7 ms·
If you are old enough you remember posting to Usenet and the warning that would accompany each new submission: This program posts news to thousands of machines
by SoftTalker 1y ago
If you are old enough you remember posting to Usenet and the warning that would accompany each new submission:
This program posts news to thousands of machines throughout the entire civilized world. Your message will cost the net hundreds if not thousands of dollars to send everywhere. Please be sure you know what you are doing. Are you absolutely sure that you want to do this? [ny]
Maybe we meed something similar in LLM clients. Could be phrased in terms of how many pounds of atmospheric carbon the request will produce.
- mirekrusin 1y agoOr gigantic footer explaining you should consider impact before trying to print this email – which was always eating next page when printed.
- wmf 1y agoOnly if that same warning is attached to literally everything else you do. It's unfair to single out AI for using energy.
- SoftTalker 1y agoBut "asking ChatGPT" is something people do so casually without there being any apparent clues of the costs associated with that. I guess that is true of pretty much everything online though. Even driving your car around you at least are somewhat aware of the gas you are burning.
- asdff 1y agoThat could be solved by charging more for the service. That is the only reason you are aware of the gas burning after all, you aren't conducting your own aq test you are noticing you are filling up twice a week at $50 a tank.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoI would bet most ppl drive around with very little awareness of how much it’s costing, either in money or environmental impact. Many people I’ve met seem to measure efficiency by how much it costs to fill up the tank.
- bilbo0s 1y agoEven more fundamentally, think about how much carbon running a cup of water from your faucet produces. No matter where you live, this is more carbon than an LLM prompt generates. Or, even worse God forbid, think about how much carbon is produced to create a single bottle or carton of water. Then consider how casually people down bottles of water.
- blululu 1y agoCan you source that? A lot of places have gravity fed reservoirs that are energy positive/neutral (LA, San Francisco and New York all rely on gravity fed reservoirs that were built before energy intensive pumping was practical). There are some costs but they are pretty small per gallon.
- SilasX 1y agoI’m assuming that calculation is amortizing the cost of running the water system (including wastewater treatment) adding the cost pumping it to the point that gravity can push it through the pipes. It’s never free.
- phillipcarter 1y agoThey're aware of the price they pay for the gas, not the emissions. I would wager that the mass ignorance of the impact of fossil fuels (and rubber on roads) that the broader population has is a significant reason why we're in this climate mess today.
- jbm 1y ago> rubber on roads Funny how this suddenly became a thing after electrification became a thing. Need to find a new way to wag the finger after all.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoWell many of my fellow Americans would only accept an EV if it's gigantic, and even though I can't leave the house without seeing a Prius or a RAV4 hybrid, the news acts like it's gas versus electric as if Toyota hadn't solved this twenty years ago
- phillipcarter 1y agoIt's always been a thing? I'm pro-electrification, BTW.
- floxy 1y ago>It's always been a thing? Is there a way to quantify this? My experience as well is that the tire particulate pollution has mostly been an anti-EV talking point.
- jbm 1y agoI am 100% on the side of reducing pollutants — but this was never publicly seen as a major issue and I'm suspicious about the timing. The oil industry is a conglomerate of degenerates spamming boomer logic all the way down to the workers. Their memes propagate throughout society and lead to the other boomer characteristic of rewriting personal and societal history. The finger waggers now are being programmed to pretend they talked about tire particulates and the carheads are being programmed to pretend they never cared about 0-60. This another "We have always been at war with Eastasia", just like they all opposed the Iraq war from day 1 and didn't cancel the Dixie Chicks, et cetra. This may have been discussed in specialist literature somewhere but even when I did ecology courses in university circa 2001ish, I never heard about tire particulates, while I did hear a lot about greenhouse gasses. It's a concern but not a civilization ending concern like climate change. I low key resent these attempts to move goalposts to satisfy the writer's urge for negativity.
- wmf 1y ago"Civilization advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking of them." — Alfred North Whitehead Emissions should be fixed on the production side (decarbonization) not on the demand side (guilt/austerity).
- mulmen 1y agoWhile I agree in principle how does this work for fossil fuels? Is the idea that we should make extraction prohibitively expensive? Scaling up battery production makes EVs more appealing on the demand side. How do you disincentivize fossil fuel production?
- gbear605 1y agoMaking it illegal is always an option, and one that many countries are considering
- wmf 1y agoCarbon tax or something similar.
