12 ms·
Blizzard Network Breached; Change Your Battle.Net Passwords
- BadassFractal 14y agoI'm concerned that this is happening so often that it is no longer raising eyebrows. It's becoming one of those "just how things work on the Internet, get used to it".
- revx 14y agoEither that or 2-factor authentication will catch on and stealing passwords won't be worth anything.
- danielpal 14y agoTwo-factor makes more sense. Relying on your database never getting hacked is nonsense. Is not a matter of are you getting hacked but when are you going to get hacked... expect getting hacked. (disclaimer: I am the founder of Authy.com a two-factor auth API)
- NelsonMinar 14y agoBlizzard has 2 factor; the secrets for the mobile authenticator seem to have been compromised as well as the hashed passwords.
- jrockway 14y agoBut secrets for the mobile authenticator are much less sensitive than passwords, which are prone to reuse. It does, however, defeat the security advantage of two-factor authentication. (I always thought the really smart crackers would break in, modify the application code to weaken the password encryption, and then re-encrypt every password when the user logs in. Come back a few weeks later and collect a bunch of working passwords, with nobody the wiser.)
- Zenst 14y agoI suspect the quality of Pen-Testing being carried out or lack of is certianly an area of concern given the frequency.
- w1ntermute 14y agoOne of the many reasons using a password manager and having different, random passwords for each site is a good idea.
- dkokelley 14y agoI agree. As long as the password authentication mechanism is in place, unique, random, and complex passwords are the best way to secure yourself. Unless you can memorize each of these unique passwords yourself, the next best thing is to use a secure password manager program to take care of this for you.
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoI follow this in practice, but I always have to wonder: what if someone gets my password database and breaks it? It would only take a keylogging trojan to get everything they needed. I would be in for a world of hurt! Way worse than if a few of my accounts were compromised because I had used the same password. But still, the chances of being compromised are probably much smaller.
- DanBC 14y agoAs mentioned by other people in other recent threads some good quality password safe programs work with Yubikey, so an attacker needs something you know (your password) and something you have (your Yubikey). I'd be interested in seeing some robust analysis of password safe software. But "Password safe" and "keepass" appear to be reputable. I'd also like a native, and trustworthy, password safe for OS X that can work with something like Yubikey.
- BadassFractal 14y agoIs Yubikey superior to something like Keepass/Lastpass/1password?
- MiguelHudnandez 14y ago
- citricsquid 14y agoisn't it inevitable? Rogue employees, dumb mistakes, passwords will always be stolen: what's important is they're stored securely enough that when (not if) they are stolen they are worthless to the people that now hold the passwords.
- swang 14y ago"Some data was illegally accessed, including a list of email addresses for global Battle.net users, outside of China. For players on North American servers (which generally includes players from North America, Latin America, Australia, New Zealand, and Southeast Asia) the answer to the personal security question, and information relating to Mobile and Dial-In Authenticators were also accessed. Based on what we currently know, this information alone is NOT enough for anyone to gain access to Battle.net accounts." The part where it says, "answer to the personal security question" were accessed should be EXTREMELY ALARMING. This combined with an email addresses is usually enough to get your password reset on lots of sites. I believe this will reset your password on Google (assuming you're not using 2 factor).
- revx 14y agoThis is why you never use the actual answer to that question, but actually a separate password for those.
- csallen 14y agoThat wouldn't help. For example, let's assume your question was, "Who was your favorite teacher growing up?" and your answer was "fish123jellybean456". If that answer is stored in plaintext (no encryption) in a database that's compromised, then it won't matter that it's not the "real" answer. Attackers will see it, and then use it to answer your security questions on other sites. The only way to protect against this is to ensure you use different answers on different sites. Using a password instead of the correct answer to the question can be helpful, but in a totally different way. Specifically, it eliminates the risk that someone can guess (or research) the answer to your security questions.
- notJim 14y agoPresumably you would use a different answer on every site.
- drucken 14y agoFor most people savy enough to use an arbitrary answer, it is because you can use a different one each time (with the very few exceptions where you may not be able, e.g. banks). Offline portable password managers like Keepass/Password Safe/etc. are immense help for these non-bank services.
- duaneb 14y agoWhy is it OK to have the security answers not hashed? They are just secondary passwords, and there is absolutely no reason someone else needs to know it.
