10 ms·
How many supernova explode every year?
- didgetmaster 2y agoTwo questions come to mind. 1) When was the last supernova observed in our own galaxy? 2) How close would one have to be to be observed with the naked eye?
- ardel95 2y ago1604. One could say we are overdue. I’m not sure about dust or other obstacles blocking it, but based on brightness alone a supernova in our galaxy should be visible with naked eye.
- ahazred8ta 2y ago1604? Sort of; SN 1987A was visible to the naked eye at 3rd magnitude. It was in the Large Magellanic Cloud, which is almost in our galaxy but not quite. 170k light years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SN_1987A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SN_1987A
- darthrupert 2y agoThe whole things seems like such a massive living system that I cannot help guessing that what we think of as universe is just a somewhat large single creature.
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoIt's an appealing idea, but surely there'd be insurmountable problems with the distance/time involved for any part to communicate to another part? It'd be like trying to run a computer with a clock that takes millions (billions?) of years to make a single tick. I just don't see that it's at all feasible and that's without even trying to guess as to how different parts can change behaviour depending on its environment (one commonly used requirement of "life").
- tialaramex 2y ago> a clock that takes millions (billions?) of years to make a single tick Much worse than that, the universe is enormous and it is expanding faster than the maximum possible velocity, as a result such a clock could never complete a single tick.
- dkersten 2y agoWhat’s wrong with it taking a billion of our years to tick? Just because we, smaller than microscopic beings compared to the size of the larger structures we observe, find it to be a vastly long time, doesn’t mean that it’s a long time for something the size of the observable universe. For a single bacteria cell, our timeframes must seem immense too. I’m not saying it’s particularly likely, but it’s a trap to think that just because you can’t fathom the scales that makes it impossible. The universe is huge and very very old. It can afford to wait what is a long time to us for something to happen. I do think you’re likely right in practice though, and that it is too long for the universe to be an organism. But who knows. We already know that mathematically speaking the heat death of the universe looks identical to a very zoomed in big bang, maybe we just need to zoom out a few billion orders of magnitude to see the big picture, where the vast distances and time scales we see appear as little more than micrometers and microseconds apart…
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoThe problem with zooming out is that the speed of light sets a specific size/time scale so the more zoomed out you get, the more disconnected the big picture is. The observable universe is a mere 93 billion light-years across, so there's a limit on how far it makes sense to talk about zooming out. Also, with the universe expanding, the observable size will reduce over a long time period. The scales involved are vastly different than the minor difference in scales between bacteria and us - we don't have to worry about the speed of light for anything that we currently consider alive.
- mrep 2y ago> The observable universe is a mere 93 billion light-years across As a non-astronomer, that number still always boggles my mind. > Also, with the universe expanding, the observable size will reduce over a long time period. Also boggles my mind. Also makes me think of doctor who when the stars start disappearing. I need to rewatch that...
- Cyphase 2y agoThis reminds me of this quote from Jill Tarter of SETI, specifically the last sentence: “Might it be the discovery of a distant civilization and our common cosmic origins that finally drives home the message of the bond among all humans? Whether we’re born in San Francisco or Sudan or close to the heart of the Milky Way Galaxy, we are the products of a billion-year lineage of wandering stardust. We, all of us, are what happens when a primordial mixture of hydrogen and helium evolves for so long that it begins to ask where it came from.” source: https://www.ted.com/talks/jill_tarter_join_the_seti_search https://www.ted.com/talks/jill_tarter_join_the_seti_search (@ 3:02)
- jajko 2y agoToo idealistic view on human nature. We discovered vastly different cultures in the past, no hint of humility (rather exact opposite) or bonding, unless we find a common enemy.
- Wobbles42 2y agoTaken cynically though, is this quote not simply describing the ultimate common enemy?
- yieldcrv 2y agoI think this is not too difficult for humans to comprehend, it just doesn't address the resource appropriation and geographic property claims on this planet. Aside from generational interest, conflict areas tend to have something obviously appealing about them, so there's nothing that a bigger picture nihilism helps with.
- SwtCyber 2y agoThere's something kinda poetic (and maybe even logical) about the idea that what we perceive as scattered galaxies and physics is actually just the internal processes of something far bigger than we can comprehend.
- jxf 2y agoPoetic, or maybe Lovecraftian. A lot of "cosmic horror" has the trope of vastnesses too big to comprehend, where even trying to think about it (or in some cases merely learning of the possibility) causes you to go mad.
- SwtCyber 2y agoIt's like the deeper we peer into reality, the more it starts to look like fiction we were never meant to read.
