9 ms·
AI assisted search-based research works now
- simonw 2y agoI think it's important to keep tabs on things that LLM systems fail at (or don't do well enough on) and try to notice when their performance rises above that bar. Gemini 2.5 Pro and o3/o4-mini seem to have crossed a threshold for a bunch of things (at least for me) in the last few weeks. Tasteful, effective use of the search tool for o3/o4-mini is one of those. Being able to "reason" effectively over long context inputs (particularly useful for understanding and debugging larger volumes of code) is another.
- skydhash 2y agoOne issue I can find with this workflow is tunnel vision, making ill informed decision because of the lack of surrounding information. I often skim books because even if I don't retain the content, I can have a mental map that can help me find further information when I need them. I wouldn't try to construct a complete answer to a question with just this amount of information, but I will use that map to quickly locate the source and have more information to synthesize the answer. One could use the above workflow in the same way and argues that natural language search is more intuitive than keyword based search. But I don't think that brings any meaningful productivity improvement. > Being able to "reason" effectively over long context inputs (particularly useful for understanding and debugging larger volumes of code) is another. Any time I saw this "wish" pop up, my suggestion is to try a disassembler to reverse engineer some binary to really understand the problem of coming up with a theory of a program (based on Naur's definition). Individual statements are always clear (programming language are formal and have no ambiguity). The issue is grouping them, unambiguously define the semantic of these groups, and find the links between them, recursively. Once that's done, what you'll have is a domain. And you could have skipped the whole thing by just learning the domain from a domain expert. So the only reason to do this is because the code doesn't really implement the domain (bugs) or it's hidden purposefully. So the most productive workflow there is to learn the domain first to find discrepancy (first case) or focus yourself on the missing part (second case). In the first case, the easiest approach is writing tests, and the more complete one is to do a formal verification of the software.
- jsemrau 2y agoMy main observation here is 1. Technically it might be possible to search the Internet, but it might not surface correct and/or useful information. 2. High-value information that would make a research report valuable is rarely public nor free. This holds especially true in capital-intensive or regulated industries.
- simonw 2y agoI fully expect one of the AI-related business models going forward to be charging subscriptions for LLM search tool access to those kinds of archives. ChatGPT plus an extra $30/month for search access to a specific archive would make sense to me.
- sshine 2y agoKagi is $10/mo. for search and +$15/mo. for premium LLMs with agentic access to search.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoWhat they're talking about is access to professional archives like EBSCOnet or Bloomberg, which usually don't sell to individuals in the first place and start at tens of thousands of dollars per seat for institutional access.
- JustFinishedBSG 2y agoOfc Mistral model is a lot worse but for $14.99 you get access to AFP news. So OpenAI for $60 for the same things would be a huge joke
- ac29 2y agoThe $10 plan includes the LLM assistant a now as well (with a more limited selection of models than the $25 plan).
- jsemrau 2y ago
- btbuildem 2y agoIt's a relevant question about the economic model for the web. On one hand, the replacement of search with a LLM-based approach threatens the existing, advertising-based model. On the other hand, the advertising model has produced so much harm: literally irreparable damage to attention spans, outrage-driven "engagement", and the general enshittification of the internet to mention just a few. I find it a bit hard to imagine whatever succeeds it will be worse for us collectively. My question is, how to reproduce this level of functionality locally, in a "home lab" type setting. I fully expect the various AI companies to follow the exact same business model as any other VC-funded tech outfit: free service (you're the product) -> paid service (you're still the product) -> paid service with advertising baked in (now you're unabashedly the product). I fear that with LLM-based offerings, the advertising will be increasingly inseparable, and eventually undetectable, from the actual useful information we seek. I'd like to get a "clean" capsule of the world's compendium of knowledge with this amazing ability to self-reason, before it's truly corrupted.
- fzzzy 2y agoYou need a copy of r1 and enough ram to run it, and a web searching tool, or a rag database with your personal data store.
- btbuildem 2y agoR1 would be the reasoning model - as in, the initial part of the output being the "train of thought" revealed before the "final answer" is provided. I was able to deploy a heavily quantized version of that locally, and run it with RAG (Open Webui in this instance) -- with web search enabled, sure, but it's still a far cry from an actual "research" model that know when and how to seek extra data / information.
