5 ms·
Seagate claims spinning disks beat SSDs on carbon footprint
- nialse 2y agoThis is per TB, right? Not per IOPS?
- Liftyee 2y agoI'm curious about their methodology here. Just from a materials standpoint, a M.2 SSD has much less physical volume than a 3.5" HDD and fewer disparate materials (no moving parts = no coils,bearings,motors...) Perhaps the embodied carbon of memory chips is higher than I expect. To be cynical, there's probably a lot of corporate spin - Seagate is a HDD company after all.
- Teongot 2y ago> To be cynical, there's probably a lot of corporate spin - Seagate is a HDD company after all. applause
- xracy 2y agoPun intended?
- bmenrigh 2y agoSemiconductor manufacturing, especially using EUV, is a staggeringly power-hungry process. The EUV light production requires more than a megawatt by itself because of all the losses involved. No doubt this is why they only report on embodied carbon since it’s the one metric they can win on.
- amelius 2y agoBut a spinning harddrive contains electronics too ...
- cheschire 2y agoHDDs use much simpler electronics than SSDs. The controller in a hard drive mostly just moves the read/write head and spins the motor. It doesn’t need to do much processing. These chips are built on older manufacturing processes that are cheaper and less energy intensive. SSDs though need a fast processor to manage the flash memory for wear leveling, error correction, and keeping track of where everything is written etc. This requires more advanced chips, built on newer process nodes, which take a lot more energy and resources to make. And SSDs also need extra chips like DRAM and obviously the flash memory itself.
- whatevaa 2y agoDRAM is optional on NVME SSD's which can use host memory instead. DRAM-less SATA SSD's sucked.
- kvemkon 2y agoHDD controller calculates and checks ECC either and en/decodes the user's 0/1-bits to the 0/1-bits actually to be written on the platter but at much smaller speed (0.3 GB/s vs 14 GB/s SSD max). HDD has an extra servo controller. HDD has an extra 512 MB - 1 GB DRAM. WD HDDs 20 GB+ have some FLASH inside for metadata offload.
- dezgeg 2y agoIs the controller really going to be that much simpler on a HDD? On HDD you still have things like command queuing, caching, checksumming and bad block remapping just as with SSD. Sure you don't have the flash translation layer, but I'd expect processing of the analog signal going to/from the heads to be a processing headache too. I wouldn't be surprised if they have to do temperature compensation and factory and/or runtime calibration of the analog path. Of course much of that will be done in fixed-function custom hardware blocks, but almost certainly so would a SSD for eg. ECC calculations. https://spritesmods.com/?art=hddhack&page=3 https://spritesmods.com/?art=hddhack&page=3 has some data points on a 10+ year old HDD - 3 ARM9 feroceon cores + Cortex-M3 core. Doesn't sound too simple.
- PaulKeeble 2y ago
- jillesvangurp 2y agoNot all energy is carbon intensive. Using a lot of power is fine as long as you get the power in a sustainable way. That isn't necessarily true for a lot of current production. But that's changing rapidly. Especially in the parts of the world where this stuff is produced.
- eru 2y agoIf you are part of a large grid, power is fairly fungible (within that grid).
- rob_c 2y agoNope. Again look at Spain, not all power sources are equal and just because it's been connected to a network doesn't magically mean all of the load is then spread between all sinks. If your high school science teacher told you so, they were wrong. It's time to talk about proper grown up electronics in this discussion.
- eru 2y agoI was including the weasel world 'fairly' in front of 'fungible' exactly because I foresaw such a discussion. To be slightly more precise and wordy in what I wanted to express: The original comment said: > Not all energy is carbon intensive. Using a lot of power is fine as long as you get the power in a sustainable way. And that's true. You can buy 'green electricity' from the grid. But that mostly just means that the people who don't care get allocated a larger fraction of 'non-green' electricity. (That works, until you lose enough of that buffer of people who don't care where they electricity is coming from, that you have more demand for green electricity than is available on the grid. Then you actually need to spin up more green electricity or raise prices for that 'colour'.) Yes, there's different demand levels over time (throughout the day, and throughout the year etc), and different demanders need different reliability levels. And all the power sources have different profiles for when they are available, and how easy (or hard or impossible) it is to turn them on or off on short notice. > If your high school science teacher told you so, they were wrong. It's time to talk about proper grown up electronics in this discussion. Haha, right.
