3 ms·
I can already see CRISPR Bacon™ in our future.
by andsoitis 2y ago
I can already see CRISPR Bacon™ in our future.
- janice1999 2y agoI get it's a joke, but this won't be advertised to consumers. The current US administration (and previous ones to a lesser extent) oppose food labeling regulations. It's one of the main "non-tariff trade barriers" they complain about to the EU.
- barbazoo 2y agoWhat’s the idea behind it? Just anti consumer or is there a reasonable angle?
- conception 2y agoEats into profits and increases accountability.
- justin66 2y agoI believe they prefer the term “pro-business.”
- estebank 2y agoIf someone doesn't care one way or another, the label is useless. If someone has a positive opinion, the label helps the consumer seek it out. If someone has a negative opinion, the label helps the consumer avoid the product. If they fight against labeling it is because they consider that the third group is or can become bigger than the second.
- ryandrake 2y agoI mean, that's so vague that it can be said about anything: Some people think X is positive and will buy the product and some people think X is negative and won't buy the product. Pretty obvious. The purpose of food labels is to increase safety, transparency and honesty around the contents of food. Companies who oppose safety, transparency or honesty and/or produce products with questionable contents will oppose labels and companies who support safety, transparency and honesty will support them. I don't know many end-consumers who oppose labels themselves. But they will oppose products that contain questionable ingredients, so transparency is bad for companies that produce those products.
- tbrownaw 2y ago> and companies who support safety, transparency and honesty will support them. Not quite. Companies who can use the official labels to back up their own advertising campaigns will support them. (I know people who think that having a label for something is evidence of that thing being good or bad. No, it's evidence that someone thought that expending the effort to convince the government to have that label would have a positive return.) Companies with more ability to amortize regulatory overhead (relative to their competitors) will support them, because for then that overhead is itself a competitive advantage.
- johnny22 2y agolike gluten free on corn chips
- ThunderSizzle 2y ago> The purpose of food labels is to increase safety, transparency and honesty around the contents of food. USDA Organic label is rampant with fraud, and just having thr USDA label on it isn't a guarantee of trust. Similarly, the AHA endorsing oils blatantly bad for the heart is also similar example how labeling doesn't promote trust necessarily. Labels can and do lie, quite often even.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoI just want the label to tell me what's in the product. I can then make my own decision as to whether I think that's healthy or not.
- AStonesThrow 2y ago> just want the label to tell me what's in the product You will never, ever get that. It's simply impossible. Label games are the biggest legal tug-of-war between consumers, regulators, vendors, and the industries. When I began reading about labeling and its regulation, and all the bullshit tricks that are played to "stay compliant" but also lie out their asses to the consumer, and hide everything from us, I concluded that there is no way to truly read a label properly. It basically comes down to a question of whether you trust this vendor or provider to give you a quality product. If you do not trust, then do not purchase. If they play games and lose trust, then do not purchase. Once you have a decent-sized blacklist, then there is no reason not to patronize those survivors.
- tbrownaw 2y agoThe generic arguments against that sort of thing are distortion when the category boundaries are a bit off from where they should be, and overhead where any time you do anything there's extra compliance paperwork and delays. Overhead in particular can be rather stifling. For example environmental reviews for large projects have reached a "the process is the punishment" level of overhead.
- jfengel 2y agoThe EU already refuses to import American chicken (over sanitary practices) and has limitations on beef (over hormones). They'll ban American pork entirely if we can't guarantee that the GMO pork are excluded.
- johnohara 2y agoAre you declaring first use?
- theGeatZhopa 2y agoThe new job at McDonald's: CRISPRer - your one job is to take the bacon and grill it crispy.
- charliebwrites 2y agoI’d flip it: If I ran a bacon company and I didn’t have CRISPR pigs I’d advertise in large red print “CRISPR Free” Or “Non-genetically modified” People are afraid of lab grown meat already, they’ll be terrified of CRISPR meat My competition won’t be able to advertise the same
- nothercastle 2y agoIf this becomes common it will be illegal to label food as gmo free
- aaronbaugher 2y agoThat's possible. I don't know the current status of it, but in the 90s the FDA had ruled that dairy farms which didn't inject their cows with supplemental bovine growth hormone (BST) couldn't put that on the label. Their argument was that putting "BST-free" on a label suggested that BST might make the milk less healthy in some way, and the FDA had ruled that it didn't, so you weren't allowed to market your milk in a way that could give that impression. Kind of bizarre, considering that food advertising routinely suggests all sorts of good or bad things about products, like the idea that if you drink a certain brand of beer or drive a certain model of car you will be surrounded by hot models. But there's long been a revolving door between Big Ag and departments like the FDA and USDA, so not exactly surprising that the FDA would go to bat for a Big Ag Pharma product.
- Aloisius 2y agoSure. And I'd advertise in large print, "PRRS Virus Free" Considering the prevalence of PRRSV, it would be difficult for farms with non-CRISPRed pigs to say the same. Scare tactics can work both ways here.
- smallnix 2y agoFarms without immune pigs can still claim it. Do some sampling tests, culling etc and call the product "virus free". But calling modified pigs not modified is tougher, I think.