4 ms·
> pub transit degrades bc now it shares service with competition Privately-operated buses on city bus lanes seems fine? Like, American cities have largely fail
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> pub transit degrades bc now it shares service with competition
Privately-operated buses on city bus lanes seems fine? Like, American cities have largely failed at making bus rapid transit economically sustainable and comfortable for the broader population. Trying a different model seems prudent versus going for puritinism.
(The alternative for these riders isn’t the bus. It’s private Ubers and cars. If cities won’t permit something like this, it warrants asking if public resources are better used turning those bus lanes into standard ones.)
> Taxpayers fund Uber and buses
Why? Charge a use fee.
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> The alternative for these riders isn’t the bus. It’s private Ubers and cars. Why? If they're taking a fixed-route shuttle, why is their only alternative a different sub-service of Uber?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nickff 2y agoIn the vast majority of US cities, most people do not use transit. Most of the people who choose not to use Uber shuttles or busses will be opting for passenger vehicles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_high_transit_ridership https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_high_...
- neltnerb 2y agoYou're likely right, but I suspect only because of social stigma and classism. Literally what is the difference between a fixed route shuttle operated by Uber versus a bus operated by the city, except that one siphons the profit into a private company? I imagine flexibility of imagination more than practicality. If Uber can do it, especially if they can do it profitably, I'm at a loss as to why a city government could not accomplish the same. This seems like a vastly better approach, cities have to start somewhere. -- https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1017072 https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1017072 | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43980845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43980845
- nickff 2y agoThe government has massive advantages when competing against Uber, namely that it gets to design the infrastructure and subsidize the system, so I would be unsurprised if Uber's efforts failed. That said, the government has historically failed to innovate in mass transit, so I hope Uber is allowed to proceed, and I look forward to seeing what happens.
- hgomersall 2y agoOne entity has a public purpose to provide effective public transport across a wide area with different routes of variable profitability. The other has a goal of claiming the profitable routes and ignoring the non profitable ones.
- underlipton 2y agoI just don't follow. There is no "claim"; the municipality can run on the "profitable" routes, too. They don't have to turn a profit, though, so they can always undercut Uber (unless Uber intends to use their previous strategy of taking losses on each ride until the competitor goes out of business, and I don't know that any city would stand for it). So, then, the only reason to use Uber's routes is because they're more comfortable or direct. However, in that case, they're obliged to charge more per passenger, at a rate approaching the cost of a private Uber ride. Maybe their goal IS to run city busses out of business. Maybe they're about to FAFO.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> the municipality can run on the "profitable" routes, too Hell, the municipality can wait to see if it works, and if it does, launch a public competitor.
- hgomersall 2y agoObviously it depends on the municipality, but in the UK for example, there's a (IMO deeply misguided) view that public transport should be cost neutral. That is, the bus services in a city, say, should not be subsidised. This is to the point that it is actually illegal for city councils to run a bus services. The private contractors are consistently pushing against their minimal service obligations in areas that are less profitable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dogman144 2y agoNYC’s newer bus lane approaches and congestion pricing findings counter this. Also, you’re measuring pub transit by its economic sustainability. Pub sector services are not judged by this, nor should they be. See my OP.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> NYC’s newer bus lane approaches and congestion pricing findings counter this Could you clarify which this? (And point to the source? I’m a big fan of congestion pricing.) Would also note that my “largely” is “largely” mostly to exclude New York. Public transit works in Manhattan, and is uniquely successful in the New York metro area [1]. [1] https://www.moneygeek.com/resources/car-ownership-statistics/ https://www.moneygeek.com/resources/car-ownership-statistics...
- dogman144 2y agoThere is very little that’s unique about NYC’s ability to build a great public transit system, other than it is a uniquely very hard place to do it, and run by a uniquely crooked city govt. So, if somehow NYC could do it, what’s everyone else’s reasoning for not? To tip some cards - an obscene amount of lobbying from your local car dealer baron, if you’re in Nashville (for example)
- Henchman21 2y agoAs a former New Yorker, I’d like to hear what you think makes NY government uniquely corrupt. It doesn’t seem any more or less corrupt than anywhere else I’ve lived in the US.
- dogman144 2y agoWell, with a bit of sarcasm/exaggeration added, it’s been a while since FBI seized a mayor’s phone and indicted half his staff.
- 2y ago
- _Algernon_ 2y agoThe model works in Europe. Why double down on the thing that makes everything in the US suck (unless you're rich) and privatize more? Where privatization has been done in Europe service has largely worsened. Shouldn't be surprising since these services are fundamentally a natural monopoly.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> The model works in Europe. Why double down on the thing that makes everything in the US suck New York's subways were built by private companies. So were America's railroads. > Where privatization has been done in Europe service has largely worsened Counterpoint: Japan.
- sigmaisaletter 2y agoI would like you to read up on the railroads, and WHY private companies built them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railroad_land_grants_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railroad_land_grants_in_the_Un... The government gave them over 700 000km2 of land as an incentive. In case that number means nothing to you: That is France. Or Texas.
- mrguyorama 2y agoA reminder to all that thanks to this enormous subsidization of the railroads, we had one of the best railroad networks in the world, and Americans considered it normal to travel huge distances long before the car. These rights of way were also essential to building the first information superhighway: The telegraph network. America has always built great infrastructure, when people in office are willing to spend dollars for the public good.
- lazyasciiart 2y agoOr when they could see a way to direct that spending into their own wallet.
- 2y ago
- mmooss 2y ago> American cities have largely failed at making bus rapid transit economically sustainable and comfortable for the broader population I don't know that's true at all. Buses generally work well wherever I take them, and they are widely used in cities around the country. In many cities I can just walk to the nearest corner, or maybe another block, and catch a bus whichever way I'm going. I often don't even need to know the routes. IME a certain socioeconomic class is unfamiliar with using them, with how to use them (a barrier to adoption), and with sharing public transit with others (I don't know about you). Didn't some SV billionaire (Zuckerberg? Musk?) once say something about people should be afraid of psychopaths on public transit? Many disparage any public service, automatically assuming they are incompetent or substandard. > Privately-operated buses on city bus lanes seems fine? Public transit needs a network effect: When more people use it, there are more buses and trains and they come more often.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> IME a certain socioeconomic class is unfamiliar with using them This is absolutely part of the problem. > Public transit needs a network effect: When more people use it, there are more buses and trains and they come more often My point is the public resource is the bus lane. Not the metal running on it. Giving the public busses a monopoly on that resource may be worth playing with.
- mmooss 2y agoPublic transit could use a lower barrier to adoption. I think people familiar with it - myself included - forget how uncertain it is for the first time - is the bus late or not coming? was it early? - and all the unstated conventions, etc. Interesting about the lanes. But that metal has a large capital cost, training, etc.; we can't add and decrease capacity on demand like cloud computing resources. Maybe contract bus operation - including the metal - to multiple contractors and when customer satisfaction is low, give the route to another contractor.
- 7bit 2y ago> If cities won’t permit something like this, it warrants asking if public resources are better used turning those bus lanes into standard ones.) Undoing the only solution to a healthier city and it's citizens because it was not an immediate success is not the answer. If you don't fix the problems, cities will get more and more congested. An additional lane will not solve that problem, just postpone the inevitable. There only one way out of that problem and that is getting people to use public transport and their feet.
- scyzoryk_xyz 2y agoHa! Everyone fails to make bus rapid transit comfortable and sustainable. That is the point - it’s publicly subsidized discomfort that gets you there. Along with everyone else more or less on time. In an urban environment. Along. With. Everyone. Else. It’s a public good. I’ve lived in both the EU and the U.S. extensively using buses and the argument that “American cities have failed” is just such a load of crap. I found buses just as tolerable in both including places like suburban Cupertino. They’re not supposed to be “sustainable” because they’re a vital service same as the water in pipes. And they’re not supposed to be “comfortable” if the frame of reference used are AC/sleek private vehicles. The problem and the solutions have not changed. The only thing that has are the GPS enabled pocket computers we started carrying around. The GPS bit allowed for a real optimization. But the pocket computers also started feeding us with doubts about shit that works just fine.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> they’re not supposed to be “comfortable” if the frame of reference used are AC/sleek private vehicles Sure. But that means you have no buy in from the latter. If you add a shuttle service, with a forward-looking eye to self-piloted vehicles, you increase use and potentially also revenues to reïnvest in uncomfortable busses.
- FireBeyond 2y agoThis notion that revenues are a problem for busses is also not universal, even in the US. In the PNW the bus services in the city I am in and nearby are free - no fares charged. Their revenue is elsewhere (note that I'm not saying ridership is unimportant, but if you're deriving revenue from ads which then ties to miles driven, then it becomes less important).
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> Why? Charge a use fee. Who is paying for the maintenance of the extra bus lanes (or creating them in the first place), or the extra maintenance on the other lanes which get heavier use since some have been set aside as dedicated lanes. Taxpayers. So yeah, taxpayers funding Uber. I'd rather fund public transport.