8 ms·
FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller shortage worsens
- monero-xmr 2y agoIt would be great if actually needed, demanding government jobs could pay a market rate. And even better, we could somehow pay better people more. And even even better - fire poor performers. The more-less lockstep pay scales across the US government are bizarre, as well as government unions, negotiating with politicians. As FDR said: > All Government employees should realize that the process of collective bargaining, as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service. It has its distinct and insurmountable limitations when applied to public personnel management. The very nature and purposes of Government make it impossible for administrative officials to represent fully or to bind the employer in mutual discussions with Government employee organizations. The employer is the whole people, who speak by means of laws enacted by their representatives in Congress. Accordingly, administrative officials and employees alike are governed and guided, and in many instances restricted, by laws which establish policies, procedures, or rules in personnel matters. > Particularly, I want to emphasize my conviction that militant tactics have no place in the functions of any organization of Government employees. > … Since their own services have to do with the functioning of the Government, a strike of public employees manifests nothing less than an intent on their part to prevent or obstruct the operations of Government until their demands are satisfied. Such action, looking toward the paralysis of Government by those who have sworn to support it, is unthinkable and intolerable. It is, therefore, with a feeling of gratification that I have noted in the constitution of the National Federation of Federal Employees the provision that "under no circumstances shall this Federation engage in or support strikes against the United States Government.” - FDR, 1937 https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/letter-the-resolution-federation-federal-employees-against-strikes-federal-service https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/letter-the-resolut...
- duxup 2y agoThe limits on government salaries seems entirely counterproductive. I am all for evaluating things in an effort to establish more government efficiency. But that means you need smart people who understand that domain evaluating, and you need to be able to bring smart people on board to do the work…. not artificially low wages/ arbitrary cuts…
- jedberg 2y agoThe limits are there to limit corruption. If managers could set arbitrary salaries, the employees could just agree to cut their manager in on 10% of their raise. This probably happens outside of government, but it's just the private org who loses money, so it's up to them to stop it. But in the case of the government, it's the taxpayers who lose.
- duxup 2y agoI don’t think managers (even without limits) could just set salaries… it’s not like they all just pay the max at manager discretion now.
- jedberg 2y agoGovernment salaries are based on objective measures today -- years of service and job role. There is no "merit" part or anything subjective. To move to a system where "good people make more money", someone has to decide who the "good" people are. That person is susceptible to corruption. Moreso than in a private enterprise and with wider consequences, because government is not a business. So overpaying people doesn't have the same consequences as doing it privately.
- Jtsummers 2y agoNSPS was an attempt to push towards something more merit based (still pay band structured, NSPS bands spanned 2-3 GS grades). NSPS was rolled back in 2010 or so because the requirement was that everyone had to be on it by 2009 (early 2010?) and that didn't happen. There are various *demo (lab, acq, I think some others) that are basically the same as NSPS (in principle) and ostensibly merit based. But they're also capped because of the correspondence to GS grades. Pay can increase much faster, in theory, than under GS but also you can be denied any raise except the general pay increase (below inflation, so a real pay cut even if a nominal pay raise) if your performance is poor.
- ThunderSizzle 2y ago
- jltsiren 2y agoEasier firing would increase the market rates for every role. At least unless combined with generous unemployment benefits, as in Denmark. It could make the government more efficient in the long term, at the expense of higher spending (and therefore higher taxes) in the short term. Which many voters would not like. The issue with unions negotiating with politicians is mostly a consequence of an excessive number of political appointees. Many things would be cleaner with more career civil servants in top positions. Top officials would have fixed-term appointments, and they could not join unions or be fired without a criminal conviction. They would run their departments, while political appointees would only set the goals and directions with little direct control. And then the rest would be more like ordinary employees who just happen to be working for the government. Government employees are a mostly irrelevant category anyway. Depending on the time and place, the exact same job can be performed by an actual government employee, outsourced to a private contractor, or done by an employee of a company fully owned by the government. What the employee can or cannot do should depend more on the actual role than on the administrative structures above them.
- ericjmorey 2y agoThe US Government is not interested in hiring outside of law enforcement so they won't be able to find people to fill positions outside of law enforcement.
- dmix 2y agoMaybe federal government which hasn’t grown much (they contract everything). State and especially local government employment has been growing consistently for years, or growing very fast if you count education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_employees_in_the_United_States?wprov=sfti1# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_employees_in_the_Un... ATC should probably be private like it is in Canada, where it functions very well, and also better lines up with how the federal gov operates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nav_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nav_Canada
- sokoloff 2y agoA lot of services are provided by contractors, including a few hundred control towers, the weather briefing system, the vast majority of flight and medical examiners, etc.
- jbm 2y agoCanadian ATC has serious issues, and the whole air travel system is much, much more expensive than the US. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/vancouver-airport-delays-1.7512196 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/vancouver-ai...
- fracus 2y agoI would currently be very afraid flying to the USA for a multitude of reasons. It doesn't help that I'm afraid of flying.
- RandomBacon 2y agoAs for not falling out of the sky or hitting other aircraft, I think the U.S. still has the safest airspace. If you're referring to immigration/law/customs/etc, I can't help you there. Even flying (commercially?) in other countries is still probably safer than driving.
- chneu 2y agoAir travel is insanely safe, even in the shittiest countries. you only hear about the dozen or so crashes every year. You don't hear about the 30-40 million other flights that don't have issues in a year.
- OrvalWintermute 2y agoThe US can easily fill in gaps by taking the Special Operators Combat Controllers (CCTs) who are actually all certified Air Traffic Controllers. Furthermore, the Air Force could additionally take the Terminal Air Control Party (TACPs) - think of them as a Radio/Strike guy that coordinates Air Strikes, that accompany tactical platoons and cross train them into Air Traffic Control, further augmenting their ability to perform this role.
- somerandomdude2 2y agoIt would be great to help keep CCT skills fresh and current - rotate them around with 'deployments' to civilian facilities. It'd be a win all the way around.
- throwaway48476 2y agoIt takes 1-3 years of facility based training in order to qualify as an ATC for a specific tower. A military enlistment is only 4 years. CCTs would end up doing their entire enlistment at one facility leaving no time to train as a CCT. You'd have to hire another person who's job is 100% CCT, at which point, why not just hire an ATC?
- OrvalWintermute 2y agoMilitary enlistments vary from shorter than longer to 4 years. ATCs regularly go TDY to support other locations. You’re conflating ATC training with a location
- tdpvb 2y agoIt sounds like a nice idea, but the only common factor between ATC and CCT is the certification and some fundamental core training -- everything else is super nuanced specific to each scenario. Some CCT who's specialized in deconflicting a stack overhead in wartime can't just waltz into ORD tower and say "all right boys and girls, go ahead and take a break, I've got this." Each requires domain-specific experience. And to add on what others have said: yes CCTs represent a pool of proven ATC candidates, but depleting that pool just to knee-jerk a short term-ish solution creates an equal problem for the military -- and it's a hell of a lot harder to recruit adequate candidates for CCT. For example, they have to do like, lots of pushups...
- ourmandave 2y agoWhile the incentives are a step forward, officials caution that hiring alone won’t resolve the deeper problems. The nation’s air traffic control infrastructure is aging, with 51 out of 138 systems currently labeled as unsustainable — some using components more than 50 years old. An announcement regarding technology upgrades and infrastructure improvements is expected next week. Haven't they been trying to modernize air traffic control since forever? I wonder what announcements they're going to make.
- _moof 2y agoI feel like I've been hearing about NextGen for decades. Just looked it up and I'm not far off. NextGen started in 2007 and is still ongoing.
- derbOac 2y agoBased on what I read earlier, I wouldn't be surprised if it was based on AI that Musk recently purchased. I sincerely hope I'm wrong though. I also hope whatever it is, it doesn't make the ATC system dependent on some proprietary monopoly. This discussion of ATC makes me nervous, as mandated sudden adoption of new, often proprietary tech nationwide has created a lot of nightmares in other fields like healthcare. Instead of learning lessons from that, we seem to be repeating it over again but even more so.
- kj4211cash 2y agoI haven't been able to find it since but at one point I came across a quote saying that NextGen was the "greatest failure in the history of organized labor." Or something to that effect. A bit of an overstatement but I have to admit I found the parts I could see circa 2010 ridiculous.
- throwaway48476 2y agoOne of the biggest problems with ATC hiring is that location assignments happen after trainees pass the academy. A lot of the academy graduates quit when they get an assignment they don't like. It's not like the military where they can force people. The trainee pay also sucks so the prospect of getting sent somewhere undesirable and then barely being able to afford it just isn't attractive. If they would hire based on location like they used to graduates wouldn't quit as often. The other big problem is Obama changed the hiring test from testing intelligence to testing personality in a bid to increase diversity. There was a lawsuit over this. The effect was academy failure rates soared and because class sizes are fixed there was a shortfall in the number of graduates making it to towers to train.
- FridayoLeary 2y agoAnother problem you haven't mentioned is the level of union control in the industry. Which is great as far as protecting jobs and salaries for existing controllers but it makes getting a desirable position difficult for a new graduate. From your comment it sounds like they just get dumped with the least desirable location until they've climbed high enough up the totem pole to get a good job.
- throwaway48476 2y agoMost ATCs spend their whole career at one or two towers. 'Desireable' in the case of graduates is usually wherever they or their family was living when they got hired. The union doesn't have any say in tower assignment.
- sandworm101 2y ago>> a desirable position difficult for a new graduate. These generally are not positions that people compete for across the nation. Once in a particular airspace, controllers will generally stay in that airspace. An outsider unfamiliar with an airspace would be at significant disadvantage to any local.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago
- sega_sai 2y agoI am sure the attempts of hiring for government jobs will go well, after all the indiscriminate firings experienced by many government agencies thanks to the DOGE and company.
