6 ms·
Why I Am Not Going to Buy a Computer (1987) [pdf]
- Jtsummers 2y agoPast discussions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42636195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42636195 - 3 months ago, 10 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31808269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31808269 - 3 years ago, 169 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2108463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2108463 - 14 years ago, 11 comments
- MaxPock 2y ago[flagged]
- jazzyjackson 2y agoAnti computer people are blissfully unaware of your feelings toward them, maybe they're onto something Wendell Barry had a perfectly successful career without having to touch computers, and there will be people in twenty years who lead careers without having to interact with AI personalities
- 8bitbeep 2y agoHopefully there will be careers for people in 20 years.
- LPisGood 2y agoIt’s kind of a shame that we set up a system where this is the case.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jes5199 2y agokinda hope there won’t be and we all retire to leisure
- ziddoap 2y agoWith what money? My kids aren't going to have enough money to retire to leisure in 20 years.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoUBI
- ziddoap 2y agoMinimum wage is barely (in many cases not even barely) enough to live on. Raising minimum wage is a herculean task that rarely succeeds. Federal minimum wage hasn't been raised in 16 years. But we'll have not only a livable UBI in 20 years, but one that's enough to "retire to a life of leisure"? Doubt.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoMinimum wage isn't directly comparable, because that's the government setting a rule on what two private parties can agree to. It's not the government but the employer who pays it. UBI is distributed by the government directly, so it's basically a question of what gets taxed, how much inflation results, and whether that inflation and taxation proves more unpopular than the UBI is popular.
- Analemma_ 2y agoThis is silly. To a first approximation, zero percent of the opposition to minimum wage increases comes from a principled stance of "I support taxation, even high taxation, but I am opposed to the government interfering in private labor market contracts"; 100% of it is from "they're taking my money!". There is no reason to expect any less opposition from the much, much larger amount of wealth redistribution which would be required by UBI.
- User23 2y agoThat reminds me of this: https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/email.html https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/email.html.
- edm0nd 2y ago>Anti computer people are blissfully unaware of your feelings toward them, maybe they're onto something Theodore Kaczynski had some interesting ideas about modern technology and its impact on society.
- walrus01 2y agoPlenty of people are anti "AI" because the uses they see it being put to are AI slop posted on Facebook to be responded to by boomers or bots. Or both. The dead Internet theory is becoming real.
- nelsonfigueroa 2y agoThis. I even see more professional pages (personal technical blogs, corporate technical blogs) use text and images that are straight up AI slop.
- falcor84 2y agoMaybe it's just me, but while I have an issue with text slop, GenAI images never bothered me. My experience is that they're only really used where the alternative would have been a lazy stock photo or clipart image. And in these cases, it seems to me that writing a prompt is actually more of an artistic expression than the even more minimal effort that they likely would have spent on taking the first image they would have found on google.
- Analemma_ 2y agoIn theory there's no reason this has to be the case, but in practice there is a very strong correlation between using a blog using GenAI images and the blog being shit. On Substack in particular, use of GenAI images is a strong "don't waste your time here" signal.
- vemom 2y agoThis writer doesn't look obnoxious to me they make good points. Of course they make good points only for their use case. I'd rather keep computers as a thing and have all the medical advances, plane safety, science advances we have seen. I also couldn't do what I first did on a computer with a pencil: program an automaton. But it is worth reading other points of view and seeing their side.
- II2II 2y agoI am sympathetic with his message today, when I would have been dismissive of it in 1987. I also realize that I shouldn't have been dismissive of it in 1987. Even though the industry of today is far more damaging than it was then, it is only because there were so many benefits yet-to-reap. The industry itself was just as manipulative and just as greedy. While most of the old empires have fallen, new ones have taken their place. That said, I think his tone was a mistake. It is not that technology is inherently good or bad. The fault is in how we fail to examine the role it should play. Each of the nine criteria that he lays out could have been met, but as individuals and society we have decided upon a different path.
- casey2 2y agoHis points flat suck and they aren't well thought out at all. Right of the bat "the new tool should be cheaper than the one it replaces" On what basis is this even defensible? Even if you just follow this single rule we'd all still be hunter-gatherers And the last one his mask slips "It should not replace...anything...". Why privilege what already exists over what doesn't? It had it's time.
