4 ms·
Mass grave of Roman soldiers found under Vienna sports field
- prmoustache 2y agoThere are some funny questions in the comments: "So to be clear, they were Roman soldiers killed. Not locals?"
- lifestyleguru 2y ago[flagged]
- bee_rider 2y agoThat caused me to re-read the article. Actually it is surprisingly ambiguous on that point inside the text of the article, with wording like > the human remains likely belonged to soldiers who died during a battle involving ancient Roman legionaries. Doesn’t say which side they were on. The most direct bit seems to be > X-ray images of the sheath revealed typical ancient Roman decorations: silver wire inlays […] But a German could just have traded with a Roman at some point. Of course, the headline says they are Roman soldiers. I wonder if it is hard to tell definitively.
- hx8 2y agoA simple DNA test should tell us. Roman soldiers were recruited from a diverse gene pool and fought far from their birthplace in mixed groups. A simple test to determine the average variance of genetics will let us know if they were a single ethnicity. Further cross references to compare similarity to other known genomes can tell us which region an individual was from. Whole genetic sequencing cost about $500. So <$75,000 for the sequencing of the entire 150, plus scientist time to gather samples and process results. Answering the question through genetics probably costs more than $250,000 even with cheap grad student labor, so it's probably just not worth it, especially when the moral high ground is to let the dead rest.
- tecleandor 2y agoSequencing 2K years old material is not that easy, specially WGS. From what I've been told, both from degradation and contamination, you're going to need much, much more samples and work than when doing a regular $500 sequencing. You can do simpler procedures to find their general regional origin, although it always requires more work in those conditions. Edit: Wien Museum press release says they're doing DNA and isotope analysis, but doesn't say the concrete techniques applied.
- hx8 2y agoThanks for lifting me above the Dunning-Kruger threshold so that I understand there is more to archaeological genetics then I previously conceived of.
- Tuna-Fish 2y agoDNA in the ground has a half-life of ~500 years. After 2000 years, ~6% of the DNA remains. More crucially, there will not be a single complete chromosome left, it's all a jumbled, mixed mess of DNA fragments. This can be reconstructed, but it requires a much larger sample than normal DNA analysis. (You need to get enough fragments to get a whole genome, with enough overlap everywhere that you can reassemble the pieces.) The largest problem after that is that the vast majority of DNA in all your samples will not be human DNA, but DNA of the various bacteria that live in the soil. This doesn't ruin the sample, because you can just reconstruct everything and then discard all the things that are not human chromosomes or mitochondrial DNA, but it does greatly increase the workload when compared to a pure human DNA sample. There are a lot of smaller problems that I am eliding here. But amazingly, all the problems are solvable, and the progress in this field in just the past decade is staggering. We have usable fragments that teach us new things that are >500kyr old, the oldest complete human genome we now have is ~45kyr old, and more recent samples are solving hundred-years-old historical debates, and new ones are done almost daily. We are living in the golden age of archaeogenetics, and many papers published today on it will be cited for a hundred years or more. ... but all the solutions to those problems create a lot more work, and thus a lot more cost than those $500 gene sequencing kits.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gerdesj 2y agoThe Roman empire at this time made massive use of auxiliaries - ie not Romans. These are soldiers from conquered lands. Mercenaries were also used a lot. Mercs are soldiers for hire rather than hired soldiers! Auxiliaries might be closer to slaves than soldiers and mercenaries might have fewer rights than auxiliaries. The devil is in the details. Auxiliaries might be granted Roman Citizenship at commencement or after a period of service. In general the policy was to deploy aux. from the other end of the empire to augment your top troops in a particular war theatre. Mercs were used to top up if available - think of them as Uber or Lyft when you've run out of decent taxis 8) Ideally you'd expend your aux and mercs carefully, to keep your real killers (heavy infantry) going. However its just not that simple, depending on what you (Roman General) had at your disposal in terms of troops. It also depended on you not being daft and throwing your cavalry up hill at pointy sticks or whatever. "Skirmishers" can also be devastating: The Germans (have a look at my username - yes I'm English) german - might mean spearman (I was told this by a bloke from Bayern). They were skirmishers - no armour and a big pointy stick and a buckler shield. They brought low several Roman legions. Anyway. The term Legionary is a tricky one. And so is German and quite a few other terms here.
- intrasight 2y ago"The experts also noted remarkably good dental health."
