5 ms·
Designing Cities for Families
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/ywqGt https://archive.today/ywqGt
- brudgers 2y agoSkate Parks are Growing Up reminds me that skate parks are common in small Utah cities. https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2024-skate-park-gardens/ https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2024-skate-park-gardens/
- vanschelven 2y agoI found it a bit hard to see what I'm looking at at first glance. Apparently the linked article is the announcement that the sub-articles (together, as a series) have won a Pulitzer price.
- peterhadlaw 2y agoMaybe control the crime. If you can't fundamentally live in peace, there's no point in continuing the conversation.
- Juliate 2y agoControl yes, but even more so, prevent it. If the only response to crime is repressive without managing/anticipating things way ahead, that do favour crime, it's not going to foster peace, neither a family/youth-friendly environment. As the article series suggests, architecture alone _does_ influence individuals and groups experiences and behaviours. It's been studied and worked on for a long time [1] and it's worth studying further, reporting and repeating as the OP does very well. 1: see Jane Jacobs (The Death and Life of Great American Cities), Oscar Newman (Design Guidelines for Creating Defensible Space), C. Ray Jeffery (Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design), Alice Coleman, among others.
- pdfernhout 2y agoGood point and links on architecture. I am so grateful to the architecture student who told me about Jane Jacobs around 1990 and opened my eyes to how much urban architecture design (things like height restrictions as in Philadelphia, unsafe edge effects of big special-purpose areas, sidewalks & porches, and mixed-use zoning) can affect human behavior and "eyes on the street" safety. I also liked the point that new ideas require old buildings (for cheap rents). This article and your comment makes me think of Lawrence Lessig's "Code 2.0" book where he writes that (at least) four things can shape human behavior: * rules * norms * prices * architecture All are important -- but they influence people in different ways at different times. If we want to have healthy cities, all are worth considering. Hopefully we could do so in a "Kaizen" approach of incremental improvement and usually small steps within existing cities? But we likely need a lot of new cities too with more housing (perhaps by upgrading towns on existing transit lines). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaizen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaizen
- dr_dshiv 2y agoAre you suggesting we shouldn’t build playgrounds for kids until we’ve locked up all the criminals?
- ty6853 2y agoThe children playing at the park are the criminals. https://www.phillymag.com/news/2025/03/19/tot-lot-ardmore-lower-merion/ https://www.phillymag.com/news/2025/03/19/tot-lot-ardmore-lo...
- thehoff 2y agoIs this /s? I didn't read anything about a crime or kids with criminal intent, just a dad being told that the park was for <5 year olds to play in (which is ridiculous but a different issue).
- ty6853 2y agoIf you read the codes of the city those park rules are binding as law, thus the child is a criminal.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoThat's a weird article. It's weird how one-sided the story is: because clearly law enforcement would tell a different narrative if they had been asked for comment. It is strange how the father claims that the issue was the football. But it is strange that, if the park rules say that only children up to Age Five are allowed, why the father thinks this is so unjust and so horrible. It certainly makes sense to me, that keeping small children safe could involve restricting the age group. So many things are restricted to narrow age-groups for children. Because of different maturity and physique and needs. If these parents deliberately chose an Age Five park to go play in [and they knew exactly what its name is before they even arrived], then they should've made themselves aware of the Park Rules (which are not too far away to read if you walk up to the sign. Park Rules are usually posted near every entrance and every main walkway!) And they have no right to be angry that the police intervened and had a chat with them, even if the "football toss" was an extreme red herring. I don't see anything wrong in a community wanting parents to know and abide by those rules. They aren't difficult or obscure or unjust. No, the children are not criminals. A minor is subject to their parents' responsibility, and the parents are the ones who placed their children into the park, and they are responsible for their children being there. Any liability or criminality is going to fall on the responsible adults.
