7 ms·
“An independent journalist” who won't remain nameless
- ty6853 2y agoAt $100k / resettlement it might be the world's cheapest citizenship by investment program. The closest I can think of is the Comoros program which I believe Saudi or another Arab country used to get rid of a bunch of immigrants.
- salomonk_mur 2y agoYou don't get citizenship. Just jail time.
- rurban 2y agoEsp. without due process. "A judge ordered his release". Which triggered Trump to send him to Guantanamo 2.0 Because who is some rogue judge vs the executive.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xyst 2y agoIt shocks me to this day that news articles and journalists barely cite their sources. The best I have seen is shitty hyperlinked sources l, which are subject to link rot over time. Thus losing the context/source if underlying paper goes under or company decides to overhaul content system. What’s the point of learning APA or MLA citation in high school and college but journalists don’t even bother with it? Insane to me. Would address the complaints of the author _and_ help readers "trust but verify" the claims. Of course, some sources can’t be cited properly (ie, "source close to inner circle of the family") but at least we can discern whether "journalist" did their DD or copied the source from another journalist (or just pulled it out of their ass)
- carlosjobim 2y agoOpen source journalism is the only kind of open source I can stand behind. Completely. Anything else isn't really journalism.
- kurthr 2y agoUm, No True Journalist?
- carlosjobim 2y agoJornalists who hide their sources are usually also manipulated by those sources. How do you make sure as a journalist to get access to high ranking sources within the powers that be? You write the stories they want, or they're not talking to you anymore. Every journalist will experience politicians and other powerful people wanting to tell them things "off the record". If they enter into those kind of agreements they are also betraying their profession and their audience.
- orev 2y ago> are usually also manipulated by those sources Citation needed.
- reaperducer 2y agoAgreed. This person has never been a journalist. / Former journalist
- carlosjobim 2y agoWhy are you asking questions whose answers you are not capable of understanding? An anonymous source has the power to decide what information she lets the journalist have, and thus she controls the exchange. If the journalist does something to displease the source, then the journalist is cut off from the information.
- globalnode 2y agoIsn't it for journalists' protection that they try to remain semi anonymous or at least out of the limelight? You just have to look at Assange for an example of what happens when you try to become a well known person representing certain topics.
- mooreds 2y agoIn this case, the journalist wants credit ("first reported by") from other news organizations for doing the reporting work first. She has a public blog, I don't think she's worried about being known. It's different than a journalist doing work where their identity could be problematic.
- globalnode 2y agoGood point. I was stuck thinking about it in only one way.
- simonw 2y agoThe vast majority of journalists are proud to put their name to their reporting. Cases where a journalist tries to stay semi-anonymous are rare, outside of reporting on despotic regimes, organized crime or other scenarios where there is a legitimate high-risk safety threat.
- globalnode 2y agoYep its true, those cases that I was thinking about would likely be rare.
- immibis 2y agoBut she is reporting on a despotic regime.
- mullingitover 2y agoIt's funny that universities will throw you out immediately for plagiarism (some will throw you out if you're aware of it but don't report it), but major publications will do it (this isn't the same as scholastic plagiarism, but it's the journalistic equivalent) out in the open and shamelessly with no repercussions.
- robocat 2y ago> throw you out immediately for plagiarism Only by twisting the meaning of plagiarism to be defined as word-for-word. Universities intensively train students to accept plagiarism so long as the copy is sufficiently reworded (and hopefully referenced). That sick and pointless system is ironically being exposed by student usage of LLMs.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 2y agoIt is indeed worthwhile to point out that universities care less about the actual idea of taking someone else’s work, but rather more about the idea of doing so without credit. In the charitable sense, this is what science is built on. In the less charitable sense, this is what science is built on
- TheCowboy 2y ago> (and hopefully referenced) If it's cited, it's usually by definition not plagiarism. Omitting the reference is passing the work off as your own, but providing that information is giving credit to where it is due.
- jsmith45 2y agoThat can vary. A fair number of institutions would consider an undergrad paper that consisted mostly of cited quotations, with only a small amount of original analysis and conclusion drawing to be a form of plagiarism, even while a similar paper that paraphrases many of the cited works might be more acceptable, especially if the paraphrasing was adding value, like standardizing equivalent terminology between the sources (ideally including footnotes about what each author originally called each concept). Other institutions do hold more of a view that plagiarism is not possible with credit, but they will then consider the first mentioned paper as some other form of academic violation. Even the narrow definition institutions don't view plagiarism purely as misrepresenting sources of ideas as yourself, or self-plagiarism would not be a thing. It ends up as something more like: passing off original ideas from another work as having originated in this current work.