- ravetcofx 2y agoSome might call that God. Or at least some form of Pantheism
- aoeusnth1 2y agoWell, if physicalism is true then consciousness is a phenomenon of quantum fields, which span the universe. So yes, stretching the definition of creature, this could be interpreted as literally true.
- selectnull 2y agoAstronomers will find out that naming is hard once they need to name 119741st supernova.
- pelagicAustral 2y agoI think it will be far before that, once they start hitting supernovae name jackpots like SN2026 cu*t et al.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- selectnull 2y agoI know :) This one was just the first to came to mind.
- drbig 2y agoThe universe is vast and full of nothing... Which in case of explodey stars is a very good thing indeed!
- subscribed 2y agoIt's fun to think that at some point it will be actually vast and completely dark
- jvm___ 2y agohttps://youtu.be/uD4izuDMUQA?si=LcVxE3w-ohGqZAr7 https://youtu.be/uD4izuDMUQA?si=LcVxE3w-ohGqZAr7 If you need some existential dread. It's a hypothetical video to portray the rest of the universe, the time speed moving forward doubles every 5 seconds - and it's 29 minutes long...
- Obscurity4340 2y agoReally incredible video, thanks a quadrillion
- rbanffy 2y agoWe have a couple trillion years to figure out a way to fix that.
- frainfreeze 2y agoDoes it need fixing?
- rbanffy 2y agoSince I'd like to live forever, then yes.
- db48x 2y agoWhat you really want to do is put out the stars sooner then, and feed all the hydrogen into the supermassive black hole at the center of the galaxy. Dump in all the mass in the galaxy and all of its satellites and everything from Andromeda and its satellites too and it will grow. Nudge Andromeda’s central black hole into orbit around ours so that they merge, etc, etc. Grow it big enough and and you can build a Birch World around it, with a surface area larger than all the planets in those galaxies put together. All of the exploration with none of the boring travel in between interesting places! You can seed it with life from every planet your civilization ever encountered and watch all those ecosystems compete and hybridize as you while away the years. How many years would you have? While dumping matter into a black hole destroys the matter, it doesn’t destroy the mass. It just confines all of the mass in one place. Powering your Birch World is just a matter of using the Penrose process to extract energy from the black hole for the next few million trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion years (about 3×10¹⁰⁴ years give or take a few). The stars will only last for about a million trillion years (10²⁰ years plus or minus a bit), so this plan extends your your lifetime by a factor of a trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion years. Maximal extension perhaps, but not quite forever. Forever takes a lot more work.
- roenxi 2y agoWe're dealing with the sum total of everything, if the true nature of things is that there are a finite number of supernovas I'd be surprised. The real shock is how small the number of supernovas is and how young everything seems to be in the known universe (the age of the observed universe is estimated at maybe double digit billion years). These are tiny numbers given that we're quite possibly dealing with infinity in both time and space. I judge it one of the stronger arguments in favour of the universe being constructed (or, more likely, there is a lot out there we can't see). If god built a universe numbers like 1 supernova a century make some sense for artistic value.
- eurekin 2y agoIsn't the observable universe finite? There can't be a infinite number of anything in a space of radius R, even if R is very big.
- chasil 2y agoAnything moving beyond the Cosmological Horizon can no longer be seen. As I understand it, a frozen image will remain for a time and fade, growing increasingly red shifted. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon
- foxglacier 2y agoYou can't compare a number of years or events with infinity. Saying it's tiny or huge makes no sense whatsoever. What amazes me is how young the universe is compared to life. The universe is only about 4 times as old as life on Earth.
- roenxi 2y agoThe comparison can be made; almost all positive integers can't practically be represented in hindu-arabic because they are too large. If we're dealing with numbers that can be scribed in a few seconds they are small in a meaningful way. We'd expect that the mathematicians would need to come up with a new notation to represent the age of the universe.
- jampekka 2y agoI couldn't spot the supernova and there's no answer to where it is. :'(
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoIt's in NGX 1566
- pansa2 2y agoBottom-left corner
- dwighttk 2y agoCross your eyes and lay the two images over each other and it pops out (bottom left of the ring)
- tialaramex 2y agoThat's one of my favourite hints in Outer Wilds. You will see a Supernova. Not with a fancy telescope, it's visible to the naked eye, and if you watch the sky you'll see another soon enough. You can see this right at the start, and unlike the random direction of the probe launch you don't need any game lore to, if you're smart enough, put two and two together.
- SwtCyber 2y agoHonestly one of those rare games that makes you feel like a real explorer, not just someone following a path the devs laid out.
