6 ms·
Asteroid mining by Planetary Resources
- yen223 14y ago"Our telescopes, which we call the Arkyd 100 spacecraft, are cubes half-a-meter on a side and will cost around $1 million each, though the first one, of course, will cost much more." I seriously find this mind-blowing. $1 million for a telescope launched into space sounds ridiculously cheap to me.
- sehugg 14y agoAt $10k/kg to orbit I'd guess these will have to weigh less than 100 kg. Some articles report they will be 20 kg each: http://cosmiclog.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/06/20/12326161-asteroid-hunting-venture-wants-you-to-suggest-crowdfunding-projects?lite http://cosmiclog.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/06/20/12326161-aster...
- danielweber 14y agoSpaceX can launch it's Falcon 9 for half that cost right now. They can probably get down to $1000 per kilogram with more work and/or the Falcon 9 Heavy.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe Iridium satellites demonstrated that it's possible to build satellites in an assembly line, at enormous cost savings. For a very simple satellite I think $1mil/unit is achievable.
- squonk 14y agoThe technology to discover and retrieve minerals from asteroids is likely to be simpler than resolving politics and economics of it: In order to sell the minerals, there must be a way to attain ownership. How does one come to own an asteroid, or the minerals it contains? A land grab under a single government is manageable. When there are 200 sovereign states, who decides which asteroids are owned by whom? First to discover? First to land? First to return minerals? Passed though a parsec I have rights to? Or perhaps you don't own the minerals until you cross low-earth orbit with them in your possession. Sign me up as an asteroid pirate. If a company does attain ownership of an asteroid, can they sell the asteroid before ever landing on it? Will asteroid futures be traded on the CME? If an asteroid is found to contain 100 tons of palladium, what happens to the palladium market? (Cha-ching! I hold put options on Pd!) Ya, far more interesting.... Wired started a dialog with: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2012/05/opinion-asteroid-mining/ http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2012/05/opinion-asteroid-m... Discussed ownership, but there is no answer. The Economist touched on it: "The most important members of the team, then, may not be the entrepreneurs and venture capitalists who put up the drive and the money, nor the engineers who build the hardware that makes it all possible, but the economists who try to work out the effect on the price of platinum when a mountain of the stuff arrives from outer space." http://www.economist.com/node/21553419 http://www.economist.com/node/21553419
- cwilson 14y agoYou've clearly not played EVE Online. This sounds like a joke, but it's probably the closest thing out there to an example of what the future will be like if mining of asteroids becomes insanely lucrative (and technology advances fast enough for us to even witness it). Someone who's played EVE for a significant amount of time (it's been years since I've touched any game) could probably answer everything above. This is all to say that we'll of course fight over it.
- squonk 14y agoHaven't played it, to my regret. Seems like, loosely speaking, chasing down sunken treasure, or possibly wildcatting for oil can offer precedent in some form. The notion of 'international waters' perhaps can apply to space. However, someone, sometime owned the treasure that was lost and may lay claim to it. My real question is, apparently, nations can not claim ownership of asteroids. But they will have to mutually define the legal ways any citizen or corporation on Earth can acquire ownership. What is the most likely method, once they all agree on it? Planetary Resources is at the same time forcing the issue by proceeding with their endeavor, and, making a pretty big bet that when the laws are in place, they will have legally acquired their booty.
- Devilboy 14y agoI don't see the problem. If you mine it, it's yours.
- danielweber 14y agoIf there are dozens of parties going for space, then they might fight for it. As is, I think we'll be lucky to just have one.
