14 ms·
College Towns: Urbanism from a Past Era
- nluken 2y agoThis interview needs to be edited a bit; just posting the transcript of the zoom call really hampers the readability and flow. What works for a podcast is not the same as what works for a written piece.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoA big part of why college towns work so nicely is economic circumstances of the student body. Simply put most students aren’t bringing a car to campus and by definition now need to live somewhere closer to get to class. And on top of that the town is a monocrop where maybe the couple tens of thousands of kids are the vast majority of the population. This is why it can’t really play out as nicely everywhere. You might work across town from your partner vs merely across campus, or in another town. Your location is compromised by definition and not benefiting from economies of scale like it was when it was at least compromised with another 40k people in your demographic with a similar commute and life pattern within 2 square miles. And you don’t have to pay a couple thousand a year for parking privileges either so you might be taking the car on trips that would have been a forced walk in college for lack of car. The disneyland point is a bit tired and worn imo among internet urbanists and doesn’t even make sense in practice if you’ve ever been to disneyland. Main street isnt the draw. It is this strip of shops you are obligated to walk through as you enter the park to try and tempt you from your dollar. You can’t even hang out there; all the shops are packed with people looking at merchandise, all the restaurants on main are like coffee and ice cream “please leave and keep walking” places, and during fireworks display it is a miracle and a testament to the staffing that there isn’t a crowd crush from people leaving through the bottleneck as well as people staying to see fireworks framed with the castle. In these situations they actually open up a staff only alley to the public that is parallel to main street to relieve some of this bottleneck.
- tmnvdb 2y agoThis seems like a strangely theoretical argument, as if the world outside America simply does not exist.
- zephyrthenoble 2y agoIsn't the article about college towns in America? It's not theoretical there. A more universal example is probably towns with large seasonal influxes, such as ski towns or beach towns, but unlike a college town, these locations attract people of all ages and incomes. College towns in the US have an influx of specifically 18-22 year olds who can afford college but might not have a lot of disposable income, and most leave during the summer.
- xixixao 2y agoI’m traveling through Puerto Rico. On every nice beach, when there are people, they are playing loud music. Now that is part of the local culture. To me (a European), it is abhorent, ruining the supposedly relaxing atmosphere of a beach (even more so that the music to me seems extremely repetitive). I could not convince anyone here to stop doing this. Again, for locals, this is their culture. Similarly, I don’t think most Americans can grasp the difference between American cities (including in Puerto Rico) built for cars vs for pedestrians. Most will argue (including here), that this is a function of the size of the place. And America is big, and in places sparsely unpopulated, undeniably. But this is not the reason. Europe too is big. With many less populated places. And there are cars everywhere, most people own one. It’s now cultural. Culture can change, but when combined with architecture at an industrial scale, I’m afraid the change will take much longer than a natural human lifetime.
- bbqfog 2y agoThey probably find it equally abhorrent that a European would come and police their culture. Please don't travel somewhere and complain about local culture. You're a guest, possibly and unwanted one.
- heavymetalpoizn 2y ago[dead]
- AStonesThrow 2y agoHow do we know that this is "Puerto Rican Culture Plays Loud Music on Beaches"? What if it's some obnoxious rebellious college kids who think they can get away with it? What if it's some tourists, like from Cuba or Argentina, who are rich and so nobody in authority will handle complaints against them, because tourism feeds PR's economy so effectively? What if most Puerto Rico residents don't really go hang out at the beach at all, and they stay home with their families, and they cook in the kitchen and they enjoy conversations? What if Puerto Ricans are mostly like Americans, and their faces are all in their smartphones, and some of them play loud music and some ignore it, and some hate it but don't complain, and some complain but also play their own loud music to try and drown it out? What if Puerto Ricans don't have one monolithic culture that you can generalize while we're here on an English-speaking forum, based on the mainland USA? What if Puerto Ricans don't actually eat elephants or giraffes? https://youtu.be/mzK9_TbzReQ?si=-QsUIwt_0SIcY-gt&t=28 https://youtu.be/mzK9_TbzReQ?si=-QsUIwt_0SIcY-gt&t=28
- bbqfog 2y agoIn my experience the transient nature of the college town population means that they're all kind of run down in a particular kind of way, especially housing (how many drunken ragers can a 1 bedroom apartment really handle?). It's nice that they can be beacons of culture in otherwise rural areas, but there's definitely downsides to having a bunch of kids move in and out constantly.
- frutiger 2y ago> how many drunken ragers can a 1 bedroom apartment really handle? Depends on how they were built. For some college halls in the UK, maybe a few hundred years worth?
- kortilla 2y agoThey aren’t failing structurally, they are just in a perpetually ugly state because a landlord doesn’t care about keeping a property attractive that students will abuse. So you end up with worn out carpet, paint flaking, broken door handles, etc etc. That’s why there is a different much smaller but much better pool of properties for people willing to do an 18+ month lease.
- cyberax 2y agoWhy not go into even more past eras? Urbanism from the era of bunk beds in flophouses is the future, after all.
- Mr-Frog 2y agoI unironically agree with this. 100 years ago, Skid Row and Bunker Hill in Los Angeles were full of SROs, boarding houses and long-term hotels. The people who lived there didn't disappear, they're just all sleeping in the street now.
- Tade0 2y agoI guess you never had the misfortune of sleeping in a flophouse to say something like that. One time I had this project in Switzerland and my co-worker, who also travelled there, figured he'd save money if he rented a bunk bed in illegal (due to density) quarters. Terrible experience, which got him fired eventually because he quickly lost steam due to having to share a tiny room with three other people. I on the other hand moistened every Swiss Frank banknote with tears, but splurged thrice the amount on a proper room and survived until the end of my involvement in that project.
