5 ms·
Jury orders NSO to pay $167M for hacking WhatsApp users
- jeisc 2y agospying software should be illegal to sell under any circumstance the people who need these programs should be writing them themselves not buying them off the shelf
- bell-cot 2y agoThe same argument could be made about conventional arms. Unfortunately, 99% of nations prioritize having quick & easy access to weapons. And for many nations, selling weapons is also a lucrative way to exert influence.
- palata 2y ago> Unfortunately, 99% of nations prioritize having quick & easy access to weapons. What?
- FirmwareBurner 2y agoYour police and military where you live doesn't have easy access to weapons?
- palata 2y agoI wouldn't call it easy, no.
- FirmwareBurner 2y agoHow would you call it?
- bell-cot 2y agoRe-read user jeisc's comment. There are 200 or so nations on our planet. How many of those nations have governments which believe that their own army, air force, & navy should be unable to buy (say) guns, bombs, and torpedoes? Vs. having to hire engineers to design them, then build weapon factories, then build all of their own weapons. My assertion is that zero-ish of those governments want such legal restrictions. (And obviously, actual legal restrictions on the sale of spyware might be similarly unpopular, with the people who actually write the our world's laws.)
- palata 2y agoOh right, I see what you mean. Still, I believe there is a difference. First, it feels like anyone willing to pay enough will convince NSO to "help" them. It's not the same with firearms (in 99% countries in the world): you can't just pay a private company to go rob a bank with firearms. Then for the police and the military, it's usually restricted to professionals. In my country, if a police officer gets their gun out (I'm not talking about firing), an investigation follows. If they fire their gun, a bigger investigation follows, they make the news, and the officer may lose their job (or be affected to a desk job for the rest of their career). It seems a lot easier to get access to NSO than to actually fire a gun, and to me that's a good thing. I don't want a police like in the US. To the point where I do believe that it should be as hard to access NSO as it is to use firearms.
- jimnotgym 2y agoShouldn't we be seeing criminal sanctions? If I sold app exploits I would be in jail
- saagarjha 2y agoDepends on who you sell them to
- razakel 2y agoYou're not a three-letter agency, though.
- jimnotgym 2y agoNSO is not a three-letter agency, it is a private company
- razakel 2y agoOne of the founders is ex-Mossad.
- bloppe 2y agoWhich is obviously 6 letters
- rabid_turtle 2y agoNSO is very cozy with Israel intelligence. It being private gives it the legal ability to do things that a government agency could not.
- voxic11 2y agoSelling exploits is generally legal. What law would be used to put you in jail? Using exploits can fall under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act's criminally prohibited conduct but afaik there is no similar law that covers distributing/selling exploits. In fact selling exploits to companies via their bug bounty programs is quite common. All that said NSO didn't just distribute/sell the exploits (that would be giving away their secret sauce). Instead they offered what was essentially a managed service for executing the exploits against user selected targets.
- IG_Semmelweiss 2y agoNot sure if this is too little, too late. The israeli cyber-intelligence firm primarily known for its proprietary spyware Pegasus, employed almost 500 people as of 2017 [1] . However, the US govt included NSO Group in its Entity List for acting against U.S. national security and foreign policy interests, effectively banning U.S. companies from supplying NSO [1] This makes me think that NSO is effectively frozen out of the US banking network, and therefore the whatsapp judgement is ineffective to go after US assets in US jurisdictions. So, no disgorgement outside of what banks may have frozen before this lawsuit (if anything) as a result of the Entity list addition. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSO_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSO_Group
- cedws 2y agoGiven that the NSO Group is supported by the Israeli government and their weapons have been used against US civilians, and US-aligned individuals, you would think there would be much heftier consequences.
- rafale 2y agoThey knowingly attacked and destroyed USS Liberty in 1967 and didn't face any consequences. Sometimes I wonder what's so special about Israel that they keep getting away with everything.
- logicchains 2y agoWhat's so special? A good chunk of the US population believes the Israelis were literally chosen by God over 2000 years ago to occupy that piece of land, and they're obligated to do whatever they can to help them.
- late2part 2y agoThe same chunk of population "should" (??) think that the Israeli ancestors killed Jesus, and that the Jews will go to hell if they don't accept Jesus as their savior - so - people are weird.
