4 ms·
The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated
- andrewl 1y agoLike most people I want to live a long time. But more than life span I am interested in health span. I want to feel good and be autonomous as long as possible. Fitness, especially good muscle mass, is an important part of that.
- drewcoo 1y agoI'll just add that I don't want more of the last years of my life. I'd like more of the middle.
- pmarreck 1y agoExactly. And if you consider that every hour you spend purely exercising (gym, treadmill, etc.) in the middle does NOT pay for an extra hour of life on the tail end, it doesn’t seem like the best trade. (I will say that a morning workout still supercharges your day!)
- socalgal2 1y ago> (I will say that a morning workout still supercharges your day!) And you'd be wrong. It does not supercharge my day. Maybe it superchargers your day. Just finished my morning workout and now I feel like I've been drugged and need a nap. I do not feel "supercharged"
- pmarreck 1y agoMaybe it depends on what you've done and for how long?
- socalgal2 1y agoOr maybe different people's bodies react differently? I've got many decades of life experience. Not once in my life have I ever felt energized from working out.
- smolder 1y agoMaybe. I suspect it has more to do with baseline activity level and type of workout, but I could be wrong. I only have 1 body. IME, If I do nothing all day, I'll feel sluggish all day. If I take a 30 minute walk or do some squats, pullups or overhead presses, it will get my heart rate up and I'll feel more awake afterwards. I generally don't push myself to the point of exhaustion with exercise.
- pmarreck 1y agoI will defer to your many decades of life experience. I just noticed that in my 53 year existence, only by the past 10 years, a morning workout (which I didn't do prior to that) was figuratively and literally eye-opening, not just physically but mentally. Specifically, it was the Orangetheory workout. And I regretted not discovering it sooner, and mainly I blame people who didn't emphasize not just the physical but the mental boost
- generalenvelope 1y agoDr. Feigenbaum from Barbell Medicine says "We want to add years to your life, and life to your years" :)
- melling 1y agoYes, everyone is interested in healthspan
- Aurornis 1y agoThe funny thing about the “healthspan” trend is that it’s simply describing what everyone meant when they said they wanted to live a long time. Nobody wanted to live a long time but be unhealthy in their older years. It wasn’t until health and fitness podcasters started holding up the “healthspan” term as something novel that we had to hear about the supposed difference. It’s also unfortunate that the “healthspan” influencers frequently get into health trends that have the opposite effect. The main example I can think of is Dr. Peter Attia, who started out praising ketogenic diets (recently shown to have very negative effects on cardiovascular health, not surprisingly) and later Rapamycin (briefly praised by lifespan influencers until they all decided it was hurting more than helping). I think one of the best things people can do for long-term health is limit their consumption of health and fitness influencers who are pressured to constantly invent and push new things to keep themselves relevant.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- iamthemonster 1y agoWhich study are you referring to for keto having a negative impact on cardiovascular health? I've unfortunately found studies and metastudies reaching all sorts of conflicting conclusions on keto. The top metastudies on a simple google search both conclude positive effects on CVD.
- Aurornis 1y agoKetogenic diet research is fascinating in itself for how many manipulated or misleading studies get published. The most recent example is the KETO-CTA paper, which was released in April to loud claims that high LDL in a keto diet was not really bad. It got picked up by various news outlets as vindicating ketogenic diets. The authors posted long Twitter threads full of meme animated gifs celebrating their victory over keto skeptics. Yet when people started looming into the study they noticed that the study failed to report the data from the pre-registered trial endpoint. This is highly unusual because if you establish an entire clinical trial, you are expected to publish the primary results you pre-registered. After a lot of prodding, people finally got the authors to release the percent change in non-calcified plaque volume (NCPV) values that they pre-registered for and they were extremely high. Even higher than seen in certain serious medical conditions. It became clear that they chose to hide the values because they were so incredibly bad. > The top metastudies on a simple google search both conclude positive effects on CVD. There are a lot of die-hard keto defenders who produce papers, blogs, and podcasts claiming it’s either neutral or good for CVD. You have to look past the SEO optimized content and go to actual CVD experts who do not have their internet presence tied to promoting keto diets.
- amrocha 1y agoI think personally I want to be bedridden, sick, and miserable for as long as possible but I respect your point of view too!
- mlhpdx 1y ago> especially good muscle mass I thought semi-starvation was the one and only strongly evidenced way too extend lifespan? Which obviously doesn’t require, and in fact destroys, muscle mass.