- jonmrodriguez 14y agoUh oh... "PM: You've suggested an asteroid could be brought closer to the Earth to make it easier to mine. Is that really feasible? EA: It is. One of the ways that we could do that is simply to turn the water on an asteroid into rocket fuel and burn it in a thruster that nudges its trajectory. Split water into hydrogen and oxygen, and you get the same fuels that launch space shuttles. Some asteroids are 20 percent water, and that amount would let you move the thing anywhere in the solar system." Wtf? EA just suggested a perpetual motion machine. He suggests using energy to hydrolyze water, but then de-hydrolyzing the water to get energy. He's making it sound like more energy will come out than went in (allowing propulsion), when really it would be == at best, and really < because of inefficiency. The only way his concept of storing the energy is even slightly useful is if you were to spend years and years collecting solar energy and storing it as H2 + O2 to burn later in one quick burst. But that's you storing the energy over a long long time, and getting back less than you put in.
- typpo 14y agoIt doesn't seem unreasonable to split water using a solar or nuclear energy source, and then use the hydrogen and oxygen as rocket fuel to actually move the asteroid. Anderson's goal is not a net energy gain, it's to move the asteroid.
- kolinko 14y agoI think he's not de-hydrolyzing water to get energy per se, but to generate thrust. Say, you've got a nuclear reactor (or whatever else is more practical) on an asteroid. You cannot use the energy from the reactor to propel the rock, you need to generate thrust. So you take water, you split hydrogen & oxygen, you burn it, you get thrust.
- pjscott 14y agoIf you're already bringing a nuclear reactor into space, you could use it to heat up the hydrogen and use it as propellant directly, for more efficient travel. (In situations where you need bursts of high thrust and are willing to sacrifice efficiency, you can also go with a hybrid system that uses both nuclear heat and combustion.) Oh, and fun safety fact: a nuclear reactor isn't actually particularly radioactive until it's turned on. If you launch it out of Earth's orbit before turning it on, you're sitting pretty.
- bfe 14y agoTwo Barclays commodities analysts produced a gleefully scathing research note on this project, and the Financial Times concluded that "The space mining talk amounts, however, to no more than hot air and gobbledegook", all based on laughably inadequate points of comparison. For example: "Their calculations were based on Nasa’s forthcoming OSIRIS-REx mission, which aims to launch a probe in 2016 to pluck samples from an asteroid called 1999 RQ36 and bring them to Earth. Nasa hopes it will be home by 2023, with a couple of ounces of dirt. By then, the cost will have reached $1bn – made up of $800m for the vehicle, plus another $200m for the rocket launch. Since that outlay will return just a couple of ounces of material, Barclays says it could use it as a baseline to estimate break-even prices for asteroid mining. Using the metrics proposed by Barclays, the Financial Times commodities team estimates that copper prices would need to rocket from today’s $3.81 an ounce to $476m for a similarly funded space mining project to cover its costs. Clearly, it does not look like base metals from space are likely to provide a good return on capital. So what about precious metals? Gold trades at $1,665 a troy ounce, setting a price of $518m a troy ounce for space-gold to break even." "Asteroid mining is for space cadets", The FT, April 30, 2012 - http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/9387fdc4-9081-11e1-8adc-00144feab49a.html http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/9387fdc4-9081-11e1-8adc-00144... Astonishing that anyone can take this seriously as a baseline. You don't become a commodities analyst for being able to include flexibility and imagination in your analytical capability.
- seagreen 14y agoYou'd have to be pretty dumb to bring copper back the surface. It would be far more valuable in orbit around Earth. Also NASA isn't, ah, the best example of a cost conscious and frugal organization. They probably don't make a good baseline for the expense of these trips. Planetary Resources still may never come close to turning a profit, but it's possible you're dismissing them a little too quickly.
- billswift 14y agoActually with his sloppy writing, I couldn't decide if he was dismissing Planetary Resources or Barclay's and the FT.
- typpo 14y agoAs a side project, I've been working on a site, http://asterank.com http://asterank.com, that attempts to rank asteroids by their economic potential. These calculations take into account things like the energetic cost of reaching and extracting material from an asteroid. Open to any feedback or pointers.
- djb_hackernews 14y agoThat is an awesome project. Keep it up!