- OsrsNeedsf2P 2y agoNot sure how I feel about this - on one hand the NSO Group happily sold this exploit to absolutely horrible clients[0], but on the other, app security shouldn't depend on legal enforcement. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/jul/18/revealed-murdered-journalist-number-selected-mexico-nso-client-cecilio-pineda-birto https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/jul/18/revealed-murder...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> app security shouldn't depend on legal enforcement Why not? There are significant negative externalities to not enforcing cybercrime laws.
- lazide 2y agoI think they meant solely depend on legal enforcement. For the same reason banks should have a decent vault for cash they aren’t using at this exact moment, since they shouldn’t just depend solely on any robbers getting caught.
- bloppe 2y agoIt's not like hacking WhatsApp was that easy. If it were, NSO wouldn't be able to sell it's exploits for so much
- vkou 2y agoJust because locks can be defeated by five seconds and a lockpick gun doesn't mean that the housebreaker, his fence, or his getaway driver is absolved of their responsibility.
- TZubiri 2y agoOf course law plays a huge part in computer security.
- walterbell 2y ago> app security shouldn't depend on legal enforcement EU Cyber Resilience Act (CRA) will soon impose legal security requirements on a wide class of software binaries sold in the EU.
- badkitty99 2y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 2y agoNo amount of sysadminning was going to save you from state-sponsored zero-day attacks.
- walterbell 2y agoDid Citizen Lab's sysadminning contribute to the outcome of this legal case to impose financial penalty on a vendor of state-purchased spyware? Or is the penalty considered insignificant to future deterrence?
- tptacek 2y agoThat's not what Citizen Lab did.
- walterbell 2y agoDidn't Citizen Lab perform forensic analysis of victim devices?
- badkitty99 2y agoI know we'll all get infected, but at least we could try to detect it afterwards is my point
- impossiblefork 2y agoCompetent people regularly discover state-sponsored zero-day attacks. Maybe it's a higher level than 'sysadmining', but I suspect there are people who are called sysadmins who do discover these kinds of things.
- saagarjha 2y ago"State-sponsored" covers a broad range from sending phishing links to zero-click exploit chains. It takes specialized talent to find the latter. Most of those people would not call themselves sysadmins.
- walterbell 2y agoMeta published deposition transcripts, http://nitter.poast.org/jsrailton/status/1919880291667292460 http://nitter.poast.org/jsrailton/status/1919880291667292460 https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Eshkar-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-N... https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Gil-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-N... https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Shohat-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-N... https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Gazneli-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-N...
- firefax 2y agoBelow are the Internet Archive copies, since Facebook doesn't have the greatest track record on stable URLs. (I reregistered recently and was banned for being "inauthentic" -- the URL they linked to which was supposed to detail what part of the policy I broke was broken.) https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235016/https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Eshkar-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235016/https://about.fb.... https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235104/https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Gil-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235104/https://about.fb.... https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235302/https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Shohat-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235302/https://about.fb.... https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235441/https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/WhatsApp-v-NSO-Gazneli-Transcrips_Case-4-19-cv-07123-PJH.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20250506235441/https://about.fb....
- rpgwaiter 2y agoI wonder what percentage of that $167M will go to the ~1400 victims of this hack (that we know about)
- TZubiri 2y ago0? I understood that the plaintiff is what'sapp. Not sure if it's for damages or punitive. The victims are probably not citizens of the US so they would be outside of this jurisdiction. That's between those two countries. The reason it's going to the US court is because it occured in US cyberturf (Meta's servers)
- nashashmi 2y agoNone. WhatsApp has stated it will give to a privacy advocacy organization
- Pesthuf 2y agoWhose urgent warnings on privacy concerns will be ignored by everyone, as usual.
- TZubiri 2y agoThis looks like a pretty spicy political bomb. I wonder if the group will pay, I'm assuming they won't, if they do it's because the Israeli government intervened and bailed them out. They are fighting a war after all.
- nashashmi 2y agoIsrael defense green lights the sale and use of Pegasus software. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/magazine/nso-group-israel-spyware.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/magazine/nso-group-israel...
