk will move on to introducing a service that utterly requires government approval and licensing, while costing a lot of jobs. To do this he'll have to get approval from politicians that are taking a leftist turn just to avoid being associated with either him or Trump (or didn't and are very angry at him and Trump for costing them a LOT of votes) ... Makes you want to ask, "say, Elon, how's that full-self-driving going?"
- iamthemonster 1y agoI can't believe we're still asking Elon about when we'll get full-self-driving, he's already answered that question every year since 2013. It's coming next year.
- -__---____-ZXyw 2y ago> Apparently, the goal is to keep the dreams alive without ever actually fulfilling any of them. A wonderful observation. Has someone made a stab at describing these new paradigms of advertising and value? I don't think I've seen exactly this stated or named, but there's a lot of writing and thinking out there. If it strikes anyone reading this, links welcome. Specifically, it seems like advertising may have gone from "the quality of the product doesn't matter", to "the product existing doesn't matter". Quite a big leap.
- ryandvm 2y agoI doubt there are many TSLA investors that actually believe that the company is well positioned to dominate ANY market at this point. They just believe that there are _other_ people that believe it. Greater fool and all that. Meme stocks have a way of defying normal economic gravity and irritating traditional investors up until they don't, and when that happens their demise is usually rapid and complete.
- vitorgrs 2y agoAnd they still didn't launch the new Dolphin Surf in Europe, which will cost 16k euro I believe.
- skc 2y agoIt's a curious own goal by Musk. I would imagine that Tesla have pretty detailed profile data on the average Tesla customer. Surely there were pretty clear signals that a significant number of those people would vote with their wallets based on his politics.
- spwa4 2y agoTesla was having very serious difficulty long before the election. For Musk the choice was probably to join the democrats, and get the tiniest amount of power, or help Trump and be the unofficial vice president. And as everyone was saying last year "Trump can't be THAT bad", you know, before the stock market dropped 3.66 trillion dollars.
- AlecSchueler 2y ago> you know, before the stock market dropped 3.66 trillion dollars. And the disappearing people, threats against allies, stripping of hard fought rights, siding with Putin, airbrushing women and non-white men from the history books, declaring Gaza should become a holiday resort and spreading FUD about white genocide etc etc etc
- matthewfelgate 2y agoI believe it is a security threat to allow Chinese cars in Europe.
- spwa4 2y agoMeanwhile Trump and Elon's "business buddy" was flying nuclear capable jets over Poland ... last month [1]. Also yesterday the government Elon is part of refused to implement further sanctions against Russia, that would be a problem for "business opportunities" [2]. And, in order to help fix his image Elon Musk ... makes two Nazi salutes ... Oh and today DOGE is being blamed for the biggest rise in unemployment in years [3], which caused yet another stock market heart attack yesterday. Who is the bigger security threat here? [1] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/apr/20/raf-fighters-scrambled-twice-to-intercept-russian-planes-last-week https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/apr/20/raf-fighters... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2025/05/20/us/politics/trump-ukraine-russia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/05/20/us/politics/trump-ukraine... [3] https://nypost.com/2025/02/27/business/jobless-claims-post-largest-gain-in-5-months-with-doge-firings-set-to-boost-numbers/ https://nypost.com/2025/02/27/business/jobless-claims-post-l...
- rstuart4133 2y agoOf course it is. But as the ICC just found out, it's a security threat to use USA tech in Europe too. The worlds global, you have to import a lot of tech from elsewhere, and now both major suppliers (China and the USA) are cuddling up to a rogue nation that is invading a neighbor. They are between a rock and a hard place right now.