6 ms·
ESA has a commercial launch strategy, but will member states pay?
- anovikov 2y agoIf it was an actual commercial strategy, private investors would pay. If the question is even put this way, this is bullshit and deserves to end nowhere.
- daeken 2y agoYou misunderstand the use of "commercial" here. This isn't about private corporations launching their payloads for commerce, it's about private (commercial) entities providing launch services to the ESA and other public space exploration orgs.
- perihelions 2y ago- "The top factors ESA will consider in this first phase of the challenge are each proposer's business plan, technical credibility, and financial credibility." The grand European strategy is... to task government bureaucrats to review startups' business plans?? This is going to so predictably lead to more of the same—the creation of companies optimized for writing proposals, and for pleasing bureaucrats. - "ESA also isn't setting requirements on launcher performance, reusability, or..." That they're still ambivalent whether they should pursue reusability or not shows how hopelessly unprepared they are.
- rapsey 2y ago> This is going to so predictably lead to more of the same—the creation of companies optimized for writing proposals, and for pleasing bureaucrats. The european way. I wonder if the bureaucrats even know this is the inevitable result or if it is the actual plan. Probably just the result of them not knowing any other way of working and forcing it onto everyone they interact with.
- 9dev 2y agoI would love to disagree, but after being involved with Gaia X… they cannot even pin down what Gaia X is, even when prompted to. It’s something about a standard for creating standards for a European cloud, but by now we’re several years and even more meta layers in, millions have been spent, and… nothing has come out of it. It feels like the EU could be so much, if only other people were steering it.
- thawawaycold 2y agolol you don't know the half of it. Working with ESA for anything but the most trivial project is beyond frustrating; it's basically 99% about producing swathes of documentation, which in itself is more akin to philosophy and semantic dissertations over obscure standards than actual technical work. ESA is so risk averse that it's even weird for a space company
- prettyeyes83 2y agoagreed, but what would you argue are the reasons for this mindset? i imagine the main cause is structural, ie. having to deal with all the member states?
- rapsey 2y agoA bureaucrat is not allowed to spend money on anything risky and must never allow for money to be used on something other than the intended use. So the entire process must be micromanaged to death with documentation, which results in the money mostly being spent on the documentation.
- thawawaycold 2y agonot just the members states but also all the other behemoths stakeholders like Airbus, Thales, OHB and so on, which need to make sure that new missions are as easy to adapt to their preexisting flight heritage as possible
- mauriciolange 2y agoA good counterexample is the Arctic Weather Satellite project. It was defined as a new space process at ESA, so documentation required was reduced at the minimum, and risk acceptance was increased. Absolutely successful, on time, on budget, contractors happy, end users happy. But it is a small project and still difficult to replicate at large and to spread the mindset to other sections at ESA. Source: me. I work at that project as ground segment engineer.
- throw84848484 2y ago[flagged]
- arlort 2y ago> to review startups' business plans How exactly do you imagine a government contract working if it's not reviewed before being granted? > That they're still ambivalent whether they should pursue reusability or not So they shouldn't verify if a proposal is credible because that's too much bureaucracy but they should dictate to the companies how they want to approach the problem rather than letting each company make their own plans and see who comes up with the best proposal?
- rapsey 2y agoThe government should be a regulator and set ground rules. It should provide a market and clear requirements. Then leave private business alone to meet those requirements. If they need funding, leave the business to the VC industry.
- jeeeb 2y agoThey’re offering to fund 160 million euros to bootstrap private enterprises providing launch services to the ESA. Of course they want to review the business plan to make sure it’s viable before dropping a bundle of government money on some random company.
- ghaff 2y agoTo compare, meanwhile Astra just $80 million to relaunch (so to speak).
- rapsey 2y agoWhich is completely the wrong way of doing it. They are the market. So define it and leave it to private industry to fund and develop the capabilities to meet their requirements. If they say, we are willing to spend X amount of money on Y number of launches. You can rent our launch sites for tests. Here is a list of requirements. They would see incredible results. But no europe must micromanage and do things in their own bureaucratic way that has always failed.
- croes 2y ago
- jandrewrogers 2y ago“we will continue doing the thing we have always done despite decades of evidence it won’t produce the thing we claim it will produce” At some point, they need to adopt a different strategy. It feels like every European strategy is optimized for the comfort of bureaucrats rather than actual results.