- qwertox 2y agoI feel like the benefit which AI gives us programmers is limited. They can be extremely advanced, accelerative and helpful assistants, but we're limited to just that: architecting and developing software. Biologists, mathematicians, physicists, philosophers and the like seem to have an open-ended benefit from the research which AI is now starting to enable. I kind of envy them. Unless one moves into AI research?
- bluefirebrand 2y agoI don't think AI is trustworthy or accurate enough to be valuable for anyone trying to do real science That doesn't mean they won't try though. I think the replication crisis has illustrated how many researchers actually care about correctness versus just publishing papers
- simonw 2y agoIf you're a skilled researcher I expect you should be able to get great results out of unreliable AI assistants already. Scientists are meant to be good at verifying and double-checking results - similar to how journalists have to learn to derive the truth from unreliable sources. These are skills that turn out to be crucial when working with LLMs.
- bluefirebrand 2y ago> Scientists are meant to be good at verifying and double-checking results Verifying and double-checking results requires replicating experiments, doesn't it? > similar to how journalists have to learn to derive the truth from unreliable sources I think maybe you are giving journalists too much credit here, or you have a very low standard for "truth" You cannot, no matter how good you are, derive truth from faulty data
- simonw 2y agoDon't make the mistake of assuming all journalists are the same. There's a big difference between an investigative reporter at a respected publication and someone who gets paid to write clickbait. Figuring out that the data is faulty is part of research.
- sshine 2y agoThe article doesn’t mention Kagi: The Assistant, a search-powered LLM frontend that came out of closed beta around the beginning of the year, and got included in all paid plans since yesterday. It really is a game changer when the search engine I find that an AI performing multiple searches on variations of keywords, and aggregating the top results across keywords is more extensive than most people, myself included, would do. I had luck once asking what its search queries were. It usually provides the references.
- simonw 2y agoI haven't tried Kagi's product here yet. Do you know which LLM it uses under the hood? Edit: from https://help.kagi.com/kagi/ai/assistant.html https://help.kagi.com/kagi/ai/assistant.html it looks like the answer is "all of them": > Access to the latest and most performant large language models from OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta, Google, Mistral, Amazon, Alibaba and DeepSeek
- dcre 2y agoYep, regular paid Kagi sub comes with cheap models for free: GPT-4o-mini, Gemini 2.5 Flash, etc. If you pay extra you can get the SOTA models, though IMO flash is good enough for most stuff if the search result context is good.
- intended 2y agoI find that these conversations on HN end up covering similar positions constantly. I believe that most positions are resolved if 1) you accept that these are fundamentally narrative tools. They build stories, In whatever style you wish. Stories of code, stories of project reports. Stories or conversations. 2) this is balanced by the idea that the core of everything in our shared information economy is Verification. The reason experts get use out of these tools, is because they can verify when the output is close enough to be indistinguishable from expert effort. Domain experts also do another level of verification (hopefully) which is to check if the generated content computes correctly as a result - based on their mental model of their domain. I would predict that that LLMs are deadly in the hands of people who can’t gauge the output, and will end up driving themselves off of a cliff, while experts will be able to use it effectively on tasks where verification of the output has a comparative effort advantage, over the task of creating the output.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gh0stcat 2y agoYou've perfectly captured my experience as well, I typically only trust it and have good experiences with LLMs when I have enough domain expertise to get to at least a 95% confidence the output is correct. (Specific to my domain of work, I don't always need "perfect"). I also can mostly use it as a first pass for getting the idea of where to begin research, after that I lose confidence that the more detailed and advanced content it is giving me is accurate. There is a gray area though where a domain expert might have a false sense of confidence, and over time experience "Skill Drift", where they lose expertise because they are only ever verifying a lossy compression of information, rather than re-setting their context with real world information. I am mostly concerned with that last bit.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoYup succinct summarization of the current state. This works across domains from research to software engineering.
- 2y ago
- saulpw 2y agoI tried it recently. I asked for videochat services like the one I use (WB) with 2 specific features that the most commonly used services don't have. It asked some clarifying questions and seemed to understand the mission, then went off for 10 minutes after which it returned 5 results in a table. The first result was WB, which I gave to it as the first example and am already using. Results 2 and 3 were the mainstream services which it helpfully marked in the table as not having the features I need. Result 4 looked promising but was discontinued 3 years ago. Result 5 was an actual option which I'm trying out (but may not work for other reasons). So, 1/5 usable results. That was mildly helpful I guess, but it appeared a lot more helpful on the surface than it was. And I don't seem to have the ability to say "nice try but dig deeper".
