4 ms·
I don't understand people who want to defend Apple in this case. UK is a functioning democracy, and why would you want to put a (foreign) company above that? If
by amelius 2y ago
I don't understand people who want to defend Apple in this case. UK is a functioning democracy, and why would you want to put a (foreign) company above that? If you want change, you know the route ...
- wzdd 2y agoI don't understand your comment. Apple seems to be engaging with the order in the appropriate way under a functioning democracy, i.e. by challenging it in the courts.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- amelius 2y agoYes, but this is the country that invented the CCTV.
- spacebanana7 2y agoEven functional democracies make mistakes. Calling them out is part of the correction process.
- like_any_other 2y agoSecret trials to enact mass surveillance on an unknowing population (the original demand gagged Apple from talking about it) doesn't sound like a "functioning democracy" to me.
- londons_explore 2y agoI don't know of any country with fully open governance. There are always decisions or information which is kept secret/illegal to publish.
- Leynos 2y agoAnd which parts of that governance can be kept secret should be subject to continuous review. Openness must be carefully guarded.
- HPsquared 2y agoMaybe there's a healthy middle ground.
- like_any_other 2y ago"Fully open" is a strawman. These are not names of MI5 agents, or a list of active police investigations. This is a massive breach of privacy of every UK citizen, and forced recruitment of every company into a government informant, forcing them to lie to their users that they're being given privacy, whilst informing on them. It is trying to keep the existence of the Stasi a secret.
- londons_explore 2y agoI'd be willing to bet if the government had to pick between publishing the list of all spies names Vs having backdoor access to all Comms, they'd pick having the backdoor access.
- rodwyersoftware 2y agoThe UK is not a functioning democracy, at all.
- ohgr 2y agoWell it is because the judiciary smacked the secrecy side of it down pretty hard to make sure that it was done in public. That's a pretty strong indicator of a functioning democracy.
- rodwyersoftware 2y agoThe UK has not had any real political activity for 100 years. It's all a show. If the UK represented the British natives then a lot of things would be happening that would get me banned from this website :)
- pjc50 2y agoSadly, the UK public are pretty authoritarian, especially about things they don't understand like encryption.
- mattmanser 2y agoDo you even know when our National Health Service was created? Or our social security net? When laws were repealed that suppressed minorities, when human rights were added to our legislation? National minimum wage? Freedom of information laws? Hint: All within the last 100 years.
- ohgr 2y agoAs a British native I feel well represented. It's not perfect of course. We might take a step back occasionally but this usually results in two steps forward. Some press like only to comment on the backward steps though.
- rapsey 2y ago[flagged]
- ohgr 2y agoI think you vastly misunderstand or are oversimplifying the problem here. They actually spoke up against a government mandated privacy violation. What I am worried about really is Google, Meta etc did not speak up against it and likely have had the same requests. So I am worried about some foreign companies complying with my government. And very surprised that one particular foreign company gives more of a shit about me as an end user than my own government.
- petepete 2y agoI don't think it's fair to tar Meta with that brush. WhatApp have said repeatedly they'll leave the UK before disabling E2EE.
- ohgr 2y agoI don't believe they've commented on this issue at all and they carry more messages than Apple do in the UK.
- petepete 2y agoNot in the last couple of months but they made a big deal about refusing to comply when it was raised in 2023. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/mar/09/whatsapp-end-to-end-encryption-online-safety-bill https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/mar/09/whatsapp-...
- Retr0id 2y ago"functioning" is a reach.
- Leynos 2y agoA functioning justice system is an important part of a functioning democracy.
- lynx97 2y agoSurely you are implying that everything in a "functioning democracy" can be solved by voting... I know a ton of pro-EU people that might want to have a talk with you...
- camjw 2y agoSurely you're not saying that leaving the EU wasn't democratic?