6 ms·
YIMBYism as Industrial Policy
- DeathArrow 2y ago[flagged]
- hnav 2y agosf midmarket and seattle downtown maybe, everywhere is a bit hyperbolic
- skyyler 2y agoI can assure you that the homeless people in San Francisco are not why San Francisco doesn't look as advanced as Shenzhen or even Chengdu. The parts of the city that don't have many homeless people are still old and decaying looking compared to modest Chinese cities.
- lurker9001 2y ago[dead]
- someperson 2y agoIn part it's because SF is relatively old. BART is 50 years old, and New York Subway is over 100 years old. Check back on China's gleaming rail system and newly constructed cities in 50 or 100 years. You can bet it will look older and more tired, an ageing snapshot of a once in a century construction boom. Especially if China experiences several lost decades like Japan, which is increasingly likely.
- cpursley 2y agoThis is a lame excuse, look at the Moscow Metro, it's old yet clean, maintained, safe and constantly expanding. As are many European metros - while dated, they are fine (despite the grumblings of Londoners and Parisians). This is a political will issue, not an infrastructure one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNpsWx8DPGk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNpsWx8DPGk
- skyyler 2y agoComparing Moscow Metro to BART just makes me sad. BART should be an amazing, world class rail system. Instead, it's kind of a joke.
- sightbroke 2y agoAmerica is built for maximizing consumption. Public transit gets in the way of selling cars which goes against maximizing consumption. Additionally there is a lack of infrastructure and culture to keep public transit clean.
- cpursley 2y agoMoscow has the largest shopping mall in Europe and there's a new metro stop that drops you off right in front of it (not to mention bus stops): https://maps.app.goo.gl/7fyY9hBNuAxXTLZx5 https://maps.app.goo.gl/7fyY9hBNuAxXTLZx5 So I'm not totally convinced the problem in the US is just about consumption.
- sightbroke 2y agoDoes Russia have a comparably large automotive manufacturing industry & related industry in comparison to the U.S.? I fail to see how public transit to shopping center in Russia is counter to my point that America likes to consume cars and that better public transit in the U.S. would hurt the selling (i.e consumption) of cars. Also, again: > Additionally there is a lack of infrastructure and culture to keep public transit clean.
- cpursley 2y agoAh, you specifically meant consuming cars. I totally misread that as general consumption. Yeah, I'm with you on that. American car culture is very strange, the brodozers as status symbol and mentality behind them is a pox. The culture of "you ain't no real mayun if you ain't got da big truck" is something that I think only $10+ a gallon gas can solve...
- skyyler 2y agoYou're saying that China's ability to build rail for the last 20 years while America struggled to build rail has something to do with "several lost decades" that you're anticipating? Could you expand on why you think China will have lost decades?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> why you think China will have lost decades? Demographics. Though America may save it from itself.
- skyyler 2y agoCan you expand what you mean by "Demographics"?
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoDeclining and rapidly-aging population [1]. [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/12/05/key-facts-about-chinas-declining-population/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/12/05/key-facts...
- loeg 2y agoI can assure you, 90% of Seattle just looks like it's been taken over by SFH zoning NIMBYs (because it has), with no drug addicts or homeless in sight.
- TimorousBestie 2y agoComparing homeless people and drug addicts to zombies is not helpful. Instead we could talk about returning to the horrors of the involuntary hospitalization era pre-Reagan, or we could talk about the current push to incarcerate the entire class in order to use them for forced labor (Grants Pass v. Johnson, 2024). The most humane solution would be to house them and give them a robust social assistance network, of course, but that’s obviously so far off the table that it fell out the Overton Window.
- returningfory2 2y agoThe main reason they can't get housing though is that the government of California, which is dominated by Democrats, refuses to allow sufficient housing construction to make housing affordable.
- hnav 2y agoWhat does partisanship have to do with it, voters in CA are SFH owners and thus push for things that preserve the status quo. The state gov even passed a bunch of stuff in 2024 to defang a lot of NIMBYism but it takes time to see the effects.
- TimorousBestie 2y agoI’d be interested to see how the Republican approach to the problem of homelessness works at scale, but they control few local governments the size of SF or Seattle. Two exceptions (see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mayors_of_the_50_largest_cities_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mayors_of_the_50_lar... ): Dallas-Fort Worth and Oklahoma City. Full disclosure: I don’t know much about them, and I doubt anyone in this thread cares enough to merit a deep dive. A little light googling suggests both struggle with homelessness (not surprising: both tend to have mild winters). DFW seems to take in essence the liberal approach: social services support with some encampment clearing and forced transport away from the city; OKC seems to be working on a rehousing program (how progressive of them) combined with faith-based charities and private/public partnerships.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoDehumanizing rhetoric is dangerous and something we must not engage in.