- MSFT_Edging 2y ago"The beatings will continue until morale improves". Crime in cities is seriously over reported. Any concentration of population will have higher total crime, particularly if there's poverty. Relieve the poverty, improve the education, crime drops.
- flanked-evergl 2y ago[flagged]
- pcl 2y ago[citation needed]
- gadders 2y ago"How did the authorities respond? A series of local inquiries have exposed an official response that was unforgivably inadequate." "What explains these failings? There are a range of explanations, from lack of understanding and incompetence to snobbery, misogyny and fear of inflaming racial tensions.... "There is evidence that many officials feared being accused of racism. In 2004, a Channel 4 documentary about Asian men grooming girls in Bradford was postponed over fears that it could lead to race riots; Jay found that councillors had fretted that discussion of the issue could harm "community cohesion". Telford's inquiry also identified a "nervousness about race"." https://theweek.com/crime/the-grooming-gangs-scandal-explained https://theweek.com/crime/the-grooming-gangs-scandal-explain...
- pcl 2y agoSorry, I should have been more clear. Was looking for a citation for the claim that the Oslo police avoid investigations of serious crimes in an effort to underreport crimes from non-white immigrants.
- sebstefan 2y agoI've seen no explicit mention in any sources that police in Oslo actively avoid policing serious crimes due to fear of accusations of racism. Going from that to "Non-white crime is under-reported" is a huge leap and contradicts some other well known facts For instance you might be aware that research has shown that non-white individuals are disproportionately subjected to stop-and-search police stops, which you would think should mechanically lead to higher recorded crime rates among these groups
- have-a-break 2y agoYeah but on the flip side having police show up everytime I leave the house doesn't make me feel comfortable it makes me feel like the police cant do their jobs properly. Or worse I am in some kind of warzone, which is disappointing since my family fled their home country to get away from war. How about we pay people enough so they don't have to steal and gut the police.
- newsclues 2y agoThe problem isn’t the police but the judicial system that doesn’t segregate criminals from society and when it does the penal system has no rehabilitation. Stop crimes and prevent them Put criminals behind bars Rehabilitation for those who can rejoin society Gotta do all three or it’s not going to work
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 2y agoPeople still complain about falling birth rates and family life in Singapore, one of the lowest crime (and toughest on petty crime!) cities in the world. It's important, and there's a whole sub-conversation in how to do it, but it's not a totally overriding concern.
- thrance 2y agoIgnore that crime dropped ~50% globally since the 1990s [1], then. The real issue is that the Right campaigned mostly on security since the 1980s and successfully convinced everyone that hordes of migrant criminals are patrolling the streets to mug you, in spite of the data clearly showing that crime levels are at their lowest. Ironically, Republicans are also the one wishing for a "high-trust society" while simultaneously acting paranoid against their neighbors. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop?wprov=sfla1
- fullshark 2y agoThe homeless population is the elephant in the room here.
- newsclues 2y agoAnd the progressive activists who are destroying society trying to make it a kinder place, who enable the homeless/mental health and drug crisis
- mandmandam 2y agoAmerica: - Underfunds mental health services & makes them nearly inaccessible, for decades. - Starts wars and treats its soldiers as disposable. - Rewards the bankers who created the housing crisis. - Decouples wages from productivity for 50+ years. - Treats drug use as a character deficiency rather than a societal one. Newsclues, when the results of these actions (which they were warned about by progressives the entire time) become impossible to ignore: 'Damn progressive activists! Why would they do this?'.
- thrance 2y agoFox News can really warp some people's perception of reality. The truth is Republicans have been hard at work eroding the fabric of society for decades and these guys choose to blame "progressive activists" who have literally never held office.
- newsclues 2y agoAnd yet progressive policies are making the situation worse. Note I’m Canadian and our government and NGOs have been giving safe supply opioids to addicts who sell them for fentanyl and the safe supply goes to kids who get addicted and the cycle of addiction continues thanks to pro drug activists. I say this as a former drug dealer and current drug user.
