5 ms·
Dead trees keep surprisingly large amounts of carbon out of atmosphere
- bpodgursky 2y agoInterestingly earthworms went extinct in most of north america after the last ice age, and their re-introduction in 1500+ means they are making their way through organic matter in Canada's boreal forests that were previously sequestering large amounts of carbon. No way to roll it back though. https://natural-resources.canada.ca/stories/simply-science/earthworms-threat-canada-s-boreal-forest https://natural-resources.canada.ca/stories/simply-science/e...
- canadiantim 2y agoThen the fix to climate change is clear, we must exterminate the worms!
- cmenge 2y agoWhen Worms came out in '95, I had a feeling there was something deeper, more profound to it, but I couldn't tell what it was. Now it all finally makes sense!
- Calwestjobs 2y agohippies loved earth so much, oil companies started to distribute drugs between people [btw drugs are made from oil...no kidding] (just alternate universe joke)
- Graziano_M 2y agoworms armageddon
- Calwestjobs 2y agowho would thought that one worm can emit as much co2/methane emissions as a sheep launcher...
- returntooffice 2y ago[flagged]
- ankitml 2y agoDead trees can exist as furniture, flooring and buildings too. Stored carbon with ancillary usage.
- f4c39012 2y agomy old boss had an idea - "bury trees". There's a bit of nuance to be filled out, like challenges of forest plantation monoculture and so on, but it always sounded quite practical to me. Iirc the idea derived from "coal".
- parpfish 2y agoWhy do you have to bury them? Can’t you just let the logs sit on the forest floor?
- triceratops 2y agoDecomposition returns carbon dioxide to the air. Or worse, methane, if there isn't enough oxygen.
- parpfish 2y agoDon’t things decompose underground as well?
- triceratops 2y agoThe carbon stays underground.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThey release their carbon as they rot or otherwise consumed. That's why the article talks about wood in cold streams, which rots very slowly.
- myfonj 2y agoIn the long term they will decompose and return vast majority of its carbon back into atmosphere. Blame fungi and bacteria.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoMaybe we can make coal powered earth movers in order to bury the trees.
- myfonj 2y ago> "We can expect the carbon pool stored in these forests to increase substantially," Interesting. I would have guessed that any kind of forests have quite limited cap how much carbon it could retain in dead wood, and that this cap will be pretty much fixed. Unless something will stop natural decay processes releasing the carbon back to the atmosphere I don't see how existing grown forest could increase its capacity, since I suppose it is already at its equilibrium. (Unlike peatlands, where most of accumulated carbon remains underwater, so it presumably has much larger capacity.) Simply said, without "burying or sinking wood mass" I see no easy way to prevent carbon from returning into the atmosphere. Basically if we need to take carbon from the atmosphere, we should ideally put it back from where we have been mining it for last couple of centuries.
- rypskar 2y agoDon't forget about the root system, a large part of a tree is underground, so naturally buried
- myfonj 2y agoI'd call it semi-buried, since it is not isolated from the atmosphere, so in a long term I suspect that almost all its mass gets re-circulated back again – still through microbes, fungi, insects, and perhaps living root systems of surrounding trees. (Last time I tried to get some data about how much carbon remains in the soil after aerobic wood/plants decomposition in agriculture I remember it was pretty much negligible. Forest have way higher limits for maximum soil carbon accumulation, but this limit is reportedly reached after about three centuries of uninterrupted growth.)
- throwup238 2y agoDepends on the ecosystem. Anything embedded into bogs or peatland like roots will generally not decay at all, instead building up a very thick layer of captured carbon as peat. Plants get most of their carbon from CO2 anyway, so in most cases carbon accumulates in the loam (outside of intensive agriculture at least). They produce far more than decomposers have a use for and that's how CO2 accumulates in soil. It only needs to be replenished by the rest of the carbon cycle because of erosion.
- vbezhenar 2y agoIf our civilization would switch to individual wood houses, assuming that cut trees were regrown, that would allow to capture quite a sizeable chunk of carbon as well.
- modo_mario 2y agoThose planks and beams will still rot, burn, etc. None of this is in any way a long term solution for anything it seems.
- vbezhenar 2y agoAs they rot, people would replace them, so overall captured carbon will be maintained as long as our civilization alive. My only concern is that building those houses might actually emit more carbon than they are supposed to keep. But assuming that we moved from Oil era to Nuclear and/or Renewables, that should not happen.
- tinco 2y agoPlanks and beams rot substantially slower than they take to grow if built correctly. My house was cheap labor housing in the 1910's so no particularly fancy practice and only the exposed wood has been partly replaced. I've been told some of the beams were even recycled from Holland's old wooden shipping fleet.
