3 ms·
Can't we just use Ethernet instead?
by amelius 2y ago
Can't we just use Ethernet instead?
- formerly_proven 2y agoThe short-reach single pair Ethernet (xxxxBASE-T1) is largely developed for automotive and robotics, yes. Also supports PoE.
- liamkinne 2y agoHave a look at Ethercat. Based on the same physical layer as Ethernet but allows daisy-chaining devices.
- camtarn 2y agoSimilarly, PROFINET, the confusingly named EtherNet/IP (IP here stands for Industrial Protocol not Internet Protocol), POWERLINK, and others - all based on Ethernet but with a custom protocol layer replacing IP. "We need something that is high speed but also supports rapid deterministic communication" is pretty much a solved problem in the industrial space. I wonder what Tesla's game is here: is it really just reinventing the wheel, or are they perhaps using higher speed Ethernet as industrial Ethernet tends to still be limited to 100Mbit? Or perhaps it's tightly linked with the proposal to communicate over 48V lines?
- eqvinox 2y agoIndustrial Ethernet uses 100Mb speeds because (and when) those are sufficient for their use cases. There is no technical limitation there. 1000base-T1 (and even 2.5, 5 & 10G SPE¹) show where this is going. ¹ Single Pair Ethernet
- camtarn 2y agoHuh, I didn't know single pair ethernet went up that fast - neat! We're still living in the 100Mbit world at my company - and, yeah, it's fast enough for pretty much everything we need.
- throw-qqqqq 2y agoVanilla Ethernet requires much more hardware and software (IP stack etc.) to function, than CAN does. It’s just not cost effective for many cars. Time triggered Ethernet is used in aviation though.
- Muskisapuss 2y ago[dead]
- throw-qqqqq 2y agoYes very seriously. Many microcontrollers come with CAN support natively, but no PHY for instance. So CAN is available for even the cheapest MCUs, not so with Ethernet. There is also a lot more supporting hardware required for Ethernet compared to CAN, and the price for producing a cheap Ethernet capable board is many times that of CAN. The galvanic isolation in Ethernet (magnetics) costs about 1W idle pr port, so the power budget is also on a whole other level. I spent the previous decade in embedded, designing both CAN and Ethernet-capable cobtrol systems for industrial applications. Ethernet is much more expensive than CAN, but can also be much faster etc. CAN and Ethernet normally do not compete for the same applications :)
- eqvinox 2y agoYou're comparing CAN with classic Ethernet. You should be comparing CAN with SPE (Single Pair Ethernet), which was developed to replace CAN (among other things) and is in fact well on its way on doing just that - cars are getting built using it.
- throw-qqqqq 2y agoI know there are variants on the “classic” Ethernet. I was talking about vanilla Ethernet and answering a questions about “The most common standard known to mankind”, so I stuck with that.
- 2y ago
- throw0101b 2y ago> Can't we just use Ethernet instead? Growing trend of it for certain use cases: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethernet_over_twisted_pair#Single-pair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethernet_over_twisted_pair#Sin... * https://www.keysight.com/blogs/en/tech/educ/2024/automotive-ethernet https://www.keysight.com/blogs/en/tech/educ/2024/automotive-...
- throw0101d 2y agoAddendum, there is 10BASE-T1S, which uses a single-pair and is multi-drop from that pair: * https://www.keysight.com/blogs/en/tech/2024/02/8/how-is-10base-t1s-different-from-can https://www.keysight.com/blogs/en/tech/2024/02/8/how-is-10ba... * https://www.analog.com/en/signals/thought-leadership/why-10base-t1s-is-the-missing-ethernet-link.html https://www.analog.com/en/signals/thought-leadership/why-10b... * https://www.graniteriverlabs.com/en-us/technical-blog/automotive-ethernet-10-base-t1s https://www.graniteriverlabs.com/en-us/technical-blog/automo... In some ways this is going to Ethernet's roots with a common transmission medium (Thicknet, Thinnet).