- danso 2y agoTruly one of the most purest of video games in terms of player freedom, I’m still sad that I didn’t think to record my own playthrough as everyone’s path of discovery is more or less unique. The freeform gameplay and incredible ending makes OW easily my pick for best game of all time, even though it’s also my least replayed favorite game.
- SwtCyber 2y agoIt's like a memory you treasure instead of an experience you repeat
- RicoElectrico 2y ago[flagged]
- delusional 2y agoHUGE SPOILER ALERT. SERIOUSLY, PLAY OUTER WILDS. It's a little more than just " the sun will also go supernova". The core conceit of the games story is that you're living in the final moments of dying universe.
- 2y ago
- deadbabe 2y agoCan the thread title be rewritten to be less obnoxious? “How many supernova explode every year?” is fine. This isn’t Reddit. Thread titles should not imply some kind of personality or use cliche meme speak. The all caps is definitely an abomination.
- fooker 2y agoPlease read the article along with bikeshedding titles. It's a good one.
- bonoboTP 2y agoThe article itself is also written in that kind of quirky meme personality tone. I guess some find it relatable and humorous. Others (like me) find it obnoxious. Matter of taste or perhaps of age bracket. This is the text version of "Youtube voice", which is also evidently successful but not all like it.
- deadbabe 2y agoNo. The title sounds like low effort clickbait trash.
- 9rx 2y agoClickbait is appealing. This sounds like the opposite.
- Timwi 2y agoAgree. For the record (in case it gets changed), the title at time of writing is “Wait. HOW MANY supernova explode every year?”.
- herendin2 2y agoIf I got the math right, then about 1 in every 32,000 stars in the universe goes supernova each year. That's scary. But I think I'm getting the math very wrong. edit: I guess my error might be related to confusing a probability factor with the number of incidents in a period. edit: The right answer is probably up to 1 in every 10bn stars go supernovae in the universe each year (or 1 in 10bn die and a fraction are supernovae). Thanks: yzydserd and zild3d
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Someone 2y ago> If got the math right, then about 1 in every 32,000 stars in the universe goes supernova each year Can’t be right, can it? It would make the Sun (over 4 billion years old) an enormous outlier. It also would mean stars, on average, do not get very old. Over 10% of the stars that the ancient Greeks saw in the sky would have to have gone supernova since then.
- herendin2 2y ago> Can’t be right, can it? It would make the Sun (over 4 billion years old) an enormous outlier. Yes. That fact that I'm thinking made me think I was certainly wrong
- crag-jene 2y agoNot all stars can go supernova. Sol will never go supernova. Only very massive stars can—or stars that become very massive by absorbing other stars.
- btilly 2y agoBinary white dwarf systems can also go supernova, even if the combined mass is not that large as far as stars go.
- zild3d 2y agoHe mentioned a rough estimate of one per century per galaxy. Estimate for average stars per galaxy is 100 million, which would be 1 in 10 billion stars every year
- dr_dshiv 2y agoThe most stars a person can see with the naked eye? About 8000. And, less than half that, actually — since we can’t see the other side of the hemisphere
- SwtCyber 2y agoAbsolutely mind-blowing how much our ability to observe the universe has exploded
- a3w 2y agoexploded, he-he.
- Wobbles42 2y agoArguably, our ability to observe in any meaningful sense is still limited to light waves occuring inside a volume not much larger than the earth itself. I mean this in more than just a semantic sense surrounding the verb "observe" -- for all practical purposes everything outside of our solar system is indistinguishable from a preprogrammed light show being projected on a sphere centered on our sun with a diameter of less than a light year. There is a decent chance that will never change. The sheer size of the universe traps us in the ultimate version of Plato's cave.
- SwtCyber 2y agoBut at the same time, it's wild what we can infer from just those shadows
- layer8 2y agoNow many minds per second does it blow?
- thih9 2y ago> [Supernova discovery statistics for 2021] says there were 21,081 supernovae seen in 2021 > When the Vera Rubin survey telescope goes online, it’s expected to see hundreds of thousands of supernovae per year by itself.
- whoisthemachine 2y agoMaybe they will have to transition from Base 26 counting to Base 64!
- IggleSniggle 2y agoIt's in the article. SN2067aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa vs SN2067aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa. Apparently astronomers find base26 very straightforward and reasonable!
- IggleSniggle 2y agoAlso, as a cousin comment alludes to, for there to be one of the above supernovae, there will also be a supernova named SN2067iamsoverystupidoopssorry and a SN2067thisnamingschemawasabadidea
- bee_rider 2y agoI guess we’re already hitting four letter words, was there a supernova “butt” last year?