- dangrossman 14y agoBecause they need to do really fuzzy matching for call-in support, which is where the security question gets most used. Hashing makes that impossible and raises the average call length since the agent would have to type each response rather than simply compare to the answer on screen. No amount of normalization would make "The Blue Dragons" match "Dragons" or "Warwick Elementary School" match "Warwick", or whatever the answers to the questions are. Security questions aren't precise like passwords.
- duaneb 14y agoAlso, Blizzard has a 16-character password limit... seriously disappointing.
- Steko 14y agoBlizzard has numerous server side protections that prevent your lower case 16 character p/w from ever being brute forced. It's not that big of a deal.
- natesm 14y agoAny password length limitation (within reason, not allowing a 1MB password is reasonable) says to me "we are not using hashes". That may or may not be the actual case, but it's the only reason I can think of for limiting password length. Hashes used for passwords have fixed lengths regardless of input, so any length password will "fit" in a database column. If you're using hashes, limiting the lengths of passwords is extra work.
- Steko 14y ago"That may or may not be the actual case" It is not the actual case so I guess your blanket assumption was completely wrong.
- natesm 14y agoI'm not talking about Battle.net specifically. I'm talking about in general. That's merely the impression that a password length limit gives to me, on any site. Can you think of any another "rational" reason for limiting password length? I see two possibilities: 1. They're not using hashes. 2. They are using hashes, but they don't understand what that actually does, and that there's no reason to have a limit on input length. The passwords might be more secure, but it calls into question the general competency of their security (do they salt? per user?). This also applies to character restrictions (no ____ characters). I can understand requiring at least N instances of a class of characters, but the entire UTF-8 character set should be valid input. If I want an emoji password, there's no reason to disallow it. bcrypt will be happy to take those bytes. So, here's a comparison of site purposes and security practices. This is largely unrelated, but it gives better insight as to what I was talking about, not just making a random assumption about Battle.net (which I theoretically have an account at, but I don't really care about it anymore, I don't play video games anymore). Chase is a bank. They handle money. They allow up to 32 character passwords, with no "special" (whatever that means) characters whatsoever. Twitter is a social networking site. I have a 50 character password of various character types, because that's how far 1Password will go. Bank of America is also a bank. Twenty characters. Twenty. Characters. And none of those are allowed to be "special". Facebook is user for the same purpose Twitter. I have a 50 character password there as well. Why do I trust social sites more than my banks? Security is so messed up.
- DigitalSea 14y agoThis is ridiculous. Maybe the world is ending, because it feels like every major website/provider of some popular service is getting hacked these days. A company of Blizzard's stature and wallet size has no excuse for this kind of thing happening, no excuse at all. If you're charging people exorbitant amounts of cash to buy your games and then charging some of your customers a fee for the privilege of using your so-called "secure" servers every month then you should be providing a certain level of security in return, it's not rocket science - employ someone who knows how to secure a server. This is certainly not limited to Blizzard, it seems like everyday there is a new story about some kind of security breach and then we're told to change our passwords and some details may have been stolen. As an owner of both Starcraft 2 and Diablo III and I am heavily disappointed especially considering how much I paid for both of those games here in Australia (bought digitally as well).
- zheng 14y agoBlizzard operates in a free market. Average consumers don't care that much about security until something happens, then they forget. Therefore, security isn't a priority to Blizzard. It is really as simple as that.
- Steko 14y agoSecurity seems like a priority at Blizzard based on everything I know. Priority =/= invulnerability.
- DrStalker 14y agoI was able to get an authenticator from Blizzrd years before my bank made it possible to do the same. They care about security if only because they lose a lot of money spending time to fix up hacked accounts, and this will be even worse now they have a real-money auction house. In WoW they can just rollback items and if they duplicate some that were sold off by attackers it's no big deal. If they start duplicating real money then they need to pay out on it.
- colanderman 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tomkit 14y agoThey're after my 150K DPS Demon Hunter.
- feefie 14y agoHow is a breach like this detected and how would they determine what data was accessed? How likely is is that that other sites on the internet are breached but don't detect it? If the answer is too long and you could recommend a book or website I could read up on this topic, that would be awesome.