- modo_mario 2y agoThat's still a temporary and limited solution. What we're pulling up now is far more and mostly won't be sequestered for countless thousands of years unless we put insane effort into making it so. Also everything about those houses has an insane footprint as of now. The steel, insulation, glass, etc It's not like you're going to outbuild climate change even if you tried.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AngryData 2y ago
- Calwestjobs 2y agoefficiency of plants - 1% efficiency of photovoltaic - 20% so photovoltaic is 15 times more land efficient then burning biomass. so we absolutely need trees to provide ecological functions. but in era of 5kwp PV array paying itself in 5-6 years(and still working afterwards), to heat water... its is ridiculous to cut trees and burn them to have hot water. 80% of time Canadian citizen can have 100% solar hot water (PV), less then 100% rest of the year.
- throw82928383 2y ago[flagged]
- elric 2y agoI am happy to see that PV is being deployed at incredible speeds. But dismayed at the lack of large scale storage projects & international interconnects.
- WorldMaker 2y agoIs distributed scale storage projects not enough? The grid doesn't need huge storage projects if every house has a house-sized battery and an increasing number of cars can double as a storage buffer (V2G/V2X). Both of those things are statistically hand-in-hand with current PV rollouts, not always sold together, but they form a virtuous cycle for the average home owner if a home can manage PV, storage, and EV all together to (selfishly) reduce reliance on the grid and keep energy patterns much more localized (if not fully "off grid"). A PV-heavy grid potentially starts to look a lot more distributed in interesting ways like scale than the traditional grid which was always more centrally orchestrated than it sounded.
- elric 2y agoNot every house has enough space for battery storage. And management of millions of small batteries is harder than management of thousands of bigger batteries. Millions of small batteries are also vastly more expensive than thousands of bigger battery projects.
- hermitShell 2y agoIn N Stephensons “Anathem” there are “fuel trees” and a couple paragraphs describing how they are ‘cooked’ for hydrocarbon fuels. I like trees and his vision of a future where genetically modified trees are the best way to collect solar energy and then harvest and store it. Solar panels are cool but one of the themes of the book is civilization over many millennia, and I can see how he arrived at his conclusion that most tech doesn’t work as well as trees.
- tastyfreeze 2y agoSounds like that isn't far from the truth. Cooking wood in an anoxic environment creates wood gas and charcoal. Wood gas can be burned as it comes out of the retort or can be refined into methanol and other hydrocarbon fuels. The charcoal product is a high quality activated charcoal. That can also be burned as fuel or charged and put back in the ground as biochar.
- pfdietz 2y agoOne can get about twice the liquid fuel from wood by reacting it with hydrogen than one can get from the wood itself. Wood is (simplistically) carbohydrates. So, C(H2O) + H2 --> CH2 + H2O. This treats wood more as a carbon carrier than an energy carrier.
- Sharlin 2y agoIndeed charcoal fueled the early stages of the industrial revolution, and its massive production was one of the primary reasons Western Europe lost most of its forest cover. As wood became scarce, charcoal was replaced by the more difficult to extract coal and lignite.
- ianburrell 2y agoThere aren't enough trees to support industrial civilization. Britain was burning coal before the Industrial Revolution and would have quickly exhausted all land for wood. Wood is useful for other things, buildings and paper would compete with fuel. It is the same problem with turning food crops into fuel. Solar doesn't require high tech. We use solar panels cause we are good at making circuits. But solar thermal with mirrors should work for lower technology. They wouldn't have the chips for controlling mirrors, but could have some system of central control or just have people move them.
- everdrive 2y agoI'm very confused by this -- does the rate rate of carbon release matter more than the total volume? Won't the carbon in the trees eventually be released, just on a slower timeframe.
- WastedCucumber 2y agoI'm not sure what you question is getting at, but yes, the carbon will eventually be released from any wood. If wood-as-carbon-storage was going to be actively applied towards climate change, then it would be important to control the rate of released, by, for example, using the wood in buildings, burying it, or submerging it in water, so that it wouldn't decompose from fungus or termites.
- mikepurvis 2y agoSure, but it being delayed still matters a lot, particularly if it's "renewable" in the sense that trees falling into streams and being preserved underwater will be replaced over time by other trees that fall into that water on top of them. It's the same logic for construction materials. A house has dozens of trees worth of lumber in it, and that carbon is now trapped in the house for however many decades it takes until the house eventually burns down or rots. Meanwhile the trees that were cut regrew, so the total "inventory" of trapped carbon has increased. (Appreciating of course that the lifetime carbon cost of the emissions required to maintain and climate-control a house will far exceed the modest value of what is trapped in its walls, but all of this is just for the sake of argument.)