- ty6853 2y agoWell that and the fact that we did the thing everyone suggested and gave lots of welfare money to descendants of freed slaves and that still didn't solve the cultural problem of them being neglected by greater society. There are a ton of cities where culturally no matter how rich the people are there is a big cultural divide in certain areas and where there is an othering people are less likely to be kind to those families.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoThe problem is not cities, never has been. Almost everything in modern society is anti-family, by design, the design of cities is maybe the one rare exception. You can design cities for families all you want, but if you keep lying to people and telling them having children is bad, and it's better to live alone, then they won't do it. Not to mention crime and taking money from families and paying people who are tax leeches.
- ty6853 2y agoThe fertility rate has relatively plummeted pretty much anywhere with a socialized retirement system. Why would you go through the trouble of kids when you can just mostly offload the time and cost of that on someone else then tax those kids when they're grown for your own retirement and get about the same size slice as the person that actually raised them?
- pmg101 2y ago> Why would you... Joy!
- ty6853 2y agoIIRC studies on joy of children, there is pretty marginal gains in satisfaction with having children beyond one, except a weird bimodal blip somewhere beyond 3 that trends with a small segment of society that really loves pumping out kids.
- streptomycin 2y agoTo be fair, it's also plummeted pretty much anywhere without a socialized retirement system too.
- ty6853 2y agoOn average I'm not sure it's as 'relatively' deep. Definitely merits further study. Most the places I can think of without a social security system had drops but not the inverted pyramids we're seeing in the west.
- dakiol 2y agoI see this as a contradiction to be honest. On one side, yes, I like to "walk" the city (to go for groceries, to buy some tech stuff, to buy clothes, to go to restaurants, cinemas, etc.). One the other side, I don't want to live (as in "forever") in the city, because that means I end up buying a flat (and prices for flats are higher than what I can pay, even if I'm in the top 90% of earners in my country... I would still need to pay a mortage for decades. That sucks). I would love to buy a house instead (as in, with garden, and something bigger than a flat), but the average city doesn't have houses, so I would buy a house far away from the city and I would need a car anyway (or good transportation system) to go to the places I mentioned above. For me is a contradiction. House prices are high too, but I definitely don't want to spend the savings of my life buying a tiny apartment with neighbours up and downstairs, even if that means I have all the places mentioned above at a walkable distance. So, these walkable cities are designed for not necessarily poor families, but for families that cannot afford a bigger places. For young people without families, though, walkable cities are great!
- citizenkeen 2y agoThat’s not a contradiction, you just don’t want to live in a city with kids. Lots of people do.
- loughnane 2y agoI live right next to Boston in a town called Brookline---specifically the region above Rt. 9 called North Brookline. It could be better, but it checks the boxes that make it a wonderful place for families: * Neighborhood schools over 90% of people walk to. Builds community. * Lots of parks, both near the schools and elsewhere. Gives kids a place they can go by themselves and have some independence. * Dense neighborhoods so it's easier to go play with your friends rather than play video games over the internet (they still do the latter sometimes of course) * Nearby shops. Kids and parents can walk to the grocery store, movie theater, bookstore, pharmacy (ie candy store for the kids) * Wide sidewalks and relatively safe streets for kids to walk to these things. * Bonus: we've got a trolley that stretches the neighborhood and goes into downtown Boston for the older kids. You can find pockets like this (sans the train) across the US, but they're just that: pockets. I don't know of any city or town that has all these traits in its entirety (South Brookline for example doesn't cut it, for example). However, as long as they're scarce they'll be expensive. I hope we see a move towards building more neighborhoods like it so that more kids can grow up in them.