- kgwxd 2y agoI fear they'll look like RMS looks in regards to proprietary hardware and software today. Show me a nightmare warning that hasn't become reality.
- User23 2y agoRemember that the FSF happened because printers suck. Shockingly printers still suck.
- pipeline_peak 2y agoThere’s not much motivation for improvements in something that’s been dead for 30+ years.
- makotech221 2y agoi dunno ask the nft/memecoin/VR/3D-TV people. Sometimes the anti-new thing people are actually correct
- aurareturn 2y agoAsk internet people, TV people, computer people, GPU people, solar energy people, etc. We going to play this game?
- Jedd 2y agoBy anti-AI, do you mean people who oppose the seemingly whimsical (while potentially being an existential threat) creation of genuine artificial intelligence without exercising unprecedented levels of caution, or people who mistake LLMs for intelligence?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jes5199 2y agohuh. I’m aware of this author for other reasons - he’s popular among some carbon-capture enthusiasts. This… colors my opinion.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tom_ 2y agoI'd never heard of them before! But I'm sure some people that disapprove will come along soon enough to balance things out.
- 4b11b4 2y agoI know the author from Unsettling America.
- wwweston 2y agoI have questions about whether Berry would own that relationship even if (big if) he were convinced carbin capture was beneficial. But more importantly — chances are VERY strong that Berry transcends most of the categories you’re familiar with and a few that you aren’t. He’s an outstanding voice, and a worthy thinker for anyone to sharpen their own mind with or against. Though even where I part ways with him — for example, I was always going to buy a computer (and more computers) — I usually discover that there was a tradeoff and value worth defending on the other side of my choice. Also, the overlap between his standards for technology and open source values is pretty high.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoWendell Berry is a pretty prolific activist and writer, and has been for more than half a century. You would do well to fully understand his own stances before judging him based on how other people choose to interpret him. You might come to the same conclusions, but they would be defensible at the very least.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- analog31 2y agoAn amusing anecdote: I was in grad school in 1987. The university had a campus computer store, which gave out a pamphlet: "Should I get a computer?" It listed many pro's and con's, nothing surprising for the era. I already had a computer. The thing that stuck with me, was the advice: "Don't expect a computer to organize you. If you have a messy desk, you will have a messy computer." Sure as shootin', even to this day, I still have a messy computer.
- Terr_ 2y agoNevertheless, I go through life with the persistent unconscious belief that if I buy products-for-organizing I will become organized. :p
- jaredsohn 2y agoIn a similar way, buying exercise equipment gets you in shape.
- callc 2y agoIf you buy enough equipment then the act of carrying the equipment inside will get you in shape. Just like my bogo sort. It’ll get there eventually.
- throwup238 2y agoThe most exercise I’ve ever had is solo assembling a 295 pound Rogue Fitness Monster Lite power rack and raising it from the horizontal position I assembled it in to the vertical position. I figured after that much effort I needn’t exercise ever again. I sold it the next week at a loss (cheapest hobby I’ve ever had). Although to be fair I didn’t realize at the time that I needed to buy the barbell and weights too. Lesson learned: stick to the monthly gym membership that I will never use. The second most exercise I’ve ever had is solo raising my Grizzly 14” bandsaw to standing. Also never used, but at least I never had the heart to sell it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ViktorRay 2y agoIt's neat how this magazine printed the essay along with the responses of people to it. Many of those response letters are quite biting (in a good way). Sometimes I feel disheartedned when I see harsh internet comments in response to an essay. For example, sometimes Paul Graham posts essays and people on Hacker News post blistering biting responses. I guess we should remember the letters that people used to send to magazine essays like this and remember that sometimes these harsh responses are par for the course when writing essays...
- dredmorbius 2y agoThe published magazine letters are likely curated. If nothing else, they were also posted by (snail) mail, not instantaneous emogi-laden adTech-fueling online ragelettes. An elegant weapon for a more civilized age.
- abe_m 2y agoI find it funny the old "I'm so feminist" prose thinking they're empowering women, while their actually demeaning the work the wife did. One comment from Toby Koosman directly lumps the wife in with servants. Published work (writing) gets better with an editor helping, so she is providing valuable work, that even today computers can't engage in. Are the ideas expressed clearly? Does the piece make sense overall. Is the narrative properly built. Are their weird parts hanging around that get in the way of the intended message? You have a couple that is engaging in each other's ideas, discussing issues that are most likely of interest to both of them. People often couple up who share a view on how to live, so it is likely that the wife is just as into the low tech lifestyle as he is. There exist women who like the rural and homesteading lifestyle. The overall tone of the comment section is pretty disrespectful towards the wife.
