5 ms·
EU offered 'zero-for-zero' deal to US weeks before tariff announcement
- ggm 2y agoI would think this re-inforces the performative aspects of the situation. It is very hard to see good-faith negotiations existing between these trade blocs if an offer like this was not discussed seriously. I believe a reddit observation I have read is that Musk called for "zero tariffs with europe" and a response was "it was 1.4 to 1.5% on average between the US and EU before you blew this up"
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoIf one was to believe the goal is to move manufacturing back to the states, a zero for zero would never be considered, as it wouldn't move the needle on the wanted end state.
- dgoldstein0 2y agoKey word, "if". Trump hasn't stated that goal. It's unclear he has a particular goal in mind other than "trade deficits bad, tariffs can fix trade deficits therefore tariffs good".
- femiagbabiaka 2y agoThey're quite explicit about their goals, they're just quieter about it now because they don't want to give away the game. Alex Danco, one of my favorite finance writers, wrote this piece about it, recommend: https://danco.substack.com/p/if-youre-first-out-the-door-its-not https://danco.substack.com/p/if-youre-first-out-the-door-its...
- ggm 2y ago"give the game away" -c'mon, this isn't trade secret. If the outcome is dollar revaluation and releasing the trigger finger on US debt, then thats been the plan for a long time. The part of the equation where manufacturing jobs magically came back onshore and somehow all the other impacts were "not material" continues to escape me. Those manufacturing jobs won't come back even with a worldwide GST of 10% paid to the USA, and those other impacts are going to play out for decades.
- femiagbabiaka 2y agoI didn’t say it was a good plan or that it was being executed well — but if you don’t broadcast your every move you maintain plausible deniability, just like with the initial denial of Project 2025. If he said “I’m trying to make American labor cheaper” that would obviously be unpopular. And yet that is exactly the plan.
- AlecSchueler 2y agoThe article you linked admits to being based on various assumptions. I'm not sure how guesses from a third party equate to the administration being explicit about what they're doing and why.
- femiagbabiaka 2y agoIt is based on the same set of assumptions the entire world is working off of, and the strategy described is what has been done so far. We won’t get better than that unfortunately.
- AlecSchueler 2y agoThat's fine but my point is that the word "quite" is doing quite some heavy lifting in the claim "they've been quite explicit about their goals" if the entire world has to work off of guesses and assumptions.
- solumunus 2y agoHe absolutely has been banging that drum for ages, I’ve no idea how you’ve missed this.
- ggm 2y agoI only partially agree. They could e.g. have negotiated some outcome which altered the goods of trade on the same bilateral basis so France and Germany got better wine entry with a boost to rural sector jobs, in return for some US manufactured goods being given an easier ride in. It's not like Trump wouldn't have enjoyed shitting on the West coast wine industry, for some east coast car -related love. Thats a silly example but there would presumably be jobs-creating outcomes for both of them in a negotiated outcome. You couldn't call this a BATNA
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- femiagbabiaka 2y agoThe sooner Europe turns away from the U.S., the better. I understand that realpolitik is at play, but the U.S. can barely afford to fight the Houthis at the moment, nevermind an entire planet who evicts their military bases.
- oiasuodauosd 2y ago[dead]
- dagw 2y agoU.S. can barely afford to fight the Houthis at the moment I'm as critical of the US as the next person, but that is just a ridiculous statement. What the US does and doesn't do militarily with regards to the Houthis has nothing to do with what they can and cannot afford. Any limits on their actions against the Houthis is purely down to political will and strategic interests, and obviously not financial limitations. Push comes to shove and we all know that the US military could count on being backed up by more financial muscle than any military force on the planet (with the possible exception of the Chinese).
- BurningPenguin 2y agoThe US also depends on several bases in Europe and other countries. If the decision is made to close them, they're going to have a harder time projecting all that power. I may not be a military expert, but i'm guessing that would also influence operations in the Houthis region.
- r721 2y agoI guess that was a reference to a recent NYT article: >U.S. Strikes in Yemen Burning Through Munitions With Limited Success >In just three weeks, the Pentagon has used $200 million worth of munitions, in addition to the immense operational and personnel costs to deploy two aircraft carriers, additional B-2 bombers and fighter jets, as well as Patriot and THAAD air defenses to the Middle East, the officials said. >The total cost could be well over $1 billion by next week, and the Pentagon might soon need to request supplemental funds from Congress, one U.S. official said. >So many precision munitions are being used, especially advanced long-range ones, that some Pentagon contingency planners are growing concerned about overall Navy stocks and implications for any situation in which the United States would have to ward off an attempted invasion of Taiwan by China. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/04/us/politics/us-strikes-yemen-houthis.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/04/us/politics/us-strikes-ye...