- simonw 2y agoThat sounds like a Deep Research query, was that with OpenAI or Gemini?
- saulpw 2y agoThis was OpenAI.
- Gracana 2y agoYou can tell it to try again. It took me a couple rounds with the tool before I noticed that your conversation after the initial research isn't limited to just chatting: if you select the "deep research" button on your message, it will run the search process in its response.
- baq 2y ago> I can feel my usage of Google search taking a nosedive already. Conveniently Gemini is the best frontier model for everything else, they’re very interested and well positioned (if not best?) to also be the best in deep research. Let’s check back in 3-6 months.
- throwup238 2y agoIMO they’re already the best. Not only is the rate limit much higher (20/day instead of OpenAI’s 10/month) but Gemini is capable of looking at far more sources, on the order of 10x. I just had a research report last night that looked at 400 sources when I asked it to help identify a first edition Origin of Species (it did a great job too, correctly explaining how to identify a true first edition from chimeral ones).
- jillesvangurp 2y agoGoogle has two advantages: 1) Their AI models aren't half bad. Gemini 2.5 seems to be doing quite well relative to some competitors. 2) They know how to scale this stuff. They have their own hardware, lots of data, etc. Scaling is of course the hard part. Doing things at Google scale means doing it well while still making a profit. Most AI companies are just converting VC cash into GPUs and energy. VC subsidized AI is nice at a small scale but cripplingly expensive at a larger scale. Google can't do this; they are too large for that. But they are vertically integrated, build their own data centers, with their own TPUs, etc. So, once this starts happening at their scale, they might just have an advantage. A lot of what we are seeing is them learning to walk before they start running faster. Most of the world has no clue what perlexity is or any notion of the pros and cons of claude 3.7 sonnet vs. o4 mini high. None of that stuff matters long term. What matters is who can do this stuff well enough for billions of people. So, I wouldn't count them out. But none of this stuff guarantees success either, of course.
- energy123 2y ago> The user-facing Google Gemini app can search too, but it doesn’t show me what it’s searching for. Gemini 2.5 Pro is also capable of search as part of its chain of thought but it needs light prodding to show URLs, but it'll do so and is good at it. Unrelated point, but I'm going to keep saying this anywhere Google engineers may be reading, the main problem with Gemini is their horrendous web app riddled with 5 annoying bugs that I identified as a casual user after a week. I assume it's in such a bad state because they don't actually use the app and they use the API, but come on. You solved the hard problem of making the world's best overall model but are squandering it on the world's worst user interface.
- loufe 2y agoThere must be some form of memory leak in AI Studio as I'll have to close and open a new tab after about 2 hours as it slowly grinds my slower computers to a halt. Its ability to create a markdown file without escaping the markdown itself (included code snippets) is definitely my first suggestion for them to fix. It's a great tool, but sometimes frustrating.
- energy123 2y agoIt's a great model, but the web developers that built the web app either don't care or are incompetent.
- oulipo 2y agoThe main "real-world" use cases for AI use for now have been: - shooting buildings in Gaza https://apnews.com/article/israel-palestinians-ai-weapons-430f6f15aab420806163558732726ad9 https://apnews.com/article/israel-palestinians-ai-weapons-43... - compiling a list of information on Government workers in US https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/elon-musk-s-doge-using-ai-to-spy-on-us-federal-workers-insiders-claim/ar-AA1CxvT2 https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/elon-musk-s-doge-usi... - creating a few losy music videos I'd argue we'd be better off SLOWING DOWN with that shit
- esafak 2y agoProgramming is not real world?
- das_keyboard 2y agoYeah right. We also got "vibe coding" out of it.
- oulipo 2y agoI said "the main use cases", not "the little toys to distract and amuse engineers while the ruin the environment with CO2 emissions"
- esafak 2y agoIt is not a little toy, and when you consider the carbon footprint of humans and the productivity savings afforded by AI the balance evens out. AI is a very powerful technology if you know how to wield it.