- FirmwareBurner 2y agoThe Roman army must have had good deductibles.
- remoquete 2y agoAnd CDI plans better than those in year MMXXV.
- credit_guy 2y agoMMDCCLXXVIII AVC https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ab_urbe_condita https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ab_urbe_condita
- ToValueFunfetti 2y agoMMXXV is a legitimate usage of Roman numerals, but CDI is unauthorized
- gerdesj 2y ago-49? Mind you, 0 needs inventing or what happens between 1 and -1 ... oh and -1 needs defining too, whatever that nonsense is! People haven't somehow magically become cleverer over the recent millennia. We just have some fancier tools these days. I'm sure if you gave a few Romans enough wine and the starting point of "Quid CDI significat?" then you would probably get a decent discussion.
- Someone 2y agoCertainly in modern use CDI is “a hundred less than five hundred, plus one”, or 401 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_numerals#Standard_form https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_numerals#Standard_form: “The numerals for 4 (IV) and 9 (IX) are written using subtractive notation, where the smaller symbol (I) is subtracted from the larger one (V, or X), thus avoiding the clumsier IIII and VIIII. Subtractive notation is also used for 40 (XL), 90 (XC), 400 (CD) and 900 (CM). These are the only subtractive forms in standard use. […] While subtractive notation for 4, 40, and 400 (IV, XL, and CD) has been the usual form since Roman times [citation needed], additive notation to represent these numbers (IIII, XXXX, and CCCC) very frequently continued to be used, including in compound numbers like 24 (XXIIII), 74 (LXXIIII), and 490 (CCCCLXXXX).[12] The additive forms for 9, 90, and 900 (VIIII,[9] LXXXX, and DCCCC) have also been used, although less often“
- wolfi1 2y agoRomans usually burnt their corpses, so it is quite unusual to find skeletons.
- mikestew 2y agoFrom TFA: “Since cremations were common in the European parts of the Roman Empire around 100 AD [CE], inhumations are an absolute exception. Finds of Roman skeletons from this period are therefore extremely rare,” said Kristina Adler-Wölfl, head of the Vienna City Archaeology Department.
- jandrese 2y agoWhich might tell a story in itself. This might have been a small detachment that was ambushed and utterly wiped out, leaving nobody alive on the Roman side to perform the traditional funeral rites. Instead the attackers were left to bury the bodies in their own tradition.
- lukan 2y ago"Instead the attackers were left to bury the bodies in their own tradition." Germanic tribes usually burned their bodies as well. But that does not mean, they feld oblieged to give the enemy a proper rite.
- fsckboy 2y ago>This might have been a small detachment that was ambushed and utterly wiped out or even three legions, 16,000–20,000 killed. "Teutoburg Forest is considered one of the most important defeats in Roman history, bringing the triumphant period of expansion under Augustus to an abrupt end. It dissuaded the Romans from pursuing the conquest of Germania, and so can be considered one of the most important events in European history." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Teutoburg_Forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Teutoburg_Forest
- woodson 2y ago
- SubiculumCode 2y ago[flagged]
- morninglight 2y agoCan anyone tell me the manufacturer and model of the small, round vacuum cleaners in the photograph? You cannot believe how filthy my workshop gets.
- atombender 2y agoHave you looked at Shop-Vac? They make multiple sizes, the small wing being a cute 1 gallon (3.7 liters) desk version: https://www.shopvac.com/products/shop-vac%C2%AE-1-gallon-1-0-peak-hp-micro-wet-dry-vacuum https://www.shopvac.com/products/shop-vac%C2%AE-1-gallon-1-0...
- gerdesj 2y agoCould be a variety of Henry: https://www.myhenry.com/ https://www.myhenry.com/ However it looks like the wheels in th piccie are outside the major plan view of the body, so perhaps not.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- glxxyz 2y agoI'm pretty sure it's this Einhell Wet/Dry Vacuum Cleaner: https://www.einhell.nl/en/p/2342370-tc-vc-1812-s/ https://www.einhell.nl/en/p/2342370-tc-vc-1812-s/ this guy in England seemed quite happy with his: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyOu6TyEUuY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyOu6TyEUuY I also wondered about the power extension reels, looks like two of them are the REV model shown here: https://www.amazon.de/dp/B07KKQMVLW https://www.amazon.de/dp/B07KKQMVLW although one is a bit battered and the outer blue plate has fallen off.