4 ms·
> “At this point it's difficult not to suspect their awful 0pSec is a choice, and that there are specific people (ahem cough cough the Russians cough) to whom t
by amelius 2y ago
> “At this point it's difficult not to suspect their awful 0pSec is a choice, and that there are specific people (ahem cough cough the Russians cough) to whom they're leaking secrets, with incompetence being merely plausible deniability for their true, treasonous agenda,” one critic wrote on Mastodon.
Good point.
- kurtis_reed 2y agoHanlon's razor
- fspoettel 2y agoI would normally second this, but the Trump admin did order a suspension of offensive cyber operations against Russia in March. So not sure you can truly rule out malice in this case.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoAnd also asked Russian intelligence services to hack his opponent in 2016, which they did the next day.
- conartist6 2y agoyou could not make this shit up, right!?
- SauciestGNU 2y agoThere was specifically the televised "Russia, if you're listening..." quip followed by the release of the DNC emails.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 2y ago>a suspension of offensive cyber operations against Russia in March. uhhh... why are we commiting offensive cyber operations against a nuclear power? Somewhere in your line you seems to think that it's justified? And that biden was doing the right thing by provoking a major power? Some people just want the world to burn, and when someone puts out the fire, they think that's unamerican?
- Rexxar 2y ago> why are we commiting offensive cyber operations against a nuclear power? Maybe because they are doing it too ?
- TrapLord_Rhodo 2y agoSuch Biden logic that ended with us launching missiles into russia. A constant escalation with no real end in sight and always matching "tit-for-tat- instead of trying to solve the root issue. You don't think trump is actively involved in negotations with russia to stop all this madness? Don't you think that one of the first signs of good faith in negotations would be to stop attacking eachother?
- psadauskas 2y agoYou misspelled Reagan. (Though to be fair, every president since Truman has escalated things with Russia/USSR, except maybe Clinton. Reagan just did more than most.) > You don't think trump is actively involved in negotations[sic] with russia to stop all this madness? No, I think Trump is doing whatever Putin wants him to do.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 2y agoNo other president has given explicit permission to launch american missles and use american guidance systems to launch missles into russian territory... Besides biden. What are you talking about? And you forgot... besides Trump. because trumps not a warmonger, people like to act like he's on the side of the russians. People have lost their minds.
- psadauskas 2y ago> trumps not a warmonger In the last 3 months, Trump has threatened to invade: - Greenland - Canada - Mexico - Panama - Cuba > people like to act like he's on the side of the russians Trump has said that Ukraine is the one that started the war, and the "deal" he negotiated to end the war excluded Ukraine from the discussion and would give Russia everything it asked for. > People have lost their minds. You're right on that point, but its probably not the people you're thinking of.
- foobahhhhh 2y ago[flagged]
- poincaredisk 2y agoYeah, sure. Seeing a conspiracy and 4d chess in everything is a proof of having an enlightened mind. I work in this space and many actors, including nation state actors, are just incompetent. You may not believe me, that's OK.
- SkipperCat 2y agoThis isn't an example of incompetence. DOGE staff broke laws when they connected their personal computers to classified system. They knew better, plenty of people told them not to do this and they still did it. They could have followed OpSec rules and still done their work. They chose not to do so. Their willful disobedience of the laws and OpSec might stem from multiple rationals, but it doesn't matter, because their actions are criminal and their negligence is beyond incompetence.
- namaria 2y agoThe caveat is that intentional stupidity is indistinguishable from malice.
- sys_64738 2y agoIn law we shouldn't be focused on ignorance and cluelessness. The outcome of what they have allowed is the crime. All the DOGE dudes need life without parole.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 2y agoDo you actually believe that? Do you not think that at least SOME OF THEM, are working their asses off to save american tax payer dollars? Can you point to any of the contracts in the wall of savings that have saved billions of dollars and disagree with any of them? https://doge.gov/savings https://doge.gov/savings
- AlotOfReading 2y agoDid you look through that page before posting it? Currently, the default list of biggest savings is topped by things like eliminating a refugee intake facility, various HHS programs making sure public housing meets basic standards of habitability, and eradicating polio. Is the argument that government was so efficient before that eliminating these seemingly useful programs was the best and only way to save taxpayer dollars?
- TrapLord_Rhodo 2y agoI guess we just disagree on what's important. $2.9B for 3,000 children. That's 967K per child. What in the actual fuck? https://www.fpds.gov/common/jsp/LaunchWebPage.jsp?command=execute&requestid=278830486&version=1.5 https://www.fpds.gov/common/jsp/LaunchWebPage.jsp?command=ex... Edit: the contract was 3.3B, so that changes the calculus to 1,109,966.78 per child. Haven't seen the facility, but i highly doubt they are staying in million dollar condos, but if they are... there are better ways to do that. $1,136,436,294.65 for paying their legal services... Why are we paying a billion dollars for legal services of a program we have discontinued? 1,021,000,000 to eradicate polio... Of which that last case in the united states was in 2022... Polio is all but irradicated here in the united states. We just seem to disagree with what's important and what's wasteful. You could build a brand new city for those amounts in the private sector.
