6 ms·
New material gives copper superalloy-like strength
- dcl 2y agoRearden metal...?
- sanex 2y agoNot as strong as steel, real or imaginary.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoThat's a copper-iron alloy.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mjevans 2y agoBackup link https://web.archive.org/web/20250415035227/https://news.lehigh.edu/new-material-gives-copper-superalloy-like-strength-0 https://web.archive.org/web/20250415035227/https://news.lehi... """ Unlike typical grain boundaries that migrate over time at high temperatures, this complexion acts as a structural stabilizer, maintaining the nanocrystalline structure, preventing grain growth and dramatically improving high-temperature performance. The alloy holds its shape under extreme, long-term thermal exposure and mechanical stress, resisting deformation even near its melting point, noted Patrick Cantwell, a research scientist at Lehigh University and co-author of the study. """ This sounds exotic, but possibly better performing in some use cases?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- WrongOnInternet 2y agoI'm tired of articles with titles like "X makes Y bigger/faster/stronger," then never giving an answer to the obvious question: "How much?" This article is happy to tell you it costs $25M to develop , how many hours the annealed the metal, the patent numbers, the years the researchers got their degrees, but never once gives a single number related to the materials performance. Maybe its 0.1% better, maybe its 1000% better. I guess its not important.
- shakna 2y agoThere's a few numbers in the Science article, and they do actually link to it, unlike some. [0 And the intro numbers are... Exciting. > This core-shell structure neither dissolves nor coarsens at temperatures of up to 800°C while also causing the yielding strength to be in excess of 1 gigapascal. [0] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adr0299 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adr0299
- nine_k 2y agoIn other words, it makes the copper allow much stronger than mild steels, like the stainless steels, and on par with strong (but by far not the strongest) steel alloys. Imagine cutting stainless steel with a copper-based blade, and not the other way around.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- A_D_E_P_T 2y agoOkay, this is cool. It's a copper-tantalum-lithium alloy: 96.5% Cu, 3% Ta, 0.5% Li. Tantalum isn't soluble in copper and doesn't form any intermetallic compounds, so under normal circumstances you'd get something like a metal matrix composite -- pure tantalum particles dispersed in a copper matrix. Add lithium, though, and the intermetallic Cu3Li forms, and tantalum is apparently very attracted to this stuff, so you end up with Cu3Li particles with Ta shells in that copper matrix. Yield Strength = ~1000MPa, so it's genuinely on par with high-temp nickel superalloys, though somewhat weaker than the cobalt-base ones, and far weaker than the best steels. Interestingly, it's actually a little bit weaker than the copper-beryllium alloy C17200. (YS: ~1200-1300 MPa.) But CuBe is very expensive, not very ductile, and potentially hazardous. Tantalum, though expensive, is still 10x cheaper than beryllium. Depending on its thermal and electrical properties, and on its ease of manufacture, this could be a very versatile material, and may replace nickel/cobalt alloys in certain applications.
- nine_k 2y agoTo put this into perspective: nickel is approximately 2x as expensive as copper, and cobalt is 5-6 times as expensive, and the major cobalt producers are all politically problematic (DR Congo, China, Russia).
- sandworm101 2y agoIn the use cases imagined for this material, the cost of the base metals is basically irrelevant. Something like a jet turbine blade might have maybe 10$ worth of material, but after machining and a hundred other steps is worth 100x that ammount. A heatshield for a hypersonic missile? Maybe a kilo of copper, but perhaps a 1m+ purchase price
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nine_k 2y agoMore affordable price seriously widens the range of applications, and thus the total addressable market. Not using hazardous substances like berillium additionally helps.
- wpollock 2y agoCould this material be a cost-effective replacement for stainless steel? I'm thinking of applications where the antimicrobial properties of copper would be beneficial.
- coder543 2y agoNope... this stuff is 96.5% copper, and copper is ~3x as expensive as stainless steel. Even if tantalum and lithium were free, it would be substantially more expensive. Tantalum is not free, though. It's a very expensive material at about 100x the cost per kg relative to stainless steel, so it nearly doubles the cost of the raw material inputs by itself with its 3% contribution. The process of making this alloy is also likely to be expensive. I'm also not sure how much being in an alloy would impact the antimicrobial effects of copper.
- kragen 2y agoYou're right about the cost angle, though it might be cheaper than stellite, inconel, monel, that kind of thing. Generally copper does retain its antibacterial properties in alloys where it's a high proportion of the alloy, like this one.
- thehappypm 2y agoWell, this could dramatically increase the demand for tantalum, which (econ 101) could dramatically increase the supply over time? Is tantalum in much demand today?
- coder543 2y agoHuge demand for copper hasn’t brought its price down to the price of stainless steel, has it? Most definitely not, so it seems like Econ 101 was incomplete. Not all goods are perfectly elastic. Inelastic goods do not get cheaper with more demand. Tantalum is in demand today, yes. Tantalum capacitors are a well known application, but it is used in all sorts of things. My point was that even if tantalum were free, a material that is 96.5% copper is still not going to be significantly cheaper than copper, which I think is a pretty self-evident outcome.