- estebank 2y agoI think the interaction of "thing is cheap" and "thing is tiny" break all of our heuristics for "thing is difficult and energy intensive to produce".
- PaulKeeble 2y agoThe thing is that anything electrical energy intense is going to become less CO2 producing every year as energy systems transition. Its the use of Iron and other necessary fuel usage that will become the CO2 intense items over the next 5 to 10 years. The energy usage wont be the issue and CO2e for production of any item is going to drop quite drastically.
- im3w1l 2y agoIron and steel can be made without fossil fuels. It's just more expensive.
- wtallis 2y agoIs anyone using EUV for SSDs? I don't think it's economical for NAND manufacturing. I'm not sure if SSD controllers are using EUV yet; they usually aren't on leading-edge process nodes.
- diggan 2y ago> and fewer disparate materials (no moving parts = no coils,bearings,motors...) But even so, isn't the lifetime of a SSD less than a HDD given the same amount of writes? Especially when you try to have the same amount of storage available. So say I want 16TB, I can either get 1 16TB SATA drive, or something like 4 4TB SSDs (or 8 2TB) to have the same storage, is the physical volume still less in that case? And, if I write 16TB of data each month to each of these alternatives, which one breaks first and has to be replaced?
- PaulKeeble 2y agoA typical consumer hard drive is going to last about 5 years, maybe more but it will wear just from existing. If you wrote 16GB to it a month that wont be a challenge for it. The SSD however will be specified on a life of how many writes it can do. For example a 990 Pro from Samsung will have a specified life of 1200TB. That is about 76,800 months of operation at 16GB, this is not only not a challenging workload for an SSD but you have 8 of them so 8 * 76800 months of operation on average. I have SSDs that are quite old, my original Intel 80GB G1 still works and still has 80% of its life left but its utterly obsolete as its too small to be useful and 500MB/s on SATA is a bit dated. All the OCZ SSDs are dead long ago but the Crucial M4 is still trucking along and its 512GB so still useful enough as is the Western Digital 1TB. I have barely scratched the surface of their usage life despite writing 35TB on them they still have 95% life over 42,000 hours of operation. So at 16GB writes monthly they are going to last as long as the silicon and PCB lasts, which if made well could be decades. They will certainly become obsolete in speed and size more than likely rather than dying.
- diggan 2y ago> I have barely scratched the surface of their usage life despite writing 35TB on them they still have 95% life over 42,000 hours of operation. What are you using these drives for, if I may ask? It seems to barely be used for anything, or I'm an outlier here. Here's an example of my main drive in my desktop/work computer: Model: Samsung SSD 980 PRO 2TB Power On Hours: 6,286 Data Written: 117,916,388 [60.3 TB] I'm just an average developer (I think), although I do bounce around a lot between languages/projects/manage VMs and whatnot, and some languages (Rust) tend to write a lot of data to disk when compiling. But the ratio difference seems absurd, you have ~0.0008 written per hour, while I have ~0.0096, that's a huge difference. Here's what I ran to get the data, in case others wanna check theirs: https://gist.github.com/victorb/f120f5b9bcc1c04a4c3d0107f6333d51 https://gist.github.com/victorb/f120f5b9bcc1c04a4c3d0107f633...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- voidUpdate 2y agoWhat load are these drives under? Is that just idle consumption, or constantly actively reading/writing?
