2 ms·
> very little that’s unique about NYC’s ability to build a great public transit system Have you been to New York? We’re uniquely dense, rich and collectivist.
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> very little that’s unique about NYC’s ability to build a great public transit system
Have you been to New York?
We’re uniquely dense, rich and collectivist. We have a long and proud history of public transit and a culture that doesn’t put social cachet on vehicle ownership. That’s entirely different from the rest of America.
> if somehow NYC could do it,
what’s everyone else’s reasoning for not?
New York’s government is larger, and has a larger remit, than many countries. More practically: they haven’t.
> obscene amount of lobbying from your local car dealer baron, if you’re in Nashville (for example)
This isn’t being launched in Nashville.
- dogman144 2y agoYa and it’s also granite on swamp, with significant cost multipliers to get anything built. Latter is a literal statement, engineering bids have geoloc multipliers for costs. To your later point, I’d love to see some data on why modern city states are the only ones able to build public transit. As a Ny’er, I stand by my point that it’s crooked as heck. Not sure how you could spend any time under an Adams or Giuliani admin and think otherwise, to barely scratch the surface. Tammany hall anyone? Lastly - you’re a NYer and saying pub transit is untenably uncomfortable Metronorth isn’t too bad and has new cars within the last decade. Amtrak is similar.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> it’s also granite on swamp, with significant cost multipliers to get anything built We're still talking about busses, right? If we're pivoting to subways, the granite isn't why building subways in New York is expensive. It's one part the existing density of the city and nine parts the usual American permitting hell [1]. > I’d love to see some data on why modern city states are the only ones able to build public transit Fixed costs scale with distance (not area--routes are 1D) serviced. Revenue potential scales with area around stops. (And drops non-linearly as travel time for potential customers increases from each stop.) Latency and travel time scale inversely with number of stops. Put it together and you need revenue per stop to cover the cost of, ideally, the distance halfway to the next stops. Herego, density reigns supreme [2]. > you’re a NYer and saying pub transit is untenably uncomfortable I said busses are uncomfortable. Trains are fine. But you're not going to get an LIRR and subway system working sustainably in Dallas, Baltimore or even Chicago--everyone already owns a car, which makes the marginal cost of driving oneself uncompetitive with public transit. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-... [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590198220301718 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259019822...
- xethos 2y ago> uniquely dense, rich and collectivist And yet on the list of North America transit systems by ridership[0], while New York City takes the top spot, every other city in America loses first to Mexico, then to Canada. I can't speak on Mexico with any authority, but telling me multiple cities in Canada are more dense and financially well-off than every other city in America is more than a little shocking. Telling me the (allegedly, but very publicly and loudly) Christian country is more collectivist than both Canada and Mexico is odd, unless we take a very cynical view of what it means to be Christian in America > doesn’t put social cachet on vehicle ownership > This isn’t being launched in Nashville Yes, the point is that the social cachet around vehicle ownership is marketing, pushed by car dealerships (among other institutions) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_North_American_rapid_transit_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_North_American_rapid_t...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Telling me the (allegedly, but very publicly and loudly) Christian country is more collectivist than both Canada and Mexico is odd OP mentioned Nashville. I wasn’t considering places outside America. Within America, New York is unique in those aspects. As a global city, it’s strikingly inefficient. > point is that the social cachet around vehicle ownership is marketing, pushed by car dealerships (among other institutions) Sure. Whatever. I disagree, but that’s irrelevant. It’s the field we’re given to play. We can complain about the field or we can play to win. Lots of problems could be solved if wishing upon a star that people were different did anything. It doesn’t. So we’re left with real solutions and pipe dreams. If one side offers only the latter, particularly if conspiratorially tinted, you go with the other option.
- freejazz 2y ago>Have you been to New York? Rude. I'm a lifelong New Yorker and nothing about your posts seem reasonable or made apparent by anything that's just "obvious" about being in new york. There's also great bus transit in Queens... but you don't mention that. You just continuously suggest all your points are self evident.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> There's also great bus transit in Queens Sure. If you don’t see why Queens is uniquely well situation to be served by such a system, particularly in comparison to e.g. Nashville, I’m going to be similarly surprised.
- freejazz 2y agoYes, manhattan is the only special place in the country that can have public transit. Oh wait yeah, except for Queens! No, they aren't particularly alike and yes it is true that plenty of cities outside of the US have great public transit, despite not having what the special Manhattan and/or Queens sauce, but yes... Nashville.