- milliams 2y ago> If possible, it should use some form of solar energy, such as that of the body. Am I missing something here?
- jml7c5 2y agoIt's an excessively brief way of saying that the nutrients we consume ultimately come from the sun. It caught me off guard for a moment, too.
- echoangle 2y agoThen basically every form of energy humanity uses except nuclear is from the sun. Oil is also plant- and animal-based if you go back far enough.
- zahlman 2y agoNot to mention, the point of using "solar energy" as we normally conceive of it is to avoid CO2 emissions, but humans exhale CO2.
- Liftyee 2y agoThough all the carbon we eat eventually traces back to plants which absorbed equal CO2 from the atmosphere... so it's technically carbon neutral.
- svara 2y agoIt's just carbon neutral, not "technically" carbon neutral. The reason we even care about CO2 emissions is that industrial emissions reconnect carbon reservoirs that were disconnected from the atmosphere for millions of years, i.e. underground oil, gas and coal deposits, back to the atmosphere. Not that CO2 in itself is harmful in any way.
- zahlman 2y ago
- tankenmate 2y ago"Finally, it seems to me that none of my correspondents recognizes the innovativeness of my essay. If the use of a computer is a new idea, then a newer idea is not to use one." Hardly a new idea, I'm fairly certain that Berry had heard of the Luddites, maybe he didn't realise he was hewing as close a course as he was.
- roschdal 2y agoThe list of reasons for using new technology seems reasonable: 1. It should be cheaper than the one it replaces. 2. It should be at least as small in scale as the one it replaces. 3. It should do work that is clearly and demonstrably better than the one it replaces. 4. It should use less energy than the one it replaces. 5. If possible, it should use some form of solar energy, such as that of the body. 6. It should be repairable by a person of ordinary intelligence, provided that he or she has the necessary tools. 7. It should be purchasable and repairable as near to home as possible. 8. It should come from a small, privately owned shop or store that will take it back for maintenance and repair. 9. It should not replace or disrupt anything good that already exists, including family and community relationships.
- dredmorbius 2y agoIs much as I appreciate Berry's work and writing, I'd actually look to that list as a foundation of counterarguments, and possibly, alternate rationales. Many (though not all) innovations benefit by scale. This would include freshwater viaducts, transportation canals, sewerage systems, and mechanised agriculture (even at modest levels). Many technologies are less expensive at scale. Berry's beloved typewriter is more expensive than a quill pen, as one of his respondents notes. Computers rather famously have fallen tremendously in price:performance (though we've also bumped up the minimum acceptable performance level). Some technologies are truly transformational. Going back before computers, and in the realm of information storage, retrieval and distribution, I could point to the lowly index card, reversable bindings (which made subscription updates to information possible, as with encyclopedias, business directories, manuals, specifications, and the like), and the printing press and moveable type themselves. Computers fit into this continuum, to which we could add telecommunications (signal flares, optical and electrical telegraphs, the telephone, broadcast and cable radio and television, packet-switched communications, as well as automated data systems, databases, revision control systems, and wikis). Reparability is fine, and I'm strongly opposed to unnecessary additional barriers to repair (as the Right to Repair folks are correctly fighting). But again there are cases where the complexity and maintenance costs are offset by the increased capabilities. It's ironic to note that the computers of 1985 which Berry writes of are extremely repairable by contemporary standards (presuming you can find, or fabricate, replacement parts). I could go on. Mind that I'm sympathetic to Berry's points, and I'd be inclined to make similar arguments against much current technology. As Douglas Adams said: Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. Anything that’s invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. Anything invented after you’re thirty-five is against the natural order of things. (As quoted by Cory Doctorow: <https://www.frankenbook.org/pub/ive-create-a-monster/release/1 https://www.frankenbook.org/pub/ive-create-a-monster/release...>, also at <https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Douglas_Adams https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Douglas_Adams>.) I'm also in general agreement with Berry's meta-argument: we should be mindful of what technologies we introduce into our lives. And as much as I like typewriters, I'm typing this on a computer. But not one of those newfangled mobile abominations.