- moron4hire 2y agoNo, but there was an "AHOY" https://www.wis-tns.org/object/2024ahoy https://www.wis-tns.org/object/2024ahoy
- bronson 2y agoNo, but this is close: https://www.wis-tns.org/object/2024ass https://www.wis-tns.org/object/2024ass
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoNo wonder the Millennium Falcon takes so longer to calculate its jump to hyperspace. Tens of thousands a year is one an hour! There are so many supernovae you really could bounce too close to one and that would end your trip real quick
- ninkendo 2y agoStar Wars takes place entirely within one galaxy, and the number of supernova per galaxy is something like 1 per century, so, nah, Han was just bullshitting to stall for time while his busted-ass computer cobbled together numbers.
- IggleSniggle 2y agoNot only that, it happened a long long time ago. I'm no astronomer; would that be more or less supernovae?
- Wobbles42 2y agoIndeed. They didn't say it happened an "int" time ago. They didn't even say a "long" time ago. They said a "long long" time. I'd have to pull up a copy of the C standard to be sure, but even if the units of "time" are plank times, I suspect the implications could easily be that the story occurs before the big bang.
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoI suspect you're thinking of a double (floating point). A long long is only a 64 bit integer. 2^64 planck times is 9.9e-25 seconds. Planck times are really tiny. 2^64 nanoseconds is 584 years.
- Wobbles42 2y agoOh, you're right! I do remember doing this calculation with integers at some point. I might have been using something like a UUID as my bitfield length. The context was timestamps -- I (playfully) figured out how many bits we'd need to count Planck times before the expected heat death of the universe, thus being truly future proof. I was expecting the answer to be a rediculous number, but in fact it was more in the "not efficient, but definitely feasible" range. Floating point gets us there too, of course, but it has its own drawbacks and it isn't nearly as funny.
- henryway 2y agoSounds like he was caught beneath landslide, in a champagne supernova… a champagne supernova in the sky
- croes 2y agoWas surprised by the „Und so weiter“ in the text.
- weard_beard 2y agoDas ist mir Wurst
- nashashmi 2y agoAnd just when we add that variable to our formula we can finally teleport ourselves on to hyperspace.
- ben_w 2y agoHmm… So that's cool, but now I'm thinking: the distant galaxies are redshifted and time-dilated in equal proportion, and also more densly packed because the universe was smaller in the past, so I expect the actual rate of supernovas to be significantly smaller than simply multiplying 1/century/galaxy by 1e11 galaxies. Edit: also I don't know if rate of supernovas changes over history thanks to different steller environments giving the population-1/2/3 generations of stars…
- wolfram74 2y agoI would imagine the supernova rate to be higher in the early universe, as we've already passed peak stellar formation rates and the heavier (and shorter lived) stars were more likely to be formed earlier when the average density of the universe was higher.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ls612 2y agoIt probably isn't wildly lower today, we know of at least five or six big supernovae in the Milky Way in the past millennium. For 200B stars in our galaxy the size normalized rate implied by that would be like one ever 300 years. So if you extrapolated the Milky Way alone in (cosmological) modernity you would get 10/sec not 30/sec.
- btilly 2y agoThere is dust between us and most stars in the Milky Way that blocks them from view in visible light. Therefore we can only see a fraction of the supernovae in the Milky Way. It is substantially easier for us to see supernovae in other galaxies that we're not facing edge-on. And we have a large sample size of such galaxies. That's why our best estimates of supernovae frequency are based on observations of such galaxies, and not on our observations of the Milky Way.
- rookderby 2y agoFirst off, dont look at the outer wilds discussion on here, just play the game. Second - they didnt say how many letters we need to encode all of the observable supernova in a given year! So 100 billion galaxies, 1 per year per galaxy, we have around 1 billion to encode. Sorry two edits this moring, first one was right. due to math without coffee. 1e9/26^6 is about 3, 1e9/26^7 is less than one. So we might see 'SN2050aaaaaah'!
- danso 2y agoLOL just started replaying OW for the first time in years, and my immediate reaction to seeing this headline was to go to the comments and make an OW reference
- criddell 2y agoI bought Outer Wilds based on recommendations like yours and I found it kind of boring. The world is mostly empty and the repetitiveness wore me down. I didn't finish it. It's a great looking game though and the first hour or two I had a blast.
- packetlost 2y agoSame here. I found the controls to be frustrating and the game-play loop to be kinda dull. The story on the other hand, is very good. I get that the game-play is meant to illicit certain feelings, but it just didn't do it for me. I did enjoy reading a synopsis of the story on the wiki though.