- kitten_mittens_ 2y agoOn the northern edge of Jamaica Plain (east of Brookline in Boston proper), there's a pretty stark example of Brookline's accumulated advantages. On the Boston side of the pond that separates the two, there's Jamaica Way. It's a four lane road with few pedestrian crossings, and drivers regularly going way over the 25mph speed limit. The multi family housing on the Boston side is significantly cheaper and denser as well. It too has a trolley (the E branch of the Green Line), but unlike the Brookline side, the trolley on the Boston side isn't grade separated, so it's quite slow. It also typically runs older rolling stock.
- loughnane 2y agoI went to school at Northeastern and so spent plenty of time in that neighborhood. We actually looked at buying in Jamaica Plain because of the price difference. Ultimately we didn't because our kids had grown roots in Brookline and the Jamaica Way was too much of a barrier between the neighborhoods. I think the biggest difference in the price between the two neighborhoods is the schools. Once you cross over the border (either into JP, or the less segmented allston) the prices drop. Brookline's got well-regarded schools (though they've been coasting), whereas Boston is a mixed bag with a lottery system.
- grumpy-de-sre 2y agoI always find the comparison between the former West and East Germany super interesting. Great randomized trial where you take the same group of people, expose them to different conditions and can easily measure the results. East Germany was also interesting in that it wasn't some patriarchal, ultra conservative society. GDR = German Democratic Republic (East Germany), FRG = Federal Republic of Germany (West Germany), Numbers indicate total fertility rate (TFR). 1950s–60s | GDR: 2.3 | FRG: 2.4 | Similar postwar boom 1970s | GDR: decline to 1.5 by mid-70s, then rise to 1.85 | FRG: 1.55 | East introduced pro-natalist policies (childcare, housing, maternity leave) 1980s | GDR: 1.85 | FRG: 1.35 | East stabilized; West kept declining 1990s (post-reunification) | GDR: 0.8 | FRG: 1.3 | Economic/social upheaval hit East hard 2000s–present | GDR: gradual recovery | FRG: slight rise | Gap narrows but regional differences linger
- grumpy-de-sre 2y agoIdeology: GDR: Socialist, collective responsibility for families | FRG: Conservative, traditional nuclear family model Women's Role: GDR: Encouraged to work and have children | FRG: Expected to choose between work and motherhood Maternity Leave: GDR: Up to 26 weeks paid leave + 1-year partially paid "baby year" (from 1976) | FRG: Shorter leave (14 weeks), limited benefits and job protection Childcare Availability: GDR: Universal, heavily subsidized childcare from 3 months old | FRG: Scarce childcare, especially for kids under 3; long waiting lists Financial Support: GDR: Birth grants, scaled child allowances, housing priority for families | FRG: Modest child benefits (Kindergeld), no housing incentives Career Impact: GDR: Mothers retained jobs and career paths with little penalty | FRG: Mothers faced career setbacks; part-time work common Contraception & Abortion: GDR: Free contraception; abortion legalized in 1972 | FRG: More restrictive laws; abortion controversial Cultural Messaging: GDR: Motherhood seen as patriotic duty; state actively promoted it | FRG: Emphasis on family values, but less direct messaging on fertility
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bruckie 2y agoWhat do the numbers indicate? Birth rate per capita? And are the arrows expressing ranges, or expressing changes from the beginning to the end of the decades? (Or maybe those are equivalent in this case?) Also, for those who don't remember the official names: GDR = German Democratic Republic = East Germany FRG = Federal Republic of Germany = West Germany
- anonymous_54321 2y agoDesigning cities for families with young children is expensive. I skimmed the articles and did not see any notable coverage of: * Bedrooms, bedrooms, bedrooms! Families with 2-3 children need 3-4 bedrooms. I estimate over 90% of the housing stock is < 3 bedrooms in my nearby city of over 500,000 people. * Noise insulation. Babies cry a lot. Being neighbors of a family with a new baby will degrade your sleep quality. Thick walls with noise-cancelling features greatly help. I'd love to see data on a city that has such housing stock available for families not in the top 10% of income, where crime is not 50% higher than its suburbs.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]