- ribcage 2y ago[dead]
- stodor89 2y agoGreat article, thanks for sharing. I enjoyed hearing the author's viewpoint, and his list of criteria for buying stuff can be useful with some minor adjustments. Also, the replies regarding his wife were hilarious, if a bit nosy and presumptuous (or maybe because of that).
- dredmorbius 2y agoBerry has stuck to his guns: "Why Wendell Berry is still not going to buy a computer" (2019) <https://www.csmonitor.com/Technology/2019/0418/Why-Wendell-Berry-is-still-not-going-to-buy-a-computer https://www.csmonitor.com/Technology/2019/0418/Why-Wendell-B...> (From an earlier HN discussion, thanks Jtsummers for linking: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43883115 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43883115>.)
- greenie_beans 2y agoi worked at a well known bookstore and the owner invited him to a reading, but he turned down with a hand written letter basically saying: "your bookstore seems nice but i never leave my farm and don't want to for a reading"
- gizajob 2y agoWhere do I buy a wife to do my typing and grammar checking?
- harvey9 2y agoYou can buy one online. But you'll need a wife to do that for you of course.
- Jordan_Pelt 2y ago"My wife types my work..." Those five words render the entire essay meaningless.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Skunkleton 2y agoI get your point, but good luck with that. Most (every?) influential figure had has something problematic about their person. If you can't see the good through the bad, then you will quickly find yourself with nothing.
- SoftTalker 2y agoShocking that a wife might willingly want to help her husband with something important to him.
- Jordan_Pelt 2y agoI'm sure she does, but that's beside the point. Why should we pay any attention to the opinions of a person on replacing something he doesn't use with something else he won't use. He may as well say that he won't buy a snowblower because his groundskeeper uses a shovel and does just fine.
- magneticnorth 2y agoI think you'll appreciate the first response in the "Letters" section - the one that starts off with "Wendell Berry provides writers enslaved by the computer with a handy alternative: Wife - a low-tech energy-saving device." It got a chuckle out of me, for sure.
- greenie_beans 2y agoi been filling my head with computers knowledge i hope to delete
- erehweb 2y agoHarper's (where the article was originally published) requires you to submit by snail-mail, but many places require email submissions. Guessing that computers won partly because they are a lot more convenient for publishers - if you're typing something up then the publisher has to type it again on their end.
- YeGoblynQueenne 2y agoIn a cruel twist of fate most people today neither own, nor use a computer, not in the sense used in the essay. They instead use their phones to do a very restricted sub-set of things they could do on a computer and in a very limited manner. I guess the forward-looking tech nerds of the '80s, the tip of the spear of the information revolution, must now be crying in their corn flakes with the irony of it all. Nowadays only nerds (really) use computers. P.S. Obviously I own computers. I have four laptops and a bunch of small-form clamshells left over from a period when I collected them semi-enthusiastically (including a Viliv, a Zaurus and a Ben Nanonote). I recently went on the market to see if there are any new ones around and ended up buying two, which I shall not advertise. I'm a victim of tech advertisement.
- qiine 2y agoits impressive how persieved convenience trumps all when it comes to mass adoption
- aleph_minus_one 2y agoThere exist lots of definitions of "convenience". I, for example, find it deeply inconvenient to be have a device with me that basically spies on me all the time.
- SoftTalker 2y agoWhem it comes to phones and social media apps, it's not people using computers but the other way around.
- demaga 2y agoThis sounds smart and could 100% be something I would say too, but it is not true at all. People benefit greatly from phones (and in some sense, social media). The way to test it is to give up phones for some time. I spent 3 months without smart phone, and it was inconvenient as hell. Not having maps, calculator, or wikipedia at all times sucks. So almost everyone I know definitely does use computers, in all meanings.
- reilly3000 2y agoThis article makes me consider how the medium of production affects the final content. There is a certain cost of writing a sentence on paper, typewriter, computer, and phone. The higher the cost of forming words, the more cognition it invites. The greater the cost of revision (especially with typewriters), the more likely one tends towards precision. It leads me towards a belief that better writing must start on paper. For my ADHD brain, handwriting is difficult. As I progress through an idea I can watch my handwriting degrade into illegibility and the marginalia increase markedly. Crafting a cogent essay isn’t easy in any medium, but I seem to get along ok with a Doc these days. Perhaps there is something meaningful in the act of preparing a handwritten essay for broader publication that refines the work more critically than if it were ready to distribute instantly. At the risk of being too romantic it seems like handwriting may take on the quality of hand-thrown pottery, imbued with some spirit that is void in mass production. As I peck this comment out with my thumbs I wonder how that constraint impacts the words that reach you. Next time I’ll write it on a legal pad first, but maybe you’ll not hear from me in a while.
