7 ms·
ARMv9 Architecture Helps Lift Arm to New Financial Heights
- Neywiny 2y agoAs an almost exclusively microcontroller user of Arm's products, a big meh from me. v8 is still slowly rolling out. M33 is making headway but I was really hoping for M55 to be the bigger driver.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoThat folks are still making new Cortex-A7 (2011) designs is wild. A-35 doesn't seem to be very popular or better. Cortex-M33 (2016) derives–as you allude to–from ARMv8 (2015). But yeah it barely seems only barely popular, even now. Having witnessed some of the 9p's & aughts computing, I never in a million years would have guessed microcontrollers & power efficient small chips would see so little change across a decade of time!!
- bsder 2y ago> I never in a million years would have guessed microcontrollers & power efficient small chips would see so little change across a decade of time It's because the software ecosystem around them is so incredibly lousy and painful. Once you get something embedded to work, you never want to touch it again if you can avoid it. I was really, really, really hoping that the RISC-V folks were going to do better. Alas, the RISC-V ecosystem seems doomed to be repeating the same levels of idiocy.
- 01100011 2y agoSwitching microcontrollers means you have a lot of work to do to redo the HW design, re-run all of your pre-production testing, update mfg/QA with new processes and tests, possibly rewrite some of your application.. and you need to price in a new part to your BOM, figure out a secure supply for some number of years... And that just assumes you don't want to do even more work to take advantage of the new chip's capabilities by rewriting even more of your code. All while your original CPU probably still does fine because this is embedded we're talking about and your product already does what it needs to do.
- marsven_422 2y ago[dead]
- danhor 2y agoRISC-V is even worse: The Cortex-M series have standardized interrupt handling and are built so you can avoid writing any assembly for the startup code. Meanwhile the RISC-V spec only defines very basic interrupt functionality, with most MCU vendors adding different external interrupt controllers or changing their cores to more closely follow the faster Cortex-M style, where the core itself handles stashing/unstashing registers, exit of interrupt handler on ret, vectoring for external interrupts, ... . The low knowledge/priority of embedded of RISC-V can be seen in how long it took to specify an extension tha only includes multiplication, not division. Especially for smaller MCUs the debug situation is unfortunate: In ARM-World you can use any CMSIS-DAP debug probe to debug different MCUs over SWD. RISC-V MCUs either have JTAG or a custom pin-reduced variant (as 4 pins for debugging is quite a lot) which is usually only supported by very few debug probes. RISC-V just standardizes a whole lot less (and not sensibly for small embedded) than ARM.
- ryao 2y agoBeing customizable is one of RISC-V’s strengths. Multiplication can be easily done in software by doing bit shifts and addition in a loop. If an embedded application does not make heavy use of multiplication, you can omit multiplication from the silicon for cost savings. That said, ARM’s SWD is certainly nice. It appears to be possible to debug the Hazard3 cores in the RP2350 in the same way as the ARM cores: https://gigazine.net/gsc_news/en/20241004-raspberry-pi-pico-2-risc-v-debug/ https://gigazine.net/gsc_news/en/20241004-raspberry-pi-pico-...
- magicalhippo 2y ago> If an embedded application does not make heavy use of multiplication, you can omit multiplication from the silicon for cost savings. The problem was that the initial extension that included multiplication also included division[1]. A lot of small microcontrollers have multiplication hardware but not division hardware. Thus it would make sense to have a multiplication-only extension. IIRC the argument was that the CPU should just trap the division instructions and emulate them, but in the embedded world you'll want to know your performance envelopes so better to explicitly know if hardware division is available or not. [1]: https://docs.openhwgroup.org/projects/cva6-user-manual/01_cva6_user/RISCV_Instructions_RV32M.html https://docs.openhwgroup.org/projects/cva6-user-manual/01_cv...
- ryao 2y agoThe RP2040 and RP2350 are fairly big changes from the status quo, although they are not very energy efficient compared to other MCUs. Coincidentally, the RP2350 is part of the RISC-V ecosystem. It has both RISC-V and ARM cores and lets you pick which to use.
- fidotron 2y ago> It's because the software ecosystem around them is so incredibly lousy and painful. This is reaching breaking point entirely because of how powerful modern MCUs are too. You simply cannot develop and maintain software of scale and complexity to exploit those machines using the mainstream practices of the embedded industry.
- duskwuff 2y agoYou can get a lot of mileage out of a Cortex-M7. NXP has some which run up to 1 GHz - that's a ridiculous amount of power for a "microcontroller". It'd easily outperform an early-to-mid-2000s desktop PC.
