4 ms·
America's College Towns Go from Boom to Bust
- beej71 2y agoI finally after all those years got my dream gig teaching at the university and it's all crashing down. Too bad foreign countries aren't courting teachers like they are researchers.
- domoregood 2y agohttps://archive.is/ngnWt https://archive.is/ngnWt
- mjevans 2y agoSkimmed TFA. This might be an accurate summary: Less kids are enrolling in college due to several factors. A decline in birthrates (right around the 2008 recession), a decline in those who calculate that college provides a real return on investment and the cost of lost opportunity, and also a third strike in the form of federal funding cuts. There's a bunch of example case sob story, a lot of emotional focus. Yet I didn't see much (obvious) about any positive paths forward. It's far too late at this stage to prop up schools that are surplus relative to population. Re-purposing them for other educational tasks or possibly businesses (rather than just a shooting range complex) might be happening elsewhere. College could be made less of a rat-race hassle. The core aspects of an education and experience in college probably should be more fool-proof (all the classes delivered as a scheduled package that works, threaded for multiple years with a couple slack openings for retakes). With some slack time built in for making up a dropped class or three (not entirely skipped semesters!). Also social mixer and electives courses. Though crack down on the crazy party stuff, moderation is key, and as a tea toter, I'd like to suggest a very strong look at banning all mind altering drugs (including alcohol, other than limited quantities for cooking) during the educational years. As far as the question of if college is worth it? That might differ from person to person. Trades / Vocational work can also be fulfilling and maybe some people might enjoy that. We all need mechanics, electricians, and construction workers. Though those jobs might seriously benefit from some augmentation / automation / tech to prevent worker burn out and body damage.
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoThere's also been the 20+ years of STEM dogma driving students away from liberal arts colleges teaching a classical curriculum.
- poulsbohemian 2y agoTrue - but my alma mater (midwest liberal arts school) has had a CS program since the 1970s and added programs like data science over the past decade, plus always had a 3+2 engineering partnership with another school. In the small PNW town where I now live, the liberal arts college added a CS program a few years ago plus also had a 3+2 engineering partnership for decades. So my point is - even for those students who wanted to do something STEM related, these liberal arts schools started augmenting their programs a long time ago.
- somenameforme 2y agoBurn out and body damage from trades is not really factually based, especially not compared to something like software. You can actually quantify this. For instance the median age of a construction worker is 42. [1] In some states it's pushing near 50. By contrast in software there is extreme defacto age discrimination. I don't think it's usually real age discrimination but simply companies don't really value experience in software much, and so somebody with many years years of experience is often seen as less desirable than somebody with little to no experience, but who you can pay a far lesser wage to. Whatever the reason, the point is that software is, for most, going to be a relatively short-lived career. I can't find a good source for the data on the age of developers, though there are a million blog style or Q/A posts bemoaning the increasing difficultly finding a job as developers age. The Stack Overflow survey [2] is probably not representative, but matches observation at least, with a median age in the younger side of the 25-34 bracket. And that brief window of time you have in software is after you [typically] spend 4 years in college, and then spend however many years paying off your college debt before you finally get to enjoy your full salary. And obviously I am speaking big picture here. There are people who have a catastrophic injury in the trades and live the rest of their life on disability from age 22. And there are software developers still coding at 50. But these are rare exceptions, and not the rule in either case. [1] - https://www.nahb.org/blog/2023/06/age-of-construction-workforce https://www.nahb.org/blog/2023/06/age-of-construction-workfo... [2] - https://survey.stackoverflow.co/2024/developer-profile#demographics-age-prof https://survey.stackoverflow.co/2024/developer-profile#demog...
- rekenaut 2y agoStudents entering smaller colleges now have to ask themselves more than ever whether their university will be open in four years when they plan to graduate. With increasing closures of private and public colleges alike, I’m sure this will continue to fuel the flight from regional schools to state flagships.
- timr 2y agoAnyone who looked at demographic trends 10+ years ago knew that this was coming. As far back as the late 90s, it was clear that universities were overinvesting into the one of the last echos of the baby boom.
- somenameforme 2y agoA lot of people are, in general, in denial of what reduced fertility will bring. Consequences lag effect by decades so it's not exactly a secret what the future will hold. For instance most don't realize that Japan is still in the 'good ole days', relative to what awaits them in the future, even as places like Tokyo start to shrink today. I also think people don't realize how fast things start happening once they do start happening. For another example there you can approximate the change in population due to fertility (once a fertility rate is shared among a population) as being a scalar on population of fertility_rate/2 every 20 years. So a fertility rate of 1 means each and every woman has 1 child on average, yet nonetheless that means your population ends up declining by 50% every 20 years, exponentially, until you start having a healthy number of children again, or go extinct. So for a bemusing one one, North Korea and South Korea are still technically at war. And North Korea is going to win, simply by continuing to exist. South Korea with their fertility rate of 0.75 will not only see catastrophic population decline, but their entire economy will collapse alongside it. Going from 0.75 to a healthy fertility rate is probably not going to happen, so the North needs to merely wait, and keep having children.
