5 ms·
[stub for offtopicness] [submitted title was "How I Blog with Obsidian, Hugo, GitHub, and Cloudflare – Zero Cost, Fully Owned"]
by dang 2y ago
[stub for offtopicness]
[submitted title was "How I Blog with Obsidian, Hugo, GitHub, and Cloudflare – Zero Cost, Fully Owned"]
- Zambyte 2y agoWhat do you mean "fully owned"? There is no mention of that in the post Edit: I guess you mean the content itself is still on your machine if the services go away, and you can choose to host them elsewhere
- ingav 2y agoBy "fully owned," I mean that I control the entire stack: - Content is just Markdown files in my local Obsidian vault - Hugo builds the site locally - no dependency on external editors or platforms - GitHub is just used for version control and deployment - Cloudflare Pages handles static hosting, but I can move it elsewhere anytime
- lucideer 2y agoWhile "fully owned" is ambiguous, the only other term I can think of here would be "fully portable", which has other connotations, so it's probably the best term for this. Would be nice to coin an unambiguous term for this as it's a useful design goal.
- intrasight 2y agoI don't think there is a good term in the context of the Internet. Or offline for that matter. Even if you printed your blog and handed it out on street corners, for it to be "fully owned" would that mean you make your own ink and paper?
- jprjr_ 2y agoSo I agree in the sense that, you're always going to rely on something. Even if you're hosting on hardware you own at your house, using your own self-signed SSL certificates, you're still relying on an internet connection from some company. But, I think using the term "fully-owned" to refer to pushing up to GitHub, then deploying to Cloudflare Pages is definitely not "fully-owned"
- ingav 2y agoWhat I meant by "fully-owned" is really about owning the content and the workflow: everything lives locally in plain text, versioned in Git, and built with open tools. I can move it to any host without being locked into a platform or losing anything. You're right that hosting on GitHub and Cloudflare isn't infrastructure ownership. I should’ve been more precise with the wording.
- throwaway519 2y agoIt would mean you owned the ink and paper. The OP's fully owned is analogous to someone else doing the printing for the privelege of spying on your readers.
- angra_mainyu 2y ago"Vendor-agnostic" maybe? It's not perfect but I get where OP is coming from. Personally, the use of the term is completely reasonable.
- gosub100 2y agoYou're being obtuse. Paper and ink are fungible commodities. Try again.
- righthand 2y agoNot “fully-owned” though if you need external services to do the heavy lifting. I think they mean deployed onto a personal vps.
- jprjr_ 2y agoIt's deployed onto Cloudflare Pages - I think this is 100% the opposite of fully-owned.
- riffraff 2y agoI think the point is that it's not someone else's blogging service. If CF or GH die, you can port this to some other platform or your own server without losing anything, compared to e.g. blogger.
- ingav 2y agoYes. That's exactly what I meant. The content is not locked-down and is fully portable.
- wongarsu 2y agoAs long as they use their own domain and have that registered with some other registrar they can trivially move the blog to any other hoster, including a random VPS. So while the current setup depends on github and cloudflare they don't hold much power over him. It's not really fully-owned, but it's owned in the ways that matter most
- bitbasher 2y ago"Fully-owned" when it's relying on GitHub Pages, Hugo, Obsidian and Cloudflare to function. Two of which are services operated by a corporate entity and one of which is a closed source piece of software. The only thing "owned" here is the fact that the entire blog is simple markdown and the domain name. However, that doesn't mean it's very portable. It's not impossible, but it's a lot more work than I would want to do.
- 2y ago
- xyst 2y ago“Zero cost” until cloudflare management decide to kill the free program.
- bryanhogan 2y agoThere are so many other services that allow you to host static pages for free though, at least currently.
- begueradj 2y agoObsidian, Hugo, Github, Cloudflare ... none of those are owned by you.
- Brajeshwar 2y agoThe idea is to use them as tools that get the job done and get out of the way, while you own the content. All of these tools are easily replaceable and the pipeline can still publish to the final blog domain without any worry.
- victorbjorklund 2y agoObsidian is just an editor for markdown files, Hugo is open source. If we can't count open source as "self-owned" then god no one owns anything because pretty much no one runs their computer on a OS they build from scratch with no contributors or using any existing code.
- Saris 2y agoObsidian is just a markdown editor, so the files are portable. The context is that the content and methods to publish it are not someone elses.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- begueradj 2y agoYou do not own it (unless if it's you who released it to run on a platform you don't own)
- zoezoezoezoe 2y agoI really dont agree with "fully owned", you arent running on anything you actually own ie self-hosting. It's all on the cloud, which dont get me wrong, is pretty cool and helpful, but hardly yours.
- ingav 2y agoI’m using “fully owned” more in the sense of control rather than infrastructure ownership. The content lives locally, it’s versioned in Git, and everything’s built with open tools. I can move it to another host any time without being locked into a specific platform or format. I agree it’s not “self-hosted”. But compared to a closed CMS or paid platform, it feels meaningfully more in my hands.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Minor49er 2y agoIn that sense, everything is "fully owned" and the phrase is meaningless. But in the context of the summary where you're using it, it certainly sounds like you are claiming ownership on the infrastructure
- zoezoezoezoe 2y agoI do agree that the phrasing may be poor, but I see where ingav is coming from, if you're using hosted Wordpress and only keep your data in the Wordpress CMS, if Wordpress disappears today, so does all of your content. Although, that may seem foolish to some of us, there are definitely people out there who do that.
- tanelpoder 2y agoYup. I'm using Vim + Hugo + GitHub + Netlify in a similar fashion. Just edit my markdown post, git push and it shows up on my website. I used some other static hosting service previously, don't even remember which one, but switching was super easy as I just pointed the output to some other bucket. So the public web hosting provider is completely commoditized and easy to switch from. Also, I like treating my blog as a version-controlled, declarative "codebase" that's just a bunch of plaintext files (no MySQL tables, XML or JSON to crawl through).
- focusgroup0 2y agonot your atoms, not your bits
- mangeshm 2y ago[dead]
- indiansdontwipe 2y ago[flagged]