6 ms·
First Successful Lightning Triggering and Guiding Using a Drone
- dolphin0 2y agoNext step, use the energy?
- ahahahahah 2y agoYes, thanks for repeating the content from the article. "In addition, we aim to not only trigger and control lightning, but also to harness its energy. Future efforts will focus on developing technologies for capturing and storing lightning energy for potential use (Figure 7)."
- dinkblam 2y agoisn't conventional wisdom that this is "impossible" because you cannot charge batteries that fast?
- fudged71 2y agoLike most things, you’d probably end up heating water somehow and using that energy.
- borski 2y agoIf the energy is going into batteries. It doesn’t necessarily have to. Also, technology continues to improve, and this isn’t a “next year” thing.
- schoen 2y agoMaybe a bank of (extremely) huge capacitors that get charged up very quickly, and are then connected to a battery pack to charge it more slowly? Keeping control of those charges seems like a huge challenge, as they literally contain the electrical energy of a lightning bolt. I guess for physically plausible capacitors you'd also need to step the voltage way down (by six or eight orders of magnitude!?) before it reaches the capacitors. Are there physically-plausible transformers or other devices that could do that? Or something that somehow captures the lightning as (lots and lots of) mechanical or thermal energy and then gradually converts that back into electricity?
- lud_lite 2y agoStick the caps in series?
- myrmidon 2y agoThis is never going to be economical. Lightning is ~5GJ per strike. That means you'd need ~4 lighning strikes per hour just to keep up with a single large offshore wind turbine (15MW with 40% capacity factor). There is also no realistic way to scale the whole thing up to significant levels of power; with the wind turbines, you just build several hundred to get into the GW range. There's simply not enough lighning to achieve that. And the whole power buffering infrastructure that you would need would be an underutilized waste of (expensive) components. There's never been any serious attempt at harvesting lightning at scale because a single glance at the numbers reveals how (economically) pointless an exercise it is.
- dhagberg 2y agoWow, getting a drone to survive the massive electromagnetic fields (and plasma!) around lightning strikes is quite an accomplishment. Prior art in the area used rockets trailing a similar light wire to trigger lightning - used by Dr Uman's team at University of Florida (https://ufdc.ufl.edu/UFE0047331/00001 https://ufdc.ufl.edu/UFE0047331/00001).
- kjkjadksj 2y agoAnd the prior art before that involved a kite and a key
- aaron695 2y agoRockets triggering lighting with wire has been since the late 50's (M. M. Newman), what's cool about the drone is you can send back data before the strike. Obviously a kite or aerostat would work as well. I'm sure someone in the 90's was using rockets without wires, the exhaust from the rocket made the trail. I cannot source it. These guys charging cars shows they are not really serious, but a lot of forest fires are lightning, it's a worthy thing to control if possible.
- dotancohen 2y ago> I'm sure someone in the 90's was using rockets without wires, the exhaust from the rocket made the trail. I cannot source it. Apollo 12, in November or December 1969, was struck by lightning due to the exhaust.
- Someone 2y ago> I'm sure someone in the 90's was using rockets without wires, the exhaust from the rocket made the trail. I cannot source it. https://bigthink.com/hard-science/rocket-guided-lightning/ https://bigthink.com/hard-science/rocket-guided-lightning/: “A patented new rocket design eschews the copper wire and chemically creates the lightning path. The rocket fuel is doped with small amounts of salt. Sodium chloride, calcium chloride, or cesium chloride is pulled through the motor, heated, and broken into charged ion components spewed out in the exhaust. The positively charged Cs, Ca, or Na atoms cool and bond with water molecules in the air, forming saltwater droplets. These droplets are far more electrically conductive than freshwater droplets, leaving a high-conductivity trail in the rocket’s wake.” Patent link (https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/af/69/e2/0303f8671eead7/US6597559.pdf https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/af/69/e2/0303f86...) says it was filed in 2001, however, not the ‘90s.
- dole 2y agoThis [1] article claims that the electricity from 115 strikes could power the entire US grid for a year, but it's surely napkin math. Awesome tech, though! [1] https://www.treehugger.com/how-much-energy-is-in-lightning-8733935 https://www.treehugger.com/how-much-energy-is-in-lightning-8...
- xnx 2y agoThat article seems very very wrong. I think they missed the difference between GW and GWh. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fs28lEq9smw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fs28lEq9smw
- npunt 2y agoHah quite the oversight! To put a spin on an old saying, a little math is a dangerous thing.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- janalsncm 2y agoApparently a single lightning strike contains the equivalent of about 40 gallons of gasoline. It’s very powerful but not that significant on the scale of a whole city. In fact a quick back of the napkin math suggests it would only power a city of a million people for half a second. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvesting_lightning_energy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvesting_lightning_energy
- FlyingSnake 2y agoI wonder if we managed to harness and store this electricity from the lightning into some kind of large battery. If a drone can successfully fly and connect with the lighting, this seems like a possibility. Edit: I read past the line where they mentioned this was in the plans.
