4 ms·
Can we build an AI device X that can start a conversation with another device X (but alien) and figures out the language rules of the alien language? What woul
by amelius 2y ago
Can we build an AI device X that can start a conversation with another device X (but alien) and figures out the language rules of the alien language?
What would such a device be called? Perhaps universal translator?
- tough 2y agoCorrect https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Universal_translator https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Universal_translator
- amelius 2y agoI think the difference with the UT from star trek is that the device X will talk to another device X instead of listening/interacting directly in the spoken language.
- zaik 2y agoWhat data will the AI be trained on?
- amelius 2y agoThe idea is that the AI will have a conversation with the device of the aliens, exchanging information and learning on the way. Depending on the performance of both devices this can take seconds, or hours.
- soco 2y agoBut will they be exchanging anything, and would that anything be worth calling "information"? There's a lot of assumptions in this sentence, to the level of calling it magical thinking. (Our) AI is not magic, and is only interpolating human knowledge, so I don't think it can figure anything out by itself. In any case nothing novel. Note I'm not saying "impossible" but definitely not just "let them chat" - which already assumes they found a way to do (what we define as) chat.
- Ukv 2y ago> But will they be exchanging anything, and would that anything be worth calling "information"? If I'm understanding, the main idea is for it to figure out language/grammar rules, which would then enable communication between the two species. I think it makes sense to call that information, but its utility is independent of what we call it. Such a device might make sense as something to include on probes we send out in case they encounter life, since in many cases round-trip communication back with Earth would take a long time. > (Our) AI is not magic, and is only interpolating human knowledge, so I don't think it can figure anything out by itself. I don't think deep learning models are interpolating in any literal sense - curse of dimensionality means essentially no real inputs or outputs fall within the convex hull of the training samples. LLMs aren't currently as good at reasoning as humans are, but figuring out language rules does feel within their wheelhouse. Granted our architecture choices, like attention, do convey some priors that are true of human languages but might not be of alien languages, so we shouldn't expect them to be as good at picking up alien languages as human languages, but similar can be said of our own brains.
- deadbabe 2y agoOr eternity.
- blueflow 2y agoThere has to be a shared set of knowledge to bootstrap from. On earth this is a given because we all breathe, drink water and eat fruits from trees. We can point at things and call their name, and that works because both parties know the object and a word for it.
- amelius 2y agoWe can start by teaching basic mathematics, e.g. 0=0, 1=1, 2=10, 3=11, etc., then geometry, circles, squares, angles, etc., pythagoras 3^2+4^2=5^2, etc.
- palmotea 2y ago> Can we build an AI device X that can start a conversation with another device X (but alien) and figures out the language rules of the alien language? > What would such a device be called? Perhaps universal translator? Such a device is properly called "a fantasy."
- butlike 2y agoC3-PO
- butlike 2y agoWould such a device be a "human security hole?" Any bad actor alien species could study the AI construct and get a great overview of the holistic capacity of humanity, which would expose any weak areas ripe for invasion.