- redacted_ib 2y agoThe USA needs to shift its mentality towards this if we ever hope to get high speed rail that's up to par with other developed countries
- bluGill 2y agoThere is a reason for all the restrictions. Some of it is bad reason, but we have done some really stupid things as well. Anyone who wants to be YIMBY (which includes me) needs to come up with ways to figure out how not to do the bad as well.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> how not to do the bad as well What is the bad that rivals our current housing crisis and infrastructure depletion?
- pchristensen 2y agoUrban renewal, massive concentrated public housing, and highway construction through cities burned a lot of goodwill towards building. I'm very pro-building, but there's a lot of scar tissue (physical and mental) from last century.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Urban renewal, massive concentrated public housing, and highway construction through cities burned a lot of goodwill towards building The common thread is these were done by the federal government.
- pchristensen 2y agoFunded and enabled by the federal government, but routes and locations were largely chosen by local political leaders.
- bluGill 2y ago
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- daedrdev 2y agoYeah nimbyisn isnt just blocking homes. Its rampant for every project. High speed rail in california has spent billions and years fighting nimbys. Every factory, every buisness, every job often faces nimbyism to try and keep out economic growth because the area will be slightly buiser lmao.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoNot endorsing here but it's not like that's not over entirely nothing. Our car-centric infrastructure means anywhere that is busy is basically impossible to navigate, which... I mean nearly every other G20 nation has a much more diverse transportation system than us, and car focused infrastructure is by far the most inefficient way to move people. It's why I'm still a remote worker despite loving my job, coworkers, and the office: I don't want to deal with commuting in a major metro. Numerous others who work where I do regularly clock commutes in the 30 minute range to travel 10 miles. It's absurd. And it's not JUST inconvenient, it's costly. Living in a place with more people and more traffic means you pay higher insurance premiums and spend more on fuel, unless you have an EV of course. Again I don't mean to fully cosign NIMBYism I'm just saying, especially with the shit way the United States goes about building, it isn't a position completely without merit.
- lazyasciiart 2y agoIt is completely without merit when used to block non-car transport like trains and light rail and buses and bikes.
- ameliaquining 2y agoAt the risk of being That Guy, traffic on high-demand corridors is not caused by building too much or too little or the wrong things; it is caused by lack of congestion pricing. If you don't have that, then you'll have congestion anywhere people want to be, regardless of whether you build lots of roads or build lots of trains or don't build at all. Building roads or trains might (or might not) still be a good thing to do, in the sense of creating more economic value by increasing throughput and so making more marginal trips viable, but that induced demand means the roads will still be congested. Whereas if you have congestion pricing you can just decide how much congestion you want to tolerate and set it at whatever level achieves that.
- cyberax 2y agoNah. NIMBY keeps cities livable, we need more of it. And it works. A great example from Europe: Copenhagen. It's the world's best city in several rankings. How did it get there? By using every inch to build "affordable housing"? Nope. It got there through ruthless population control measures, that actually _reduced_ the Copenhagen population: https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/20894/copenhagen/population https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/20894/cope...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> the world's best city in several rankings …by the Danish tourism board? > through ruthless population control measures The best city people choose not to live or have kids in. Got it.
- cyberax 2y ago> …by the Danish tourism board? Nope. E.g.: https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/28/10-most-livable-cities-in-the-world-vienna-copenhagen-top-list-eiu.html https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/28/10-most-livable-cities-in-th... > The best city people choose not to live or have kids in. Got it. Pretty much. The only way a dense city can work is by limiting its growth. The denser the city, the smaller the birth rate (in the developed world). The best place for kids as evidenced by the birth rate? Suburbs.
- loeg 2y ago"Affordable housing" (sub-market rate lotteries subsidized by increasing the cost of market rate housing) is IMO more of a NIMBY policy than a YIMBY one. The net effect is market rate housing gets more expensive, which hurts everyone except the lucky lottery winners.
- Aloisius 2y agoThis. Demanding new developments all be affordable housing is a strategy NIMBYs use to prevent new construction, since most builders will just go elsewhere. If a builder does try to comply with the demand, they come up with other reasons to block construction (doesn't match neighborhood's character, not enough parking, demand yet another environmental review, etc.)
- mistrial9 2y agosuch a broad subject, with so many stakeholders.. really, starkly different stakeholders.. yet the topic is "Industrial Policy" so, worth a mention is a collection of thinkers in the USA and elsewhere, who envisioned synergetic clusters of heavy industry.. where the waste products of one can be handled or repurposed into another distinct endeavor, at close range.. also limiting the brownsfields left as industry moves on.. one search term is "Industrial Ecology" .. Ford Motor Company sponsored some unique works at that time, with that thinking.. all the more relevant today
- rcpt 2y agoHome building is the largest manufacturing job in the nation. Want to bring manufacturing jobs to the US? You don't need some insane tariff policy, all you need to do is allow people to build housing on land that they own. Bonus: this will grow GDP by double digit percentage points instead of throwing into another recession https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/06/opinion/housing-regulations-us-economy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/06/opinion/housing-regulatio...