- rapsey 2y agoA bureaucracy can not simplify itself. It is a complex system that can only go one way, ever more complex, until it deadlocks and eventually someone burns it to the ground and starts anew.
- DeathArrow 2y agoWhen you task bureaucrats to lead the economy, science, technology, research and development it is not going to end well. Soviet Union and other communist countries tried it and failed. If you want something to be economically viable, you should create economic incentives, reduce regulation and reglementation and let private enterprises compete. US had an entirely different vision of the economy and private sector and that's why it succeeded in many areas.
- 9dev 2y agoIt’s all trade offs, though. The US has vast problems with identity theft, fraud, and perverse privacy violations, because there is no regulation in that area. The market will only care about profits, and not the humans on whose backs these profits are materialised. There must be something in between these extremes on the spectrum.
- DeathArrow 2y ago>There must be something in between these extremes on the spectrum. That's for sure. We should take what was proved it works and adjust it to our conditions.
- rapsey 2y agoYou can take examples of working systems and adapt what works and discard what doesn't. Europe has spent decades and trillions on programs that do not work and produce nothing but word documents. With no sign of anyone acknowledging the poor results of these programs. Since I can't post on this thread anymore I will edit. I am talking about what this thread is about. Misguided and poorly designed industrial development programs that Europe has wasted trillions on with nothing to show for it. Not criticising every aspect of the EU.
- 9dev 2y agoNow that’s just hyperbole, and factually wrong, too. The EU has managed amazingly much over its existence. After WW II, it managed to keep peace, establish the worlds largest single market, enabled free trade, allowed citizens to move, live, and even work in any member state; it implemented regulation that makes food, drinks, and products some of the safest to consume and use on earth; it devised standards that are globally adhered to; it funds art, research, and urban development across all member states (as the Brits painfully realised); it distributes wealth in Europe, making the union stronger overall; and that’s just a small sample. There’s lots of things in dire need for improvement for sure, but downright dismissing the EU as having achieved nothing is just spite and not helpful. That attitude got the Americans where they are now, and I sure don’t want to go there.
- rich_sasha 2y agoMeta; US produces well funded startups presumably because the exits are good. Investors don't mind the risk, expecting an outsized return. Exits are good, perhaps, because US stock valuations are just much better. Investors are happy buying at a higher P/E ratio, expecting it to go up in even further, and make a good return. Now, for a long time, there has been talk of US equities being woefully overvalued. Of course a value is only what investors are happy to pay. But supposing this is true, and US is due a major correction, Trump's "shock therapy" on markets might actually achieve it. If that's true, US valuations would drop relative to the rest of the world (this hasn't really happened yet, most of developed markets moved roughly in unison - but it's early days perhaps). If that happens, US might actually stop looking like a most attractive VC market. This would presumably lead to a general drop of VC investments - but also to a greater geographic spread in VC investments. In particular, more money going into things like European space companies, as opposed to US ones. There's a lot of assumptions here. Maybe US equities have higher valuations because they are genuinely better, or a correction won't actually come. But it always puzzles me why the US seems better at churning out well-founded startups for no totally obvious reason, and maybe that's it.
- IrishTechie 2y agoTwo factors stick out to me. Investing in the stock market is far more common in the US compared to the EU for the average person (something like 60% versus 15% of people in the EU). I imagine that has a huge impact on the amount of money sloshing around to fund companies from the top down. The EU is bigger than the US in population terms, but when it comes to raising funding for a new startup it’s hard to look far beyond the borders of your own small country for many reasons. If this could be fixed it would make a massive difference in my view. I’ve been involved in the founding of a few companies in Ireland and raising funding is tough and for all the work the figures are tiny compared to the US. You’ll likely be talking to Irish and UK investors only.
- basisword 2y ago>> Investing in the stock market is far more common in the US compared to the EU for the average person (something like 60% versus 15% of people in the EU). Is this accurate? For example, 80% of the UK has a pension and those are invested (partially) in stocks. Unsure how this works across the rest of Europe but 15% seems really low. >> The EU is bigger than the US in population terms, but when it comes to raising funding for a new startup it’s hard to look far beyond the borders of your own small country Completely agree with this. As much as the EU is a single market, in a lot of ways it falls short. Even if you're in some of the larger capitals you still end up looking for funding within your country. What do you think the solution is? Is the problem language? The completely different tax systems in each country? The spread of things (e.g. less concentration in one or two cities the way tech is in the US)?