10 ms·
2024 sea level 'report cards' map futures of U.S. coastal communities
- tw04 2y agoThe sad part is anticipate the current administration will see this report and attack any federal funds William and Mary receive unless they remove and retract the data.
- burkaman 2y agoWilliam and Mary actually have a very in depth page on their opposition to federal suppression of free speech and what they are doing about it: https://www.wm.edu/sites/federalguidelines/ https://www.wm.edu/sites/federalguidelines/
- hammock 2y agoI may be misremembering but I believe they wrote a similar letter a few years ago when Facebook and others were in the news for working with the government to suppress speech during the lockdown. I really admire W&M for their consistency in supporting the issue
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoAre you referring to the case that went all the way to SCOTUS who ruled that the government is in fact allowed to report things to social media companies (1st Amendment protected speech) and that social media companies, if they want to, are allowed to act on those reports (also 1st Amendment protected speech)? I think the main missing element was that the social media companies didn't even claim to be coerced by the government whatsoever and have consistently stated they moderated content as they saw fit on their own platforms (which, again, is their 1st Amendment right)
- renewiltord 2y agoThe "nice business you got here; shame if anything were to happen to it" loophole.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoInteresting because during this exact time period, every social media company declined all sorts of requests from the government, as I'm sure they do a couple dozen or hundred times per day? I wonder if these multi-billion dollar companies have anyone on staff who is aware of the company's 1st Amendment rights (they do). Edit: jcranmer's comment reminded me to be explicit on this: it is in fact illegal for the government to coerce private parties to regulate speech. That's why it's important that those private parties never claimed they were coerced, and there's given that they agreed with some requests and didn't with others, there's no evidence whatsoever they were coerced.
- jcranmer 2y agoJust so you're aware, an actual implied threat like that is considered an unconstitutional act by the government. It's just that a politician complaining about social media on the campaign trail isn't anywhere near the level of implied threat to be considered unconstitutional.
- renewiltord 2y agoOh sorry. As a BIPOC, I meant the "nice business; here's a list of people I don't like; no threats implied; to be clear: we are not threatening you; do what you like with this list" loophole.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoThis is a cool skill, it’s like three-hop mind-reading. You somehow know that the platforms were coerced despite them never claiming it, and they were specifically coerced by threats that were never actually stated! Super neat.
- throw0101c 2y agoAbout 30-40% of the US population lives in a coastal county: * https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/population.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/population.html * https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/visualizations/2019/demo/coastline-america.pdf https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/visualizat...
- zamadatix 2y agoAnd about 6% of the population less than 3 meters above sea level. This is much more relevant than the county is coastal, for some it's basically the entire county. https://www.iai.int/en/post/detail/snapshot-3-how-many-people-live-in-vulnerable-coastal-areas-of-the-u-s-a https://www.iai.int/en/post/detail/snapshot-3-how-many-peopl...
- c-linkage 2y agoThe chart is good because it shows actual measurements, but I'm concerned about the baseline being 1970. It is possible that measurements prior to 1970 are higher and make the projected measurements look worse than they are, especially since many charts for mid-Atlantic sites were clearly on a downward trend shortly after 1970. I'm not saying there is an intentional attempt to bamboozle readers. It's just hard to judge the report on such a short time scale. EDIT: I'm not a climate denialist, but I have many people in my life who are. I was really looking forward to showing them this website but refrained knowing that they would come back with the argument I mentioned.
- crystal_revenge 2y agoI shouldn't be surprised that we still see this standard climate denial logic, but it's worth pointing out that your logic here is not particularly strong. The problem with this line of reasoning is it takes the assumption that all we have is measurements without any real understanding of the process that's happening to cause those measurements. Sure, if we knew nothing about Earth's climate (and also didn't have plenty of other ways to measure historic sea level), only having 50 years of measurements might be misleading. But we know that sea level is rising and we know why it is rising. We have a very strong hypothesis as to what's happening and we see this hypothesis confirmed again and again across a very wide range of subjects that otherwise have no relation to one another. On top of this, we do have plenty of other measurements for historical sea levels that all indicated yes, sea level is raising they just aren't perfectly apples-to-apples "actual measurements" so it wouldn't be perfectly honest to include them in this chart.