- bmenrigh 2y agoThey only estimated “embodied carbon” which is all the carbon used to make the thing. They conveniently ignore the “operational carbon” to use them which is going to be way higher than SSD / NVME. They’re way slower which keeps the rest of the computer waiting and using power for much longer.
- voidUpdate 2y agoThe third column of the table is CO2/TB/Year, doesn't that mean how much they use per year, which would depend on how they're being used?
- bmenrigh 2y agoNo, they just assume drives last 5 years so they divide the carbon by 5.
- user32489318 2y agoThey also failed to adjust for expected lifetime of a product.
- bmenrigh 2y agoYeah “manufacturing carbon per TB” has got to be one of the most creative units I’ve seen used in corporate marketing bullshit.
- jbverschoor 2y agoCurious to see what WD / SanDisk has to say about this
- userbinator 2y agoBecause they don't wear out with each write and need to be replaced regularly like current SSDs do? Oh wait, we're talking about Seagate disks...
- Zekio 2y agowell unlike SSDs you need to regularly replace HDDs no matter the workload :D
- everdrive 2y agoUntil we start optimizing code, websites, etc this is a meaningless argument. Computers could use much less carbon than they do, but everyone needs them to be really fast, really powerful, use ray tracing, etc. But what most people do on computers could easily be done from a computer 20+ years ago; email, chatting, watching videos, word processing. In an alternate reality, the computing advances over time would have all been about efficiency, and code, operating systems, and websites would be written lean to work on much slower devices. We'll never live in that world, so Seagate's argument could potentially be true in a technical sense, but ultimately doesn't matter.
- eru 2y agoA lot of the computer advances of the last two decades have been about power efficiency: remember, phone are also computers. Laptops and tablets, too. 'Thanks' to limited battery capacity, consumers have been very interested in power efficiency.
- nottorp 2y agoI don't think the desktop CPU and video chip manufacturers got that memo... But as the top of this thread said, the most unjustified carbon footprint comes from javascript.
- maccard 2y agoNo, intel didn’t get it. AMD certainly did. An i7 14700k can draw 253 watts and do 5.4 GHz, a 9800X3D can boost to 5.2GHz at 160W. Thats pretty close to the top end of desktop CPUs (for home use). As you go down the chain, you’ll see huge drops in power usage. Intel in particular are guilty of replacing their mid and low range CPUs and replacing them with neutered low power cores to try and claw back the laptop market.
- nottorp 2y ago160 W is less than Intel, but still a lot. And I bet that even with AMD you get 85% of the performance with 50% of the power consumption on any current silicon... And 85% of the current performance is a lot. I have an AMD box that I temperature limited from the BIOS (because I was too lazy to look where the power limits were). It never uses more than 100W and it's fast enough.
- bob1029 2y agoI think the numbers might be broken? If it costs you 5000 kg of CO2 to manufacture the SSD, you will never recoup in operational terms no matter how it's sliced. A modern NGCC power plant generates 400-500kg of CO2 per megawatt-hour of energy produced. It would take well over 100 years of operation to begin approaching this at a consumption level of ~10w.
- gnfargbl 2y agoI thought so too at first, but after a little bit of research, those really do appear to be the correct numbers. For instance, a detailed report [1] into one of Seagate's 1.92TB SSDs suggests that it consumed >200kg CO2 per TB. Eye-opening, really. [1] https://www.seagate.com/files/www-content/global-citizenship/en-us/docs/seagate-koho-enterprise-ssd-lca-summary-2016-07-29.pdf https://www.seagate.com/files/www-content/global-citizenship...
- PaulKeeble 2y agoOne of the estimates my Solar system gives me is the amount of CO2 saved from using the system. I save about 6 Tonnes a year for having a 5.5KWp system. That is about 2.2 Tonnes of coal not burnt but its also only about 3 trees worth! Its quite staggering the amount of CO2 our energy use is actually producing. KGs of CO2 for an items manufacture is pretty normal.