- sandspar 2y agoYou seem ideology motivated instead of truth motivated which makes you untrustworthy.
- oulipo 2y agoSo give some citations of other notable uses?
- swyx 2y ago> Deep Research, from three different vendors dont forget Xai grok!
- M4v3R 2y agoWhich, at least in my experience is surprisingly good while being much faster than others.
- fudged71 2y agoyou.com is surprisingly good for this as well (I like the corporate report PDF export)
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoHorrible compared to sota. I only find it being mentioned by random ai influencers who are a waste of air and who live on twitter.
- softwaredoug 2y agoI wonder when Google search will let me "chat" with the search results. I often want to ask the AI Overview follow up questions. I secondarily wonder how an LLM solves the trust problem in Web search. What's traditionally solved (and now gamed) through PageRank. It doesn't seem ChatGPT is easily fooled by Spam as direct search. How much is Bing (or whatever the search engine is) getting better? vs how much are LLMs better at knowing what a good result is for a query? Or perhaps it has to do with the richer questions that get asked to chat vs search?
- vunderba 2y ago> I wonder when Google search will let me "chat" with the search results. You don't hear a lot of buzz around them, but thats kind of what Perplexity lets you do. (Possibly phind too but it's been a while since I used them).
- dingnuts 2y ago>I wonder when Google search will let me "chat" with the search results Kagi has this already, it's great. Choose a result, click the three-dot menu, choose "Ask questions about this page." I love to do this with hosted man pages to discover ways to combine the available flags (and to discover what is there) I find most code LLMs write to be subpar but Kagi can definitely write a better ffmpeg line than I can when I use this approach
- temp20250421 2y ago[dead]
- KTibow 2y agoWhen AI Overview was called Search Generative Experience, you could do that. You can do that again now if you have access to AI Mode.
- 63 2y agoOne downside I found is that the llm cannot change its initial prompt until it's done thinking. I used deep research to compare counseling centers for me but of course when it encounters some factor I hadn't thought of (e.g. the counselors here fit the criteria perfectly but none accept my insurance), it doesn't know that it ought to skip that site entirely. Really this is a critique of the deep-research approach rather than search in general, but I imagine it can still play out on smaller scales. Often, searching for information is a dynamic process involving the discovery of unknown unknowns and adjustment based on that, but ai isn't great at abstract goals or stopping to ask clarifying questions before resuming. Ultimately, the report I got wasn't useless, but it mostly just regurgitated the top 3 google results. I got much better recommendations by reaching out to a friend who works in the field.
- xp84 2y agoFrom article: > “Google is still showing slop for Encanto 2!” (Link is provided) I believe quite strongly that Google is making a serious misstep in this area, the “supposed answer text pinned at the top above the actual search results.” For years they showed something in this area which was directly quoted from what I assume was a shortlist of non-BS sites so users were conditioned for years that if they just wanted a simple answer like when a certain movie came out or if a certain show had been canceled or something, you may as well trust it. Now it seems like they have given over that previous real estate to a far less reliable feature, which simply feeds any old garbage it finds anywhere into a credulous LLM and takes whatever pops out. 90% of people that I witness using Google today simply read that text and never click any results. As a result, Google is now pretty much always even less accurate at the job of answering questions than if you posed that same question to ChatGPT, because GPT seems to be drawing from its overall weights which tend toward basic reality, whereas Google’s “Answer” seems to be summarizing a random 1-5 articles from the Spam Web, with zero discrimination between fact, satire, fiction, and propaganda. How can they keep doing this and not expect it to go badly?
- ljsprague 2y agoI have stopped using Google when I have a random fact I need answered. Faster to ask ChatGPT. I trust it enough now.
- CSMastermind 2y agoThe various deep research products don't work well for me. For example I asked these tools yesterday, "How many unique NFL players were on the roster for at least one regular season game during the 2024 season? I'd like the specific number not a general estimate." I as a human know how to find this information. The game day rosters for many NFL teams are available on many sites. It would be tedious but possible for me to find this number. It might take an hour of my time. But despite this being a relatively easy research task all of the deep research tools I tried (OpenAI, Google, and Perplexity) completely failed and just gave me a general estimate. Based on this article I tried that search just using o3 without deep research and it still failed miserably.