- adrian_b 2y agoThere are no similarities between Cortex-M7 and Cortex-A7 from the POV of obsolescence. Cortex-M7 belongs to the biggest-size class of ARM-based microcontrollers. There is one newer replacement for it, Cortex-M85, but for now Cortex-M7 is not completely obsolete, because it is available in various configurations from much more vendors and at lower prices than Cortex-M85. Cortex-M7 and its successor Cortex-M85 have similar die sizes and instructions-per-clock performance with the Cortex-R8x and Cortex-A5xx cores (Cortex-M5x, Cortex-R5x and Cortex-A3x are smaller and slower cores), but while the Cortex-M8x and Cortex-R8x cores have short instruction pipelines, suitable for maximum clock frequencies around 1 GHz, the Cortex-A5xx cores have longer instruction pipelines, suitable for maximum clock frequencies around 2 GHz (allowing greater throughput, but also greater worst-case latency). Unlike Cortex-M7, Cortex-A7 is really completely obsolete. It has been succeeded by Cortex-A53, then by Cortex-A55, then by Cortex-A510, then by Cortex-A520. For now, Cortex-A55 is the most frequently used among this class of cores and both Cortex-A7 and Cortex-A53 are truly completely obsolete. Even Cortex-A55 should have been obsolete by now, but the inertia in embedded computers is great, so it will remain for some time the choice for cheap embedded computers where the price of the complete computer must be well under $50 (above that price Cortex-A7x or Intel Atom cores become preferable).
- kvemkon 2y agoIn embedded old Cortex-A53 (and A72) are the most "new" cores used compared to A9 (and A15). E.g. TI AMxxxx [1] and Xilinx UltraScale+ vs Zynq. [1] https://www.ti.com/microcontrollers-mcus-processors/arm-based-processors/overview.html https://www.ti.com/microcontrollers-mcus-processors/arm-base...
- adrian_b 2y ago
- conradev 2y agoIsn’t there some dynamic at play where STM will put one of these on a board, that board becomes a “standard” and then it’s cloned by other manufacturers, lowering cost? (legality aside) STM32H5 in 2023 (M33): https://newsroom.st.com/media-center/press-item.html/p4519.html https://newsroom.st.com/media-center/press-item.html/p4519.h... GD32F5 in 2024: https://www.gigadevice.com/about/news-and-event/news/gigadevice-launches-gd32f5-series-mcu https://www.gigadevice.com/about/news-and-event/news/gigadev... STM32N6 in 2025 (M55): https://blog.st.com/stm32n6/ https://blog.st.com/stm32n6/ i.e. it takes some time for new chips to hit cost targets, and most applications don’t need the latest chips? I don’t know a lot about the market, though, and interested to learn more
- fidotron 2y agoThe way you put it makes it sound like STM have a serious security problem with their manufacturing.
- conradev 2y agoIt’s a serious problem for their lawyers, primarily: https://olimex.wordpress.com/2015/11/09/chinese-clones-attack-stm32-microcontrollers/ https://olimex.wordpress.com/2015/11/09/chinese-clones-attac... cheap Chinese clones of US IP is a broader problem that affects more than just STM
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoSome chips that have come out in the past 3 years with Cortex A7: Microchip SAMA7D65 and SAMA7G54. Allwinner V853 and T113-S3. It's not like a massive stream of A7's. But even pretty big players don't really seem to have any competitive options to try. The A-35 has some adoption. There is an A34 and A32 that I don't see much of, don't know what they'd bring above the A7. All over a decade old now and barely seen. To be fair, just this year ARM announced Cortex-A320 which I don't know much about, but might perhaps be a viable new low power chip.
- Neywiny 2y agoAt a trade show I saw a chip coming out with DDR3L. Imagine a 2025 chip with RAM from 15? years ago. They said it's all that they needed. Probably have a perpetual license or something.
- mrheosuper 2y agoeven some new SOC from Rockchip use DDR2 RAM
- the__alchemist 2y agoSame. On v7 still for most things, even on newer MCUs. The v8 ones, for the use cases I've encountered, primarily add IOT features like secured Flash.
- Neywiny 2y agoRight. And I'm not IoT so I don't care. Could be fun to play with helium, though.
- tails4e 2y agoI am surprised more uC use cases have not moved to RISC-5. What do you see keeping you on ARM for what you work on?
- RF_Savage 2y agoGood documentation and support.
- the__alchemist 2y agoESP-32C are the only mainstream ones I've encountered.
- ryao 2y agoThe RP2350 lets you choose between 2 RISC-V cores and 2 ARM cores. I believe it even supports 1 RISC-V core and 1 ARM core for those who like the idea of their microcontrollers using two different ISAs simultaneously. Microchip Technology has a number of RISC-V options.
- Neywiny 2y agoDepends on the task. My favorite example is a chip that has a lot more than a microcontroller onboard, but it's an old v7m. I need the rest and have to struggle with what they give. If it was RV, power PC, mips, whatever, I'd have to use it.
- ksec 2y agoThis is nothing about ARMv9 the ISA but much more about their new CEO Rene Haas. Arm has always been pricing their design on the lower end, bundling GPU and other designs IP. I have long argued since they enter 64bit era their performance profile and profits does not align well especially when comparing to AMD and Intel. Even with the increased pricing the Cortex X5 / X925 and upcoming X6 / X930 they are still pretty good value. Unless Apple has something big with A19 / M5 the X6 / X930 should be competitive with M4 already. I just wish they spend a little more money on R&D for the GPU IP side of things. Hoepfully we have some more news from Nvidia in Computex 2025
- ryao 2y agoAMD and Intel actually fabricate chips for sale to others (outsourced to TSMC in AMD’s case) and take the risks associated with that. ARM on the other hand is just an IP provider. They are not comparable. ARM should have kept its original strategy of aiming to profit from volume that enabled its rise in the first place. Its course change likely looks great to SoftBank’s investors for now, but it will inevitably kill the goose that lays the golden eggs as people look elsewhere for what ARM was. That said, ARM’s increased license fees are a fantastic advocate for RISC-V. Some of the more interesting RISC-V cores are Tenstorrent’s Ascalon and Ventana’s Veyron V2. I am looking forward to them being in competition with ARM’s X925 and X930 designs.