- iugtmkbdfil834 2y agoSo.. how long do we have before situational personal lightning bolt is a thing?
- Noumenon72 2y agoApparently they already have the ability to create lightning bolts in the lab for testing. Maybe they can license that. > we conducted artificial lightning tests on drones equipped with the lightning protection cage. The results showed that the system withstood artificial strikes of up to 150 kA—five times greater than the average natural lightning strike—without any malfunction or damage, covering over 98% of naturally occurring lightning conditions.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 00N8 2y agoThe future is now: Check out Lightning On Demand, https://lod.org/ https://lod.org/ (Tesla tower approach & scientific motivations) & https://youtu.be/lix-vr_AF38?si=w78LyF9tlxGJB8Ay https://youtu.be/lix-vr_AF38?si=w78LyF9tlxGJB8Ay (capacitor driven Lorentz plasma cannon demo)
- barbazoo 2y ago[dead]
- walrus01 2y agoThat's a freefly Alta X in the photos which is a $20k drone commonly used in cinematography.
- _benj 2y agoThat is impressive, specially the drone surviving! I expect something along the lines of disposable drones, which would like still be cost effective at saving 100-200b yen a year! It’ll be fascinating seeing this deployed!
- rkagerer 2y agoThis is really cool, but I'm super skeptical of their proposed use case for protecting cities. Aren't lightning conditions often preceded by strong winds and poor weather conditions? Not a great time to be flying drones. And the approach seems more complicated than simply installing lightning rods. I'd sooner envision people using the technique to get a kick out of throwing lightning around like they're Zeus.
- bestouff 2y agoAFAIK the electric buildup starts even before the meteorological shenanigans.
- prawn 2y agoI've flown my Mavics in rain and strong wind before - certainly stronger than anything I'd associate with lightning. Most of the lightning storms I've seen haven't been especially windy, but it might vary elsewhere. And that's a consumer drone with negligible weatherproofing. I assume if there's a business case, they'll eventually automate this with drone swarms that wait in cabinets on building rooftops.
- binary132 2y agoFWIW, where I live there are often intense thunderstorms during the spring and summer, and they are usually accompanied by windstorms, sometimes generating tornadoes.
- bamboozled 2y agoI've been in Tokyo in some massive storms (NTT is a Japanese company), the wind and rain is absolutely insane sometimes. Kind of like a 30 minute hurricane.
- wodenokoto 2y agoMy scepticism was more like “don’t cities already have lightning rods?”
- mbreese 2y ago> Aren't lightning conditions often preceded by strong winds and poor weather conditions? Not a great time to be flying drones. Well, the drone would be tethered by the ground attached wire, so it might not need to be that controllable. Elevation is the main concern, so as long as it can reach the right altitude, the tether could keep it reasonably in the right area.
- anonymousiam 2y agoThe lightning "strike" mentioned in the article was probably not a direct hit. Nothing can really survive >30kA of current. I recall concerns from Boeing engineers when they switched to carbon fiber fuselages, that a strike would be far more serious than before, with Aluminum fuselages. https://www.weather.gov/safety/lightning-power https://www.weather.gov/safety/lightning-power https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/35493/are-carbon-fiber-composite-aircraft-at-greater-risk-from-lightning https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/35493/are-carbo...
- cantrecallmypwd 2y agoThere's 2 kinds of CG and there's long-line-induced EM. Ordinary -CG is 30 kA / 30 C / energy of 1 t of TNT. +CG is 10x that. Direct hits are survived all the time by lightning rods for the past 275 years. Long, unshielded lines of any sort can induce massive transient voltage transients (low current) that need to be protected with appropriate TVS circuits that will wear more in storm-prone areas. EMI from nearby lightning in unshielded computing systems with antennas or even without antennas can also be a factor.
- londons_explore 2y agoA lightning rod is copper the thickness of your thumb. Anything thinner would melt. Lightning rods are expensive because thick pieces of copper cost a lot.
- Animats 2y ago> I recall concerns from Boeing engineers when they switched to carbon fiber fuselages, that a strike would be far more serious than before, with Aluminum fuselages. It's a serious problem for carbon-fiber wind turbine blades. Fiberglas is an insulator, and doesn't have lighting problems. Aluminum is a good conductor, and doesn't have lighting problems as long as there's a good a path to ground through the hub. But carbon fiber is a resistor, so conducting a lightning strike generates heat. Some copper or aluminum wire has to go into the turbine blades to bypass this.