- AnthonyMouse 1y agoBatteries and EVs are the production side. Reducing demand is e.g. requiring you to drive fewer miles. You get a car that doesn't run on petroleum and CO2 goes down while vehicle miles can stay the same or go up.
- mulmen 1y ago> Batteries and EVs are the production side. That’s what I said? > Reducing demand is e.g. requiring you to drive fewer miles. Demand can be reduced by increasing fuel prices. Either at the pump through consumption tax or at production. The effect remains the same. > You get a car that doesn't run on petroleum and CO2 goes down while vehicle miles can stay the same or go up. Obviously. What does that have to do with disincentivizing fossil fuel production or consumption?
- 1y ago
- marcellus23 1y agohttps://simonwillison.net/2025/May/6/whats-the-carbon-footprint-of-using-chatgpt/ https://simonwillison.net/2025/May/6/whats-the-carbon-footpr...
- paulcole 1y agoObviously people have zero awareness of or interest in their true impact on the environment. This extends to every facet of life and is not at all limited to AI use. Do you really think the average person could within 2 orders of magnitude when estimating their carbon footprint for a year?
- sanktanglia 1y agoPeople spend hours a day mindlessly scrolling social media apps(streaming video calls to boot) that also take up water and energy usage per hour but are totally disconnected from it
- pjc50 1y agoThe real thing here is that these tools are currently in the "subsidy" phase, so the pricing doesn't reflect actual costs. Only once they've been made indispensible and impossible to remove will the prices be jacked up and the product enshittified.
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agofairness to one polluter over another isn't the real issue - look at prop 65 in california; or if you're not used to this in CA, think of any time you've been on-call. alert fatigue is real and diminishes the urgency of the underlying message.
- reaperducer 1y agoIt's unfair to single out AI for using energy. Why? AI isn't a human being. We have no obligation to be "fair" to it.
- thot_experiment 1y agoYeah we do, it's basic epistemic hygiene. If you don't freak out about running your shower or microwave for a couple seconds or driving a few hundred feet you shouldn't be concerned about prompting an AI.
- reaperducer 1y agoApologizing for AI boiling the oceans sounds like a lot of whataboutism. I can picture an Elizabeth Holmesian cartoon clutching her diamond necklace. "Oh, won't somebody think of the tech billionaires?!" If you don't freak out about running your shower or microwave for a couple seconds or driving a few hundred feet The basic premise of the modern tech industry is scale. It's not one person running a microwave for a couple of seconds, it's a few billion people running a microwave for the equivalent of decades.
- tensor 1y agoIn a way the whole AI hand wringing is already the ultimate whataboutism. We’ve had irrefutable evidence of human caused climate change for over a decade at least, with dire consequences. And? Very little action. In fact, we’re now going backwards. The right way to look at this is comprehensively, not looking only at one issue. So yes let’s hand wring over AI and continue to do nothing about everything else. And we’ll probably do nothing about AI either, but the endless articles will no doubt keep people distracted.
- const_cast 1y agoExcept we do care about those things. We used to get tons of PSAs for carbon footprint. Turn off the lights when you leave a room, turn off your computer overnight, turn off the faucet when you're washing your hands. That type of thing.
- yongjik 1y agoA lot of us live in a country where "rolling coal" is a thing. I fear your prompt may have an opposite of the intended effect.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoTaxing anything that can pollute (methane, gasoline, diesel) would let The Hand sort it out
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- freeone3000 1y agoCarbon taxes are incredibly unpopular, because it makes easy and convenient things expensive.
- triceratops 1y agoThey're incredibly unpopular because even when they're made revenue-neutral (meaning, everyone gets a refund check) people don't realize most of them would make money if they actually reduced their carbon.
- KennyBlanken 1y agoThey're incredibly unpopular because the ultraweathly use massive amounts of fossil fuels and thus lobby very, very hard against them...and make sure the public is often told just how evil they are and how expensive they'd hurt Johnny Everyday Worker, even car ownership, especially in a city (where much of the US populative lives) is not affordable to a large segment of the population. If memory serves Jet A is not taxed at all federally in the case of for-profit corporations (while non-commercial users DO pay a tax!) and many states also either do not tax it or tax it very litte. It's completely insane that we do not tax fuel usage for probably the most energy-intensive way to move people and/or goods and often that movement of people is entirely frivelous.