- nyokodo 2y ago> And North Korea is going to win, simply by continuing to exist. Except their fertility is below replacement also and as a poverty stricken repressive regime that relies on food aid from South Korea, China, and probably Russia lately the latter having their own terminal demographic crises… they might not out-survive the south for long. 1. https://www.newsweek.com/how-north-korea-news-births-compare-south-1955156 https://www.newsweek.com/how-north-korea-news-births-compare...
- somenameforme 2y ago
- decimalenough 2y agoThe title is misleading. As the article itself notes, "Large flagship universities—blessed with strong academic reputations and high-profile sports programs—continue to boost local economies". It's the second and third-tier institutions located in economically depressed areas, like the one profiled here (Western Illinois University’s Macomb campus), that are suffering. After all, why would you fork out a lot of money for a diploma that's worth little and won't even connect you with local job opportunities?
- mmooss 2y ago> why would you fork out a lot of money for a diploma that's worth little and won't even connect you with local job opportunities? To learn, to sharpen your mind, to grow and change yourself.
- threatofrain 2y agoAnd why should you sacrifice the ability to connect with opportunity just because you wanted to expand your mind? It's unfortunate that people should be presented with this forced choice.
- mmooss 2y ago> sacrifice the ability to connect with opportunity just because you wanted to expand your mind Growing as a person and intellectually is a great opportunity, a lifelong change. Better than some immediate cash in an entry-level job.
- kohbo 2y agoThere are other ways to do that. School is an investment.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> There are other ways to do that. School is an investment For most people, yes. For our elites, I think one of the great losses over the past generations has been this financialisation of education. Measuring ROI solely in monetary terms, thereby sacrificing the civic and cultural parts for that which is easily measured and marketed.
- keiferski 2y agoNow really seems like an opportune moment for one of these third-tier colleges to rebrand itself as a trade school but aimed at students that would have otherwise gone to college (and not the traditional trade school audience.) I bet there is a ton of demand for a trades-based education but in a college experience wrapper.
- alex43578 2y agoI disagree. The changes a school would need to make to the school, the curriculum, and the faculty to switch from teaching accounting or gender studies to welding or HVAC would mean you'd be pasting an expensive University of Misc State logo and mascot onto a whole new enterprise, implicitly putting a premium on an educational path that's really all about ROI.
- keiferski 2y agoI think many people would be willing to pay that premium for a college experience. And from the college's point of view, changing focus is certainly better than shutting down completely.
- keiferski 2y agoJust to add to this: I did a little research into this idea and there seem to actually be a few places like this already - Thaddeus Steven’s Institute of technology is one.
- alex43578 2y agoWhat is the college experience in this context? Networking? The library and research efforts? Socialization? Parties? Frats? Sports teams? On the "academic" side, I don't see how the college experience would work for a trade school, while on the "social" side, it's crazy to think you'd pay the premium for most of these things (except networking, as people often point out for "regular" colleges) when there's other avenues for socialization or sports.
- Yeul 2y agoWhen the Dutch government cut funding for universities they found a new cash cow: foreigners! But for Chinese students the Netherlands is exotic nobody wants to go to Missouri I guess. (Ironically the government is now complaining that there are too many foreigners and that everyone is speaking English).
- burnt-resistor 2y agoXenophobia is an automatic signal of ignorance/stupidity/insecurity. I worked with a Chinese-American naturalized citizen who moved from PGP/Symantec to work at Stanford just long enough to get his kid the tuition discount (10 years still?). That's real love, dedication, and sacrifice for one's kids.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoAt least these students physically are in Netherlands? Over here there are many "private universities/academias" with students from outside of EU but they are permanently on "scholarship in Africa" or "yoga classes in India". It's basically a foot in the door for the EU stay permit.
- alephnerd 2y ago> But for Chinese students the Netherlands is exotic nobody wants to go to Missouri I guess. They used to go to these schools. There just aren't that many Chinese anymore either. A decade ago, UIUC (mentioned in the article) was derisively called the "University of Indians and Chinese". Now, UIUC's Chinese admissions collapsed [0] - a trend that happened in every university. The same thing will happen with Indian students within a decade, because Green Card waiting periods act as a quasi-thousands talents program, and you can demand an EU level tech salary in India with US (especially SV, Seattle, or NYC) work experience. Already, a couple of my peers who worked at top ML labs in the Bay have begun transferring to the Indian branches of American R&D labs and/or taking faculty positions at top universites, when barely 15 years ago you would be hard pressed to find an American educated CS professor from a school like MIT, UIUC, or UW in India. [0] - https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/11/29/university-illinois-insures-itself-against-possible-drop-chinese-enrollments https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/11/29/university-il...
- ckemere 2y agoMusing - Universities historically were easy to create in rural/underdeveloped areas with cheap land. (Particularly the ag/tech variant funded by the federal government.) A very small number aggregated enough people to generate sustained urbanization. The rest have always been tenuous in the sense that they exist because of a state-federal consensus that they are worth subsidizing. Without this, urban/suburban universities are more likely to sustain themselves. Further thought - on the timescale of history, professors have always been (lower) middle class. Perhaps we should not be surprised to see a return to the mean…
- roody15 2y agohttps://archive.md/20250519010301/https://www.wsj.com/us-news/education/college-towns-economy-macomb-illinois-aae84dcc https://archive.md/20250519010301/https://www.wsj.com/us-new...