- nandomrumber 2y ago> just are perfectly apples-to-apples aren’t?
- crystal_revenge 2y agoFixed, thanks!
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- iambateman 2y agoI grew up a few minutes away from the picture at the top of the article. Knowing that many of the places I love, which formed me, will soon be under water gives me a kind of sadness which doesn’t go away.
- shaboinkin 2y agoWhat I wonder about sea level rise is what happens to all of the development that gets swallowed by the sea? I’m not optimistic that there will be proper cleanup of the stuff that was built up over time. If I recall from the LA fires last year, the burnt down homes left some toxic stuff behind that require proper disposal. The same stuff in those homes presumably exists in the buildings and infrastructure that will be taken by the sea. How much pollution is going to be introduced into the environment? And what long term consequences will result from that?
- bix6 2y agoWe still have decaying nuclear material off the west coast and Tijuana has been flooding the border with polluted water for years now so anything more will just cause additional strain and more beach closures / illness.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoThe tijuana situation is pretty untenable when you view it less along internatial border lines and more along metro region lines with SD and TJ being part of one megacity. They very much are a megacity in practice. Now imagine the flack that would happen if you say took the Bronx and subject it to border security checkpoints and let the people have materially significantly worse sewer and other living conditions. People would call it a travesty and a dark mark on nyc as a whole for allowing such a thing to happen to its own people. Yet over in SD that very situation happens with all the commuters and trade that goes on between there and TJ. And people don’t bat an eye to it, if only to blame TJ for the sewer situation.
- kortilla 2y agoWhat are you suggesting though? Annexing TJ?
- jemmyw 2y agoI would guess it should be more about cooperation on the problems and maybe some money needing to flow from the richer side to the poorer, and the poorer side agreeing to some policies. Annexing wouldn't work because a new city would pop up along the new border. The border is the attraction.
- simonebrunozzi 2y agoI live in Venice, Italy. This issue has been urgent and critical for Venetians for a few decades now. The problem here is that even a 60cm (2 feet) increase in sea level would essentially: 1) force to shut the dams (MOSE) almost always during the year. 2) ruin the lagoon ecosystem 3) create uncountable damage to the city of Venice, and nearby islands. 4) possibly displace tens of thousands of people.
- pc86 2y agoNot trying to be pedantic but how can something both "be urgent and critical" and have been a problem for "a few decades?"
- kjkjadksj 2y agoIn the same way an asteroid doomed to strike in a few decades is urgent and critical
- ehnto 2y agoThis is a perfect example actually, the remediation actions required should have been taken decades ago, it was urgent then. We have just gotten so used to seeing no immediate downside to kicking the can down the road that we have collectively forgotten how urgent it was. Now it is urgent and critical still, but we have far fewer options for remediation. Kind of like how changing your cars oil is urgent once you cross the service date. You don't immediately see any downsides, but they are accumulating, you can't roll back the damage, and total failure to change the oil is eventually catastrophic.
- chgs 2y ago60cm would basically wipe out some countries and cause the loss and displacement of dozens of millions as cities like Dhaka and Jakarta are flooded
- bix6 2y ago“Mitchell also notes that most West Coast localities have been fairly stable, despite past predictions that they would increase rapidly. “This has led to some questions about why,” she said.” ^ this interested me, apparently it’s due to geological uplift combined with regional water patterns. The regional water patterns are due to winds and the ENSO cycle, which can mask long term effects. Apparently it will increase faster once Antarctica starts shedding in earnest.