- tails4e 2y agoRISC-V is not immune from license fees, unless you want to design a high performance core from the ground up. If you want something as capable as an M4, there is years of R&D to get to that level. I'm sure a big player could do just that in house, but many would license Si-Five or similar. It will be interesting to see if Qualcomm and the like would make a move towards RISC-V, given their ARM legal issues
- xbmcuser 2y agoChina will likely be the country taking forward RISC-V and ditching Arm and x86 completely. With USA trying to stop other countries from using latest Chinese tech they are given more reason to ditch any and all propitiatory US tech. So over the next decade I expect RISC-V architecture to enter and flood all Chinese tech devices from Tvs to cars and everything else that needs a CPU. I personally hope China get's competitive in the node size as well as I want gpu and cpus start getting cheaper every generation again as once TSMC got big lead over Intel/Samsung and Nvidia got a big lead over AMD prices have stopped coming down generation to generation for CPU's and GPU's
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoBefore reading article: I would like to know if this architecture will help Linux close to Apple architecture efficiencies.... After reading article: I suddenly realize that CPUs will probably no longer pursue making "traditional computing" any faster/efficient. Instead, everything will be focused on AI processing. There are absolutely no market/hype forces that will prompt the investment in "traditional" computing optimization anymore. I mean, yeah, there's probably three years of planning and execution inertia, but any push to close the gap with Apple by ARM / AMD / Intel is probably dead, and Apple will probably stop innovating the M series.
- Calwestjobs 2y agoapple M4 vs Intel Core Ultra 9 285K. apple m4 vs AMD Ryzen AI 9 365 apple has to do something. im not sure intel cpus can have 196GB ram, or it is some mobile ram manufacturing limit, but i really want to have atleast 96GB in notebook, tablet.
- junon 2y agoSome Intel chips have a max of 192GiB. Others 4TiB. It depends on the chip, but there are definitely machines running terabytes of memory.
- wqaatwt 2y agoM4 still has >2x better performance per watt than either of those chips. Of course they are pretty much ignoring desktop so they can’t really compete with AMD/Intel when power is not an issue but that’s not exactly new
- guiriduro 2y agoApple is ignoring desktop?
- joshstrange 2y agoI guess that depends on your definition of “desktop”. What that really means (I think) is they aren’t using the power and cooling available to them in traditional desktop setups. The iMac and the Studio/Mini and yes, even the Mac Pro, are essentially just laptop designs in different cases. Yes, they (Studio/Pro) can run an Ultra variant (vs Max being the highest on the laptop lines) but the 2x Ultra chip so far has not materialized. Rumors say Apple has tried it but rather could get efficiencies to where they needed to be or ran into other problems connecting 2 Ultras to make a ???. The current Mac Pro would be hilarious if it wasn’t so sad, it’s just “Mac Studio with expansion slots”. One would expect/hope that the Mac Pro would take advantage of the space in some way (other than just expansion slots, which most people have no use for aside from GPUs which the os can’t/won’t leverage IIRC).
- moshegramovsky 2y agoTimothy Prickett Morgan is a fantastic writer and analyst. Love reading his stuff.
- margorczynski 2y agoDoesn't ARM have a problem with RISC-V and Chinese CPUs? Long term seems they're bound to loose most of the market by simply being priced out.
- chvid 2y agoMost of the high end Chinese chips are based on ARM as of now.
- surajrmal 2y agoWhat about in 5 years? riscv isn't competitive at the top end but it's closing in fast.
- chvid 2y agoHuawei is probably the one that possibly might move away from arm because they have their own operating system. The US could tighten their controls more and ban them from arm altogether- so far they are prohibited from arm 9. I am not sure Huawei would go for riscv - they could easily go for their own isa or an arm fork.
- SillyUsername 2y agoARM used to be UK owned until Conservative government lack of foresight allowed it to be sold to Softbank, leaving AIM (UK's NASDAQ, part of LSE) despite being in the national interests, and security, to keep it British. Thanks Mrs May (ex-PM) for approving that one (it was the last regulatory hurdle, that it was not in national security interests, so had to go past her). Of course Boris Johnson (the next PM) __tried to woo ARM back to LSE__ because they realised they fucked up, and of course what huge foreign company would refloat on the LSE when you have NASDAQ, or bother floating on both? Can you imagine if America had decided to allow Intel or Apple to be sold to a company in another country? Same sentiment. - Yep I'm a pissed off ex-ARM shareholder forced out by the board's buyout decision and Mrs May waving it through.
- surajrmal 2y agoThey did the world a favor by indirectly helping riscv. So arguably it's a net positive move.