- simonw 2y agoThat is an excellent prompt to tuck away in your back pocket and try again future iterations of this technology. It's going to be an interesting milestone when or if any of these systems get good enough at comprehensive research to provide a correct answer.
- minraws 2y agoIf you keep the prompt the same at some point the data will appear in training set and we might have answer. So even though today it might be a good check it might not remain as such a good benchmark. I think we need a way to keep updating prompts without increasing complexity in someway to properly verify model improvements. ARC Deep Research anyone?
- ljsprague 2y agoWouldn't somebody need to answer the question below? Or do you mean the discussion of its weakness might somehow make it stronger the next time it's trained?
- minraws 2y agoI think it can be both, what happens if discussing weakness provides more relavent links for the question and help the model that is trained scraped web data to learn somehow. I am not sure if the model will need the exact answer or just the backlinks to site where they can find them is enough. Maybe just documenting how to do it could do the job as well...
- Havoc 2y agoAre any of the Deep Research tools pure api cost? Or all monthly sub?
- simonw 2y agoI think the Gemini one may still be available for free.
- sublimefire 2y agoI do prefer tools like GPT researcher where you are in control over sources and search engines. Sometimes you just need to use arxiv, sometimes mix research with the docs you have. Sometimes you want to use different models. I believe the future is in choosing what you need for the specific task at that moment, eg 3d model generation mixed with something else, and this all requires some sort of new “OS” level application to run from. Individual model vendors cannot do such a product as they are biased towards their own model, they would not allow you to choose models from competitors.
- jeffbee 2y agoThe Deep Research stuff is crazy good. It solves the issue that I can often no longer find articles that I know are out there. Example: yesterday I was holding forth on the socials about how 25 years ago my local government did such and such thing to screw up an apartment development at the site of an old movie theater, but I couldn't think of the names of any of the principals. After Googling for a bit I used a Deep Research bot to chase it down for me, and while it was doing that I made a sandwich. When I came back it had compiled a bunch of contemporaneous news articles from really obscure bloggers, plus allusions to public records it couldn't access but was confident existed, that I later found using the URLs and suggested search texts.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- otistravel 2y agoThe most impressive demos of these tools always involve technical tasks where the user already knows enough to verify accuracy. But for the average person asking about health issues, legal questions, or historical facts? It's basically fancy snake oil - confident-sounding BS that people can't verify. The real breakthrough would be systems that are actually trustworthy without human verification, not slightly better BS generators. True AI research breakthroughs would admit uncertainty and provide citations for everything, not fake certainty like these tools do.
- spongebobstoes 2y agothis remains true for pretty much all advice or information we receive. doctors, lawyers, accountants, teachers. there have been countless times that all of these professionals have given me bad advice or information sure, at least I have someone to blame in that case. but in my experience, the AI is at least as reliable as a person who I don't personally know
- neural_thing 2y agoI tested o3 on a medical issue I've had that 50+ doctors couldn't diagnose over the span of 6-7 years, ended up figuring it out through sheer luck. With my first prompt, it gave a list of probabilities, with the correct answer being listed as the third most likely. It also suggested correct tests to run for every option. I trust it way more than I trust human doctors who were confidently wrong about me for years.
- arkh 2y agoI'm still thinking a simple expert system used by some nurse used to getting people to explain their symptoms would be enough to replace a general MD. Less time and money spent to train those nurses, which you can then spend on training specialists. And your expert system will take less time to update than training thousands of doctor every time some new protocol or drug is released.
- franze 2y ago
- blackhaz 2y agoThis is surprising. o3 produces incredible amount of hallucinations for me, and there are lots of reddit threads about it. I've had to roll back to another model because it just swamps everything in made up facts. But sometimes it is frighteningly smart. Reading its output sometimes feels like I'm missing IQ points.
- in_ab 2y agoClaude doesn't seem to have a built in search tool but I tried this with a MCP server to search google and it gives similar results.
- jonas_b 2y agoA common google searching thing I counter have is something like this: I need to get from A to B via C via public transport in a big metropolis. Now C could be one of say 5 different locations of a bank branch, electronics retailer, blood test lab or whatever, so there's multiple ways of going about this. I would like a chatbot solution that compares all the different options and lays them out ranked by time from A to B. Is this doable today?