- shhsshs 2y agoQuestion for you and commenter above, do you play games with controls similar to Outer Wilds often? Do you play many games in general? I've seen this comment a few times and I'm curious why this is such a common talking point. I thought the controls were very intuitive, so I'm curious if it's a familiarity issue or something else.
- 2y ago
- ur-whale 2y agoSpoiler alert: > THIRTY SUPERNOVAE PER SECOND, over the entire observable Universe.
- Wobbles42 2y agoIf we have events occuring at some rate in the entire observable universe, and that rate is one a human can easily visualize (e.g. "30"), then the answer to the question "how often do supernovas occur" is probably best summarized as "almost never".
- belter 2y agoThe SuperNova Early Warning System (SNEWS): https://snews2.org/ https://snews2.org/ brings together the fantastic [1] Super-Kamiokande, the [2] IceCube, and other global detectors, to provide early warning of Supernovas. You can subscribe... https://snews2.org//alert-signup/ https://snews2.org//alert-signup/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super-Kamiokande https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super-Kamiokande [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IceCube_Neutrino_Observatory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IceCube_Neutrino_Observatory
- croisillon 2y agomaybe some Supernova-Names get deleted, like SN2021acab?
- jxf 2y agoI think this says less about supernovas and a lot more about how staggeringly, incomprehensibly vast the observable universe it.
- daxfohl 2y agoOr how small we are
- BitwiseFool 2y agoIt would be a tragic shame for life to inhabit such a vast universe only for faster than light travel to be impossible.
- fourthark 2y agoUnless it keeps civilizations safe from each other.
- sexy_seedbox 2y agoNow let us all stop thinking about the incomprehensible and go back to providing value to our shareholders.
- coryfklein 2y agoNear the top he shows two photos of the Cartwheel galaxy, one from 2014 and one from 2021 with the caption: > Can you spot Supernova 2021 axdf? Are you supposed to be able to spot the supernova? All I've noticed is a couple of small stars that disappear in the latter photo, but this mostly seems to be because it's more blurry.
- kakuri 2y agoI really feel like this article should also mention the rate of formation of new stars. According to [1] Universe Magazine the James Webb telescope has revealed that more than 3,000 stars are formed every second. [1] https://universemagazine.com/en/james-webb-comes-closer-to-revealing-the-main-mystery-of-the-stars-birth/ https://universemagazine.com/en/james-webb-comes-closer-to-r...
- Taek 2y agoI don't understand this comment. Like yes, 3000 stars per second, cool fact. But why would that fact make sense in the article? The article was about being surprised by the name "SN 2021 afdx", which has nothing to do with star formation. In my opinion the article was great and is also complete. More cool astronomy facts belong in some other article or format.
- dgs_sgd 2y agoBecause the amount of stars that can go supernova is limited by how many stars there are in the first place? A comment about the staggering rate of star formation makes sense to me in relation to an article about the staggering rate of star supernovas..
- citizenpaul 2y agoBased on this about 5.5 million stars are created every 30 minutes and only about 1 start goes supernova in the same period? This seems like it really reinforces the we are still in the early stages of the universe theory if the ratios are that imbalanced. Still though the imbalance in those events makes me suspicious that we are missing something.
- BobAliceInATree 2y agoThe vast majority of stars don't supernova. Also, we're at the tail end of star-forming era. about 95% of all the stars that will be formed, have already been formed. https://www.scientificamerican.com/blog/life-unbounded/the-stars-are-beginning-to-go-out/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/blog/life-unbounded/the-s...
- 28374654 2y ago[flagged]
- jl6 2y agoAh, the good old column naming convention from MS Excel. Now there’s an amazing creation that occasionally explodes catastrophically.
- state_less 2y agoReminds me of the last lines of the diamond sutra. > So you should view this fleeting world— A star at dawn, a bubble in a stream, A flash of lightning in a summer cloud, A flickering lamp, a phantom, and a dream.
- rwky 2y agoThis reminds me of a few years ago when I was doing my MSc our group was learning how to work one of the remote telescopes and we were asked to point it at the brightest object found by Gaia that week and it turned out to be a supernova. Very cool for your first observation using a remote telescope! If anyone wants to see it here it is https://ibb.co/Kzqbfq30 https://ibb.co/Kzqbfq30 And here is the Gaia data http://gsaweb.ast.cam.ac.uk/alerts/alert/Gaia23bqb/ http://gsaweb.ast.cam.ac.uk/alerts/alert/Gaia23bqb/
- fswd 2y agoI've seen two super nova in my life time. once in 2008 and another in 2012