- emmelaich 2y agoSite seems to be down or overloaded so here's an archive link: https://archive.is/ziyRe https://archive.is/ziyRe
- compuser0503 2y agoI can clearly understand why this journalist is mad - she broke the story but she isn't getting the benefits (readership, money) from it. That would feel unfair for sure. But the complaint that bigger outlets didn't immediately follow her story by crediting her seems like an understandable situation from the other outlets' point of view. Who will take the heat if it's wrong? A popular outlet that runs with it will get shit on if it's wrong, even if it's citing the independent journalist as the source (in a way they won't if they were just following another popular outlet). So these outlets need to either 1) verify it on their own, or 2) cite another popular outlet. It'd still be courteous to name the original reporter, but until she's built enough clout and reputation to stand on her own as a credible source, it seems structural that this will keep happening.
- arrosenberg 2y agoIt’s not understandable, it’s abusive. These large outlets have the resource to both verify, credit the original work, and deal with the fallout. That they choose not to comes from avarice that should be regulated or litigable.
- djoldman 2y agoThe news industry makes a lot of sense when viewed as a category of entertainment. Reporters write stories and people read them to be entertained. Newspapers make money when more people read the stories. No wonder that newspapers don't cite others... That's just an advertisement for their competitor. This isn't the only way to view the news industry but it certainly explains a lot.
- dylan604 2y agoModern news sites refer to other new sites frequently. "as reported by _____" is seen frequently. links to other sites' Twitt..er, X feeds are also common.
- padolsey 2y ago> That's just an advertisement for their competitor. I think the simpler explanation is just laziness and no positive incentive or obligation, as opposed to proactive competitive practices..
- permo-w 2y agonewspapers have semi-regularly updated style guides. I don't see how its much of a stretch that some would decide to include this. let's remember who we're talking about here
- marcus_holmes 2y agoThere's also a professional divide between "journalists" and "bloggers" [0]. If anyone can start their own website and write stuff, without getting any kind of qualification or accreditation, and without following any editorial policy or maintaining any kind of journalistic integrity, and still get credited with a story, then journalism itself has an identity crisis. Meanwhile, (some) journalists at (some) news organisations are being forced to write stories that have no integrity under an editorial policy that is designed to promote a partisan point of view. There's no working business model for real investigative journalism, but our democratic systems need real investigative journalism in order to function properly and hold politicians to account. Nothing else does. Independent journalists can make this happen, but how do we recognise a "real" independent journalist doing real investigative journalism from an activist blogger with an axe to grind? [0] I'm not saying that the author is not a journalist, or inferring that they're a blogger.
- lovelysoni03 2y ago[flagged]
- ricksunny 2y agoI love the quote of one of the comments, the odd mix of wistful promise yet shuddering, which sent me down a context-sourcing rabbit hole: Quote: This is very much a "the new world struggles to be born, now is the time of monsters" moment, but you are weathering it as well as anyone I've seen. (Commenter L.O.)
- Max-Ganz-II 2y agoShe's on BlueSky, which is where I came to know of her. She has been essential to keeping up to date with developments in the USA regarding Donald. I subscribed to her newsletter last month. It seems to me mainstream media doesn't really cut the mustard. I get most of my information these days from specialist blogs, run by individuals.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoIt's a tricky one; one wants to trust the media because they should have integrity and checks and balances and the like - which you don't know if unafilliated independent bloggers have. But the bloggers are also great, but you need to do some more homework to decide if they are trustworthy - no editorial team, no journalistic ethical codes (if those actually exist), etc. The other factor is that a lot of the conspiracy thinkers based their beliefs on blogs or the equivalent thereof (FB posts, youtube videos, etc), stuff you wouldn't see in the mainstream media - because it's nonsense, but the fact the mainstream media doesn't cover it actually draws the attention to the conspiracy bloggers.
- davidsainez 2y agoDirect link to her profile: https://bsky.app/profile/marisakabas.bsky.social https://bsky.app/profile/marisakabas.bsky.social
- BoingBoomTschak 2y ago[flagged]
- sam345 2y agoAny type of journalism that actually talks to people and gets the facts straight is rare these days. Most news reports and journalism these days just repeat hearsay. You have to read print sources that actually make money off this stuff through paid subscriptions such as the New York times or the Wall Street journal. And even then you have to wade through the poor reporting and agenda driven journalism. Having said that I'm not sure if the author of this piece could be called a journalist except in her own world, her articles are rife with presumption and opinion which is fine but it's not factual journalism it's writing with an overt agenda to persuade to her political viewpoint. Can we just have a required statement on every news source stating what its overall values and political agenda are? Regulators love disclosures why not a viewpoint disclosure? You could argue it's unnecessary but you have too many news sources running around claiming they are objective. Witness the recent PBS executives sounding shocked they are being accused of political bias.