- talon88 14y agoBreach is generally detected in one of two ways - information is sold and that leads to scrutiny when users write in, and/or you have auditing mechanisms (ip geolocation, for example) which points out behavior that does not seem to be correct. Once you see this, you run through a full audit of all of your accesses, searching for things that don't fit a pattern. Logins of your admins — did they login at some time that they don't usually? Was there a login from a Russian/Chinese/Unusual IP? Did someone go into something they usually shouldn't? It's not an exact science, which is why it's really hard to do — you may never be sure what exactly was compromised. Finally, how likely it is that other sites are breached: highly likely. The problem is that when you have leaked email/passwords, there's a large number of people that reuse passwords, and those people can be working at Blizzard, banks, or other companies. Unless they have proactive intrusion detection scanning in place, you don't know until after they've come in, looked at what they wanted to, and left.
- Steko 14y agoHere's the last big thread from when people freaked out about Blizzard's lower case passwords: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4022145 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4022145 There's a lot of information about Blizzard's security safeguards, worth the time to read through.
- hanapbuhay 14y agoHere's some detailed information on what happened [1]. A press release from Mike Morhaime [2]. Also, they're currently working on allowing users update their secret question and answers [3]. [1]: http://us.battle.net/support/en/article/important-security-update-faq http://us.battle.net/support/en/article/important-security-u... [2]: http://us.blizzard.com/en-us/securityupdate.html http://us.blizzard.com/en-us/securityupdate.html [3]: http://us.battle.net/support/en/blog/6940803 http://us.battle.net/support/en/blog/6940803
- LOLvis 14y agoUntil the secret-answer fix is ready, users are advised to change their the names of their first pets and/or favorite teachers.
- vitalique 14y agoLooks like Vivendi should have moved quicker with their plans on selling Activision Blizzard. Poor guys. I wonder how much this sad news will impact the success of the WoW: Mists of Pandaria (launch planned on 09/25).
- alanfalcon 14y agoMy guess: almost zero impact, long term.
- dsl 14y agoFrom my time reverse engineering the WoW client, I can tell you Blizzard uses SRP6 [1] for authentication. You'd have to really try hard to be storing anything other than a hash on the backend. 1. http://srp.stanford.edu/design.html http://srp.stanford.edu/design.html
- StavrosK 14y agoOh wow, I wasn't aware of that. So the password (or a hash of it) never leaves the client, so an eavesdropper can never get any information? That's very interesting. It looks like both parties end up with a session key, too, which is an added bonus.
- dsl 14y agoPretty much. The Blizzard guys know their shit. You wouldn't go wrong replicating anything they have done security wise, which is why this breach is surprising to me.
- stipes 14y agoDown-thread [1], someone claims to have found SRP to be about 172 times slower than SHA1 on CPU due to the modular exponentiation and other overhead. Some numbers run by zaroth (down-thread) [2] show that we could see 100k 1024-bit modular exponentiations per second on a new Intel Core i7 with the cryptography extensions. A 2011 implementation paper [3] had about 20k 1024-bit RSA decryptions per second on a GTX260 using Montgomery exponentiation, so it doesn't seem like using the GPU has that much benefit for performing modular exponentiation. I haven't had time to figure out an estimated price/attempt for SRP, so it's hard to compare to the existing SHA1 figures [4]. Still, if we take the 100k/second figure for modular exponentiation (extrapolated from the number of cycles per 1024-bit modexp on a Core i7), versus the 5B/s for SHA1 on a single GPU, being 50000 times slower than the best SHA1 speeds seems pretty good to me. 1. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4365079 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4365079 2. http://www.opine.me/blizzards-battle-net-hack/ http://www.opine.me/blizzards-battle-net-hack/ 3. http://trone.di.fc.ul.pt/images/e/e2/ASAP11-paper.pdf http://trone.di.fc.ul.pt/images/e/e2/ASAP11-paper.pdf 4. http://golubev.com/gpuest.htm http://golubev.com/gpuest.htm
- ChuckMcM 14y agoFor a long time World of Warcraft accounts sold for more money on the black market than credit card numbers [1]. It was said that this was due to the fact that you could make money using those accounts (primarily through selling 'gold' or in game items) which could not get 'clawed back' by credit card companies. So having battle.net get hit is a pretty cherry target. That said, what is the current crack rate for SRP on a GPU for 7, 8 and 10 character passwords? [1] This was one example but I've also seen other more credible reports on the eset blog. "WoW login I might want to check if they also have Diablo 3 on their account and vice versa. WoW accounts are already more valuable than credit card numbers on the black market, this will only increase their value." -- http://www.gosugamers.net/diablo/news/17557-it-s-the-economy-stupid-how-the-real-money-auction-house-will-affect-diablo-3-part-1 http://www.gosugamers.net/diablo/news/17557-it-s-the-economy...
