5 ms·
It's still an advertising company you're doing business with. I mean, would you buy cookies from a brand that is known for producing rodenticides?
by amelius 2y ago
It's still an advertising company you're doing business with.
I mean, would you buy cookies from a brand that is known for producing rodenticides?
- crazygringo 2y ago...yes? I mean, the company that makes Raid also makes Saran Wrap and Ziploc bags. Corporate conglomerates can do lots of things. The entire Google Cloud org is funded by regular customers paying money, not advertising.
- righthand 2y ago> The entire Google Cloud org is funded by regular customers paying money That can’t be true, how did they bootstrap it? How do they pay for R & D for their half baked offerings?
- wiseowise 2y agoDidn’t they start it for themselves and then saw an opportunity to make it a business? In a sense, yes, it was bootstrapped by ads and now pays for itself.
- surajrmal 2y agoWould you prefer VCs to have fronted the money to bootstrap it? How is it relevant today if ads are no longer enabling their financial viability? Ads largely finance Google's consumer offerings, not their enterprise offerings. Most enterprise Google customers understand the difference.
- tfsh 2y agoI don't think you're wanting to converse in good faith, but on the off chance this is a question - yes, GCP was revenue losing for a number of years, but since Q1 2023 they've been profitable. It takes money to bootstrap anything - obviously - this is the case for the vast majority of companies and their offerings, especially so for one which requires vast amounts of compute resources, SREs, legal, etc.
- righthand 2y agoSo just to clarify the entire cloud org was funded by advertisers for most of it’s existence.
- azinman2 2y agoWhat’s the problem? Google is trying to diversify their revenue streams. I don’t understand the relevance. Apple TV+ is paid for by iPhones. Ok? And?
- righthand 2y ago> Ok? And? This is a thread about using your money for better things than paying an ad company. The comment that started this argument you want to have pointed out that it’s self sustaining. But I pointed out that wasn’t always true. Tfsh backed my claim. So today maybe there isn’t a problem to which your money isn’t being spent with the ad org but it was that way for a very long time to which we can grant the OP some grace as it’s a rather recent change. There is even still an argument to be made that while you may not be giving money to the ad org you are still giving money to Google thereby helping them deflect the damage they cause the world in their other orgs.
- crazygringo 2y agoNo, even if you were Google Cloud paying customer #1, your money was going to Cloud. It wasn't supporting anything to do with ads. The ads were providing income to Google which allowed Google to bootstrap Cloud until it was profitable on its own, not vice-versa. When you buy (or bought) Cloud services, that doesn't affect Google's ad revenue or advertising behavior at all, not for the better and not for the worse. They're basically unrelated orgs within the corporation. Using Cloud isn't promoting ads or whatever you seem to think, not now and not previously.
- righthand 2y agoBut it’s not about killing Google’s ad revenue, it’s about hurting Google as a whole. It’s a complete monster, regardless how many heads the hydra has.
- NicuCalcea 2y agoI buy Lidl store brand biscuits as well as Lidl store brand cleaning products, among many other things, so I guess I would.
- rafaelmn 2y agoLidl produces none of those, just brands them. More comparable would be something like Raid cookies I guess
- sahila 2y agoDidn't google just buy deepmind and rebrand it too?
- tomschwiha 2y agoLidl produces a lot of products on their own, as well as packaging (Schwarz Produktion) [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarz_Group https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarz_Group
- paxys 2y agoGoogle Cloud had $50B in revenue last year, so clearly plenty of companies didn't get your memo.