- spongebobstoes 2y agoDoes this theory mean that phones invite more cognition when writing than laptops or desktop do? I can type significantly faster on a computer than on a phone, and revisions are easier too. I think this is just romanticizing the past.
- wjnc 2y agoAs a child of a scientist and teacher from the ‘40s and ‘50s I think there is some romanticism in your opinion. Can’t argue with your personal situation, but I know for a fact that writing notes, copywriting, stenciling, multiplying and distributing were all tasks my parents were very happy to see replaced by technology during their careers. They were early adopters of digital typewriters, pc’s, word processors and the internet and otherwise very much not technically inclined. Those were mostly chores. (I agree with your point, as an economist ;), that the average value of a word is higher when the cost are higher.) The one thing my mom did teach me very early was a zettelkasten-like system. Never appreciated that trial (unsuccessful, alas) enough until I read about zettelkasten.
- 2y ago
- waynenilsen 2y agoAlso potentially interesting thoughts along a similar line https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/unabomber/manifesto.text.htm https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/unab...
- nuancebydefault 2y agoWriting with pencil on paper is very very slow and takes much more space per letter. If you write a lot, chances are high of developing RSI. I'm not even thinking about editing. I don't see how the author advocates 'the tool should be better than the one it replaces' and then chooses not to buy a computer. I got my Atari ST around '87 and i loved it.
- yuhong 2y agoFor a long time using a computer means dealing with spinning rust, and while SSDs exist nowadays...
- KingOfCoders 2y ago"I'm not going to buy a computer, because I have a wife, and I bought her a typewriter, and doing all the tedious work, and she's fine."
- wolvesechoes 2y agoTrue chad
- dredmorbius 2y agoFor those who find the notion of rejecting a computer in favour of a typewriter (or even the typewriter-spouse combo set), maybe pitch the essay in terms of current consumer options, such as WiFi-enabled, Internet-connected refrigerators, cookers, clothes-washers, driers, and the like. Or the trajectory of always-connected devices such as Nest thermostats (first editions now EoL'd and abandonware), Ring doorbells (part of state surveillance), or the question of mobile and/or smartphones by students in schools. Berry's arguments and philosophy can be translated to other domains. I'd also strongly suggest you consider that what he was writing about were computers in 1987. The IBM PS/2 was released that year, and featured Intel processors (8086, 80286, or 80386, depending on the model), 512KiB to 64MiB RAM (most shipped with 512KiB -- 4MiB AFAIU), a floppy drive if you were lucky (720 KiB to 1.4 MiB), hard drives were optional, and ranged from about 20 MiB to 400 MiB (again, mostly smaller). There was no networking absent a very rare modem, to which there were few options to connect to, and no public Internet access. Printing was dot-matrix or daisy-wheel. Displays were typically 640x480 pixels, at 256 colours of any (though monochrome displays were common as well). Even the "cruel twist of fate" pseudo-computers most people carry today (<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43887109 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43887109>) have vastly greater raw performance and interactivity options. They definitely have their negatives, and I'm not convinced of their net usefulness. But used with intention they can in fact be quite useful. (The fact that marketing and design teams deploy billions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of engineers to frustrate such intentional use is a major argument against such devices, of course.) I'm cognisant and sympathetic to Berry's arguments, but don't share his outright rejection of much technology, and find several of his arguments and principles unconvincing (see earlier comments in this thread for examples). But even as someone who finds computers generally useful now, I didn't find it persuasive to purchase one of my own until the latter half of the 1990s, and even then what was available as a mid-market personal system was just teetering on the threshold of usability. I'll also note that Berry's argument wasn't that the computers of his time simply weren't very useful. His case is far more fundamental than that. But the combined case would be pretty persuasive, and was: computer owners in 1987 were the overwhelming minority even within quite wealthy nations. And that wouldn't change for at least another decade.