4 ms·
Currently, I am working on a file management tool that uses tags fairly heavily. Obviously I think tags can be useful. But the claim that folders can or should
by joe_the_user 14y ago
Currently, I am working on a file management tool that uses tags fairly heavily. Obviously I think tags can be useful.
But the claim that folders can or should be eliminated is seriously misguided.
* Tags aren't enough once your file number exceeds a certain amount.
* File path provides a unique human-readable and human-understand identifier for everyone's file. A system where pieces of data don't have unique identifier is going to be serious drag at some point. Even average people need logical consistency occasionally.
* While folders may be a somewhat hard metaphor for new and casual users to understand, so are tags. A many-to-many relationship isn't actually something people quickly understand fully even if they can quickly get fuzzy understanding it.
* When you throw out the spatial metaphor of folders and files, you've thrown out the guarantee that a file is "somewhere". I've lost and seen other lose files in a disturbing fashion on MACs. Without a keyword for file X, that you just uploaded, you can't "look around" for it.
- barrkel 14y agoIndeed. Have enough tags (and with files, you'll end up with enough tags) and you'll need ontologies for those tags; you'll end up recreating hierarchical structure out of naming conventions. The same tag "name" within different contexts will have different meanings, and the concept of "context" by itself tends towards hierarchy of analytic decomposition.
- bsphil 14y ago>A system where pieces of data don't have unique identifier is going to be serious drag at some point Reminds me of trying to organize/tag my mp3 library. Those fringe cases of imperfect tagging get so cumbersome to manage. Also, with folders, it's so easy to just dump x number of files into a folder and have it organized. Batch tag editing just isn't as intuitive. Now I have an Android and use that as my mp3 player, and Poweramp has a "Folders" view that I almost exclusively use.