- yesfitz 2y agoThe person you're responding to suggested Single Room Occupancies, flophouses, etc. are a better alternative to sleeping rough (on the street). You suggested that flophouses are worse than a proper room. Both of these things can be true.
- pyfon 2y agoAs an aside you can see why it is hard/impossible for a homeless person to pull bootstraps when a successful person can't keep their job living not-even-homeless.
- tmnvdb 2y agoThe current American urbanism is from the past! The assumption that other urbanisms somehow represent a blast from the past, while 70 year old American car-centric urbanism embodies the eternal modern 'now,' simply doesn't hold up to scrutiny. There are numerous contemporary urbanisms, and newer approaches increasingly tend to be far less car-centric.
- janalsncm 2y agoIt’s too easy for a vocal minority to veto good policy, like building more housing. You see this all across the country, in college towns and in California overall. It is formalized as “zoning” but that is just an official way of implementing a shortsighted policy. If you do not zone for housing you are zoning for homelessness. Plain and simple.
- spwa4 2y agoYou can do what rich people do: force others to take care of your problems by kicking out the homeless.
- janalsncm 2y agoThere are plenty of rich people in San Francisco which has a severe housing shortage and homelessness issue. Homelessness is the exhaust fumes of rapid growth, which SF and CA as a whole have experienced. Smart politics knows this and plans ahead to handle it, rather than allowing exploding housing costs stunt the growth of the city. There are many talented people who otherwise would have went to SF who didn’t. You don’t have to go far from SF to get to single family houses, which should not be possible. They can solve this by adding a land value tax inversely proportional to the distance from specific city functions.
- oceanplexian 2y agoHate to be the bearer of bad news but you could build infinite housing in San Francisco and the streets would still be riddled with drug-abusing vagrants. They may technically stop being "homeless" if you give them all a free apartment but it's not a magic wand that will solve SF's problems.
- janalsncm 2y agoHaving sufficient housing doesn’t mean you can’t also have basic law enforcement. SF is doing neither. I am saying to do both. We can have beautiful, clean and safe cities that are much more affordable. It is a choice not to.
- davidjama 2y agoIsn’t it bizarre how in college short distances, walkability and building high capacity accommodations on a budget are a priority to create productive, collaborative, social and affordable environments but after college, people move to suburban hell
- shostack 2y agoNot at all. When you're young and not tied down, and also likely lack much money, you prioritize a different lifestyle and are also in college to, presumably, accomplish your goal of getting a degree and learning something. For many, once they get older and desire a slower, calmer, quieter life, and especially if you want more space with kids, the suburbs start holding more appeal. And that also factors in constraints about job availability.
- subpixel 2y ago> the suburbs start holding more appeal. Suburbs don't need to be car-dependent. The suburban appeal in fact has nothing to do with cars. In Germany as just one example, there was (when I lived there) excellent, reliable bus service in and between suburbs. And connecting the suburbs to light rail, which connected to the city center. The big complaint I had in my 20s was that the light rail stopped running before midnight.
- xp84 2y ago> Suburbs don't need to be car-dependent Probably true, but unless you have infinite money, building enough housing with expensive rail infrastructure is pretty tough. We can only manage truly world-class(ish) transit in (parts of) one city, NYC, and plenty of people still routinely choose to move out of Manhattan upon having kids instead of staying, either because they can't afford enough space to reasonably make a go of it, or because it's so much easier to do the car-dependent suburb. So, the people themselves are choosing it. Whatever anyone thinks of it, there is plenty of evidence that a lot of people who have a choice choose something other than the urban walkable deal. PS: Don't come at me please, I loved living in a big urban city, but moved out because I refused to choose only one of: big enough home, safe neighborhood, decent schools, reasonable commute distance. And honestly to stay in the urban core where I used to live, only "commute distance" was even available.
- bentt 2y agoLet's not forget that in America, when you have a college or university, you have historically created a money funnel from the government/parents, through the students, to the city. There's an outsized incentive to cater to that opportunity and get the students accessing the business areas. Also, American liberal culture tends to follow higher education, which not only means a desire for certain things, but also a love of rules to block "bad things". This often means preserving old cities.
- m463 2y agoAnother observation is that college towns are a fake/planned environment, and much is controlled in a very authoritative way. The population is very uniform and willingly gives up many freedoms.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- parpfish 2y agoOne of my more tin-hattish ideas: higher ed has drifted toward more of an “all inclusive resort” model over the last 50 years where students get to live in a “parallel” version of the city with their own police force, medical center, dining halls, entertainment venues, etc. this is an intentional move to let them live in a utopian setting that pacifies them to prevent widespread student activism like the 70s
- pests 2y agoI like the organic mix of university and city development that University of Michigan has in Ann Arbor. It feels like the two grew together and coexist. I do get that feeling you describe when in Wayne State downtown though
- rtollert 2y ago> Art Deco City From Time and Jerry You mean Tom and Jerry? > Ryan Allen is a professor of international education at University of America in Southern California What in the… what? That’s not a university. That’s not even a university system. The only sort of person I would expect to call… I don’t know, USC?… that has never observed the name of an American state university used in context in the English language. Enormous red flags in like the first three sentences.
- zeckalpha 2y agoUh well https://ua-edu.us/ https://ua-edu.us/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- neilknowsbest 2y agoIt appears to be the Soka University of America. https://www.soka.edu/about/faculty-staff/ryan-allen https://www.soka.edu/about/faculty-staff/ryan-allen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soka_University_of_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soka_University_of_America