- Aissen 2y agoThe source on Embodied Carbon in SSDs seems to be this 2022 paper: https://hotcarbon.org/assets/2022/pdf/hotcarbon22-tannu.pdf https://hotcarbon.org/assets/2022/pdf/hotcarbon22-tannu.pdf ; but unless I'm mistaken, it does not claim anything like the full Seagate "report": https://www.seagate.com/content/dam/seagate/assets/resources/decarbonizing-data-report/pdf/decarbonizing-data-report-03-2025-a4-en-gb.pdf https://www.seagate.com/content/dam/seagate/assets/resources... ; there might have been an "extrapolation" because 30TB SSDs did not exist then (outside labs). I'd treat it with a two-order of magnitudes (at least) grain of salt.
- Timshel 2y agoThx, there is a graph for embodied cost at the start of page 3 and figure vary wildly. The biggest drive at the time was 3840GB, and its production emitted ~425kg. But if we look at the more prevalent models the emission vary widly: for 512: between ~25 to 225kg and for 1024 from ~60 to 275kg. And while the paper start with the assertion that manufacturing a Gigabyte of Flash emits 0.16 Kg CO2, I expect emission to be highly dependent on the number of flash module and not so much on the capacity itself.
- lupusreal 2y agoI find it hard to imagine a situation in which carbon footprint could be a tie breaker in a storage purchasing decision.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- GuestFAUniverse 2y agoAFAIK a gram of purified silicon has used the equivalent of 75kg of charcoal -- I wish I still had the sources. So, yeah. Possibly. Then again: the amount of hard drives I need to get a RAID that performs anything close to even the slowest SSD(RAID) is unfathomable. -> hard drives need more resources and a lot more power considering performance
- PaulKeeble 2y agoI suspect in CO2e if performance is the limitation of what you are doing then an SSD is going to be less CO2e emitted because you can do it on fewer devices. However if you are just looking for space and the performance isn't an issue then the HDD will be the less CO2e emitting solution for now. This i think will change however as more of the grid uses renewable energy, there is nothing instrinsic in the silicon process that must be burning CO2, its all electricity based and while it uses a lot of energy it doesn't require burning fuel like making Iron does (at the moment).
- GuestFAUniverse 2y agoAgree. These were pretty old numbers and are getting irrelevant by the day. And as I tried to argue: for performance SSD are a no-brainer in all dimensions. Space vs. cost: you don't have to tell me. We take care for more than a PB in-house. Guess what? Still mostly on HDs.
- mhnuam 2y agoWe have been trying to investigate this SSD/HDD lifecycle carbon footprint tradeoff over the past months, albeit limited to a case study of KV-stores so far. The work is getting published at CCGrid2025 which is currently taking place, so the paper should soon be available. > However if you are just looking for space and the performance isn't an issue then the HDD will be the less CO2e emitting solution for now Yes, that is what our results showed and this is the "easy" conclusion: if a HDD can handle the load, then it should be used as it will have both lower operational emissions as well as lower embodied emissions. Where it gets more complicated is when you have a load that you could handle with a single SSD but where a few HDD would be needed in parallel to achieve the same performance. In that case, one of the big factors (besides device lifetime and embodied carbon estimates) is the carbon intensity of your operational electricity: if the electricity footprint is low, you can afford the lower operational efficiency of your HDD setup, since the increased energy consumption is less impactful. The reason this is relevant is because this > This i think will change however as more of the grid uses renewable energy does not apply equally to all parts of the lifecycle. Hardware manufacturing is expected to decarbonize much slower than the operational part. See also https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3604930.3605717 https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3604930.3605717 (very insightful article in general).
- rapestinians 2y ago[flagged]
- ChrisNorstrom 2y agoI can't wait to see their reaction one day when they realize "Climate Change" is actually caused by the sun's increased output and upcoming scheduled micronova. I saw an article floating around that admitted there's no man made climate change, it's actually the sun, which was pretty brave.
- drbscl 2y agoSolar irradiance has been declining for the past three decades...