5 ms·
Drag racers are ditching superchargers for scuba-style tanks and compressed air
- PaulHoule 2y agoAmazed it didn't happen earlier. For a long time it's been seen that an economical way to store energy is to store compressed air in a cavern and feed it into a gas-fired turbine in lieu of turbocharging: see https://urbanao.com/post/compressed-air-energy-storage-caes-a-comprehensive-2025-overview https://urbanao.com/post/compressed-air-energy-storage-caes-...
- potato3732842 2y agoIt didn't happen because like everything else that the peanut gallery deems "obvious" the actual pros and cons of implementing it didn't pencil out until recently. This was tried in the 1950s and 1960s. IDK why it didn't make the cut then. Probably cumulative weight of tanks. It takes A LOT of air to run an engine.
- rkagerer 2y agoI noticed the tank in the article's photo looks like carbon fiber wrapped aluminum. Those are noticeably lighter than the pure aluminum or steel tanks common in the 60's. (Source: Have carried each on my back as a volunteer firefighter)
- hydrogen7800 2y agoThis is pretty smart. Why carry the compressor and intercooler with you? Save the mass and complexity, as well as shifting the energy required to compress the air to a device off the car.
- mperham 2y ago[flagged]
- potato3732842 2y agoDrag racing is just about the purest most scientific competition of vehicle tuning you're going to get. The driver doesn't really make or break it as long as they're at least decent. On the other end of the spectrum you have racing types that are more of a competition among drivers with the vehicle not really making or breaking anything as long as it's typical for the class.
- mperham 2y agoI get racing on a twisty track. They are legitimate tests of human skill and vehicle endurance engineering. Drag racing has none of that. There's little skill beyond reaction time and drag vehicles have almost no relation to normal vehicles.
- SAI_Peregrinus 2y agoThink of drag racing like the CO2 cartridge race car competitions you see in lots of high-school science classes. It's an engineering challenge, not a skill-based race.
- jcgrillo 2y agoHave you ever tried it?
- mperham 2y agoI participated in motorcycle track days on race tracks for 15 years. I've dragged knee at 90pmh. _That_ takes skill and balls. Drag racing seems dumb by comparison.
- mikestew 2y agoThat's a long-winded way to say, "no, I've never tried it". If one has never tried a pursuit, I can understand how it might "seem dumb". What seems dumb to me, though, is doing track days for years on end, and never once trying to see how fast you could launch a bike down a drag strip, and then going on about how dumb drag racing is.
- hex4def6 2y agoQuestion -- why not go with liquid oxygen? Does that push the danger-meter too high? On the plus side, you're not dealing with 3000 psi compressed gas. I'm assuming the costs involved in making engines capable of withstanding cryogenic temperatures probably make that impractical (?)
- chongli 2y agoAnd instead of gasoline carry liquid hydrogen. Dragsters are practically horizontal rockets anyway. Might as well stop pretending!
- lupusreal 2y agoLiquid hydrogen is very bulky, the tank might be large enough to impact the aerodynamics. Use kerosene instead, and maybe use RFNA instead of oxygen, just to bump the danger level up to Abjectly Stupid.
- wiml 2y agoI'll just flip my copy of Ignition! open to a random page and build a car around that...
- dabiged 2y agoLiquid hydrogen can also cause hydrogen embrittlement. Not ideal in a high performance machine.
- shitpostbot 2y ago[dead]
- a_shoeboy 2y agoIf you're going to cheat, way cheaper to put nitrous oxide in the tank and claim it's compressed air. 50% boost in oxygen content without having to engineer your engine to not burn when pure O2 hits it.
- kazinator 2y agoThe properties of air that you care about are basically immutable, so why not pre-compute a bunch of compressed air instead of compressing it on the fly, and then having to carry the equipment to do that. There is an energy cost to supercharging. While you get an overall horsepower boost, it's less than what it would be if the compression cost nothing.
- Aurornis 2y agoThis article gets the concept slightly wrong.The compressed air becomes very cold air when it expands rapidly in the intake. Colder air is more dense and therefore carries more oxygen. More oxygen allows more fuel, which allows more power. Here's a better explanation in a single paragraph on the company's website: > The end result of these expansion processes is that the charge air temperature entering an engine is dramatically lower than can be achieved with conventional MAP increasing technologies (supercharging and/or turbocharging with after-cooling). Hence very high charge densities can be attained at relatively low MAP levels. The goal is to increase the amount of air going into the engine by making it very cold and dense, not by pressurizing it like a supercharger. Low MAP means low manifold absolute pressure. In other words, it's not boost like a turbo or supercharger. EDIT: It looks like the website is also unclear. There is some mention of a secondary valve shutting off the intake valve to prevent air leaking out from the air filter. Their website is strangely unclear. This isn't mentioned in the "Theory of Operation" section but does get mentioned later as an "isolation valve" See here: https://casupercharging.com/tech/#system-overview https://casupercharging.com/tech/#system-overview
- exabrial 2y agoIt says they're boosting to 10psi, in addition to the colder intake charge
- Aurornis 2y agoI know what the article says, but the author seems to misunderstand how the system works. The systems has regulators that step the air pressure down from thousands of PSI in the tank to a much smaller, regulated number at the nozzle that gets sprayed into the intake. From the source company that sells the system: > The very low temperature medium pressure air stream is then throttle one more time in the Electronic Pressure Regulator before being discharged into the engine air intake tract. The throttling effect that occurs here is small compared to that which occurs at the Mechanical Pressure regulator but, similar in nature. The tuner can adjust the pressure that is being discharged into the intake tract, but that's not equivalent to the pressure in the manifold. The system works by having the air expand rapidly in the intake, causing a rapid cooling effect. The company describes it better on their own site: https://casupercharging.com/tech/#system-overview https://casupercharging.com/tech/#system-overview EDIT: There is some mention of an "isolation valve" but not within the "Theory of Operation" section of the company's own description: https://casupercharging.com/tech/#system-overview https://casupercharging.com/tech/#system-overview So there might be some scenario where the system shuts off the intake valve, too, but it's weirdly unclear from their own system description.