- BergAndCo 2y ago[dead]
- metalman 2y agomost of the worlds water just so happens to be at around 2~4°C, which is where water density is the highest, warming or cooling a bit causes it to expand, so just maybe it warms up a bit, and the total increased volume is enough to flood, everything we want dry. Oh ya, we are on track for the warmest and most ice free artic summer ever.We just finnished the warmest and most ice free winter, so, ya, right. https://nsidc.org/sea-ice-today https://nsidc.org/sea-ice-today
- IncreasePosts 2y agoThe average temperature of all water in the ocean is approximately 3.5° C, but I think most of the warming would be contained to surface waters which averages around 17° C. A bigger issue decreased density of seawater would probably just be melting ice
- harmmonica 2y agoNot to diminish the fact that this is happening, nor that humans are at least a principal cause of it, but does anyone think, at least in the US, that the costs to mitigate sea-level rise would not be shared across the US, at least in those places with significant population? The contradiction is not lost on me, but most of the time when people are asked "should the government bail me out?" the answer seems to be yes regardless of where one sits on the political spectrum. I bring this up because the same people who would deny that this is a problem will also be amongst the people who will take a "check" from the federal and/or state government to mitigate any issues that arise from it. And it's, at least partially, that reality that keeps people from actually trying to mitigate it with their own actions. I'm not saying people consciously are sitting there saying that, but I do think it's an underlying belief. For instance, is this guy or gal (https://www.realtor.com/news/unique-homes/florida-most-expensive-house-flood/ https://www.realtor.com/news/unique-homes/florida-most-expen...) going to pay for the levy or whatever solution keeps the water from inundating their property without first lobbying the government to take care of it for them?
- IncreasePosts 2y agoMaybe? There's only 800 ft of ocean frontage. The problem with lobbying the government to do your bidding is you might not like the method they choose. I'm imagining you can easily afford to build about 2.5 mi of wall exactly how you want it if you spent $225 million on a home
- harmmonica 2y agoOh that's an interesting point. Maybe they bought the property with the expectation that it would turn into their own private island once seal level rises enough to force them to build a wall. I'm not sure if I'm even being sarcastic with that comment given the sums of money we're talking about.
- adrr 2y agoThey do beach replenishment to build up the beach to give more buffer. Spend lots of money on it. Also there is the federal flood insurance program that is running up a big debt. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-u-s-spends-a-fortune-on-beach-sand-that-storms-just-wash-away https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-u-s-spends-a-...
- calvinmorrison 2y agoWe spent billions bailing out after Katrina in south jersey and now shore front properties are in the millions. Yawn.
- somishere 2y agoAs an aside we went to see the new David Attenborough film Ocean over the weekend. Equal parts stunning and heartbreaking - it sews a compelling narrative for the oceans, spread between climate and ocean ecology, the extent of our exploitation, and the renewed hope (if you could call it that) that it holds for humanity's survival ... A hard watch but also a must see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIZAdCtKT_g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIZAdCtKT_g
- doakes 2y agoI work in this space of measuring (mostly coastal) water levels and it's pretty amazing how many different vertical datums there are. When people say something has a height of X, you don't always consider what it's relative to. Is it sea level? High tide or low tide? Maybe it's relative to one of the many geodetic ellipsoids. Maybe a nearby physical benchmark put into the ground by a surveyor. Many cases (like this article) just care about the relative changes locally, but even for that you have to be careful of places like Southeast Alaska where glacial melt causes the land to rise and give the appearance of sea levels dropping.
- thebeardisred 2y agoTIL: The US West coast will see less of the increase than other places due to wind and tectonic movement.
- efitz 2y agoThis is great. Let us remember this link, and archive the data right now. I will wager $1000 of my own money right now that if the exact same methodology is used to measure sea level in 10 years, as was used at the publication of the study, and if the editors do not apply any “offset” to sea levels, that in 10 years the sea level will have risen less than 50% of their predictions at more than 50% of stations. Applying any offset for any reason or changing methodology will invalidate the bet. I’ll try to set up a Kalshi market. If climate change studies should be used to influence public policy, then they must be empirical, repeatable and have predictive value.
- tim333 2y agoThe history of sea-level rise is kind of interesting. Up 120m since 18000 BC. There used to be about a France sized area of land with lions on it around what are now the British Isles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland