3 ms·
Is it an oddly academic question? If every search is personalised then what does a personalisation-free search tell you? It's possible that it will no be close
by andybak 14y ago
Is it an oddly academic question?
If every search is personalised then what does a personalisation-free search tell you? It's possible that it will no be closer to what most people see as very few people jump through the hoops you're jumping through.
It might even be less like the majority of search results.
- etherealG 14y agoI think the crux is objectivity vs subjectivity. You'd like to be able to get an objective set of results to a query.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoandybak's point is a good one though, if you get an objective SERP then that's not going to tell you anything very useful as all your potential customers are getting a personalised version. Looks like an opening: have a group of users sorted across demographics that you can automatically send a query too. The system returns the SERPs from each user and compiles a master SERP showing position based on demographics of the user? So you can, say, run a search for "search engine" across 1000 user machines and then look at average placement (with variance) for Windows 7 users aged 30+ in USA, or whatever. You could probably do a similar thing with Tor (or a botnet) but the relationship between the SERP data and the demographic of the user is probably the most pertinent information and that would be lost then.
- andybak 14y agoThe snag is that running searches on other people's profile will alter that profile. The results will be less accurate over time. Not to mention they would get some very strange things popping in Google Now! Oh, it's a tangled web we weave...
- nhaehnle 14y agoThis is a very good point. Ideally, one should be able to explicitly override personalization-related input as much as possible, so that one can freely explore what kind of results other groups of people get. I suspect that Google are reluctant to provide such an interface as it might make it easier to game the system.
- rwos 14y agoIdeally, there should be a feature that lets you see the personalized (that is, real) search results of others. Maybe divided into target groups ("programmers", "male users under 20", etc.). Of course, everyone's real search results will be slightly different, incorporating "+1"s of Google+ friends for example. But, I assume, the bulk of the search ranks will be the same for people in the same (advertising) target group. (I have nothing to back up that assumption - it just would be the most sensible thing to do, I think.)