- munchbunny 2y agoReminds me of this piece of motorsports history: https://fordauthority.com/2017/12/how-ford-cheated-the-rules-with-the-2003-ford-focus-rs-wrc/ https://fordauthority.com/2017/12/how-ford-cheated-the-rules... Take, for instance, Ford’s car from the 2003 FIA World Rally Championship. Through a knowledgeable automotive tuner and journalist named Stav from the UK (Facebook page), we learned that the 2003 Ford Focus RS WRC used an ingenious, mostly-hidden system to store excess pressurized air from the turbocharger in a titanium tank until it could be advantageously crammed into the engine on straight portions of the course, elevating power beyond what would otherwise have been possible.
- danielsokil 2y agoI planned to implement this system in a project car years ago, but never got to it. Do have a parts list, and the overall cost is quite reasonable. My goal focuses on in-vehicle recharging rather than tank-swapping approach. https://gist.github.com/s0kil/9bd6815ea2ab4e65a786c6382a5bfa33 https://gist.github.com/s0kil/9bd6815ea2ab4e65a786c6382a5bfa...
- ck2 2y agoAren't there stock electric cars now that do quarter mile under 10 seconds? When battery weight gets cut in half next decade and capacity doubles, the only reason why they will race ICE engines is for the noise
- mikestew 2y agoOur Hyundai grocery-getter does a 1/4 in 13s, the "N" go-fast version does it in 11s. And those are Hyundais with full-sized, heavy-ass batteries, and abysmal stock tires. Porsche Taycan GT (with a full-sized, heavy-ass battery) turns 1/4 in 9.3s. Now cut those heavy batteries in half because you're not driving from SF to LA, and I could see that Porsche turning 8s if you could get the power to the ground (IOW, launch control and much better tires than stock).
- SideburnsOfDoom 2y agoIf you want to get into electric small-batch performance cars, BYD has you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yangwang_U9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yangwang_U9
- fanatic2pope 2y agoAFAIK the fastest "production" EV is the McMurtry "Spéirling" that does a quarter mile in under 8 seconds. Watching it set the record for goodwood is mind blowing, because it looks like the video is being played in fast forward, but it isn't. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JYp9eGC3Cc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JYp9eGC3Cc Although you can in theory buy one, it uses down force fans so I don't know if it would even be street legal in most places. Personally, I find car like this to be way more interesting than drag racers.
- josefresco 2y agoI don't believe there's anything even remotely competitive in the electric world to Top Fuel dragsters. You could also make the same argument about F1 vs E1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Fuel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Fuel > Top Fuel is a type of drag racing whose dragsters are the quickest accelerating racing cars in the world and the fastest sanctioned category of drag racing, with the fastest competitors reaching speeds of 338.94 miles per hour (545.5 km/h) and finishing the 1,000 foot (304.8 m) runs in 3.641 seconds.
- linsomniac 2y agoSome facts about top fuel dragsters: the supercharger uses around a thousand horsepower to run, but that's ok because the motor puts out over 10x that. It uses around 15 gallons of fuel for a single quarter mile run, but that also includes the burn-out.
- WalterBright 2y agoIf you're anywhere near the pits, and the crew fires up the motor, and then just blips the throttle, the sound waves generated are like physical blows to your chest. The only sweeter sound is a V12 Merlin coughing into life. I snagged a ride in a P51 once. OMG. That machine just leaped into the air. I was smiling for a week.
- linsomniac 2y agoStory of coincidences, I guess: I'm adopted, but a total car nut. My adoptive family weren't really car people except my uncle. A couple years ago I found my birth family, and they are all car nuts. My half sister was a test driver for Audi, my mom and much of the family worked at the local drag strip.
- arresin 2y agoThat’s amazing how influential your genes were on you
- WalterBright 2y agoWhen very little, I thought I wanted to be a farmer, and tried growing crops in the back yard. Total failure. I threw an entire bag of grass seed in my yard 6 weeks ago. Not a single seed sprouted (a flock of birds ate every one). Total failure. But by age 7 I knew that I was a born engineer. Engines, electronics, software, structures, all of it.