- bombcar 2y agoHome building is rampant in some areas, it's just not in the insanely VHCOL coasts. Tax incentives or other reasons to have companies offer jobs in places like Milwaukee or Boise reduces housing pressure on the big cities. What we used to have is smaller (in area) cities, who were not governed in lock-step, and if housing was needed, entire new cities would pop up (sometimes called suburbs, but check them - often they're their own legal entity).
- Hammershaft 2y agoStudies have found if you JUST upzoned and deregulated SF & NYC 30 years the avg income across the country would be %25 - %35 richer today. building out the VHCOL cities is the fastest path to high growth and social mobility. These are far and away the country's most productive places (even for low skilled work) and build up, reducing housing cost, and bringing in migrants and making them more productive turbocharges growth.
- rcpt 2y agoWe used to have completely different technologies in the world. For better or worse the modern economy depends much more on agglomeration and cities are more important than ever. Work from home didn't change this as some people thought it would. We need to unlock our economic centers if we want to survive.
- dangjc 2y agoI live in a VHCOL coast (the Bay Area) and am trying to add onto my house. Contractors are quoting broadly between $500-$1000 per square feet for an addition, for an ADU, or for a new house. We need both YIMBY procedure reforms and also somehow to bring down construction costs. I’m hopeful prefab/modular can help.
- bowsamic 2y ago[flagged]
- bendigedig 2y ago[flagged]
- bowsamic 2y ago[flagged]
- bendigedig 2y ago[flagged]
- bowsamic 2y ago[flagged]
- bendigedig 2y ago[flagged]
- bowsamic 2y ago[flagged]
- lazyasciiart 2y agoNo; be as resistant to local environment change as you are to global climate change. If you’re not doing anything about the second then don’t do anything about the first. (If you are doing something about the second, you probably know better than to try and prevent housing being built in a location that is not threatened).
- bowsamic 2y ago
- janalsncm 2y agoMountain View, California looks like this: https://www.commercialcafe.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/sites/10/shutterstock_1028985868_Featured-image.jpg https://www.commercialcafe.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/sites... It is home to (or adjacent to the home of) the most valuable companies in the world. The reason it doesn’t look like Shenzhen is because 1) Americans invest a huge portion of their life savings into their homes which means 2) preventing that asset from depreciating is important and 3) scarcity is the easiest way to accomplish that and 4) homeowners have disproportionate political power to do so. As long as these (by national standards) mediocre houses keep appreciating, homeowners will fight change.
- rcpt 2y ago1,2,3 are also true in Shenzhen. It's 4 that's different here.
- janalsncm 2y agoThe US has also exercised eminent domain historically. We can do it. American cities weren’t all government property before Uncle Sam put highways through many of them. It might be wise to revisit this for other improvements. When the Chinese government exercises eminent domain, my understanding is that many people want their homes to be targeted because of the (comparatively) lucrative payouts. Cash neutralizes concerns 1, 2, and 3. Now that people in California have held their homes long enough, buying them out is a lot more expensive. There are better ways to make the numbers work, though.
- ameliaquining 2y agoIt's not trivially obvious that upzoning would be bad for property values. If it becomes possible to build a giant apartment building on a plot of land in a high-demand area, that makes developers willing to pay substantial sums for it. (The homeownership paradigm does cause various other problems, though.)
- rcpt 2y agoIt's the variance, not the expected value. People are already 5x leveraged into the asset they don't need the extra risk.
- crq-yml 2y agoOur lack of building is directly tied to dollar reserve currency policy. We export a lot of dollars; other countries export goods to the US and end up with dollars. The things they can invest their dollar in are dollar-based assets. That results in the massive consumer sector and bubble dynamics. Simultaneously, calls to "reinvest in America" fall on deaf ears, because this reserve currency model needs free trade, and free trade allows capital to uproot and leave a place, whether in a direct sense or through creative loopholes. So long as the balance sheet of the assets is prioritized, the country cannot invest in its people, because that will show up as a cost(in tax, benefits, or regulation). Balance-sheet efficiency means consolidating and centralizing profits while outsourcing costs, and what is actively supported by policy and investment is whatever the market is hyped for(dot coms, social media, crypto, AI), which results in technical development towards the ends of oligarchs. Nothing new can be built unless it's pitched in terms of profit and market share. The current regime is the endgame: The distortions grew large enough to cause a flip to mercantalist policy-making and winner-loser dynamics. It has a short-term logic to it, but it is also incompatible with where we are. All the biggest businesses in modern America were built around dollar debt, consumerism and outsourcing, and all the workers were likewise tied to either the fortunes of these businesses or the government itself. All it'll do is produce a crisis, which can only resolve through a more holistic policy framework.
- Hammershaft 2y agoLack of urban building has nothing to do with the reserve currency (beyond making imported housing materials cheaper) and everything to do with NIMBY's steering municipal politics to choke development.