- QuarterReptile 2y agoHow bad were the firings in ATC?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- RandomBacon 2y agoNon-existent as far as I've heard (source: am ATC)
- verzali 2y agoSounds like at least some people were fired: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-begins-firings-of-faa-air-traffic-control-employees-weeks-after-fatal-dc-plane-crash https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-begins-firings-o...
- RandomBacon 2y agoI read your link and nowhere does it say that any ATC were fired.
- mint2 2y ago“Yes, it’s true 95% of the forests in CA are prone to wildfire and many have recently burnt, but trust me my house in the forest is safe, it isn’t in a forest that has burned yet!!! Would you like to buy my house?” So nearly every org in our government has been decimated twice over, including many critical ones, under staffed ones, and efficient ones. Is it far fetched that people would now be incredulous about the well being of the few departments not yet decimated twice over?
- frustratedlazy 2y agoMore context - https://viewfromthewing.com/diversity-in-the-skies-faas-controversial-shift-in-air-traffic-controller-hiring/ https://viewfromthewing.com/diversity-in-the-skies-faas-cont...
- Flatcircle 2y ago"The nation’s air traffic control infrastructure is aging, with 51 out of 138 systems currently labeled as unsustainable — some using components more than 50 years old." this is okay for the post office or DMV, but probably not as okay for air traffic control infrastructure.
- joezydeco 2y agoDidn't DOGE just lay off a number of probational employees (new, promoted or transferred) in the infrastructure division? https://apnews.com/article/faa-firings-trump-doge-safety-airlines-27390c6a7aac58063652302df5a243d3 https://apnews.com/article/faa-firings-trump-doge-safety-air...
- Jtsummers 2y agoFAA, but not ATCs. I think a lot of the FAA folks were also offered their jobs back, like with other agencies. As a consequence of court decisions and "oh shit, those are actually important jobs".
- rsynnott 2y agoWould tend to make recruitment more difficult, though. "Yeah, we just had a bunch of people fired by some weird Twitter idiot, but you should totally train for years to come work for us, that couldn't possibly go wrong."
- lanfeust6 2y agoNot a surprise after the reputation they've built - https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-faas-hiring https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-fa...
- iamleppert 2y agoWhat incentives could possibly exist to go to work for government at this point? It used to offer job security but that’s no longer the case. All I see is low pay, poor benefits, no job security, lack of employer diversity and significant regulatory risk that is tied to whatever administration happens to be in office.
- deadbabe 2y agoThat’s the point, just hire private industries to do everything instead.
- chneu 2y agothey'll never prioritize money over safety. nope, never.
- DaSHacka 2y agoAnd the government doesn't?
- const_cast 2y agoNo, a lot of government agencies are specifically positioned to not favor money over safety. Something like the FAA or FDA would never be conducted by the private sector. Because they're money sinks, and knowing how safe something is, is bad, actually. The private sector would much rather be blissfully unaware. Less liability that way. The only time something like the FDA "fails" is when they give too much plausible deniability to the private sector. Like when they like J&J handle their asbestos BS in the 70s. And then... we got 50 years of asbestos baby powder. Oops! Should've never trusted them.
- watwut 2y agoOf economy becomes bad enough, those jobs will be desirable again.
- kj4211cash 2y agoCan any controller or person who otherwise works in this area comment on the tracingwoodgrains blog post? I always see it linked on HN, but never mentioned anywhere else. Seems like there would be a huge scandal with lot of commentary and links if it were true.
- RandomBacon 2y agoU.S. ATC here: opinions are my own and do not necessarily reflect that of the FAA. But to be safe: no comment. Otherwise, if I knew something was untrue, I could say that.
- NaOH 2y agoI'm not qualified to evaluate that post, but there was some critique of it and the suit's merits in a thread a few months ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42874983 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42874983
- ivraatiems 2y agoI'm not sure how "we want ultra-high non-woke pure-meritocracy hiring standards and we'll aggressively filter out anyone who even smells like they won't pass those standards" is compatible with "we need butts in seats doing this work immediately." I also am not at all surprised that people do not want to begin working for a government which has made it clear it despises all of its workers. You really can't have it both ways. (And plenty of perfectly capable/qualified people, myself included, read all this "anti-DEI" stuff exactly the same way that the anti-DEI people read DEI itself, as a means of preselecting who is entitled to compete for jobs.) The solution is not to "de-wokify" anything - nor is it to "wokify" anything. All of that stuff is a sideshow. The solution would be to offer massive incentives in order to get highly competent people to see ATC as a good career choice. That means big salaries, very flexible training timelines, and in general, willingness to spend a lot of money on the program to make it attractive. ATC is an intense job being done by people who are under a lot of strain. It doesn't sound appealing to most. That would need to change. What am I missing here?
- more_corn 2y agoDidn’t they Doge just fire all their recently promoted and hired air traffic controllers?