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> Compressed air is stored at 3,300 psi in carbon fiber tanks that weigh roughly 30 pounds each when full When are the kids in California going to grab a tank, point the nozzle down, and ride that thing like a rocket from the beach, parachuting into the ocean? We could call them "beach jumpers".
- johnatwork 2y agoI worked at a speed shop in my youth and at the time I was into Paintball so I had an idea. We tried something similar to good effect, but we unfortunately had no good knowledge on how to refine it. It's hard to just shoot compressed air into the manifold and not have it blow back out of the intake. Either way we figured out a way to increase the volumetric efficiency as well as gains from running cool dense air. We were very close to pre-spinning the existing turbo/super setups and experimented with that as well. We gave up because Nitrous oxide at the time was much easier to work with and popular, and the tanks we had to experiment with was tiny compared to the large scuba tanks. We also tried using compressed CO2 bottles to spray towards the intercooler to cool that down considerably, that worked decently as well, but no good data to support.
- arprocter 2y agoVolvo came up with a way of spooling the turbo by injecting compressed air into the exhaust manifold https://www.carmagazine.co.uk/car-news/tech/volvos-turbo-lag-solution-is-just-hot-air-car-may-2016/ https://www.carmagazine.co.uk/car-news/tech/volvos-turbo-lag...
- magicalhippo 2y agoWhat blew me away was that the high-end engines[1] turn just a few hundred RPM during a race, which to me seemed ridiculous when you see wall of flames from the headers when they release the car at the line. Also how they use aluminum for the connecting rods instead of stronger and stiffer metals like titanium, as they can then act as shock absorbers protecting the crankshaft bearings. Lots of interesting tech to eek out performance and lifetime. I've been enjoying watching Steve Morris's YouTube channel[2], he shares a lot of such information. He's mainly making drag and drive engines, which has the additional constraint of having to survive thousands of miles of regular roads between races. I've also enjoyed Brian Lohnes channel[3] for interesting historical accounts from the early days. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Fuel#Performance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Fuel#Performance [2]: https://www.youtube.com/@stevemorrisracing/videos https://www.youtube.com/@stevemorrisracing/videos [3]: https://www.youtube.com/@brianlohnes3079/videos https://www.youtube.com/@brianlohnes3079/videos
- mjan22640 2y ago> Also how they use aluminum for the connecting rods instead of stronger and stiffer metals like titanium The 7000 aluminium alloys are similar to titanium in strenght/weight
- magicalhippo 2y agoYes but they have lower Young's modulus[1] so compress more under the same force. Thus acting as a shock absorber to reduce peak loads on the rod bearings. Again no expert but from what I can see, high-end aluminum rods can use 7075 aluminum[2], which has a Young's modulus of about 72 GPa, while titanium has a modulus of about 105 and up[3][4], depending on grade. At least that's my understanding. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young%27s_modulus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young%27s_modulus [2]: https://www.enginebuildermag.com/2017/03/racing-rods-builders-many-options-choose/ https://www.enginebuildermag.com/2017/03/racing-rods-builder... [3]: https://titanium.com/alloys/titanium-and-titanium-alloys/grade-1-cp-4/ https://titanium.com/alloys/titanium-and-titanium-alloys/gra... [4]: https://titanium.com/alloys/titanium-and-titanium-alloys/ti-grade-5-6al-4v/ https://titanium.com/alloys/titanium-and-titanium-alloys/ti-...
- neilv 2y agoIs there added fire and/or explosion hazard?
- m463 2y agoIsn't this basically cheapo nitrous? is it skirting some kind of rule and being specifically NOT nitrous? Or maybe it is just cost - scuba compressor to fill tank.
- derelicta 2y ago[flagged]
- DrNosferatu 2y agoWhy not compressed pure oxygen? Had this idea since the 90s, but no racing team listened to me just because I was a kid in school.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoWikipedia says uncited that N2O produces heat when it decomposes into nitrogen and oxygen, but that's the opposite of other comments saying that cold oxygen is better because it's denser
- DrNosferatu 2y agoCompressed - cold - pure oxygen, that is. Held in a lightweight composite thermic bottle.
- 00N8 2y agoYou'd get better energy density that way, but I think it's offset by worse efficiency & more damage to the engine. The inert gas fraction (N2, CO2, H2O) provides a useful working fluid to convert combustion heat to force pushing on the piston. Burning pure O2 would mean a lot more heat is needed for the same amount of force. Higher peak temperatures & more available oxygen will tend to create hotspots & knock/pre-detonation, & possibly erosion of the cylinder wall & piston from directly burning the metal. Using nitrous or cool compressed air keeps most of the benefits while mitigating the problems of using pure O2.
- droopyEyelids 2y agoThese tanks are called “SCBA” self contained breathing apparatus… no “u” for underwater. They’re what firefighters use.
- hoseja 2y agoLike at this point what's stopping you from strapping a couple SRBs on the frame.