- Alex_001 2y ago[dead]
- Glyptodon 2y agoI wonder about the other end of liability - if the app was so broken that merely calling a phone with it could lead to a back, it seems like users might reasonably also blame its authors.
- Meekro 2y agoUnfortunately, the smartest programmers in the world (people like Linus Torvalds) sometimes screw up and create security issues. If Linus can't get it 100% right, what hope is there for the rest of us?
- aitchnyu 2y agoI've been thinking about requiring iMessage and other codebases in memory unsafe languages to be built by WASM compiler with the objective of being memory safe and minimal performance loss.
- aussieguy1234 2y agoWho gets the damages here, Meta or the hacking victims?
- saagarjha 2y agoMeta who says they will donate it to digital rights organizations.
- ebfe1 2y agoOk ....where is the form so as an ex-whatsapp user, I can get a piece of that 167M pie? Oh... there isnt one... :)
- notepad0x90 2y agoI'm on NSO's side here. It's quite hypocritical of everyone involved to be against NSO but not gun makers. I don't even want to touch civilians abuse of guns, just governments buying guns from weapons manufacturers and using them in properly sanctioned wars. People are acting like exploits are more dangerous than bullets or restricted like nuclear, biological and chemical weapons, they are not! The demand is there and the suppliers exist. without companies like NSO, the price of exploits goes up and it becomes more lucrative for malicious actors to sell them to even more nefarious actors. The exploit brokers become more anonymous. And when they sell to the really bad actors, it will require deanonymizing market places on Tor instead of having law suits like this. It is much better for everyone involved to tolerate companies like NSO and regulate them.
- ktallett 2y agoIt isn't an either or scenario, NSO can be in the wrong and rightfully fined and weapons can also be sold by governments to the wrong parties. The latter should be regulated as well, not the former being let off as well. Demand shouldn't always equal supply.
- dqv 2y ago> It is much better for everyone involved to tolerate companies like NSO and regulate them. That's what this is. That's what a lawsuit is. This is them being regulated. They aren't being ordered to shut down, they're being ordered to pay damages.
- notepad0x90 2y agono, there is no regulation or law for what they do. This is a civil suit between two companies, it is not a regulation. had they actually violated the law, it would have been a criminal prosecution. civil damages are not government regulation. if you can simply be anonymous, you won't even break the law as you sell to any party.
- dqv 2y ago> no, there is no regulation or law for what they do Yes, there is: the CFAA. Corporations and the government have even weaponized criminal complaints against individuals under the law. > This is a civil suit between two companies, it is not a regulation The venue in which regulation is enforced does not change its status as a regulation. The distinction between criminal and civil is irrelevant here. (Notwithstanding the possibility of a corrupt judge) Meta would not have been able to continue their suit had there not been a regulation. > had they actually violated the law, it would have been a criminal prosecution No, had a prosecutor wanted to pursue an indictment, it would have been a criminal prosecution. A prosecutor's willingness to enforce a law and bring trial is at their discretion. In the same way that charges don't necessarily indicate criminality, a lack thereof doesn't necessarily indicate the absence of wrongdoing. > civil damages are not government regulation. Civil laws are regulation. The judge is the regulating authority who enforces the penalty for being out of compliance with those laws, which comes in the form of ordering money damages in this situation. > if you can simply be anonymous, you won't even break the law as you sell to any party Yes and maybe the fact that they're anonymous brings it it to the level of criminality in a prosecutor's eyes. That desire to conceal their identity could the turn preponderance of the evidence (civil) into beyond a reasonable doubt (criminal). Or it could always stay in the civil system. The criminal system is political just like anything else. See above.
- b8 2y agoThey're based in Israel, so it's unlikely they'll pay. It's interesting that Zerodium has slowly stopped their gears (at least publicly) even though the USG was buying their exploits to target HVTs. It's like when the DOJ posts an arrest warrant for a Russian or a Chinese military official, it's mainly for show.
- arresin 2y agoIt’s amazing how much justice you can get when you are a billion dollar company > The jury also awarded WhatsApp $444 million in compensatory damages.
- autoexec 2y agoThis is a great day for people who can make more than $167M by hacking whatsapp users! On the off chance that they happen to be caught in the first place they now know what their profit margins will look like after Facebook goes to court to take their cut.