- UncleMeat 2y agoThis is not an invincible decision making tool. It does not mean that literally every thing that can be explained by idiocy must be. We might start by leaning towards idiocy as an explanation but we are allowed to adjust our opinion as we see more and more information.
- watwut 2y agoHanlon's razor was originally a joke. Not like, serious observation about how world works.
- psadauskas 2y ago¿Por qué no los dos? (Spanish for _Why not both?_)
- watwut 2y agoHanlon's razor is overused and abused. Quite often, it is actually a malice and if you are willing to look at the situation dispassionately, it is quite visible. Hanlon's razor was originally a joke. Not a scientific observation how world works, but a funny sentence about there being a lot of incompetence in the world.
- GuinansEyebrows 2y agoHanlon's razor has been weaponized against good-faith applications
- threatofrain 2y agoHanlon's razor is for a peaceful heart, not for helping you win bets.
- amelius 2y agoHanlon's razor can be taken advantage of.
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago>Good point. Is it a good point? How so? Without any proof or arguments, to me that Mastodon comment is just your average brain rot social media conspiracy slop, especially when you examine the profile of the user who wrote it. Is this what journalism has now become? Parroting othe people's unhinged takes off social media, then upvoting it on HN?
- akimbostrawman 2y agoBut it's coming from the right/good side so any conspiracy instead of panic and dehumanization is plausible and not worth discussing further.
- conartist6 2y agoLikely not the choice of the engineers, who appear not to know that they're being used as pawns in an international spy game that could send them to prison for a very long time. I fully believe that the engineers themselves are wildly optimistic about society and their own abilities, but good security comes from realism and pessemism. Someone, probably many people, in the chain of command above them has moral and legal responsibility for choosing this course knowing it carried this risk and not caring.
- conartist6 2y agoKnowing their choice of targets too (definitely not left up to the engs), by which I mean only DOGEing and compromising the security of what they consider left-leaning agencies: with that targeting and their care to cover their tracks digitally, why not choose a strategy that lets the Russians in quietly? Shortly after they compromised the security of the NRLB they were making blackmail threats by taking drone videos of people (who threatened to reveal their malfeasance) where they lived and worked. Clearly someone in the chain of command is thinking carefully about what they can learn from how Russia governs
- abouthn 2y agoRemember that checklist meme from /.? The “You seem to be advocating/here is why it will not work”? Well, you’ve burned a bit of time on HN with the karma you’ve accrued. The non-conspiratorial truth is that if you go back and read HN over a longer period of time, it amounts to people parroting other people’s unhinged takes. Least offensive is tech, which is merely juvenile. But the other topics, especially medical ones, are dangerous. Political ones, with zero verification are the worst from a board culture/health perspective. HN has turned itself into slop in large part due to the voting and flagging mechanisms, because the community was never mentally equipped to use either tools responsibly. And pg/dang never set the tone. So now you see how far it has fallen. My advice: don’t come here to read comments seriously. Yes, from time to time someone of good taste shows up to a topic they have first hand experience with and they have to educate the rest as to why their takes are completely wrong (and sometimes dangerous, see above). Instead, come here to get the news, laugh at the shit flinging if you must, and move on. I’ve been contemplating doing an HN-without-HN filter board; show just the tech stuff, have commentary without voting or flagging. Because while you’re just seeing how things are now, I am afraid to say they’ve always been so.
- belter 2y agoHow bad can it be? Be pardoned by a SCOTUS immune president?
- satanfirst 2y agoAsk Rudy Giuliani or any architect foolish enough to take a project from him. While Trump might know more about protecting people who help him than he did then, it would be out of character for him to expend the time it takes to sign something if his benefit in the transaction is over.
- belter 2y agoThe 6 January rioters who got 20 years in prison, after beating and indirectly causing deaths at the capitol police have ALL been pardoned and are walking free. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capitol_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capito... "...The extraordinary pardons and commutations extended to those who committed both violent and nonviolent crimes on Jan. 6, including assaulting police officers and seditious conspiracy..." https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/20/us/politics/trump-pardons-jan-6.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/20/us/politics/trump-pardons...
- EasyMark 2y agoThat won't save you from a lawsuit
- akimbostrawman 2y agoIs the point good enough to elaborate further preferably with actual proof instead of just opinion?
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago"We don't do that here" - T'Challa
- amelius 2y agoIf it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, then at some point you gotta assume it's a duck. No need to run a DNA test.
- halJordan 2y agoIts more like "i see something waddling and quacking, is it a mallard or gallwad"
- Grimblewald 2y agoI dont mind, its open season and neither is on the protected list.
- tbugrara 2y agoThis perspective is ripe for being manipulated. Use critical thinking and learn to sit with uncertainty.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- amelius 2y ago> Use critical thinking and learn to sit with uncertainty. Maybe tell that to the guy in the white house. I'm tired of being held to much higher standards than that person. There are limits.
- 2y ago
- FireBeyond 2y agoI imagine it is "all of the above". Exactly as you describe, and I'm sure for other foreign interests, everyone at DOGE became massive targets for very highly directed nation-state level interest for phishing/malware/compromise.