- blkhawk 1y agoI find that message very curious because the message itself clearly does not cost much but the machines it is send on do. So the more messages that are send the less the messages will cost.
- anon7000 1y agoWell, Usenet is 45 years old, and the internet was not nearly as cheap and ubiquitous then
- keybored 1y agoYou don’t need it for any pragmatic benefit because it won’t work. It doesn’t work for eating meat. It won’t work for AI. The only purpose is to scapegoat the possible environmental or economic fallout. Might as well put it on individuals. Like what’s always done. I’ve already seen it on the national broadcast. There some supposed experts were wagging their fingers about using AI for “fun”. Making silly images. Meanwhile we’re gonna put AI to good use in arms races: more spam (automated applications, ads, ads, ads, abuse of services) and anti-spam. There’s gonna be so much economic activity. Disruptive.
- reginald78 1y agoAI will probably increase GDP. In the same way shooting the windows out of everyone's houses would increase GDP. Then we can claim is grew the economy.
- kmeisthax 1y agoIndividual LLM requests are vanishingly small in terms of environmental impact; inference providers use a lot of batching to do lots of work at once. Furthermore, LLMs and diffusion models are not the only ML workload. While generative AI tickles investors, most of the ML actually being deployed is more mundane things, like recommendation systems, classifiers, and the like; much of which is used for adtech purposes adversarial to that of users. If LLMs and diffusers were the only thing companies used ML for, but efficiency gains from new hardware remained constant, we'd still be at the 2017 baseline for environmental impact of data centers. Likewise, I doubt that USENET warning was ever true beyond the first few years of the networks' lifetime. Certainly if everything was connected via dial-up, yes, a single message could incur hundreds of dollars of cost when you added the few seconds of line time it took to send up across the whole world. But that's accounting for a lot of Ma Bell markup. Most connections between sites and ISPs on USENET were done through private lines that ran at far faster speeds than what you could shove down copper phone wiring back then.
- cj 1y agoIf what you're saying is true, why are we hearing about AI companies wanting to build nuclear power plants to power new data centers they think they need to build? Are you saying all of that new capacity is needed to power non-LLM stuff like classifiers, adtech, etc? That seems unlikely. Had you said that inference costs are tiny compared to the upfront cost of training the base model, I might have believed it. But even that isn't accurate -- there's a big upfront energy cost to train a model, but once it becomes popular like GPT-4, the inference energy cost over time is dramatically higher than the upfront training cost. You mentioned batch computing as well, but how does that fit into the picture? I don't see how batching would reduce energy use. Does "doing lots of work at once" somehow reduce the total work / total energy expended?
- lkbm 1y ago> If what you're saying is true, why are we hearing about AI companies wanting to build nuclear power plants to power new data centers they think they need to build? Well, partly because they (all but X, IIRC) have commitments to shift to carbon-neutral energy. But also, from the article: > ChatGPT is now estimated to be the fifth-most visited website in the world That's ChatGPT today. They're looking ahead to 100x-ing (or 1,000,000x-ing) the usage as AI replaces more and more existing work. I can run Llama 3 on my laptop, and we can measure the energy usage of my laptop--it maxes out at around 0.1 toasters. o3 is presumably a bit more energy intensive, but the reason it's using a lot of power is the >100MM daily users, not that a single user uses a lot of energy for a simple chat.
- smusamashah 1y agoYour quote is actually telling the opposite of your suggestion. So they used to send this message, but then it stopped I assume. Costs lowered a lot or the benefits outweighed all associated costs. Same can happen here.
- FollowingTheDao 1y ago> Costs lowered a lot or the benefits outweighed all associated costs. How is this even quantifiable? How about this. Before using AI to make fake images and help kids cheat on their homework, we take it offline and use it to solve it's own problem of energy use. You know what this does not happen? Because the goal is profit and the profit comes not from solving real important problem, but by making people think it is helping them solve made up problems.
- kokanee 1y agoYeah, someone will probably make AI less damaging at some point. So let's not worry about it. That's the right mindset. Edit: it's sad that I'm not sure if the downvotes are because people can't tell that this is sarcasm, or because they know that it is.
- admiralrohan 1y agoWe can't be pessimistic, that hinders flow. Should rather focus on creative ways to increase energy requirements. We will figure this out.