5 ms·
Long read; these bits were notable to me: > But the insurer’s defense went even further, to the very meaning of “prior authorization,” which it had granted wom
by ceejayoz 2y ago
Long read; these bits were notable to me:
> But the insurer’s defense went even further, to the very meaning of “prior authorization,” which it had granted women like Arch to pursue surgery. The authorization, they said in court, recognized that a procedure was medically necessary, but it also contained a clause that it was “not a guarantee of payment.” Blue Cross was not obliged to pay the center anything, top executives testified. “Let me be clear: The authorization never says we’re going to pay you,” said Steven Udvarhelyi, who was the CEO for the insurer from 2016 to 2024, in a deposition. “That’s why there’s a disclaimer.
> At the trial, Blue Cross revealed that it had never considered any of the appeals — nor had it ever told the center that they were pointless. “An appeal is not available to review an underpayment,” acknowledged Paula Shepherd, a Blue Cross executive vice president. The insurer simply issued an edict — the payment was correct.
> On several occasions, though, Blue Cross executives had signed special one-time deals with the center, known as single case agreements, to pay for their wives’ cancer treatment.
- HumblyTossed 2y agoThis is the frustration that leads to getting a dictator wanna-be elected President. People are SICK SICK SICK of these shenanigans and seriously want it to change.
- quickthrowman 2y agoBut the person they voted for is normalizing these sorts of things, they voted FOR more corruption and self-dealing.
- Whoppertime 2y agoDo you mean the people who voted for Donald Trump or the people who voted for "Fire the prosecutor investigating Burisma which gave a lucrative position to Hunter Biden" or "10% for the Big Guy held by H"? Just to clarify what you're talking about when you talk about voting for more corruption and self-dealing
- quickthrowman 2y agoI mean the guy that is shaking down law firms and countries and universities and immigrants. The guy that launched a multi billion dollar pump and dump crypto scheme on the eve of his inauguration. The guy that is almost certainly selling pardons to people like the former CEO of Nikola. The guy that is possibly tipping off his friends and donors about when a tweet of his will send the stock market up 10%. I don’t give a shit about Hunter Biden, he wasn’t the president. Nepotism happens everywhere, good luck stopping it. Hunter Biden is a crackhead and shouldn’t have had the position he did, but he is a sideshow to distract you. Trump himself was impeached for withholding foreign aid from Ukraine to try and boost his reelection chances, but you conveniently left that part out. I’ll admit it was partly political, but it still happened. If the Biden family was doing corrupt things like receiving bribes, by all means prosecute them. If there’s evidence Joe Biden got kickbacks from Burisma, the DoJ should file charges. There’s not a personality cult for Biden like there is for Trump. Trying to compare an actual convicted felon who is nakedly corrupt in public vs a guy who has a few accusations is ridiculous in the same way as presenting young earth creationism as equally valid as the universe being 13.7B years old. It’s “but both sides!” at its worst. Joe Biden is no saint, he’s a politician after all, but he’s not even close to Trump. Bob Menendez (D, NJ) is much closer to Trump than Biden, he was actually tried and convicted for corruption. I’m glad he was found guilty.
- Whoppertime 2y agoWe can't prosecute the Biden family because they all got pre-emptive pardons. https://youtu.be/4EpUpC9fCSg https://youtu.be/4EpUpC9fCSg Did Trump actually withhold foreign aid from Ukraine, or did he threaten to do so? https://youtu.be/UXA--dj2-CY https://youtu.be/UXA--dj2-CY Because if it was threatening to cut funding this is a pot calling the kettle black situation https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/11/us/politics/trump-ukraine-timeline.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/11/us/politics/trump-ukraine... And checking this NYTimes timeline, they say that the funds were released on September 20th. So the funding to Ukraine was not withheld, but delayed. The exact same thing that Joe Biden was doing. Saying in all caps "It's a great time to buy" before the stock market goes up 10% isn't insider trading, it's a politician delivering on his promises immediately.
- CamperBob2 2y agoHow does electing a dictator who promises "Vote for me and I will make it worse" help, though? That's the part I don't get. If the dictator promised to round up these CEOs and send them to El Salvador without a trial, that would be one thing... but the opposite is true, and I think the electorate understood that well enough.
- beej71 2y agoSome people feel that anything different must be better. But they are unfortunately incorrect.
- HumblyTossed 2y agoBecause people are desperate for something to change. The status quo is literally killing people. I'm not saying I agree with their voting decision, but I can, in part, understand their frustration.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anderber 2y agoYou can never doubt that things can get a lot worse, no matter how bad they currently are. This is what we're finding out now.
- simonh 2y agoSo they vote for the party that eviscerated the ACA and defends the medical insurance industry. Look at Trump’s talking points. It’s all about immigrants, foreigners and wokeism that are coming to get what you have. The US is a wealthy, prosperous nation, and I think even lower income segments of the US population are aware they’re night and day better off than people in the same economic segment in the countries immigrants come from. Wanting more is part of it, but it’s mainly about not sharing what Americans have, even though it’s not actually under threat. That doesn’t matter, people still feel threatened. I’m a Brit. My mother is a wealthy middle class retired woman in a safe idyllic bit of countryside, but she is utterly obsessed with foreigners coming to rape and steal and destroy British society. They’re all coming to get us. She reads in the papers (The Daily Mail) and sees it on TV (GB News) every day.
- throwawaysleep 2y agoSo they vote for the shenanigans? As that’s what they did. The American people basically legalized fraud and looting for the next four years.