- pfannkuchen 2y agoI don’t like Trump and I think it’s dystopian that we have basically a reality tv star in the white house. However - I do think it’s interesting how his over the top bravado is translated into stupidity by the media. Like he is all about shock and awe negotiating. He doesn’t mean everything he says or does in a direct way, much of it is for effect. When he drops massive tariffs on everyone at once, it’s intended to force people to the table to negotiate with an uncomfortable starting position for them. Obviously there are side effects in the market, and it is kind of disrespectful in the current political culture, but I think it remains to be seen whether these will even be long term effects. If a few major countries capitulate in the next couple of weeks I think the market will probably catch its breath. In this case trump probably feels that he has the leverage to achieve a net positive arrangement and not just a neutral one. If someone is treating you badly for a while, which is not objectively true about the EU necessarily but clearly trump thinks it, it’s normal human behavior to not settle for a draw unless you are the weaker party. The media is almost doing him a favor in a way, like portraying him as being so crazy that he “just might do it”. They’re giving him a mad dog aura. Hmm.
- watwut 2y agoReality that what you call bravado and consider cool when your friends do it ... everyone else sees as X is being dumb again. Trump is emotional and with low self control. He flips flops and is insecure. He crashed his companies around 6 times and managed to crash a casino. We are getting to see how and why it happened. He has certain charizma so some rich friend always helps him, including Putin. And plus the massive level of corruption he engages with helps him stay rich. But fundamentally, his businesses do badly.
- pfannkuchen 2y agoI mean bravado on a personal level (especially if someone is bad at it) and bravado in international negotiations are completely different animals. I feel like if you pretend it’s 1850 and there’s some great powers struggle afoot, trump makes a lot more sense. The game theory around international relations hasn’t really changed much since then, there’s just a veneer of ideology strapped on top of it. Btw it’s much easier to just label someone stupid than to seek to understand them. It is definitely tempting.
- ofrzeta 2y agoAnd the genius just refused that deal because he thinks it is not enough. Somehow his idea is that Europeans are obliged to buy US products - otherwise it's "unfair", to say the least. It doesn't seem to get into his mind that Europeans just don't like to buy US cars because there's no incentive to. Why would anyone buy a US car when there are dozens of European car manufacturers with better networks etc. Asian car manufacturers have a better price/performance ratio, too.
- ponector 2y agoIt's not wise to buy a car you cannot fit into any parking lot.
- ofrzeta 2y agoThat is true, especially for the Dodge RAMs that occasionally can be found in Europe, too. However it's also true for a lot of SUVs that have been built here. I always wonder why the responsible authorities (in Germany it is the Bundeskraftfahrtamt) even allowed this, when the parking lots and streets were clearly built for smaller vehicles.
- fvdessen 2y agoI always hear about tariffs but isn’t part of the trade imbalance due to corporate taxes being usually much lower outside the USA, incentivizing American companies to outsource production and keep the money abroad ?
- rich_sasha 2y agoThe imbalances also conveniently exclude services, for no good reason. Europe buys more services from US than vice versa, i.e. US is a net exporter. So that reduces the trade imbalance, and substantially so.
- DarkWiiPlayer 2y ago> [...] for no good reason. Europe buys more services from US than vice versa [...] One could suspect, and many have, that this is the reason.
- robocat 2y agoA bigger problem is foreign investors. If foreign ownership of stock market increases by 1% that is 0.62 trillion of imports which could dominate other imports. In 2023, the total value of international U.S. imports of goods and services amounted to 3.83 trillion U.S. dollars The lovely graph in this link suggests that foreign ownership of stocks was 40% in 2019 and growing rapidly: https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/who-owns-us-stock-foreigners-and-rich-americans https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/who-owns-us-stock-foreign... The total market capitalization of the U.S. stock market stands at $62.2 Trillion (January 1, 2025) Your idea is likely irrelevant since companies would retain ownership of foreign capital. Metaphor: owning JPY or USD makes little difference. Disclaimer: not an economist. I'm extrapolating from my own experience as a New Zealander buying US stocks. I've sold 75% of my US holdings since January. Sold more since tariffs. Scaring away foreign investors might crash market but fix trade imbalance? Presumably the signal would be other stock markets going up as money shifts away from US.
- robocat 2y agoTo add, Levine's latest missive says: Peter Navarro writes: The US cumulative trade deficits in goods from 1976 — the year chronic deficits began — to 2024 have transferred over $20tn of American wealth into foreign hands. That’s more than 60 per cent of US GDP in 2024. Foreign interests have taken over vast swaths of US farmland, housing, tech companies..." and: [Foreigners] pump "so much money into the U.S. economy that it fuels economic vulnerabilities and crises." There is too much foreign demand to own our tech companies, so we have to reduce it, by making the tech companies’ stocks worth less.
- rsynnott 2y agoThis is, of course, something that the EU has been quite keen on for about a decade; it’s basically what TTIP (which Trump broke) was about.
- verzali 2y agoHas everyone forgotten about the TTIP deal that was being negotiated between the US and EU and that Trump abandoned in the first term?
- tim333 2y agoMusk has also been suggesting a zero tariff between the US and EU. He also recently called Navarro, a main architect of the tariffs, "dumber than a sack of bricks" and "truly a moron." Not sure things are fully harmonious over there.
- profstasiak 2y agoTake a look at the map of Free Trade Agreements of EU and USA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_trade_agreements_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_trade_agreements_of_the_U... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_trade_agreements_of_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_trade_agreements_of_the_E... I might be wrong and biased, but maybe EU gains the most from this US vs world trade war?