- lutusp 2y agoLegitimate content aside, this article is a perfect example of modern public relations writing, of flash over substance. Each paragraph is larded with PR buzzwords like "breakthrough," "cutting-edge," "groundbreaking," etc. to the degree that the topic is nearly lost in the lexical shrubbery. And it's clear the article's author doesn't understand scientific writing. Each participant is identified as having a PhD (when true), contrary to accepted academic practice. Imagine a scientific article by Albert Einstein, tagged with "PhD" -- except that in 1905, any relevance aside, Einstein didn't have one. My point is that the participants' academic degrees are irrelevant to the science. As Richard Feynman said, "Science is the organized skepticism in the reliability of expert opinion". Oh -- wait -- did I mention that Feynman had a PhD? My favorite phrase from an article that tries to raise empty PR prose to an art form: "... Lehigh is the only university in the Lehigh Valley to have this designation ..." Noted. But this is like saying, "We're tops in our ZIP code!"
- syllogistic 2y agogood take overall, though the last point is forgiven as a subtle dig at lafayette
- kragen 2y agoRearden metal heat exchangers, eh?
- fnord77 2y agowill it make a good bicycle frame?
- eCa 2y agoThey mention both high temperature durability and conductivity as positives. Not really the most important qualities in a bike frame to be fair. I doubt it beats aluminium in cost, so it would need to significantly beat carbon in performance to make it worthwhile.
- xyst 2y agoIt would be a very expensive bicycle frame. That is for 100% certain ;)
- fc417fc802 2y agoWell it's on par with stainless steel strength wise while being both more expensive and heaver. Presumably also much more prone to corrosion.
- Beretta_Vexee 2y agoFor a bicycle frame, we want an alloy that is relatively light and easy to weld. At no point is weldability considered, and it is not impossible that this alloy welds very poorly (losing its properties in the area thermally affected by welding, requires a very narrow energy range to weld properly). The advantages of this alloy do not make it a better choice than special steels or titanium alloys when it comes to metallic materials. There are few cyclists on Venus.
- Maken 2y agoIf you don't mind it being heavier than a steel frame.
- Qwertious 2y agoNo, copper is stupidly expensive and steel/aluminium/magnesium are already very competitive. Also, wood is technically an option. It might compete with titanium frames (or carbon fiber frames) perhaps, but that's a niche market and I doubt it.
- pfdietz 2y agoThis could be useful in heat exchangers and rocket engine thrust chambers. I imagine this has very high thermal conductivity compared to steels. The thermal conductivity of copper is about 20x that of stainless steel. So, you can make the walls of the passages an order of magnitude thicker, increasing their strength proportionally.
- jbay808 2y agoThis might be a great alternative to beryllium copper for the spring contact element in high-current electrical connectors.
- xyst 2y agoBesides space and ~~efficient killing/murdering~~ military industries, where would this “superalloy-like” strength be useful in? Nuclear plants? Maybe useful in supercomputing/quantum computing?
- topspin 2y agoIt's difficult to predict. High performance heat exchangers are an obvious application, but the potential is great for many other things. "Nuclear plants?" Sure. One of the most challenging problems in a PWRs is heat exchange; the so called "steam generators" that circulate primary and secondary water, for instance. They're huge, expensive heat exchangers and their primary failure mode is cracking. A durable, high temperature, high thermal conductivity copper based alloy goes directly to this. Better thermal conductivity could make these devices substantially smaller, reducing costs in all sorts of way, or enable novel designs.
- kragen 2y agoIt still might be prone to fatigue cracks.
- topspin 2y agoYep. Cracking is a subtle process. This new material and the new designs based on it will be either better or worse than the nickel alloys that have been used, but only time will tell. At least an opportunity exists for improvement now.
- Beretta_Vexee 2y agoPressurised water reactors use Inconel tubes. Inconel 600 alloys are high-chromium nickel alloys for steam exchange tubes that are highly resistant to various forms of corrosion (capable of withstanding to 30 years in water with boric acid and 300°C+). The design of these alloys and exchangers is extremely complex and benefits from several thousand years of operational experience. This applies to the alloys themselves, their heat treatment, shaping, interaction with other materials, ageing, etc. It is highly unlikely that these alloys will be abandoned in the next 20-30 years.
- chuzz 2y agowould this be useful for better power lines? assuming electrical conductivity is about the same, as implied by the article
- philipkglass 2y agoPlain copper is already too expensive for power lines, and this alloy is more expensive than copper alone. Transmission and distribution lines are typically made with aluminum conductors layered over a steel core for mechanical strength: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium-conductor_steel-reinforced_cable https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium-conductor_steel-rein... Aluminum is a worse conductor than copper on a volumetric basis but a better conductor on a mass basis, which is important for overhead lines supporting their own weight against gravity. It also costs significantly less than copper.
- chuzz 2y agoMy point was that maybe the improved mechanical performance would help with their own weight. I concede that a more expensive, heavier overhead line that could hang for longer distances does not sound good unless costs are dominated by tower construction
- gregdetre 2y ago[flagged]
- schlegelt1 2y ago[dead]
- convivialdingo 2y agoWonder if this could work for li-ion batteries as a current collector? You could potentially lower charging times and handle higher power applications and higher temperature ranges.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoIt seems copper is often found with admixtures of arsenic, nickel, mercury, antimony, bismuth, cadmium, zinc, gold, silver, ... I was wondering if some naturally occurring copper ores could give a hardness advantage over pure copper, before the true copper-tin Bronze Age kicked off.