- api 2y agoThey vote for the person who is not saying "we will continue business as usual," which has been the Democrat message. The Democrats have succeeded at suppressing the populist wing of their party, which led to them being defeated by the populist wing of the Republican Party.
- Whoppertime 2y agoPeople wouldn't be saying "they basically legalized fraud and looting for the next four years" if Bernie Sanders was President. People don't really see the populist left and populist right the same way.
- api 2y agoSanders was not a choice. I didn’t vote for Trump but I get it and him winning doesn’t surprise me.
- salawat 2y agoAnd whose fault is that? The DNC's. You had a man explicitly calling out so much of what ails this country, and instead of elevating him, they shunned him because think of the billionaire donors. FAFO of the highest order.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- LeafItAlone 2y agoWell that was very short sighted. Because the other person was clearly saying how they’d make it much much worse. But nobody had ever accused the voting public of the U.S. of being able to see the past the end of their nose. https://www.bu.edu/sph/news/articles/2024/project-2025-could-become-a-political-reality-that-would-upend-medical-practice/ https://www.bu.edu/sph/news/articles/2024/project-2025-could...
- DannyBee 2y agoFirst off, you won't convince me these folks don't belong in jail. I just dont' think anything less than serious criminal penalties is going to get us anywhere anymore. But at the same time, i guess i'll be contrarian and say the other notable bit to me is that the person wants the absolute best doctors working on her, at the absolute best place possible because they pioneered the technique. I get why. But it's not necessarily reasonable. Obviously, if her cases needs that, she should get it. But it's really unclear from the article - is her case one that any competent surgeon could do, or only these surgeons can do. It does say they pioneered one technique, but that doesn't mean they are the only ones who do it or are good at it. She just says "i want the people who teach other people working on me", which certainly resonates with lots of people (i'm sure that's why it's there), but also, probably too high of a standard? In the end - the absolute best of everything is expensive. Very expensive. I doubt a system can afford to have that happen for everyone, even if the insurers were not evil fraudsters. So even if we ever fix the insurer side, I think we will also have to fix the patient expectation side around standards of care.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> First off, you won't convince me these folks don't belong in jail. I just dont' think anything less than serious criminal penalties is going to get us anywhere anymore. Agreed. Company wise, I’d like to see these things handled like the FDIC handles a bank failure. The Feds come in, wipe out upper management, and have another org take over as caretaker. Otherwise these fines just get paid out of increased premiums. Which probably makes the folks responsible giggle as they immediately go and do the same thing again.
- spicymaki 2y agoI would have agreed with the caretakers proposal a year ago. However you can see how it could be abused. Even jail as a remedy is precarious these days.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoBusiness penalties shouldn't be fines but partial government ownership. This 1. hits the management/owners but in a way in keeping with the benefits/protections that corporation provide (government isn't directly coming after owners/management) so we keep a 'do business' friendly regulatory environment. Owners are simply diluted with less ownership and management now have the government operating from within giving the government more visibility. 2. Over time, companies that continue to break the law become government owned. Additional fine percentages should be on a increasing scale. There needs to be rules about ownership and a time period they are held so the government doesn't just seize business but the current corporate fine structure simply doesn't work.
- game_the0ry 2y ago> On several occasions, though, Blue Cross executives had signed special one-time deals with the center, known as single case agreements, to pay for their wives’ cancer treatment. Just when I thought healthcare reached new lows... Wow. Just wow.
- Loughla 2y ago>pay for their wives’ cancer treatment. Fuck. These. Monsters. Fuck them and their friends and family. Fuck them to the moon and back. Fuck them until humans evolve to the point that we don't have genitals and then find a new way to fuck them. But also how is that legal?
- gruez 2y ago>but it also contained a clause that it was “not a guarantee of payment.” Blue Cross was not obliged to pay the center anything, top executives testified. “Let me be clear: The authorization never says we’re going to pay you,” said Steven Udvarhelyi, who was the CEO for the insurer from 2016 to 2024, in a deposition. “That’s why there’s a disclaimer. That quote is far less damning when you consider the surrounding context. The reasoning he gave for why "authorization never says we’re going to pay you" is that there might be deductibles, and out of network deductibles might be higher. That seems totally reasonable to me? [1] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25882446-steven-udvarhelyi-deposition/?mode=document https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25882446-steven-udva...
- ceejayoz 2y agoIt’s damning when you read the rest of the article. You’re right about the point of the disclaimer - it was not supposed to secretly mean “lol we have no intention of paying for this ever”, but they used it that way. > They acknowledged that the disclaimer was not meant as a general excuse to free the company from paying bills. A prior authorization “usually” resulted in a payment, testified Brower, who reviewed the center’s bills. He said that the notice was intended for specific situations. For instance, Blue Cross would not cover a woman who dropped out of her insurance before the operation. Nor would it pay anything if a patient had not met her deductible. But otherwise, Brower said, Blue Cross intended to compensate for a procedure that it had authorized. “It’s inappropriate for us as a company to approve a code and then turn around and deny it,” Brower said.
- gruez 2y ago>it was not supposed to secretly mean “lol we have no intention of paying for this ever”, but they used it that way. Are you talking about the "Targeted Provider List"? The article says: >The blocked list meant that each bill from the center received a manual scrub by payment specialists before reimbursement. That's not the same as “lol we have no intention of paying for this ever”.
- ceejayoz 2y ago