- StavrosK 14y ago> That said, what is the current crack rate for SRP on a GPU for 7, 8 and 10 character passwords? If I understand the thing I just first heard about ten seconds ago, SRP is a protocol, not a hash. The passwords are hashed using some hash method, maybe SHA or bcrypt.
- thechut 14y ago> That said, what is the current crack rate for SRP on a GPU for 7, 8 and 10 character passwords? That is a really good question, SRP is actually pretty serious. Based on the small amount I know about SRP, a simple rainbow table brute force attack would take a VERY VERY long time per hash; even on an extremely fast multiple gpu rig. Somebody with more specific knowledge about SRP could probably calculate an exact number. However, since they have stolen other information (perhaps even some, like the modifier, salt or modulo data, that they have not disclosed) they could possibly create a more advanced and targeted rainbow table attack which would greatly reduce the time it would take per account.
- shadowmint 14y agoHm... I'm getting persistent login failures here now. Maybe they've disabled something? "https://sea.battle.net/login/login.frag https://sea.battle.net/login/login.frag is not available" Error 501 (net::ERR_INSECURE_RESPONSE): Unknown error.
- suresk 14y ago> and information relating to Mobile and Dial-In Authenticators were also accessed. I don't know a ton about 2 factor auth implementation details, but I'm assuming that if you were able to access the serial # or whatever is used to uniquely identify an authenticator, you could generate valid tokens, essentially rendering the 2 factor auth useless? If so, and if they were also able to access information about the key fob authenticators, that could be messy. Hopefully that isn't the case.
- Digitalxero 14y agoSo I went to update my password for my World of Warcraft account after I saw this. And guess what I discovered, my current password is more secure than their current password policy will allow. So I filled out a support ticket with the following question (which all Blizzard account holders should ask them) I was wondering why even after you discovered a security breach you have not updated your password policy to actually allow secure passwords. Your current password policy only allows password that will take a day or two to brute force crack. see http://xkcd.com/936/ http://xkcd.com/936/ These two rules totally nullify any security of your passwords "Your password must be between 8–16 characters in length. Your password may only contain alphabetic characters (A–Z), numeric characters (0–9), and punctuation." In fact my current password is better since I apparently created it before your policy changed to not allow non alpha-numeric characters. The only reason to have those two rules is because you are storing the password in plain text so anyone who gets access to the database can read them freely. Please update your password policy to "Your password must be at least 20 characters long." That is it, let me make a 400 character password if I want, let me use cyrillic, chinese, or whatever other unicode characters I want to use. If you truly care about security you will fix your broken password policy!
- elithrar 14y ago> "The only reason to have those two rules is because you are storing the password in plain text so anyone who gets access to the database can read them freely." That is certainly not the only reason to have those rules; in fact, it's probably one of the least popular reasons. It's done to keep customers creating short-ish passwords, which are likely to be more memorable, and therefore reduce the support load for password resets. Whether this is actually effective or not is another thing entirely.
- Digitalxero 14y agothey have a "I am an idiot and forgot my password" button so people forgetting their passwords is no additional support, and if they allow longer password it actually makes them easier for people to remember and harder to crack, win win.
- 14y ago
- john2x 14y agoTried resetting my password. Blizzard limits it to 16 characters. Why?!
- SeanDav 14y agoGreat, in Diablo 3, the only game I play, Blizzard forces you to be online at all times, even to play single player and they can't even look after your passwords. Just great.
- jaredstenquist 14y agoI feel much more productive knowing I have no idea what a "battle.net" account is.
- Karunamon 14y ago16 character max password with no special characters allowed. .. Are you people high or something? This is 2012, when every major provider has been owned at least once. Not AOL circa 1995. Get with the program, Blizzard!
- ZoFreX 14y agoWhile that is bad, according to my napkin calculations that still gives you 82 bits of entropy for your password (if you randomly generate it, taking into account that they aren't case-sensitive {seriously}). 82 bits is actually "good enough" so, for now, not too big a deal. The bigger deal is the SHA1 + salt hash they're using to store them!