- Noumenon72 1y ago> Next, the researchers examined how fitness was associated with the risk of dying in random accidents such as car accidents, drownings and homicides. They chose random accidents because they assumed that there ought to be no association between the men’s fitness in late adolescence and the risk of dying in random accidents. Blank slatism is the curse of the sciences. Of course the kind of people who die in car accidents and homicides are not identical to everyone else but for random luck. They're less educated[1], they make poor decisions, they have dangerous neighbors, frequently they're immigrants from countries with lots of car accidents and homicides. We've known that "everything is correlated" since 2014[2], when will science figure it out? 1. https://www.theverge.com/2015/10/2/9438197/traffic-accident-study-education-level-deaths https://www.theverge.com/2015/10/2/9438197/traffic-accident-... 2. https://gwern.net/everything https://gwern.net/everything
- stepanhruda 1y agoI thought these studies often control for additional factors like wealth, education etc. not sure about this one, but genuinely curious whether I am mistaken and science “did not figure it out” yet
- gwern 1y agoThose studies never 'control for those'. What they do is a crude statistical approximation (sometimes extremely crude - eg most studies will 'control for education' by counting up 'years', which equates 4 years at Caltech with 4 years in community college), and hope that not too much leaks through as "residual confounding" (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0152719 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...). Unfortunately, because everything is correlated, there's residual confounding everywhere. This is why every time someone does a Scandinavian population registry study and compares eg siblings within the same family, often the correlation just disappears then and there. It's 100% unsurprising that this is true of fitness too. This is what always happens. You look at something like a corporate health fitness plan and you find some correlate even after you 'control for' SES, prior health record etc etc; wonderful! Then you do a randomized experiment and it turns out that the residual confounding was still larger than any causal effect which might be there: https://gwern.net/doc/statistics/causality/2022-wallace.pdf https://gwern.net/doc/statistics/causality/2022-wallace.pdf Ah well. Maybe next time you'll manage to 'control for' the confounders...
- riskassessment 1y agoProbability of dying in a random accident is the probability of a random accident occuring times the probability of dying from a random accident conditional on one occurring. I am not convinced that fitness would be entirely unassociated with both of these probabilities, particularly the latter. Meaning that the extent to which this outcome is a good negative control is overestimated.
- knuckleheadsmif 1y agoThere is mortality and there is quality of life and someone who is fit will have a better quality of life even if they don’t necessarily live longer.
- _dain_ 1y ago>Next, the researchers examined how fitness was associated with the risk of dying in random accidents such as car accidents, drownings and homicides. They chose random accidents because they assumed that there ought to be no association between the men’s fitness in late adolescence and the risk of dying in random accidents. This method is called negative control outcome analysis and involves testing the validity of your results for a primary outcome by comparing them with an outcome where no association ought to be found. If, however, an association is found, it may indicate that the groups studied are not actually comparable, and that the study suffers from what is typically referred to as confounding. The researchers found that men with the highest fitness levels had a 53 per cent lower risk of dying in random accidents. Yet, it is unlikely that the men’s fitness would have such a big effect on their risk of dying in random accidents. I haven't read the underlying paper so maybe they addressed this, but: couldn't this just be because sedentary/unfit people tend to drive everywhere? So they're involved in more car accidents than healthier people, who walk places more. Also if you're fat and don't exercise, you've got a lower chance of surviving emergency surgery after a car crash, or swimming to safety after falling in water, or dodging a knife ... I don't think it's a given that physical fitness is unrelated to surviving those things.
- azan_ 1y ago> I haven't read the underlying paper so maybe they addressed this, but: couldn't this just be because sedentary/unfit people tend to drive everywhere? It could be and that's the point - the exact causal effect of fitness might be overstated because some mortality reduction might have stem from - for example - driving less.
- imcoconut 1y agoI agree completely. Also definitions matter. Currently in the US one of the leading causes of death, if not the leasing cause, is opiods which the CDC classifies as “accidental overdose”. The healthiest people in the US are probably abusing opiods at lower rates and therefore less likely to die from the leading cause of “accidental death”. The study is from sweden but just pointing out that the assumption they make is flawed - “we should not expect a relationship between fitness and accidental death”.
- akamaka 1y agoThey appear to have proven that by walking more and driving less, you have a lower chance of dying prematurely in an accident, but for some reason which they have yet to uncover, that effect is not due to the extra fitness you get from walking.
- ahazred8ta 1y ago'accidents' includes non-vehicle related accidental deaths, such as "Hold my beer and watch me do this."
- manwe150 1y agoYou also do have a higher chance when walking of getting fatally hit by a car (because right turn on red is legal in most of the US). So it probably isn’t quite that simple. I think that was one of the original Freakonomics book studies?
- SchemaLoad 1y agoThe study is from Sweden. Most of the world doesn't run people over nearly as much.
- ninetyninenine 1y agoFinding a random association doesn’t establish causality or de-establish causality on another different association. The causality was originally just assumed. Now with this new association, what changed? Logically nothing has changed right? There is no logical conclusion derivable from this.
- gregors 1y ago>>>> n the study, the researchers leveraged data from 1.1 million Swedish men So in other words, light years better shape through out all age ranges compared to your average American.
- ohelabs 1y ago> In the study, the researchers leveraged data from 1.1 million Swedish men who were conscripted for military service between the years 1972 and 1995 For anyone from the US reading this just throw it out… we eat significantly less healthy and have significantly more obesity. Sweden as a country is significantly more healthy and active. To everyone reading this and thinking that this applies is sorely mistaken. Fitness might not “extend your life many years” but being morbidly obese will most certainly end it significantly early.
