3 ms·
Is the caveat in #1 actually required? As I understand it, there's nothing in the DMCA requiring that a copyright holder file a takedown notice with the site be
by _delirium 14y ago
Is the caveat in #1 actually required? As I understand it, there's nothing in the DMCA requiring that a copyright holder file a takedown notice with the site before they file one with Google, since those are independent. They could file one with Google for the search results first, or they could file the notices simultaneously. That would result in sites being demoted even if they do comply with takedown notices, because under Google's new policy they'd be demoted just by the fact of Google having received DMCA notices.
- maxerickson 14y agoPresumably they will mostly only get demoted if they host a large amount of content that is subject to DMCA notices.
- e12e 14y agoI don't see how you can be confident of this: Look at how youtube handles allegations of copyright infringement. There's also a problem with flow of information; if your provider takes down something under the DMCA, they inform you, so you know about the (possibly frivolous) claim. I don't see how Google could make any reasonable guarantee to be able to inform the affected parties -- neither the author/user that publish, nor necessarily the various admins and providers that would be affected (Think shared hosting, shared domain, community message board...).