- Auguste 14y agoHow can I change my security questions? I can't find them in the account settings.
- StevenRayOrr 14y agoAs far as I can tell, you can't. But Blizzard has announced that they will be putting something in place for users to do that in the next few days. Keep an eye on your B.Net email.
- zaroth 14y agoSRP is great at many things, but terrible at securing the server-side password database from brute force attacks. A quick look at http://srp.stanford.edu/design.html http://srp.stanford.edu/design.html and http://srp.stanford.edu/demo/demo.html http://srp.stanford.edu/demo/demo.html and you can see that SRP uses simple SHA1 plus a Salt to store the hashed passwords. With the hashes and salts stolen, please assume your password has been brute forced by the attacker (1 billion hashes per second with SHA1 is not expensive). This is LinkedIn all over again. If Blizzard customized their SRP algorithm to use a more expensive hash than SHA1, they should come out and say it. Otherwise, we should assume their statement that using SRP "means that each password would have to be deciphered individually" is nothing more than a salted SHA1. Combined with their reduced entropy password policy, all stored passwords are likely brute forced already.
- thechut 14y agoSRP is supposed to make use of multiple types of entropy to ensure the passwords are far more complicated that salted SHA1. While I agree it's possible that the attackers also got this information but I don't think we can jump to conclusions about the overall security of the passwords until more information is known.
- zaroth 14y agoPlease read the RFC, it's right here: http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2945.txt http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2945.txt Password entries are generated as follows: <salt> = random() x = SHA(<salt> | SHA(<username> | ":" | <raw password>)) <password verifier> = v = g^x % N G = 47 N = 112624315653284427036559548610503669920632123929604336254260115573677366691719 What was stolen was no better than LinkedIn hashes -- for the purposes of dictionary attacking the database
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 14y agog^x is slow, therefore better than linkedin hashes for the purpose of dictionary attacking the database.
- zaroth 14y agoSRP is great at many things, but terrible at securing the server-side password database from brute force attacks. A quick look at http://srp.stanford.edu/design.html http://srp.stanford.edu/design.html and http://srp.stanford.edu/demo/demo.html http://srp.stanford.edu/demo/demo.html and you can see that SRP uses simple SHA1 plus a Salt to store the hashed passwords. With the hashes and salts stolen, please assume your password has been brute forced by the attacker (1 billion hashes per second with SHA1 not expensive). This is LinkedIn all over again. If Blizzard customized their SRP algorithm to use a more expensive hash than SHA1, they should come out and say it. Otherwise, we should assume their statement that using SRP "means that each password would have to be deciphered individually" is nothing more than a salted SHA1. Combined with their reduced entropy password policy, all stored passwords are likely brute forced already.
- smokinjoe 14y agoSo, what about us with inactive accounts? Is there some sort of action we should take place?
- cowpewter 14y agoSo why am I finding out about this via HN/Kotaku? Why haven't I gotten an email from Blizzard yet? I haven't logged into my Battle.net account in the past few days, so maybe they're alerting people on login, but you know, a lot of people don't have the time to game every day, or even every week. An email alerting me to the need to change my password would be appreciated.
- alanfalcon 14y agoI know that marketing messages can take days to weeks to send out because of the incredible number of customers Blizzard has (and avoiding being flagged as spam an other considerations). It may be that an e-mail has started going out, but in the meantime the website and game launcher have been updated with messaging and Kotaku/WoW Insider/etc. is a pretty good way to get info to Blizzard's core player base.
- staunch 14y agoProbably explains why the credit card I used there was canceled. Last time was a few months ago for Steam. Hackers play games. Hackers hack game companies.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- akandiah 14y agoI'm not surprised - Blizzard don't understand the meaning of security in the first place! For instance: the passwords that a user chooses are case-insensitive. Feel free to try this one out on your battlenet account!
- hxf148 14y agoBring on touch screens with print scanners. I really hate login/pass. I realize in away the more secure the token the more private it can become but the screens could at least check for a pulse too. (it's late)
- tterrace 14y agoI still haven't received an email about this. My last email from blizzard was three months ago when I bought D3. I hope they plan on sending out something soon with a good explanation on why hackers having your ASQ is a really bad thing.
- tterrace 14y agoAlso a detailed post-mortem would be neat but I'm not holding my breath on that one.