- lithocarpus 2y agoThey do, and, mostly they will eventually rot and release the carbon back - but it may take hundreds or thousands of years - if ever - for a forest to reach equilibrium where it's emitting as much as it's accumulating. One way humans can improve on this is by making charcoal out of wood and burying it or just spreading it on soil. This drastically improves the fertility of the soil improving the rate that that soil can sequester carbon by growing trees even faster, and, as long as the charcoal is mixed in soil and not in a huge dry pile on top where it might burn, this process need never reach an equilibrium and can keep accumulating more and more carbon, more and more fertility and water retention capacity, more and more abundance of food production. This is what the ancients did in making terra preta in South America and similar charcoal-infused soils that have been found all over the world. We do this where I live in California. It's a way to reduce forest fuel load while increasing carbon sequestration and fertility. Only cost is labor. It's theoretically possible to do at large scale with machinery instead of people, though the attempts I've seen have not proved viable. For a low expense human-scale way to do it, just making big piles and burning them from the top down (so no smoke) - piling more and more fuel on as it burns, and then dousing with water once it's mostly a big pile of coals, works quite well. With the addition of a big metal ring for a kiln, efficiency can go up even more from (very roughly) 50% of carbon turned to charcoal, to maybe 80 or 90%. Numbers vary considerably. But in all cases, the amount of carbon moved from the rotting or burning cycle to permanently sequestered is significant. Compared to the short term carbon sequestration of building things out of wood (99% of which will burn within a few centuries), these soils have lasted thousands of years. There must be some mechanism that will eventually recycle this carbon back to the atmosphere but it may be on the timescale of hundreds of thousands of years for most of it.
- mapt 2y agoThe question is how much of that carbon turns to methane in organic decomposition. If that fraction isn't negligible, we'd be better off burning it. Determining that fraction, across a range of conditions, is nontrivial.
- gilbetron 2y agoI still like: Grow plants/trees -> create plastics from them -> use plastics -> bury plastics forever Otherwise plants/trees are just a type of carbon battery - pull carbon, burn for fuel, carbon goes back out, gets pulled back in again.
- augusto-moura 2y agoDo we need to grow plants to create plastics anyway? Wouldn't be better to just capture co2 and convert them to plastics (or other long lifespan products) directly
- beAbU 2y agoMethinks the word "just" in "just capture CO2" is doing a lot more work than you think.
- gilbetron 2y agoAs my peer comment hinted at, I think "just capture co2" is the part that plants are really good at. However, yes, the general approach is: capture co2 -> make plastics -> use plastics -> bury plastics forever. And "capture co2" can be "grow trees" or "grow algae" or "create a machine that pulls carbon out of the air" or whatever :)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AngryData 2y agoIt does take considerable energy to capture and store that carbon when it is only a small fraction of the atmosphere. Trees may not be as energy efficient as us building a dedicated process for it, but growing trees is basically free and it isn't like we are lacking land area to do so. Farmland utilization has been dropping for many decades all across the globe, and even if that didn't happen we would still be very far from running out of suitable tree growing land since trees can grow everywhere but the harshest deserts.
- beAbU 2y agoI dont even know where to to start with the math, but I always wondered if there is not a viable carbon capture business in just growing and burying plants. Get some fast growing plant like Japanese Knotweed or bamboo, grow it out for a year, harvest and dump the biomass into a decomissioned mineshaft to minimize contact with the atmosphere. Rinse and repeat.
- anon6362 2y agoNope. Philip Mason debunked #TeamTrees as yet another, completely pointless MrBeast vibe cause. Better off with bio-CSS using GMO kelp or algae, e.g., biomass that grows faster and doesn't rot or burn.
- beAbU 2y agoI don't know what #TeamTrees is, nor do I know what MrBeast's involvement in it is. I only know _of_ MrBeast because of some workplace controversy that spilled on to the general internet recently. I also did not specifically say trees need to be used. I mentioned fast growing things like bamboo. If there is another biological organism (GMO or not) that accumulates carbon-rich biomass faster, then I'm interested in understanding how that compares to more modern CCS techniques that require electricity for example.
- 1970-01-01 2y agoYou have a good idea. Ignore the armchair idiots. Another take on this idea is using plankton that has been seeded with iron. https://www.whoi.edu/know-your-ocean/ocean-topics/climate-weather/ocean-based-climate-solutions/iron-fertilization/ https://www.whoi.edu/know-your-ocean/ocean-topics/climate-we...
- elmolino89 2y agoOne does not even need to bury anything. For example miscanthus giganteus plantation will increase carbon storage in the soil by simply increasing the mass of rhisomes and excreting various organic compounds into the soil. Obviously this has it's limits since the ground will be saturated after couple of years but it's is still a progress compared with a field with no plants.
- Nifty3929 2y agoTrees and other plant life store carbon as they grow, and release it as they decay after death. Forests will store carbon as and while they are growing, but as and when they reach a stable size they will stop storing additional carbon. That is, carbon stored by growth will equal that released by decay.
- AngryData 2y agoIt will be reduced significantly, but I wouldn't expect it to actually break even for hundreds of years atleast, if then. Some material is always going to keep getting buried deeper and deeper except for a few areas prone to very high levels of erosion.