5 ms·
Honestly, as long as we’re not collectivising the cost of dental caries, and insurers can discriminate dental pricing based on fluoridation if they choose to, I
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
Honestly, as long as we’re not collectivising the cost of dental caries, and insurers can discriminate dental pricing based on fluoridation if they choose to, I’m okay with folks who don’t brush their teeth doing whatever they want to.
- jeffbee 2y agoThat's just not how a society should work. Children should get a fair chance at life no matter how ignorant or negligent their parents are. Fluoridated water keeps teeth in mouths and students behind desks instead of missing school.
- amluto 2y agoThis is also true for measles and chickenpox, both of which have quite unpleasant or even lethal medium-to-long-term consequences in some fraction of people who appear to have recovered.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Children should get a fair chance at life no matter how ignorant or negligent their parents are I agree in principle. But this just isn’t the country we live in. Smart states and communities can still think this through logically. But it may be for the best to let the antivax rural areas do their own thing and stick to themselves.
- themaninthedark 2y ago>antivax rural areas I would be careful with what size brush you are painting. >There are, of course, the familiar anti-vaxxers, who spoke up as early as February with concerns about a mandatory vaccine. There are also new groups. One is connected to far-right extremism and conspiracy theories (about the virus and otherwise). The other, termed “vaccine-hesitant,” is more surprising. It includes members of the opposite demographic — highly educated, liberal, not libertarian >While a majority of those unwilling to get a vaccine are Republicans, 42% of Democrats agree with them https://harvardpolitics.com/the-new-anti-vax/ https://harvardpolitics.com/the-new-anti-vax/
- roguecoder 2y agoThe anti-vaxx movement was really strong among ex-hippies when I was growing up. It's all the same people who believe in homeopathy and chiropractors. Part of the problem is presenting it as a choice makes people think it is legitimate to choose "no". I believe the consequence of not vaccinating should be social exclusion until you catch up: anything else is stochastically depraved heart murder.
- DrillShopper 2y ago> I believe the consequence of not vaccinating should be social exclusion until you catch up I think it should be even stronger than that: no public services or public spaces for you. No driver's license, no public school, no library card, nothing, unless you can demonstrate a medical reason why you cannot receive a specific vaccine, and then you get an exception for only that one. If you want to live in your own world where you're disconnected from society then that's fine, you can do that, but it doesn't and shouldn't come consequence free given the damage you can do to others.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThe vaccine hesitant, to my knowledge, still gave their kids the MMR. They have just been sceptical of newer vaccines, e.g. for Covid or the flue. That’s probably a long-term problem. But it isn’t creating pockets of measles- and polio-afflicted kids.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThe problem is that there is no clear demarcation of the transition from parental control to state control. Even subjects like corporeal punishment and surgical modification are murky at best. Dental hygiene seems incredibly far down the list.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Dental hygiene seems incredibly far down the list Yup. It’s also something that can be mostly fixed later in life. So turning it into a hill to die on seems strategically unwise.
- jeffbee 2y agoYou can't fix the fact that poor dental health is associated with poor school attendance and lower academic achievement, later in life.
- Empact 2y agoYou’re begging the question. If fluoridation decreases IQ through developmental neurotoxicity, is the lost cognitive capacity in the general population justified by the protection of children with irresponsible parents (who do not enforce eg the brushing of teeth) from the consequences of caries? This is a real moral problem we ought to contend with. I believe society suffers from lower IQs, and that targeted interventions against childhood caries can be applied effectively without dosing the whole population. Why don’t schools teach toothbrushing? Why not have the school nurse check children’s teeth, or have a dentist come to school periodically?
- gs17 2y ago> Why don’t schools teach toothbrushing? And/or have the school nurse check children’s teeth? Some schools used to have a fluoride rinse students would be forced to do. It looks like it still happens in some rural places.
- creaturemachine 2y agoOh the dreaded swish. I grew up in such a place.
- themaninthedark 2y agoI had the swish at school, it was opt-in, not forced IIRC. Edit add: I wonder if the swish is better overall as the fluid is spit out after rather than continuous ingestion?
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI had fluoride treatment at the dentist instead city application. It was pleasant tasting and took minutes. You don't swallow it so is local only. Anecdotal, but I am 40 and have never had a cavity. rarely floss and brush <2 times per day.
- roguecoder 2y agoIt is less effective because it is spit out rather than ingested: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Shou-Hua-Li/publication/19680021_Evaluation_of_the_comparative_effectiveness_of_fluoride_mouthrinsing_fluoride_tablets_and_both_procedures_in_combination_interim_findings_after_two_years/links/53f50dde0cf2888a74916c86/Evaluation-of-the-comparative-effectiveness-of-fluoride-mouthrinsing-fluoride-tablets-and-both-procedures-in-combination-interim-findings-after-two-years.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Shou-Hua-Li/publication... The most effective treatment was combining fluoride mouth wash and fluoride tablets.
- dughnut 2y ago[flagged]
- kmeisthax 2y agoGreat. Except fluoridation isn't a per-household choice, it's on the municipality level, so your insurance rates will go up because your neighbors aren't taking care of their teeth, even if you are.
- bpodgursky 2y agoThe OP literally said "as long as insurance can discriminate"
- roguecoder 2y agoThe problem is that children aren't allowed to choose for themselves. Their parents are able to set their kids up for a life of pain and dental bills the parents don't have to experience or pay for.
- LinuxBender 2y agoFor completeness sake that could potentially also cut both ways. If it turns out that fluoride does lower academia potential then it would be occurring in the brain's most important development period. Once they are adults they would have to live with that artificial limitation. Though they do say ignorance is bliss. My personal preference would be to let the scientists, researchers and skeptics put on boxing gloves and in the mean time give the child a healthy diet, teach them to use a water-pick daily to avoid not only cavities but other potential issues related to diet and gum hygiene.
- roguecoder 2y agoNone of these studies measured academic potential or outcomes.
- LinuxBender 2y agoThat's what I mean, if one day they actually study this correctly and have a raging epiphany then it would be too late for kids already subjected to fluoride whereas a healthy diet, good brushing with fluoride free toothpaste and using a water pick could mitigate cavities just fine among other things. Perhaps even mitigate the need for SSRI's, ADHD drugs, etc... but that's a much bigger topic.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Their parents are able to set their kids up for a life of pain and dental bills This is true of a lot of parenting, and the case is more critical for vaccines than dental hygiene because cavities aren’t transmissible. (Within reason.) So yes, ideally the kids of the uninformed wouldn’t be born into dental debt. But that’s better than them having gone blind from measles or lame from polio. (Coldly, because those costs will be socialised.)
- globnomulous 2y ago> as long as we’re not collectivising the cost of dental caries We certainly do, through ER visits and illnesses and medical events that can develop as a result of poor oral hygiene -- stroke and heart disease being among them.
- barbazoo 2y agoIs that fair to the children that have to deal with the life long effects of bad teeth?