- strken 1y ago48.3% of the Swedish population are overweight or obese, per https://data.worldobesity.org/country/sweden-207/#data_trends https://data.worldobesity.org/country/sweden-207/#data_trend.... This is obviously not military age swedes in the 90s. Still, it's not too far below the US's 70%-ish.
- amluto 1y ago> Next, the researchers examined how fitness was associated with the risk of dying in random accidents such as car accidents > The researchers found that men with the highest fitness levels had a 53 per cent lower risk of dying in random accidents. Yet, it is unlikely that the men’s fitness would have such a big effect on their risk of dying in random accidents. Wait, what? https://aaafoundation.org/rates-motor-vehicle-crashes-injuries-deaths-relation-driver-age-united-states-2014-2015/ https://aaafoundation.org/rates-motor-vehicle-crashes-injuri... The risk of being in a motor vehicle crash increases as one gets older than ~70 years. The risk of dying increases even more dramatically. Now maybe this effect is independent of physical fitness, but that’s quite an assumption. I would guess the contrary: that poor fitness quite dramatically increases one’s risk of a car crash, both due to reduced motor control and increased risk of various neurological issues. Vascular dementia, for example, seems very likely to be correlated and often caused by poor fitness. Various sources seem to think that exercise can quite dramatically reduce Alzheimer’s risk. Alzheimer’s disease is related to PCA, and I suspect that PCA is very much under-diagnosed and that it causes a lot of crashes.
- azan_ 1y agoThat's a very good point. However the median follow-up in the study was 56 with IQR 50 to 62 years, I think that reduces this issue a lot.
- anothernewdude 1y agoI'm a (fairly) fit runner. I run for about 8 hours each week, sometimes longer. I'm in a car so much less than the average person. Guess why.
- amazingamazing 1y agoYou live closer to work?
- anothernewdude 1y agoIt's 10km.
- deadbabe 1y agoI find that a lot of people these days seem to optimize their lifestyle for living up to about 50 years old, up to which point they don’t seem to care about dying off since life after that gets a lot more annoying and less enjoyable due to aging, and mounting debts that go unpaid and have no hope of being paid off. People can envision a good life up to about 50, but they struggle to imagine anything good happening after that since there aren’t many good examples on social media except for ageless rich people with all the time and money in the world.
- yakbarber 1y agoI don't think I'd agree with their hypothesis though that there's no connection between dying in a random accident and fitness. Fit people: 1. more able to "get out of the way" / coordination / agility 2. faster reaction time 3. potentially suffer a reduced injury 4. more likely to recover than die from the injury There's probably a dozen rational things we could think of to counter that hypothesis.
- 8note 1y ago5. more likely to be nearby certain types of random accidents 6. less likely to be nearby other types of random accidents
- TylerE 1y agoYou’re making assumptions not in evidence. It’s well documented for instance that drunk people do better in accidents than sober people precisely because their reactions are slower and they don’t tense up.
- amazingamazing 1y agoI’m skeptical that it’s worth it to spend too much time working out. If there are three options: 1. Sedentary lifestyle (<3 passive or active exercise weekly). 2. Moderate (~1 hour passive exercise daily, like walking a dog a few miles daily). 3. Active (>1 hr active, like running several miles or lifting). I think there’s huge value in moving out of (1), but am not sure if it’s worth going from (2) to (3) w.r.t longevity
- gdudeman 1y agoThis might explain how people who exercise for work do not seem to get the health benefits of people who exercise recreationally. It’s not the exercise, it’s that people who recreationally work out are in a different socioeconomic group. Also, this is consistent with many mouse studies.
- SchemaLoad 1y agoA lot of the "exercise for work" stuff is quite dangerous
- BrenBarn 1y agoWell, it stands to reason that more physically fit people would be better able to leap out of the way of an oncoming train, etc. :-)
- User23 1y agoAll else being equal a more fit person is more likely to avoid an otherwise fatal accident.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoWho cares, a long healthspan feels great!
- TMWNN 1y ago>I believe that every human has a finite number of heartbeats. I don't intend to waste any of mine running around doing exercises. —Attributed to Neil Armstrong
- constantcrying 1y agoPhysical fitness is obviously one of the most important characteristics for a test pilot and astronaut.
- hackeraccount 1y agoMaybe it was Armstrong who first said that maybe not but it was said by someone who doesn't know what exercise does to someone's resting heart rate.
- constantcrying 1y ago>Next, the researchers examined how fitness was associated with the risk of dying in random accidents such as car accidents, drownings and homicides. They chose random accidents because they assumed that there ought to be no association between the men’s fitness in late adolescence and the risk of dying in random accidents. This is clearly and obviously false though. Even the assumption is kind of ridiculous. Of course a person with greater general fitness is going to, on average, suffer less severe consequences from a random accident. Including drowning is especially ridiculous, because that is a scenario where greater physical fitness directly contributes to your ability to survive such an accident. The results can just as well be interpreted in a way that the original thesis is correct, but greater physical fitness also helps protect your body against the consequences of random accidents.