- pyfon 2y agoI am on holiday now and want something similar. Get me from A to B but with a memorable heuristic that I can use if I leave at any time. E.g. "if you catch a 134 or 175 bus to Kings station then get the metro 3 stops to Cental station.". Even better if you add some landmarks. This may exclude some clever routes that shave off 3 minutes if you do the correct parkour... but it means I can now put my phone down and enjoy the journey without tracking it like a hawk.
- csallen 2y agoIt's actually quite doable to build your own deep research agent. You just need a single prompt, a solid code loop to run it agentically, and some tools for it to call. I've been building a domain-specific deep research agent over the past few days for internal use, and I'm pretty impressed with how much better it is than any of the official deep search agents for my use case.
- mz00 2y agosame here. I first built the agentic workflow in python and later nextjs. uses dozens of llm apis. works well, and am also impressed with the results.
- csallen 2y agoCurious what you mean by dozens of llm apis. Different models? Or different tool calls?
- mz00 2y agodifferent models. high level approach: N models receive the same prompt → responses are consolidated through a simple embedding-based similarity matrix → another model performs a simple assessment of deduplicated responses → these are then consolidated into a research report & data visualization. the whole contraption uses ~10 different models, but more can easily be plugged into the initial generation phase. happy to demo it sometime! [edit: email on profile].
- mehulashah 2y agoI find that people often conflate search with analytics when discussing Deep Research. Deep Research is iterated search and tool use. And, no doubt, it’s remarkably good. Deep Analytics is like Deep Research in that it uses generative AI models to generate a plan, but LLMs operations and structured (tool use) are interleaved in database style query pipelines. This allows for the more precise counting and exhaustive search type use cases.
- gcanyon 2y agoThe concern over "LLMs vs. the Web" is giving me serious "The Web vs. Brick and Mortar" vibes. That's not to say that it won't be the predicted cataclysm, just that it might not be. Time will tell, because This Is Happening, People, but if it does turn out to be a serious problem, I think we'll find some way to adapt. We're unlikely to accept a lesser result.
- Tycho 2y agoI tried o3 for a couple of things. First one, geolocation a photo I saw in a museum. It didn’t find a definitive answer but it sure turned up a lot of fascinating info in its research. Second one, I asked it to suggest a new line of enquiry in the Madeleine McCann missing person case. It made the interesting suggestion that the 30 minute phone call the suspect made on the evening of the disappearance, from a place near the location of the abduction, was actually a sort of “lookout call” to an accomplice nearby. Quite impressed. This is a great investigative tool.
- gitroom 2y agoI feel like half the time these AI tools are either way too smart or just eating glue, tbh - do you think people will ever actually trust AI for deep answers or are we all just using it to pass time at work?
- soulofmischief 2y agoDo you understand how search works? After finding something, you still have to verify it.
- noja 2y agoCan it geotag my old scanned photos?
- simonw 2y agoLatest models might actually be able to help with that - they are getting spooky good at guessing the location of a photograph: https://techcrunch.com/2025/04/17/the-latest-viral-chatgpt-trend-is-doing-reverse-location-search-from-photos/ https://techcrunch.com/2025/04/17/the-latest-viral-chatgpt-t...
- noja 2y agoEven with slightly blurry old photos?
- simonw 2y agoWorth a try. It's pretty fascinating seeing what it hooks into - it figured out where my backyard was based on the moss on the trees and the architectural style of the buildings ("coastal California, likely near Half Moon Bay" - it was just north of HMB).
- Alifatisk 2y agoHave anyone tried ithy.com yet? If you have any prompt that you know most llms fail at, I’d love to know how itchy responds!
- BambooBandit 2y agoI feel like the bigger problem isn't whether these deep research products work, but rather the raw material, so to speak, that they're working with. For example, a lot of the "sources" cited in Google's AI Overview (notably not a deep research product) are not official, just sites that probably rank high in SEO. I want the original source, or a reliable source, not joeswebsite dot com (no offense to this website if it indeed exists).
- simonw 2y agoYes, Google's AI overviews are terrible. They're an example of how not to build this. That'd what makes o3/o4-mini driven search notable to me: those models appear to have much better taste in which searches to run and which sources to consider.
- theklahomate 2y ago[dead]