- 2y ago
- mrbluecoat 2y ago> flying drones into optimal positions beneath thunderclouds to actively trigger lightning strikes, and then guiding the discharge safely away from vulnerable areas From a military standpoint, I wonder what it would take to discharge into a vulnerable area...
- stronglikedan 2y ago> I wonder what it would take to discharge into a vulnerable area HAARP /s
- foxglacier 2y agoYou could put the wire in the vulnerable area - perhaps using the same drone? But I don't think it would be any use. A lightning strike releases about 1 GJ of energy, mostly into the sky. So the effect at the target would probably be no more than a few kg of explosives which you could have delivered using the wire anyway.
- nayuki 2y agoWe've come a long way from Benjamin Franklin flying a kite into lightning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kite_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kite_experiment
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoI'm sorry but Figure 1 Lightning Protection Drone....all I see when I look at that is a abomination of antenna....like 5 or 6 roof antennas crammed into a single point in space time. Not that it don't look super cook in its own way. But I just reminds me of antennas
- TheBigRoomXXL 2y ago> Traditionally, lightning protection has relied heavily on lightning rods. However, their protective range is limited, and in some cases—such as wind turbines or outdoor event venues—it may not be feasible to install them. At NTT, we are exploring the use of rapidly advancing drone technology to create a new approach: "drone-triggered lightning"2. I can't believe that's a practical solution. Surely just installing more lighting road is simpler et more effective. They just want to do something cool and try to justify it sideways.
- kranke155 2y agoThis probably has more value as a bizarre form of weapon than anything else.
- inglor_cz 2y agoCodename Zeus.
- ourmandave 2y agoLoad up a bunch of B-52 bombers with giant Van de Graaff generators to fly over the target and then send the drone down. I'd be shocked if that worked.
- kranke155 2y agoI think it’s interesting as shock and awe somehow. You could really scare people with this. I’m not sure the precision is close enough to kill.
- tlb 2y agoThe expensive bit isn't the lightning rod itself, but the conductive path all the way to ground that has to handle 10^5 amps.
- yencabulator 2y agoWhich is still needed in this setup?
- trumbitta2 2y agoProtecting cities from lightning damage? This is a weapon and you all know it.
- AStonesThrow 2y agohttps://youtu.be/D6_ZC6BywXs https://youtu.be/D6_ZC6BywXs “Remember who the real enemy is!”
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nomilk 2y ago> Future efforts will focus on developing technologies for capturing and storing lightning energy for potential use (Figure 7). According to a quick search, a typical lightning strike carries about 1-5 billion joules of energy, equivalent to roughly 250-1500kWh; enough energy to power a typical home for 10-60 days. But larger bolts of lightning can have up to 8000kWh, almost a year's supply of electricity for a home in a single bolt!
- bennofs 2y ago8MWh is equivalent to a few hours of electricity generation of a wind turbine.
- nomilk 2y agoKuala Lumpur gets (generous assumption) about 100 lightning strikes per square kilometer per year [0]. If a single drone could service a lot of square km, then it could conceivably collect a lot of electricity. E.g. if it could service 20 square km: 20 * 100 * 8mWh = 16gWh per year. Not bad, but an upper bound, and it hinges a lot on that first parameter (service area). [0] https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/5376210/all https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/5376210/all
- myrmidon 2y agoYou need ~4 strikes per hour to keep up with a single large offshore wind turbine (15MW at 40% capacity factor). That would mean 350km² just to match a single wind turbine (at 100% capture efficiency for 5GJ lightning strikes). This is not ever gonna make economical sense.
- nomilk 2y agoTrue that an offshore wind turbine can produce 15MW. But it can cost $100m+ just for 1 turbine (built and installed). If drones are going up anyway (to protect a city/citizens from strikes), then electricity generation is effectively free, and the marginal cost is equal to the hardware required to capture it (maybe relatively low).
- exe34 2y agoWhosoever is worthy of this drone shall wield the power of Thor.
- feverzsj 2y agoSounds totally unnecessary, unless they were trying to charge Mechagodzilla.
- sheepscreek 2y agoI’m a bit disappointed that they lost an incredible opportunity to generate interest and PR by failing to capture this on video.
- thenthenthen 2y agoInteresting seeing this coming from Japan. There is(was?) this Japanese artist collective called The Play who, every year, for 10 years straight, built a 20 meter wooden pyramid on top of a mountain during the stormy season to try to catch lightning. The tower never got hit. https://www.nmao.go.jp/archive/en/exhibition/2016/play.html https://www.nmao.go.jp/archive/en/exhibition/2016/play.html